Union Of India And Others v. Ex Nk Sukhbir Singh And Another
"
!# $ %&'##'% "
# $ %&( % "
!"#"$% &
( $ %&( "% "
'
$ %&( "'% "
' (( '
) )
$ %&( #'% "
')
3-4
& $ %&( #(% "
'&
) *+) , ,) ,, *+) ,-.,,
5+ ' 6227(62 '289
2 8( 89 :6
(* +,!##!+-.-/ ' 22; <62629
2 8( 89 :6
(* +,$ - +-.-/ ' 6 729
2 8( 89 :6
(* +,$ -/+-.-/9(* +,$ /!+-.-/2 +,$ #$+-.-/ ' 6289
2 8( 89 :6
(* +,$ #!+-.-/
' 2= 6
6<289 ;12 9 :
(* +,$ - +-.-/
>>>>> ,) ,, / 0 +1 ?6
9@ :A@
+,!##!+-.-/9 (* +,$ - +-.-/9 (* +,$ -/+-.-/9 (* +,$ /!+ -.-/9(* +,$ #$+-.-/2 (* +,$ #!+-.-/B?2177
26 ;8;
6 2 27
*66 1 :8 2
1 :6
96 :212 <2C :7(* +,!##!+-.-/
-
6
96 16288 < 6 7 <
2
."
-.-/3 A +"4 2
B?
-+7
1
B289 <28 169 (62 <26 36 2: :
2
3,4 B28E49B?@6169
62B
288@
6 ::
:
28<@6B :: <:::
:7 .F/.F:8:
@
:
.
.$ -.- C
< ; @6 :212 11721 :6 12 96 < 62 27
;
-
) 2
1 8:6
821 6
: 2 '
1282 :
68 626<66
2B8?:G 72??
2
H .F:8:
62B
:
9B6 27 62B
6 B?6 2 '
1282 B D 6 2B2B8 '82?
2<<2;2
B?6 '82? 96 <2:B ::
2 <::6 27 :7 .F/.FB?6 8 2
B28;
2
."
-.-/3 A +"491 ,
* 62;
6 2 ) 2
1 8:6
2 62;
< 6<66 :8 @66 2B8 221
211
:2162
88
2 7? :
+ / .# -..,2 @2 162<
:7 , .# -.- 2:
< #?
22 " 2?:
28211
:216226 7 @6
=
6 27
:1
/ .# -..,9 6 @2 7
1288? A27
2 @2 :
::
<:72?16 2 96 B2:@6169
@2872 8? 162<
:7
/
6 1 8
B?EB8 (: 2
0 ! &12,& '
9 2?::1 ;<6 7
1 9@662
< 6 7
128
3 4
A27226 7 :6I6 12 @2: ::
< :72?16 2 2627 6 B2:@61696 I6 62B
162<
:7 9162 8?
8
:6 ::
7 6I6 :2;2
8 /2 $:D8 8 : (228?
2? @2 9 $#-E 62 6 2 2B8? 62 B
121
B?6 8?
<6 12
2 969 8
: ::
;2 22 ,.2 ,-:6 = <7
3 242 2
5+ G,.
6 12
62 : 2? 2 62 B
1
2 6 7 :
882J 211
21 : 782?
62;
:28
B< 1 2?
17 << 62 6 2
882 @2
27 :162 2 B?6
2?6 ::
<:716 2
2B :2? 1 26 7 :211
21 :=< : 2
882 @2 17B 6 2 : 6 '
1282 1288: 1 2 8C6 27 : 17<2 626 2 18 62;
7
128 A272
6 211
21 : 782? 9 B 6<6 1 << 622?16 1 @21288
:B?6 '
1282 8C
2 262;
1
@< 17 6 118626 2B8? 782?
:219+2
812:7 :
'
128 2 2
2 :7 (82 3 4 :
22<2 6-:6 :6 '
1282 @6162:88@5 G3 46 :2 2B8?
(6 B2
68 2 @62 A218?6 6 12
3/4 :
% 2B8? 82
78 K ,-
:6 2: 2 ;96
21< 6? :28
1 62 6 '
1282 62 <;
2? 2
:
9 21828?@6 6 :16
2 2B8?2;282B8 6 1 :
2
88226 7 :211
21 :782?
*6<<6<66 2: 2 :216
21<6?7 1621288? 2
7 <
: = 1B2
6
:
'
128 2
8 / 2 $ :
J8 8 :(228?
2?@2 9 $#-J96 2
882 8
: 7 2
:: 7 6:2; 2B :
2? ;
1 6@626 2
882@2 ::
<:7L 28
M 3 8
?4K26 7 :211
21 :6 9@88B 7
626 2
882@2 6?1282 7 28 1 2 6 7 : < 6 2
2 6 6 286 62 2C
K
6 92
6 8
1 :82@ 8
B?EB8
(: 2 9
, 3, 2' 92?::1 ;<6 7
1 9@662
< 6 7
128 A27226 7 :6I6 12 @2 : :9B N 8? ::
<2 2B8?9 8
6 : :
B? <::6 27 /.F26 7 @8 626 2B8?::
2B2B8 6 '82?
;2 22:6 = <7 12 3 242 2
5+ ?6 :2
286 2
88234
3!4 2 6 N 9@6 92 ; 289@6 62
22<6 2< :
22 17 :6 : <2< 9::
B ::
< :7 7 2B8? @616 2B2B8 2<<2;2
B?6 782? 9
8
B <2
6 :: <+:::
2B8?
2
88234 6 @8
1 629 6 B2 : (182
3-4I$"I3
+(4
B?6 '?: :
;
7 : 29 2
, .
-.. 96 2: 2
:72
2;282B8 8?27
1
8@6;28 2
: 92 2? 6 12 <? : 7
1
6 2B;
/ * 62;
6 2 8 2
1 8:6 2 6 8
*
2? 6 7 <
= <7 342
342 6 : 2886 2
28 @616
26 11
: <+:::6
2 7
9@6
2 1
"
728:6 72 @88B 2C :B?6 <6(2@ 882B?6 B28 <2<2
2 8 :6
B : 79:2?9@62 < <2 8
6
K "
EB8 (: 2 = <7 2
(;8
28 , :-.-/
1
.
.$ -.-/8
2
6 <2:B ::
<::6 2B8?2
3 24622<2B
9@616:2162< + B
26 62 :6
3"4 #
6 92
6 = <7 :6 EB8 (: 2
!"
#
!$% 6 27 62B
1
2<22 62
6 62 ;<62 2B8?2B
782? 8?
2
:'
1282 12B 211
1288?
@6 2B8?@2
26 7 : ? 9 ;2
222 2
&'(
!
"
#
$ %! "
#
&
'
!
!
"
#
$%! "
#
!
!
! (
!
"
#
)
'
! (
!
*
+
"
#
!
!
!
!
,
!
! !
! &
-&
')
!
!
!
3#4
.
* )
-& //
&
!
$
) 2
1 8 : 6
62;
B
2B8
6 2 :82@62;<B
8
B?6 EB8
(: 2
3 249 12 3 249
12 3 242
12 3 24
.
< ; @ 6 8
1 : 82@ 8
12 3 249 12 3 249
12 3 242
12 3 242@ 8826 :21 2 11721 : 6 12 62 2 6 7 : 19
@27
1288? A27
2 @2: :288
1 2 @28?2:
:7 62 # ?
2 @6 6
+9 6 @2 : B ::
< :7 6 72??
28<@66 :21621< ;
I72 28
28
7
128 1 62B
B<6 1 6@6( 626 2B8?2B2B8 782?
62B <96 2 2B8?62B 2B
6 782? 2 6
:
'
1282 122C 2@2?6 <6:
18276 ::
21:6 6 12 281;
6 <2:B ::2; :6
6
1;
@
1 :82@1
3$4 B : 281;
6 :
:6 <2:B : :2; -
:(* +,$ #!+-.-/96 :212 11721 ::
:76 B16:
8?6 A 62B :: <:::
:7-.F/.F62B
<2
28<@66 2 22 7B8 :6
2<:7.
./ $$#88 .$ .
-..$9@616<2:B :62B
16288 <
B?
:2 <2:B :: <:::
:7-.F/.F92
62 28 ? B
28 B? 6 B : B? 821< 821 = <7 : 3 242 6 96 2 <2:B :
1
,
:226 < ;21 :
N2<2:2 29 6288B
622 28N2 8?1;
B?6 = <7 :6 EB8 (: 2 (;8
28 ,.#!:-. -8
*+
59
1
.# .
-. !9 @6 28 6 N : 1
2 @2 <2 < 87< 6 ::2 22 7B8 :2
:6
?
29@6 6 : :2 2:6
92@2B <1827
B?6 18272@2 <2
6 1827296 EB8 (: 26 2
5+ 01112
3
! !
) !
!
! !
!
!
. 5
!
6
!
3 .4
6 !
!
/&
'
6 2<7 62B
2
/
96 2B :2?
;
?B <
6 7 <
2
."
-.-/3 A +"4 6 6 B2:6 :21 6 8
1 : 82@9
11 <8?96 @
2 7
"
<2
812349:2?92
:
#
61 ?:6
B
6 :8 :1
12 0 ,) ,,1 0-.,,
1 678
/ "
*6
2C<I 2
% *6
2B8