High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/37308/2025disposed of

Balwant Singh Now Deceased Through Lrs v. State Of Punjab And Others

2026-03-23Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja6 pages

%#B %#B %#B %#B +" %$ +" %$ +" %$ +" %$ BCB<D%$<5 @ BCB<D%$<5 @ BCB<D%$<5 @ BCB<D%$<5 @ 6 4((%!

4((%!

B B B B#<B#< #< #< #<A

###### ###### ###### ###### "("(%!

"("(%!

"("(%! 5 6

#### '%!- !"

1 1 1 1

# 1

# 1 #)!!71#(!:.+,-3%4+" "& ' "("(%! 56# #)!*+! &"+,--.###, )!

!*+/# #&)/&+01+)&(2,-3%4+" '%!- !"%#?# EEEE ,#5 +.6 ,#5 +.6 ,#5 +.6 ,#5 +.6 & & ' "("(%! ,/78+7%$' !"

"' "("(%!, 29)+&(!:%$+!% -+" - ;#<#< 5!! F) 6 '+ - /7 '%!- !" %# +!- 49)(("

%.. 4"%, %&+ +.(5$%&%"GH6 5$%&%"GH6 5$%&%"GH6 5$%&%"GH6,8& /7"& & (+''.(4+"(%!)!- 4"(%!D D %$ "& +!- 4 49)(("(%! 4", D;? 5$% &%"

5$% &%"

" G"& 4"H6 " G"& 4"H6 " G"& 4"H6 " G"& 4"H6 "+!- * 4" - / (!: /+ -/7.(0("+ "(%!# => => => => ( $.7 "+"(!:, %0 .+!- %8! - - /7 "& ' "("(%! 56.+!-%8!

56 $%0(!:'+"%$ "& 3 !) "+" %$(..+: + +9/+, &(.+!-("(4")-&(+ +!+, 4+0 "% / +49 9)( - 3(- !%"($(4+"(%! -+" - B#<A#<< @ <#<A#<< () ) - )!- 4"(%!?

?@A%$"& 4" ' 4"(3 .7$% "& ')/.(4')'% %$ ""(!:) )'+ 8+(! +2 2 "+" )..+')+2&+,("(4" )-&(+!+#!8+-)!- 4"

%$"& 4"8+ ++!!%)!4 -/7"& %!B# ##<<B+!-"& 4%0' !+"(%!8 - " 0(! - +" "

"& +" %$ #A .+2& ' +4 / (- :+!" %$ %"& "+")"

"%7 / ! $("# ::

( 3 - "& %$, %0 %$ "& %"& & .+!-%8! ' $ - $ !4

)!- 4"(%! D %$ "& 4", 8&(4& 4+0 "% / - 4(- - %! ?##< <B 5!! F) 6 6 /7 "& . +! - $ !4 % %)" 8&(. - " 0(!(!: "& 0+ 2 " 3+.) %$"& +49) )( -.+!-+""& +" %$ #<,<< <,<<<J' +4 # =B> =B> =B> =B> + + -%!"& +$% +(-+8+-,"& ' "("(%! ' $ -+!+''.(4+"

)!- 4"(%! D %$ "& 4" / $% '% %!- !" %# %! B<#<B#< < 5!! F) 6, ,8&(4&4+0 "%/ -(0( -/ (!:/+ -/7.(0("+"(%!3(- % -+" -;#<#< 5!! F) 6# !4 ,"& '

!"8("' "("(%!# =?> & &+3 & +- . +! - 4%)! . $% "& '+"( +!- :%! "&%):& '+' /%%2# => ' )+. %$ "& 4%- &%8 "&+", /+ - %! "& 8+- -+ +" - ?##<B'+ -/7"& . +! - $ !4 % %)","& ' "("(%! 56.+!-%8!

56 ' $ - +! +'

''.(4+"(%! )!- 4"(%! D %$ "& 4" %! B<#<B#< / $ $% '%!- !" %# , 8&(4& 8+ +''+ !".7 7 $(. - / 7%!- + ' (%- %$ "& & 0%!"&$%0"& -+" %$+8+-'+ -/7"& .

+! - $ !4 %)"# % %3 3 , ("&++.%4%0 %! 4%-"&+"+::( 3 -%$"& - " 0(!+"(%!-+" -?##<B B/7 "& . +! -

$ !4 %)", "& %"& .+!-% %8! +''%+4& - "&( %)" /7 ' $ (!: :) ).+ ("'' +.$%$)"& !

!&+!4 0 !",+!-"& +0 + "(.. ' !-(!: $% +-* *)-(4+"(%!# ! %$ )4& +'' + +., + '%(!" - %)" /7 "& . +!

! - 4%)! .$%' "("

"(%! 56,(

DDB<<? "4# # =A> "0 0+7/ !%"(4 -& "&+",(!" 0 0%$.+8.+(--%8!/7"& %!I I/. ' F%)"(! +!8+(+!-%"& 3#+7+!+ +!8+(+!-%"& 3#+7+!+ +!8+(+!-%"& 3#+7+!+ +!8+(+!-%"& 3#+7+!+ +"+" !-)"(+.+!-!$+")4"

+"+" !-)"(+.+!-!$+")4"

") ") ") ") 3 .%'0 !" 3 .%'0 !" 3 .%'0 !" 3 .%'0 !" %'%+"(%! (0(" - 56 + %'%+"(%! (0(" - 56 + %'%+"(%! (0(" - 56 + %'%+"(%! (0(" - 56 + +!- +!%"& +!- +!%"& +!- +!%"& +!- +!%"& I '%" - + G< < < < 56 56 56 56

5(3(.6 B

5(3(.6 B BH, BH, BH, BH, "& ' "("(%! .+!-%8! &+3 "& (:&" "% (!3%2 4"

"(%! D%$"& 4" 3 !(!'))+!4 %$"& $(!+.- - " 0(!+"(%!0+- /7"&(%) "(!

"& ' !-(!:

(" '' +., ' $ - +" "& (!"+!4 %$ ' "("(%!

.+!-%8! ' "

"+(!(!:"%"& +0 +49)(("(%!#

. 3+!"'++:+'&%#@A A%$ "& +$% 0 !"(%!

! -*)-:0 !"+ F"+4" -& ) )!- G # !"& ' !"4+ ,("(!%"(!

(!-(')" "&+""& ("'' +.8& &(4& 8+ +..%8 -/7"& (:&%)"3(- *)-:0 !"+!-%- -+" -!-

+7 < A8+(! ' 4"%$"& .+!-8&(4& &8+4%3 -/7"& +0 !%"($(4+"

+"(%! )!- - 8&(4&!%"($(4+"(%!"& +'' ..+!

!"I.+!-(+.%4%3 -#"(+.% !%" (! - -(')" "&+" "& +0%)!" +8+- - - /7 "& (:& %)" (! "& +(-

(" ''

' +.((! F4 %$"& +0%)!"+8 8+- -/7"& %.. 4"%)!- 4"

4"(%! % %$"& D;?4"(!"& 4+ %$"& .

.+!-%$"& +'' ..+!"#"(+.%!% %"(! -('

')" "&+" "& +'' ..+!" &+- !%" 0 0+- +! +''.(4+"(%! "% "& %.. 4 4"% )!- - 4"(%! D %$ "& D;? 4"

"# " ( +.% !%" (! -(')" "&+" '.(4+"(%!0+- /7"& +'' ..+!")!

)!- 4"(%!D%$"& D;?4 4""% %.. 4"% 8+ 8("&(! + ' (%- % %$ "& 0%!"& $%0 "& -+" %$ $ "& *)-:

-:0 !"+!-%- %$"& (:&%)"

"# A#

%0"& ' )+.%$"& *)-:0 !"%$"&(%)"(!"& 4+ %$ +- - ' 1)0 )0+( 5)'+6, (" ( 4. + "&+" "& .

.(0("+"(%! $% 0%3(!: "& +''.(4+"

+"(%! )!- - 4"(%!D%$"& D;?4"8 8(../ :(!"%)!%!.7$%0"& -+"

" %$ +8+- %! "& /+( %$ 8&(4& - - " 0(!+"(%! %$ "& 4%0' !+"(%!

! ( %):

):&"#& +'' ..+!"+ 2(!: - - " 0(!+"(%!%$"& 4%0' !+"(%!

!%! /+(%$"& *)-:0 !"+!-%- % %$"& (:&%)"(! ("'' +. %# ?;

;%$<B-+" -!- +7<A#"( (!%"-(')" -"&+""& +''.(4+"(%!% +'' ..+!" )!- 4"(%! D % %$ "& D;? 4" ( 8("&(! + ' (%- - %$ "& 0%!"&$%0!- +7<A#H

) "& ,"& - 4((%!0+- (!"& 4 4+ %$+!8+(+!-%"& +!8+(+!-%"& +!8+(+!-%"& +!8+(+!-%"& 5)'

5)'

'+6 '+6 '+6 '+6 &++.%/ !$% %..%8 -/7"& (3((%! !4& %$"&(%)"(!4+ %$K !(%!

K !(%!

!%$ !%$ !%$ !%$ !-(++!-+!%"& !-(++!-+!%"& !-(++!-+!%"& !-(++!-+!%"& & 3#& ' 4(+.+!-49 & 3#& ' 4(+.+!-49 & 3#& ' 4(+.+!-49 & 3#& ' 4(+.+!-49)(( )(( )(( )(( ("(%!%.. 4"% ("(%!%.. 4"% ("(%!%.. 4"% ("(%!%.. 4"%4)0 4)0 4)0 4)0)/ )/ )/ )/(3((% (3((% (3((% (3((% %!+. %!+. %!+. %!+.

+:("+" , +"&

+:("+" , +"& &+!2%"+!-%"& ,<5B6 &+!2%"+!-%"& ,<5B6 &+!2%"+!-%"& ,<5B6 &+!2%"+!-%"& ,<5B6

5(3(.6CDA#

5(3(.6CDA# =C>

% % %3 ,(!" 0%$&++"(!: &++"(!: &++"(!: &++"(!: J%).+/(!:&+2&+-@ # J%).+/(!:&+2&+-@ # J%).+/(!:&+2&+-@ # J%).+/(!:&+2&+-@ # # # # # "+" %$ +&++ "+" %$ +&++ "+" %$ +&++ "+" %$ +&++ +&"+@ #, +&"+@ #, +&"+@ #, +&"+@ #, '%" -+ G< G< G< G< D56;H D56;H D56;H D56;H,%!4 "& :) ).+

(" '' +. ' $ - +" "& (!"+!4 %$ $ "& %"& .+!-%8! 9)+ - " 0(!+"(%!%$ $0+2 "3+.) ' "+(!(!:"%"& +0 +49)(("(%!'%4 -(!:8 8 ' !-(!:/ $% "

"&(%)",("8+0% +''%'( (+" $% '%!- !"%#"%8+(" "& $(!+. %)"4%0 0 %$ )4& +'' +. +"& "&+! +-*)-(4+"(!: )'%! "& +''.(4+"

' $ - )!- 4"(%! D 4" +" (!"+!4 ' "("(%! J.+!-% %8! # . 3+!"'++:+'& %#"%C%$"& +$% 0 !"(%!

! - *)-:0 !"+ F F"+4" -& )!- G # !"& 4+ %$"& +'' ..+!",8 8& !"& ( 4"(%!D+''.(4+"(%!8 - 4 4(- -,/+ -%!+8+-(! % %#B+!-;%$;DB,"& 3 7+ +0 +8+ +- 8 ' !-(!: (! +'' +. / $% "& (:& %)"# %8 3 , %.

.. 4"%'%4 - -"%4%!(- "& ( +''.(4+"(%!+!-- 4(- -"& +0 %! # <#<<<#& +$" ,$ &+''.(4+ +"(%!)!- 4"(%!D8+$(. - -%! C#< <#<<;/+ -%!"& *)-:0 !"%$ $"& (:&%)"-+" -B#<B#<<;

;#" 8+ "&(+''.(4+"(%!"&+"8+& .-"% %/ !%"0+(!"+(!+/. ,/ (!:+ 4 4%!- '.(4+"(%!# A# &%):& "& ( !% 9)+ . 8 8("& "& '(!4('. "&+" %!.7 + (!

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

!4('. ,"& (:&%)"(4% 4"+ +!-*)"($( -(!"& 3( 8"+2 !(! ! "& (0'

'):! - *)-:0 !" "&+" "& 4+!!

!%" / )44 (3 +''.(4+"(%! )!

!- 4 4"(%!D(!3( 8%$ +- '1)0 0+(5)'+6#)""&+"(!%""& '% '%(!" +( (!: $% 4%!(- +"(%! & # % -%)/", "& 4%!- +''.(4+"(%! -+ -+" - C#< <#<<; $% $(F+"(%! (! .(:&" %$ %$ "& +'' ..+" 4%)" *)-:0 !" ( !%" 0+( +(!"+(!+/. #%8 3 ,(!4 "& % %.. 4"%(+.%+"$+)."(!- 4(-(!: : "&

'.(4+"(%!8& !"& 0+"" 8+' !- -(!:(!+'' +.,8 + %$"& 3( 8"

"&+" (!"

"& ' 4).(+$+4"%$"& (!"+!"4+ 4+ ,"& +''.(4+"(%!-+" -B## ;; &% %).- / 4%!(- - +$ &# 44%- -(!:.7, "& +'' +. ( -('% - %$ $ + $%..

.%8#& +!-49)(("(%!%.. 4 4"%(-( 4" -"%4%!(- +$ & & "& 4 4"(%!D+''.(4+"(%!-+" -B## ;;+!-'+%- (!"& .(:&"%$ $"& *)-:

-:0 !"%$"& (:&%)"-+" -B B#<B#<<;(! ("'' +.%#A; +!- C< < %$ ;;C %! "& $(. %$ "& (:& %)" %$ %0/+7, !4& & +" ) )+!:+/+-# % !+/.(!:"& %.. 4"

4"%"%'+%- ++/%3 ,"& % -+"

" -#<#<<<( "+(- #%8 3 3 ,"& +0%)!"+. +-7'+(-+ "% %/ -).7 .7+-*)" -#H =D> )4&, (! 3( 8 %$ "& +$% +( - $+4" +!- 4(4)0"+!4 +!- F'%("(%!%$.+8 8/7"& %!I/. )' 0 %) )"(!4+ %$&++"(!:5)'+6 &++"(!:5)'+6 &++"(!:5)'+6 &++"(!:5)'+6 +6+6+6+6+ 8 .. + +!8+ +!8+ +!8+ +!8+ +( +!- %"& 5)'+6 +( +!- %"& 5)'+6 +( +!- %"& 5)'+6 +( +!- %"& 5)'+6,,,, %!4 "

"& ' "("(%! 56.+!-%8! 56 8 !"(". - "% 0+2 2 +''.(4+"(%! )!- 4"(%! D %$ "& 4" %! "& /+( - " 0(!+"(%! 0 0+- /7 "&( %)" (! "& ' !

!-(!: (" '' +., "& & ( ' !-(!:4.+(09 9)+ - " 0(!+"(%!%$4%0' ! +"(%!8+!%""%/ - 4.(! -8& &(. * 4"(!:"& (+ +''.(4+"(%!$(. -)!- 4"(%! D%$"& 4"/ (!:"(0 /+ -#

)"& 0% ,"& & $+4""&+""& ("'

'' +.' $ -+""& (!"+!4 %$ $ 8%"& .+!-%8 8! + "(..' !-(!:+-*)-(4+"

"(%!# =;> ! )4&4(4)0"+!4 ,"& (0'):!

! -%- -+" -;#<#<'+ - /7 '%!- !" %# ( & /7 " +(- # '%!- !" %# ( -( 4" - "% F+0(! "& +''

'.(4+"(%!-+" -<##<;' $ -/7"& ' "("(%! .+!-%8!

! 2(!: - "

0(!+"(%!%$4%0' !+"(%!/+ -%!"& $(!+.- " 0(!+"(%!"% %/ 0+- /7"&(% %)"(!"& ' !-(!: ( "'' +.+((!:%)"%$"&(3 3 7 +49)(("(%!8("& &(!"8%0%!"&$%0"& - 4((%!

!(!+(-+'' +.56#"(0+- 4.

. + "&+""& +''.(4+"

"(%!-+" -B<#<B#<' $ - -)!- 4"(%!D%$"& 4 "+" "& (!"+!4 %$'

' "("(%! .+!-%8! &+..!%" / - 4.(! -/ (!:"(0 /+ -# "(

$)"& 0+- 4.

+"&+"(!4+ "& ( "'' +.' $ -+""& (!"+!

!4 %$%"& .+!-%8 8! + -(0( -,"& ' "("(%!

.+!-%8! &+../ !"(". - "& / ! $("%$ !

!&+!4 0 !"%!"& /+(%$+8+ +--+" -?##<B'+ -/7 . +! - $ !

!4 %)" +.%!:8("& +.. %"& "+")"%7 / ! $(" +!- (!"

" '%3(- -)!- "

"& 4"8("&(!"8%0%!"&%$"& +-*)-(4+"(%!/7 '%!- !"% %## =< < < <> &( (%)"(%$"& $(0%'(!(%! "&+""& ' "("(%! .+!-%8! ,+" "&("+: ,+ !"(". -$%(0(.+4%0' !+"(% !+""& +" %$ #<,<<,<<<J ' +4 %!'+("7/ /+(,+:+!" -"%"& %"& .+!

!-%8! +.%!:8("&%"& "+")"

"%7 / ! $(" '%3(- - )!- "& 4" + ' +8+- - -+" - ?##<B '+ - /7 . +! - $ !

!4 %)"#& +(-+0%)!"/ -(/) -"%"& ' "("(%! 8("

"&(! "8% 0%!"& $% %0 "& -+" %$ 4 ('" %$ 4 "($ $( - 4%'7 %$ "&( %- )/* 4"

" "% $)!(&(!:(!- 0 0!("7/%!-"%"& "%"& $$ 4""&+"(!4+ "& +0%)!" + -)4 -(!"&

("'' +.' !-(!:/ / $% "&(%)","& 7&+.. $) )!- "& +0 # = > ( ( ( ( '% -%$$ '% -%$$ '% -%$$ '% -%$$+44%-(!:.7# => > > >#

!-(!:+''.(4+"(%!56,($+!7&+.. +.%"+!--('% -%$# 5 1 6 5 1 6 5 1 6 5 1 6

+4&

+4&B,< ,< ,< ,<A "(2 & & & "& ' +2(!:J +%! - & "& '%"+/. J% J%