High Court of Punjab and HaryanaARB/781/2025allowed

M/S Rattan Constructions v. M/S Pgimer Chanidgarh And Another

2026-03-12Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri10 pages

!"!

#$%&%'

()*

# #"

+, !

%%%%%%%

# + - +","

()* ( .#/!0+.#/#

+ %%%%%%%

"1 #/ # "

($ 23( % **

!"#!$ ! !"#!$! %%%%% *

%4 +56 &$ $ !# ' ( " ! )!# * ! +!"

!" ,,) ## !-". / $$!

0!#!'* ! $" 1 0# ' !*'#!#$! /! "! 2 3 "!('#!$ !(*0 4 0*5$

4( 5 ""! * ! "'( +'( $!

#! $$!

0 !# !' * !6(*0 $

"'( !'* ! !

* $$!

*7 8 "! !# $! 9: 5 " !5

0$0 *' '5*"(!#"!#'

"!# 5!#" !

!#" '

"*$'" ($!;(

0!#6!.*' ($0+!(

7 46 * ' 5 * '

( '' $$!

0 !# !' * ! *7 ! !# $

0$0 *' '5 6 #( (*0 "

$( ! *5$ $ ! ! "

($! $!

4(#! !/ * !"'(*( !$!5" #!0$! &#! (*0

6!.*'+!(07$$!

!'* !! ;(

"($!

$( <

! ' "!('#!$! 9:

(*0 !

4 "!# 0

4(!* !"'("! '!

!" ! !# * ! "'( *7 $ !*7 ( ! " 4(($!$! !5 "

!$'76#((*0 !*;" !!# $! "' 0!#$ ! 0* #! "! (!* *'

$( "!*# !* ! ""!

'7 $$ !07*

I have heard the learned counsels for the parties. ) & 4 " !# 0 "! * !

2 "'( 5'' !" !!#

"'(*7 ("!#! " !*

$( *7' "!('#!$! &!'7 !*;" ! *7$! "' 0!#$ ! 0 * & #!

!*;" ! *7 ' "!(' #! $! !( *' 5!#'5'

!5*76!.*' ($0+!( =

! "# $> %&%'( )*+' '!! ;(

0!# 6!.*'($0+!( =

!, - ,

$ ,

.)//0

.)1//. 2%&%'0) #! '5 !'! & ' $! ! !##!

;(

0 !# 6!.*' ($0+!( $

! 3 $!

(" (

""$ "!

"# $ "%

& '

&"'

" $#

< " #

( " "

$#(%" " " &"' !% )# " " "

" %

* ! % " + "#( ""% "%

( "#( , " " ""

-. /, .

0" (*

1(% !2.32"

4 0 0 ""

#"!

"%3

* 5 ! 04 0

"# !

( "" # % $ # , "

"#( " " # "

( ( " %

( " % " 789 : "

;2!%!

#02.3 2"

(" $# "# ( "< (%"" !

=# >"

?@0!@AB

, "

% " %

)

" !" %" "# $2.32" #

% )$ #% # "# , ( ( "# ! % ( ! " #

( $ "

% ( % "! , " "(% % ( ! %"$ "" %"! " "(" ")# "(! ( " " #") &'$ $!##!

;(

! , - ,

$ ,

.)//0

.)1//.2 '!

(" (

* 2 !% ! ( % "

" <( "# " ""# , " "2 "

"" ! (

""# ,

" "$ , %"" ! "% "# !# !

"# "# (% !

"#("" "#( ( %

( # "#

"# C <( !

"# ( !

"# "# ( ""% "

" , % ,# !

2 ( "# !

1" "

D D " %"

" ( $ DD

2><"

(0" " "# % "# %! % ! % (

"#(!

(!% (" $ "!

"# $

% " !

, #" ! ! !

# " " E "#"

%=#

""#" #) "#

2, 2 (% ("# " "

" # ""% ! !

"# !

"# ! " " " "

% " "

, : ' '5#!

!*;" !

0* (!#"' 0"!* #" ( " !!#" 0"'57*/$$!$ *#! ' * ! # ! ?( & '

?( 0#!$$!

0!#* !#! # $" 7!

: 5!##!

#" "

"(0" $ $ ! ''!5 !0 ! !"

!# 6!( @! ) "! !'

!* ' @!, <2) A0 ' !0B' '''7 !0 !'* !! ;(

$(*5$ (*;"!"!0$'

"!#(!7$! !

"'(

" ! !#"

" !$$*#!' * !! 0 $'"!*# 4 "!00( " *7' * ! "! " C''*$

!' * ! ""! "5 C!(" ('!#* !" 0 2 3 * ! '! ?( ! "!0$' $!"

$ 0'

$" * ( " ! ,!# " < ?(''! "!$7!#! *!

!0! !" %&%'

6 % 1$/ D! ED@!

1$!*' ED@!