High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/9770/2025dismissed

Renault Yamuna Nagar Through Its Director & Authorised Person Aditya Chawla v. Vijay Kumar Malhotra

2026-01-15Mr. Justice Virinder Aggarwal6 pages

!" #$ #

#$ %$ # "

' %( )(* )#+ ,

--- ./ -

(- +0( $123 /4 /

- !*(.50 ,*(3 /4 ( 2 .(- -

! -

(5 6-

2 4(7 *3 8( 8.2 2 2 .( 2 40/ 2 9((/(7 / *.(4(7 :*(/ 2 *( */(

(5 2 * #/ 2551 2 5157 / .(.(7 2 (/( // 6;-- ./ <7 2 5(/ //5 ( +*/13 8* 1( +1/2(

9*( %63 / 6-6- ./ <7 2 5(/ 45 +*/1 +*( 43 8* 1( +1/2(

9*( %- 2(*12 2 / (/(3 <2 *( 24 *((57 /5/ ( 2 .(= ..5 */( (/( #> *5 6? 2 / 45 %(/*( 01 2 1 / 2

:*/18 / /( // -66-6

9*( %@3 A55 2 / (/( // @-66-6B

9*( %?3 A22 (8/ 2 4(7 */ 2 /(- 6-6- 2 .( / 2 2 8.*1/ (/( *( (8 . ((( :*(/ / 8(5 ((1*5(7 8*2 2 *( <5A 5/ ..( 2 *<4 1(*/ A((1 (55 2 .(/1- # 2* *(1/ 2 (( 2 *( 8.(4 *( 2 / :* / .(4 2 .(.* 8 .(/*(5 :*- -

2 4(7 *3 (7 * 2 *5 8(9 141 ( 2 .( .- 2 (./C.5 */ 45 ₹ * 01 (4(7 3@3?C 51 A2 ( 1 2 .(C//- * 3 2 818 2 .(8.7 A 0 <7 *(.(3 5 ( (*5 (52. 9/ <A 2 (./ / 2 .(8.7-

. (5 D*(73 A /4(/ 2 $:4 ,*8(3 2 * 2 .(3 2/ 55*// A2 2 (./.5 / */ */ < /./ 2 <0 * 2 .(8.7 A2* *2(E- -6- # (.(/ 2 $:4 ,*8(3 1 ( A2 2 (./3 2/ 55/ 2 (8 2 .(= *8( / 5/ 2 /. D*45 2D* 2 .(8.7= *3 2(<7 (1 85/1 ..( 518 (- $:4 ,*8( *(/ 2 818 2 .( 2 2 A*5/ (5 2 8( A2 2 (./ / *( 2 2 45 * A*5/

< A2/(A- 571 *. 2 *(3 2 .(8.73 */( < / / 1* <5 2 2 /.* 2/ < 8<57 (54/3 ((/ (8 ..(1 <( 2 5(/ 45 +*/1- -- $*<D*573 2 .( 8 5( 2 2 * 2/ < A2/(A <* A3 3 /(/ 4/ :*/18 / /( // -66-6- # (.3 2 .( 5/ ..5 */( (/( #> *5 6? 2 / 45 %(/*( ( 1 / 2 (/(3 :*/183 / /(- "A4(3 ( /* /(3 2 ..5 A /8/ <7 2 5(/ 45 +*/1 4/ 2 8.*1/ (/( // 6-6-- ?- .57 11(4/ <7 2 *(( /1 / 2 /85 2 .(= (5( ..53 2 .( .(((/ ..5 01 ..(.

( (5 1 2 (/( 8.*1/ 2(- "A4(3 2 / ..5 A /8/ <7 2 5(/ ..55 *( 4/ (/( // 6;--3 2(<7 541 2 .( A2 5(4 (8/7 <* 40 2 *.(4(7 :*(/ 2 *(- D*573 2 .( 45 (4 . 2 < 5/3 51 2 51573 .(.(73 / (( 2 8.*1/ (/( / 01 ..(.( (( 2 ( :*- @- # 24 2(/ 5(/ *5 ( 2 .( 512 / 24 (*557 /(/ 2 *<8 /4/ 2 <25- # 24 5 8*5*57 1 2(*12 2 ( ..(<0 A2 2 <5 3 141 /* /( 55 2 /*83 .5/13 / 8(5 .

(/ *5 ( 2 .( 2 42857 *<8/ 2 2 .(8.73 A55 2 5(/ *( <5A3 24 < 48 /5<( (*/ (2(/ <7 $:4 ,*8(3 2 * 2 .(3 55* A2 2 (./C.5- # *(1/ 2 2 8.*1/ /(3 241 < </ <7 (*/*5 83 4/ / < / 7 1 2 ( :*- (/ *5 / 2 <2 2 (5 / ..55 *( 5/ 0 * 2 8(5 2 2 .(8.7 A 85/ / /(*// <7 A 8.573 /3 D*3 // 9( 2 :*(/ 4/ 28 */( (/( #> *5 6? % / 2( .(4 5A- 2 .(3 2((3 0 2 (4 2 *( (7 2 8 :* / .(4 2 .(.* 2 (*/*5 /(- B-

2 *3 /8/ 2 2 .(8.7 /*57 (4/ 2 * */ <7 2 (./C.5- . *2 (43 2 .(8.7 2 ..( 2 .(/13 (571 *( 551/57 14 <7 8.57 2 2 * A*5/ < A2/(A- "A4(3 A *8< *. 2 .( 8.7 9( /* /51 / 8( 2 .(/1 A (4/3 ((.4 7 *( (8 8.573 $:4 ,*8(3 2 *- 4 2 8.57 2/ */(0 (5 2 8( A2 2 (./.53 2 515 <51 ..( *( (8/ A2 2 .(8.7-

B-6- 2((3 :*/18 / /( A ./ 1 2 .(8.7 -66-6- 2 .( 84/ ..5 */( (/( #> *5 6? 2 / 45 %(/*( 01 / 2 :*/18 / /( 57 -;-6;3 A22 4( 12 82 ( 2 /( / A55 <7/ 2 *(7 .(/ ? /7 .(4// ( 51 *2 ..5- !4 2 2 .(8.7 A /*57 (4/ / 2/ ..(*7 .(. 2 .(/13 2 *( <5A (1257 5*// 2 * 1(*/ 9/ 55A 2 ..5 ( 1 / 2 :*/18 / /(- 2 8.*1/ (/( /853 2((3 ( 51557 */3 :*3 / (/ A2 2 .(4 5A- - # 4A 2 (11 /* / *.

(*5 98 2 ((/3 4/ 2 2 *( <5A 24 2( 88/ 7 55157 ( / 8( 2 < / < .(4(- 2 /1 (/(/ <7 2 (5 / ..55 *( ( 1(*// 5A / *..(/ <7 2 8(5 ((/- D*573 2( 9 :*<5 1(*/ ( 2 *( 9( (45 :*(/- 2 .( .

3 <1 A2557 /4/ 8(3 A2 (/( - ;- "A4(3 5(/ 2 2 <(4 8/ 2(<4 ( //3 ( 2*5/ 27 < (*/3 9.(1 7 . 2 8( 2 */(571 /.* <A 2 .(- 55 *2 <(4 24 < (/(/ (57 2 9 2 .( (4 . / ( / 557 2 /(8 2 . * (1 ( /( 2(- 2 8 ( // 1*/ 2

/:*/ 2 .(/1 / 255 3 7 8(3 .(5*/ 2 8. *( (8 /./57 981 / //1 2 *<4 (12 / 58 2 .( (/ A2 5A- - $ 2 .(.5 8( 2 < /:*// / / 5*457 /./ (/ A2 2 /( / /1 ((// 2(3 55 ./1 855* ..53 73 / A2 ( (1 * 2 8 .(/1 255 5 / /./ D*3 A2* (D*(1 7 *(2( (/(- " # $%&$' (&() Whether reasoned / speaking?

Yes / No Whether reportable?

Yes / No