M/S Rattan Constructions Through Sh Praveen Kumar Rattan v. Pgimer Through The Director And Another




































      
    

     

  !

"#$%&%'

()* " "!+, "!-+ ,.-*-% +/

"0,1+ "

    %%%%%%%

  "

+ 2 +!,!


( -+ ,.--  +  +"3"

- + %%%%%%%

!4 "3 "!

 (# 56( % *
*

*






  
  
 !"
#!

$  ! 
  

 !"
#!

$! 
















%%%%% *

*


%7 +89  &
$


$  !
# '
( 
" !

)
!#
 *  !

+!"

'

 !
"
,,)
 #
#
!

-
". / 
$$!

0
!#

!'
* !


$
"  1 
0
# '
!
*'#
!#
$! 

/
! "!  2 3
"!('
#!

$  !
(*0 


4  
 0
*5

$ 



4(

5 "
"! 
 *  !
"'(

+'(

$!


#!
$$!

0
!#

!' * !


6
(*0 


$



"'(

!'
* !

!

*
$$!


*7

+ #
8


+19
5 "

!5 

0$0  *'

'5
*"(
!#
"!#'

"
!#


 5
!#
" !



































!#

"
'

"

*
$'"
($!

:(

0
!#
6!.*' ($0
+!(


 

   
        :  79    *  '
5 


*
'

 ( ''
$$!

0
!#

!'
* !
*7
!
!#

$ 

0$0  *'

'5
6
#(
(*0 

 "


$(
! *5

$ 

$  !


! "

  
($! 
$! 



4(
)
#!
!/ 

*  !
"'(
*( !
$!
5
" 
#!0

$! 
&#!

(*0 


 
6!.*'
+!(
07
$$!



!'
* !
!
 :(

"
($!


$(
;



!

'
"!('
#!

$! <= (*0 



!

$(
 



4 "
!#

 0

4(

!

*  !
"'(
"! 
 



'!

!

$(
 



!" !
!#

*  !
"'(
*7
 $  !
*7
( 
! "
4(
)
($!

$! 
!
5 "


$! 

!
$'7
6
#(
(*0 


!*:" !
!#
 $! 



"' 0
!#

$  !

 0
*

#! "! (

!* *'

$(

"!
*
#
!
*  ! ""!

 '7

$
$  !
07
*

0  

 I have heard the learned counsels for the parties. ) &
4 "
!#

 0
"!  

*  ! "'(

5''


!" !
!#



"'(
*7
("
!#
! " 
!
*

$(
*7

'
"!('
#!

$! 
&
!'7





2


























!*:" !
 
*7

$! 



"' 0
!#

$  !

 0 *   &
#!

!*:" !
 
*7
'
"!('
#!
 $! 

!
( *'

 5
!#

'5
'

!5
*7

6!.*' ($0
+!(

>  

 

! "#  $?  %&%'( )*+' 
'!
!
:(

0
!# 6!.*'
($0
+!(

> 

!, - , 

 $    , 

 

  .)//0 

  .)1//. 2
%&%'0)

#!

'5

!
'! 

  
& '
$! !
!#

#!

:(

0
!#
6!.*'
($0
+!( $ 
  

 

! 3   
$!

("

( 





  





 














  

!

"#





"
"


$
  "
!

"#



$
 

 "


% 







&  '






 






&"'




"
 



$#





 "



 
#






(



"








;


























"


$#(
%

"


"
 "
 &"'





 
!%


 

 )
#

 "


 


"
 "






"
% 

*

 
 
!

% "

+ "#(

""%

 "


%




(

"#(


 , "



"
 "

"
 









-
.


 

/,

. 




0" 
  (
*

1(

% !

2
.3
2"

#


 

4 
0
 

0


 



  ""
 





 





#



"!


!




 
"%3

* 5

!
 
 
 

 0

4 
0


 







 ""
 












 


"#
 


!

"#



(

"
"
#


































%


$

 #
, "





 
 "#( 


"
"
  
 


 

#

 "





6



 


   (
 (

 "
%
  



 





(




" 
%
  
 "








 


789

























































































: 
"

;
2
!%


!


 
#

0

2
.3 2"

#


(


" 
 



$#

  





"


#
 
 




(
 
"
<

 (
%


"

"
  
!


 

=#
>"




 ?@0
!
@AB


 

,


 "


%
 "
%






   




%

 


"

!"

%"


"# 

$


2
.3
2" #




1


 





  






)


























"





%
 )

$


 


#
% #

"
#


 
 


, (

( 
  




"#  !
 

%


 (

  


!


  "
 
    
#



  



$




  (


 $

"

%

 (

%

"! ,


"
 "(


%
 
%

 
(

 !

  
%"
$
 

 
 "" %

"!
 


"
 "(
"
 
")

#

 "
(
!



   (


"
 "

 
 
 #

")

  &
'
$ $
!#

#!

:(

0
$   

!  , -  , 

  $      , 

   

  .)//0 

  .)1//.2   

'!

$!

("

( 

* 
2
!%


!
(
%
"


 "



<(

  "#
  




" "

"#






































,


"
 "
2  "



 "
"


 !
 


(
 





 ""#



,



"
 "


$


,
%""

 !
  "

%

   "#

!



#

 !

"#




 

 "#
 (
% 

!

"#(
"" "#( 
 


 
(
%

 



  


 
 



(
#

 


"#


  






 

 

 


 



 


"#
 







 C

<(
 !

"#



(


 

 !

"#


"#
 (
""%

"

 "


,




% ,
#




!

"#





2

(

  "# 
!


























































































































































1

" "







 





  












D  D
 "

 




%

"





 






"  
(

$

DD





 %








2
>
<" 


(

0
"
  
 "

"#





 






% 
"#
 
 


 %
!


 



%  !

%

 



( 


  





"
 













"

"#(

!

"#




(

!%


(
"



 $

 "
!

"#



$
 





% 

 "
!
 




 
#
" !
 

 !


!

"#








#
"
 "








,


























E
 "#
"

#



"

%
"


%

=#

>"







6












!






 ""#
"


 #
)

"#




2
,


2 (
%

 

 (
"#

 

 






 

 "


 "





 




 "
#
""%
  



!

 



 !

"#




 

 

!

"#





 
!
 


"


"
 "
 

"

%
 
"

 


"


"

  
 
 





, =


'
'5


#!

!*:" !
 


  0*
(
!#

"' 0
"!
*
 


#"
 
(  " !

!#

"


0
"
'57
*
/


$$!$   
*#!

'
* !
#
!
@(  
&
 '

@( 0
#!

$$!

0
!#

* !

#!
 #   
$
"

7

!


$(
































  =
 5
!#

#!

#"

"

"(0"

$ $  !

''!5 

!0
!
 !"



!#
6!( A! )
"!

!'

!* '
A!, ;2)
80 ' !0B' '''7 



!0 


!'
* !
!
 :(

"


$(
*5

$ 
(*:"
!
"!0$'

"
!#
(!7
$! !

"'(


" !

!#

" 
 


"
!
$$
*#!
'
* !
!
  0

$'"
!
*
# 4

"!00( "
*7
'
* !

"! "  C
''
*
$

!
'
* !

""! "
5 
 C!(
" ('
!#

*  !
"

0   2
3
* !

'!
@(
!
"!0$'
 $!"

 

$

 0
'


$" *
( 
" !
,
!#
 " ;

@(
'
'! 

"!$7
!#

! 
*

!


!0
!
 !"   $%&%'

  7*

*


9 %    



1
$/  D!


































EDA!

1
$!*'






























EDA!