← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/38357/2025disposed of

Pardeep Singh Pathania v. Union Of India And ORS

2026-05-06Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja12 pages

 

        

!"#$# % &'  (")* +$, $ #$#,      



    

       &+ -.&

 / 0/&      

           !  ! "

 !#   $%& ""' (!

")  * !"

+,   $-%. ////  0/& 1 % .' 0   ,) ()   (   2 3"

        454&5&- %

23 4!'   ,) $-

        



 ! "  #  $ %& (  ,)   

 "

 &61    7      6.%"*56789):'   ,

, ,)!



/ ;#< 8 !)

 ! ( ,)  

    

"     =(> ( > 0  ! %



 2    ,        ",!

"       

"  

   

 

     &&5& "  "

.

 6.  ( 

49&:  # ;5-- ("

 6. (  ,) 

;#< 7   !!

    

  !     ! "

 1 ?@".( B@ *( @() % * '



-;555<1 8

1 -5555<1 8

1 &;555<1 8<' ;555<1 8 +=

5555<1 * "2

;555<1 * "2

,

-;555<1  ;

< 

     !  

        !  ,+  "

 6    6.   (

 (   !) 

   >     

! (   !    

 "          "

 

     >  ( &&5- "

.55<1 !(   "

 !!2

! >  (  &5&55&   !     

 " (   

   "

 1 ?@".( B@ *( @() % * '

8

.&555<1 9&- !: 8 +=

655<1 95; !: * "2

4555<1 9.. !: * "2

,

.&555<1 9&- !:  >     (   454&554   !     

" (    "

 

     "

     55<1 !(  

!"

!! ,  "

&-9:9: 6.     "

6-5<1 !

;

< ;9<

!! 

   !       "! ?

 

!9:,    "(

(  

!!)

 

 +"   45&&5  

  ,  

!(  !    , 

  #8$# " 7888  !  

  

    !  "

 # $ %!    !& (  ,)   2  !"        !  (    "

 &-55<1 ! ; <

 

    ,     

   ( !!   1

  !   

   45&&5 ,     @ A,!   B "C (   

!     ,) ,      (      ,)   @ A,!   B "

 (   

   &-5&&5&-9

B" 1&:   ,) "

!

   

!   

        &-55<1 ! ;,< 0      &65-&5&-     ! 

 "

 &61    6.   ,     $-<7     "     1  

    2  !" 

   "  B &-55<1 !  ,)  " 

!!)

 ,) @ B "C(   

(    ,

 ,  ,) !

 ( !  !

   (  !  , )     

 45&&5  ,)   "(  ,) 2  !" (

&-55<1 ! @

  ( ,  !    %/'+4 .

   4.  ;!< 7  "

 !  ", 

 

! "    



"  

    



;9< !  (   

   1  <

2  !" 

"!

  (    

      &-5&&5&-   ,)   @ A,!   B "   ,) "

!

     

   ,)  "    &-55<1  !  2  !" 

  "       

  ( !! 

  "       

  

   

 "

 &61    6. @ "",  

   "

&61    



 "!  , 

,

, ,)!

  ( ! ( 

)95:) 





 &-5&&5&-,) @ B "  "

!  "

 !   !

"

  

     ,)   @ A,!  "

   "

  ' (( )* (!

+%  &   ,-- .

/ !

1&;%&  

  !

"

,) !  "

 !   B    "

 1 ' ()* +       !        ,   

  -

    !             

   

  (./ ,   ,     !   0

    ! 



 !    !   1

2* 3  ,      

  , 

 

(./ ,      ! ,     ,   ,   ,  !    ,        ! ,       % ,  /   ,     ! ,      !   0

    *  (4* 5     ,        

  * 6  ! , , 



   !  

      ,     !    ,   7

; <    

  %    ,   

  (./ ,  * 6  

,, 

9 !     ,   ,   89      ! , ,    ! %

 (./ ,  * 

 

  ,   0

    

89          

 

  

    ,   

 

(./ ,   !      ,   ,  * 6  ,     $   

  ! 



     7

      !  !   ,   , 

       7  !      !   0

  !   * :   !- ,  (./ ,        

 !     



      ,   * 6   ,          

 ,      

  (./ , 

*;  7  "

 !  "     454&5&-  ,)  $- !

,! ,       2  !" 

 " ,  1     &-55<1 !  ,   ) $ "

,     .

  / /  *  7  #4

   ;< 7  "

 !     $  % &1

    ",  

  (    

 

     &-5&&5&- 9

B" 1&: 

!     



! ( !!  

 

 

 45&&5  ,) "

"

 #$ %!01*(     " 

;,<

    ,     

   ,)   "    &-55<1 !(( ,) @ B ""         &-5&&5&-

    ) "       

 !  

"

&61 6.  @   

"

&61 6.

"!  !) ,     

""

        ,)   !    

 ",)  "

!(   )

( (     ,     

   ,)   7   !!

 ) ", !(@ "", ,   1 ( !   

"

&61  6. 

    

   45&&5  

 "

 # $ %!0 1 *     

 ,          &-5&&5&-  ,) @ A,!  "

   "(" 



,!   !)

,)  $-,

, ,)!

   "

 !  "

 !   !

 "

  

   ,)   @ A,!  "

   "

  23   !  4( $      /   1  )./ *#  *

 5 #   4$

)    !&      '

- $*#  6, !

1;%  

  !

 "

 ,)   !  "

 !    1

      B    "

 1 ' <)* 5         

     +

     !   0

   -

 

   (

# (=<4    ,   



  !    , 

 

,

   9 

   * 5    

         !   0

     +

   7 ,       !   

;!< 

  << ,   <.>?

     ,   

,   * 5    

      

         

  <. ,  <.>?

* 5    

        !     

  (./ ,   <.>?

        ,      ,   ,   -

  

  ,   0

*  <4* +    ,   -

  ,       , $   

2          , 

   

  (./ ,  <.>?

  !    ,   ,    

  ! ,     ,     

* 6     %

   ,      ! ,   -

  

  ,  0

  +  @*?(> , (=(A  (

# (=<4* 5         ,     

  (./ ,   <.>?

     ,      , (

# (=<4*;   $   "

  ,       , !    9:1

  / //  /  ;8< @

 !  "

 !     "   1,2< 

",

 ",  9:  , !    ;7$<     

   

"

   !)

 

 45&&5  

"

 #$ %!019"

:  2  !"  

       !  

    

"   > !!  !

( 1  

&-55<1 !?"  

!     



! ( !! 

 (    ,) @ B "

 (    

   &-5&&5&-9

B" 1&:0 @ B "

;< ( "2

 )!     

 ,)  "  3" "2  !" "

 !  0" 

!  

(     2  !" (  &-5&&5&-

" (   "

!

   45&&5   ,)  " ;7$ 7<?"   

   "! 

"

 "+"

 "

    

 

     ",

 "  

   "

 "    !  

 B 

     !

"

 

   

*+ ! .

/'**/

78,( 

 @ B " !"

  ' <4* 6     , ,

, 7 ,  

    

  <A4 ,   <>4A   <( 

  ,  !    ,        !  ,!* 5        ,   

   ,   6          BB CCCCCC (<* 6    ,               ,    

   ,          ,   6        

 

    / 

      ,          , 

  ,     , 7 , 

   * 6     ,   6  

 !

  ', ;  

           

* 6      ,  ,    ,   ,    

 ,   ,   6   , 

  ,  ,  * ((* 6     ()*<<*(==?



   

,     ',   ;   ,   , 

;8<

 ,   6  

 ,   * 6 ,    , 7 ,    =A*<(*<>>> 

  ,  ,    ** ()*<<*(==? 

 7  , =?*<(*(=<)    ,      , <(  , ()*<<*(==?* (A*     



   ,  * 

 ,    ,   %  !   7 

 

             ! , 

 ,* D   

  ! ,  !,           7 

   , ,   ,   

* 5      7     ! 

    

  !  

   , ! 

       ! %

 , !  !  - 

 *;

 

(   

 @ B " ! 

(   

!

 +"    0 ! "

     !

) 

!"

"

!



 "     "

 !("!  ! "

  

  " !

 B "   +"   C  ,

  (   @ A,!  "

   "

      &-5&&5&-   "  +"

              !   ( !!   

       ,)

!

D    

2  !"   &-55<1

! 5)!



   "

3"  ,!) "

      ,) @ A,!   B ;7$ #<    ",! 

  "  !) )

 (  ,)   

!!  ?" < 

!!  " ("!

;7$<    "   

!!) " ! 9:



"

&61 6. ," 

"

!

   

<   <

,) 

!!  " !!! ,!  ! 9:

2 

&61 6.  ,   "

 )  

 ,) 7(  "(



  "

"

 !

  

 

!

 ,)   

!!  ?" < 

!!  "            

!

   ,) 

!! ?"<

!!  " !

  ,             ,    ?" 

 ' ((0 1 * @ B " !,)

"  

    ,  !(

 

!  

 ,) 

!! " ("! 3"!!) "   

!!)  "  !   2

  1   

"

&61 6.   

,

, 

!!  !

 



 )  3"!

)

) 

  ;77< ?"      , !   ,)  !)

 "

   !( !  (

 23 0 1 *    

  "!      +"   !  (   " !   

  ! 9:

2 

&61 6.   ,   

   ,) 

!!  "        +" !        !

  

 

"

&61

   (   ,   (

    

   

  "    

    

 "

 &61 (

 "   &65-&5&-  

 "

 

!+"

   ,) @ A,!   B "

 +"  &-5&&5&-   3"

!) 

;77<

,    ( 

  ,  5) ( !!( 

 ;7#< 

( ,  " 

    !    

!       



  

!!)  !   ( !!

 ,)

" (   

    &-5&&5&-   ,)   @ A,!   B " ( "

!

     

 ,)  "

   45&&5(  ,)  2  !"    ! (

  <

 &-55<1 !         "             

 "

 &61    6.   ,     !!

   1  

 



    " ( 

         

    "

   

      



   &65-&5&-(",    , ( 

!

 ;7 < 

(        "    (CA    

"      454&5&-   ,)   $-    ,)      0  

      



 

 &65-&5&-,    $-   ,  ( 

!

5) " !) 2  !" 

 !   

 , 

!!)"

 !  &-55<1 ! ,)   @ A,!   B "

   

   &-5&&5&-



!)     

 !! ! ,  !     ,    2  !"           &-55<1  ! ! (   

 3"

!<"),  

   

 

 6. 9  "

11 : 

!!) 

   ! "( !!

;7#< ;79<     

   

      !  )   $-    "    !   



 "  ( 

    

   )   

 (

  <  !! ,  !

,!   )    55555<1   

(

!!, ,  < ( 2  !! ,    ,"     EB  3" ,     !!,  , ) 2

!   ;7 <  

!! " 

9:   ) !! !    &(?$,1#$#,  % 0/& ' % %E        %

1

F1@   ! F1@