Mahabir Singh v. State Of Haryana
!
" # $ % &'
(
)#* +,- '
%# )
+,.,/+$ %
"0 * +,- '12 !
"
' -. 4 '
. # , . 5 6 #7 # 4 # 8# !
! !1
9,:# ; # ' . . ' * .*
.!4 <=' #*># + # 4 #
! '!
# .
*4 6 .!4 .
%4 <= ' #* ?
+ ..4! 4 '
"Learned counsel for the petitioner inter alia contends that at the time of retirement of petitioner there was no pending inquiry or charge-sheet against the petitioner. The charge sheet was issued after retirement of petitioner and beyond the 4 year
$)$ statutory period. As such, the impugned order is not sustainable in the eyes of law and in violation of Regulation 10(2) of the Haryana Warehousing Corporation Pension Regulations, 1996. It is further contended that Regulation 10(2) supra mandates prior sanction and bars proceedings for events more than four years old. It is further contended that the case of the petitioner is squarely covered by the judgments rendered by this Court in Anoop Singh Vs. State of Haryana and others 2020(1) SCT 89 and CWP-96062022, titled as Khairati Lal Vs. State of Haryana and others, decided on 13.10.2025 (Annexure P-7).
On advance notice Mr. Piyush Khanna, learned Additional Advocate General and Mr. Vikrant Pamboo, Advocate appear on behalf of respondents No.1, 2 and 3, 4 respectively and seek time to have complete instructions in the matter. Adjourned to 28.01.2026.
In the meantime, the operation of the charge-sheet dated 08.12.2025 (Annexure P-5) shall remain in abeyance till the next date of hearing."
@ #. '12 ' -
* * ' + 4 '!8# %
! '! !
' 7
- . #. '
' #! + '
! 8#4 # * ' ># + ..!*## *
# % ' * ,# + % # % ' # % 3 # !
! # '
* .' ! #' # *'.%.!
$A . #' *# B
A 71 +
- ..4!
$%$
!" !!
!" # !# # # $
$!#$
$ $ !
$
!#$ $
!! %
$ !
$
$
$ & ' " ( )
"
" $
$ $ # $ #& #$$
# # # !
$
"
"# * "
+ $
"
!
# # #"
$ !
! !"
" $
"
" " # #
!
+ $ !
#
# ! # "
$
$($
"
#
!
" $ #,$ "
!
"
"
$
# $
$$" $ #
"
- . %
$ !
#
# ! # "
$ ! "
$
# $
# , $! "
/ 0 #
( $
#
# %
$
# $
" !$ $
$ -1 "
** ** ** " ! # # #$
$ $ $
! !
$
$
$ !
# "( )
3 !
$+$ # # # $
! $
"
* " 0 $ "
# # "
$ !
#
$ ! "
#
0
$ "
#,$# $
( !$
!"
! "
$
$ 4
$ !
$
$
" !$ $
$ -1 "
2 $$ ! ""
# $ #
$ # " $
$ $
!
$ "
+! $ " ! (5
$ 6 &. !
. '.
C#!* % # B #$ A
9; 3+4 - #
$,$ 0 $ $#$ "
# $ 0 ! $ $
$ !
#"## #
# 4 $
$ $# " 7 8 9 5"( $ ) 0
:
0
;<= , ! - ()+-!
$ " $
$ " $ " ) $ ) >#+ $$%
& ?@2 A ! B! # $ $ $
$ C $ " ! 7 8 +"
# $ $ $
$ "
$ C $
$ + $
" C
+ $
$ $ # "
" $ $
3 #+"
$ + "
$$ #
,
$$
C !# " $ #
$ #$ ! $
+$ #
%
$ 4 " *$ !$
,
$ #
$
! ,$$
" '
C 0
,
! ,
$$ 3 !
! $#
$
$
!
$
" $ $
+
# ?
4 ! $ ! #
$
$
# $ $
" ) $ ) ># #! "
$ !
# $
" $ +!$ $
-11/! # $ $
$ !##
#
$
" +A #!
$ $ $ #
# C" # "
+ $
" ) #
)3.-/-@ -D > E# (9
!# ) $ " $
$ "
$ %
$ "
%
$
$
C !
# $ C # $ + $$
%
& ?/
$ $ " " # $
!
! # %
$ 0 %
$ $
$ !
C $ # $ ( ! $
$ " $
$&$ " #
$
# $# # $
$ $
$
$ "
$
E
$
"
" #
$ 9# ! "
$ "
" $
$
$
"
# $
$ " $
0
# $
$ + $ "
+
# $
$ #
$ "$
"
#
@@?
1+ A $
" ) )3.1@1! 4 %(
%"() ( $$ )$ >
!
1@1D1@ + ) ! > E# ( $ ! $
! "
# + )
%") ( <00!
A ! $
"# + $$ %
& ?+* " $ ! $
+
" !
$ $$$ # .
E ( (
%" F ! @ ()+ @-G >E# (9 F !@ - ()+
. E E, 9 8%< . > F !11 ()+@+ "
# $ $
$'$
! " # . "# "
%") ( !< 00 $
$ # $
+ $ #
$ "
,$
9# ! "
"
+ #
11/1-
#
$ 111!#$
-11/1+*
$ #
$ -7
! $ # # $ # (
" # # ! $ # "
$ HI$$ " * $ B 8 , ?
E 8 )
A ## )3.1D11D!
. E E, 9 8%< . >
! 111@+ )
$ " $
"#
,$ #
!# "
+ $
%
& 9
$ !#
#
#
$ " $
# ( "
0 #
! ) 9
%( :9 8%< . >
) 3 .D11/! 2" !11/ # #$ " # %
9 5"( $ ) ., :
0
!40
$*$ ( $ ) DD/ 0 " # %
A 0 # " !###$
A $
'!11D D 3
11I $
! $
!
$
$ # $
$ $
0 ! # ! $ " @I$
$ " $ ?
+ A #
" ) #
)3.-//1/! 9
% !
)$ ( !
%"
! /1D1+ ) # "
$ C !
$ # $ "
A + $ %
& ?.#! A # # $ "# J +$ -11) #
/1/
+ # A " 0 # $ # $""
$
$ $
$ ! # " $ $
9# ! $
"#
$ " #
4 !$ #$ $ # * $ "
# HI$
$ 6
$$ 6 ,*.%+
! 4 # * % # %' # % 4 #
. %.
4 7-4 #
-+ ' ' ..4
! !1
9,:# ; % 3 ' . .# ' * . ' .!4 < =' #*+ .#.
4* * *..
# . .D ! )&*)*), . ' 0!5 E51 '
. E51