Rohtash Kumar And Another v. Superintending Canal Officer And Others
!
"
!
!#$% (%)*+*&,
--
&.$#+.
/01#2 #,&$.%2 ------ %$*$*&,%2+ 3%2+0+ 405%2*,$%,(*,6 #,#7
''*)%28
%2&9%502 #,#7 *2)7% ------
%+5&,(%,$+
%2&9%502 &$.%2+
: ;
4 4
2%+%,$ 24--4- *,,#8 (<&)#$% 5%$*$*&,%2+-
2- #252%%$ 4*,6.8 0,=#>-
- - 4
;
- 2#?%2 0,(%2 2$*)7%+ &,+$*$0$*&, ,(*#8 *,$%2 #7*#8 *++0#,)% ,#$02% )%2$*&2#2* +%$$*,6 #+*(% --
8 5#++%( !%50$?
&77%)$&28 >&.#2
+.&2$ :!%50$?
&77%)$&2: #7+& --
8 5#++%( 405%2*,$%,(*,6 #,#7
''*)%28
%2&9%502
+.&2$ :4 :-
- 2*%'7?8 +0>1*$$%( #557*)#$*&, >%'&2% !%50$?
&77%)$&2 +$#$*,6 $.%2%*, +#,)$*&,%( B -
%$*$*&,%2+ )7#*1%( #2%# 7*%+ #2%
- $ #55%#2+ !%50$?
&77%)$&2 05&, )&,+*(%2#$*&, 1#$$%28 2%=%)$%( )7#*1 5%$*$*&,%2+8 <*(% --
-
-
%%7*,6 #662*%<%( #6#*,+$ --
8 52%'%22%( #55%#7 >%'&2% !*<*+*&,#7 #,#7
''*)%28 >&.#2
+.&2$ :! :8 @.*).
)#1% >% #77&@%(8 <*(% --
8 .&7(*,6 #2%
-
%%7*,6 #662*%<%( #6#*,+$ --
8
52%'%22%( #55%#7 >%'&2%
@.*).
#77&@%(8 <*(% --
8 @.%2%>?
(%)7*,%(-
- , #'&2%1%,$*&,%( )*2)01+$#,)%+8 .#<% *,+$#,$ >%'&2% &02$ +%%C*,6 2%7*%'
+8 #+ ,&$*)%( .%2%*,#>&<%-
- %#2(-
55#2%,$7?8 #552&#).%( )#,#7 #0$.&2*$*%+ @*$.
52#?%2 +#,)$*&,
'#<&02 57%# #2%# '#77+ #2%
- .% #'&2%+#*( 52#?%2 )&,+*(%2%( !%50$?
&77%)$&2 +#1% 2%=%)$%(8 <*(% --
-
- 7$.&06.8 #55%#7 >%*,6 52%'%22%( 5%$*$*&,%2+8 !
<*(% --
8 #77&@%(
5%$*$*&,%2+D .&@%<%28 '02$.%2 #55%#7 >%*,6
2%=%)$%(
&>+%2<*,6 #+ 0,(%2
! "
#$
$ $ $%
" &$$ !# " %
%
" &$$
$% " '
$
$!
$ $( ) $ $
$ $ * + , $
$ $ $ -
!)
$ .//
" $ .//$/
$ $ $ 0 . 11 2331145611 25511
$0 ..//$/
5611 25511 4 56112551
$0.$ 0 .
( $ !
$ $.
/ 7
( 8
$ $
9
7
8
$
.//
$ $ %
" &$$
!
$
/
$ 7
8
$
#$$
$
! $
0 . $ .
/ $
0 578$. + " 4 %
# 5 $ 56: ) ; # #:23 !
$%
" &$$ !# " %
!# $ % " ! # '
/
$
$
( < -
5%20+#7 #'&2%+#*( '*,(*,6+ 2%$02,%(
@&07( +.&@ >%%, (%)7*,%( 52*1#2*7?
62&0,( #CC# $#C*,6 6*<*,6 (&1%+$*)
'#77*,6 8 @%2%
- %'&2% &02$8 *$ ,&$ >%%, (*+50$%( )&0,+%7
5%$*$*&,%2+ '*A%(
B 8 @.*).
)&,)%(%(7?
52*&2
- - ,
!"# $ $!
#%
'&77&@*,6 &>+%2<#$*&, 1#(% +
$ .
/ 7 8 $ $ $
< - <%, &$.%2@*+%8 '2&1 5%20+#7 +*$% 57#,
B8 *$ %<*(%,$ 7#,(
&.$#+.
/01#2 %%$# +.&@, &2#,6% ?%77&@ )&7&02 7#,(
#=5#7 ;%%70
#1 +.&@, >70% )&7&02-
$ '02$.%2 %<*(%,$ '2&1 +*$% 57#,
B @#$%2)&02+% E0%+$*&,8 ,#CC# $#C*,6 '#77+ 52*&2 ,#CC#
4*,)% ,#CC#
'#77+ 1?
)&,+*(%2%( <*%@8
.#<% 2*6.$
- .#$ #5#2$8 &02$ $ & ' (
)*
""+,-.%/% .%7( E0%+$*&, 2%6#2(*,6 62#,$
1#$$%2 502%7?
@*$.*, 502<*%@ )#,#7 #0$.&2*$*%+-
B- &,+*(%2*,6 $&$#7*$?
)*2)01+$#,)%+8 +*,)% 2*6.$
>%%, 6*<%,
#))&2(*,6 52*,)*57% #(&5$%( )#,#7 #0$.&2*$*%+8 ,& '#07$ )#, >% '&0,( @*$.
+#1%-
-
%+07$#,$7?8 *,+$#,$ '#*7+ +#1% #))&2(*,67?8 (*+1*++%(-
- %,(*,6 #557*)#$*&,
+8 *'
#,?8 +.#77 #7+& +$#,( )7&+%(-
4
!
--
+=C+ .%$.%2 +5%#C*,6 2%#+&,%(
"%+
& .%$.%2 2%5&2$#>7% "%+
&