High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/503/2026allowed

Shivam Gupta v. State Of Punjab And Others

2026-02-23Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra15 pages

!"#$%! &&&'%%()'* +'*,#,

%!%'(-#).!/!)0(% '*, ',$()0')%, 23 +!, )(!,, &&&'%%()'* +'*,#,

%!%'(-#).!/!)0(% '*, ',$()0')%,

*&(& !*%4#5!*, '%!5,

#$ %" &

' $( # "! #

# $$

* $$

$(+ ") (+ # $$

)

##$"%$

6 78

- .

/" 0"+ 1" 2!

2 !

0"+ 2!

1 3

+ 2!

#""

2"$ + 2!+

4 3 + 2!

5(# 0 + 2!

#""

# 1" + 220+ - %

1 % 0($+ 1" 1"

6""

0 + 2!

# ,

3 #"" " #$" 7

""$ $") '" #"! # "+ ( !

$ $( %"

"# "

- ( #""+ )"$

1" &8 3 "(

, "7 7 1"+ +

#$" % "

, 298:9+

!! "

#$%# & #+ )"$

" $ 0

1 !" ;

2+ <

- % 0 1 !" ;+ <

"%$

1" " 1" =

0 1 !" ;+ <

# ) "!"

#$" # " )" + $( 9 /

$"$

-! >+ 9 1/ $"$ -! > 9 = " >>-+ $$ !"

# ""#$ #$ " > " 2 # # "+ "

)" !"$ =# ;

" %" "!"

" ##$" 01 " " " $$ +

# ;" # "

) "

#$ " ) $ "# ;

## ;"$( ₹ !"$ -

: " 5" "" + "" +

> "+ # "

1" < 2

: )"! $" # ""

""$ # " ) " )" 9 /

$"$ -! >

9 1/ $"$ -! > "

# ) # " -""

/" ? ?" % " #"+

#"" 1"! # ?" 9 /

$"$

-! > ##" : 9 1/ $"$ -! >

##" ) + #

1" < 2

<: #$"9 "" ) "

)) )"$ " ) #$"

) $"" ! ##$""

%"$+

! "" $ ") ""$ " +

> " : $ 2""$ 1"

+ > " + #"!$(

$ 1" $ ## "

#""

1"! # $$ $ $ ## "

#"" /"

? ( ! )$$( "#$" " " 7"

)

9 /

$"$ -! >

9 1/ $"$ -! > $( " # #"

$ "" " $"

# )

# " " " "!"" $) $ ! "

" ( "$ # "

#"" /" ? !"

?" ) " #"

#"" 1"! # ##" ?" 9 /

$"$ -! > : 9 1/ $"$ -! >

#"" ?" + % (

#")" $ ! "% #"" + ""$

$"%"$"( "!$! (( ))"

# "$

"!"

" " "$

#$ "

" # ""#"+

" "!$! "" ( )) '"

9 = " >>-+ " %" #"" /" ?

6 %"

1" 17"

# " 6! + " >>- #

$ $ "( " " "!"" "# "" )

# #" , ;

%$" %

$( "

" >>- " $!$$ #$"+ ! ") 7 ) !$ +

"$ "$ " )) "

#""

# $ )

& ""$ - #$" +

!"$" 2 "$ &

" " =" " ## "

")("

"( "

# !"" 1" < <&

2 )$$ , %$ ")"

# " !

"% " "

#")" "% " ""$ + "

" "

# " " % # $ (

( " $ ;"

!"" ( ( ( %" ""

# "

%"$ "+ ) +

#"" ! $$ !

$ %"$ = ## "

+ $ $

! $"

# "" " !'( #)$ * +, ,- ./ # #0$* +, / . %012 $ +34

" 5# 41 $ * + ,+ !1 1 - $ 6/ + / 7 6$ $/ &) #!$ +8 9'

/-833 ./

8) & $ + 34 / -833 / !21$ +34 /-833.

91 0#$ &7 1 + $ $ $ ,1107 /6 " /

1 #1:$1

7 ;

6 ".

#!! )#$&7 1 + ,1107 -833 +

%<$* +, !11- $ + 7

6$/$+ #)00:1$* +, #

/ 8:( !$ +8 9'

.. 7

6$$ &# $871 !! 1

# //6 7 $.$

21 $ &7 1 +

# 66 . 7 $ $ # 01$&7 1 +

7 ; ,1107 / 7 $$ #( ! $&7 1

7 ;,1107 = 1* "

# 6 7 6$ $$

1# #$" ! )"$ # ,

> $ # , + " $ 1

7( #

)" + ! #$( "! $ "

$ $ ;

7 ) $$( !"$"

=# ;

" %" )7

" "!"

#$" $ ( )"$

) #$" "!"

" " "+ "

)) $ "% ""$

" " ( $") %"$

$ $

# "" " "% ; "

# # " #$"

"" # "

1" <

<& 2 1" < <& # $ "!"$

+ ""+ ! ( ;+ " +

#$(

= # + ) $ !"$

"$"@" =

<8 + % %

"!" !$

+ %$"

"!"

( +

)""$ "$+ 01 + ( %"$$ $("+ "

"$ !"+

! $"

))"" # !"" 1"

2 A $(

")(

1" :

2+ " ""

#$"

1" < <&

))

) $$"

!" "

"A " ( $$ )

%""

A "" " ) - ""#$ ""

$( "

2$$ " "$ $ $ )

#$" +

) + "

#$" $$ ( # !""

#$ $"%$ !"" # #

"" %$ $" #$

# #) 00:1>7 + " 6B%$ # % !

$$( " $ ( $ # "

1" < <& 2 %) """"

""$ # "

1" 6! + ! " ) $

+ # ! + ") " "

))

1" 2 ;

+ )$$ "" %" 1" 2 ))""

"(+ "" ( "@ %$

" %$"!

)$"

# "

+ ") ; %)" %"$ "$$ $"(

")" "( # $ ") ""$

" + > " $ 2""$ 1" + > "

$""

# (

%"$ "+ +

"! " + "$

" $

" #"" $"%$ ""

" "!$ %""

3) # "

" # (

%"$+ " $ # ! $7 $! ( # !""

" 1" 2+

:&#), "')%-(*4'*%!)(--')4',&; :

< (' '* 4(""%, !)= (- % ' -(55(>)? (--')4',9 )!"'5=6; !

,#$$5', !)= ?((0, (* ,'* 4', (* /(% >% (#% ,,#' (- !)=) (4'9) (5!%()(-% '$*( ,(),(-% ,4%(*% ' *#5',"!0'% '*'#)0'*9>% % ')%')%()%(' !0'%!@A / ,,#', !)= ) (4' (* /55 >% (#% ,#$$5= (- ?((0, (* ,'* 4',(*/(% ) (5!%()(-% '$*( ,(),(-% ,4%9(* '*#5',"!0'% '*'#)0'*5'!0)?%(>*()?-#5! !5"')%(*

#%5,!%()(-)$#%%!@4*'0%(**'-#)0(-%!@A 4 ! !5,)$#%%!@4*'0%#,)?,#4 ) (4'(*/55*'-'**'0 %()45!#,'/ A, !55/'$#), !/5'BB )4!,',> '*'% '!"(#)%(-%!@' !0'0(*% '!"(#)%(- )$#%%!@4*'0%>*()?5=! !5'0(*#%5,'0(*% '!"(#)%(- *'-#)0>*()?5=%!C')'@4''0,- ' #)0*'05!C *#$'',9>% "$*,()"')%-(*!%'*"> "!='@%')0%(- '='!*,!)0 >% -)'& )4!,',> '*'% '!"(#)%(-%!@' !0'0(*% '!"(#)%(- )$#%%!@4*'0%>*()?5=! !5'0(*#%5,'0(*% '!"(#)%(- *'-#)0>*()?5=%!C')'@4''0,%>( #)0*'05!C *#$'',/#% 0(', )(% '@4''0 - '

#)0*'0 5!C *#$'',9 >% "$*,()"')% -(* ! %'*" > "!= '@%')0 %( % *'' ='!*, !)0>% -)'A )% '4!,'(-!)=(% '*(--')4'> '*'% '!"(#)%(-%!@ ' !0'0(*% '!"(#)%(-)$#%%!@4*'0%>*()?5=! !5'0(* #%5,'0(*% '!"(#)%(-*'-#)0>*()?5=%!C')'@4''0,()'

#)0*'05!C *#$'',/#%0(',)(%'@4''0%>( #)0*'05!C *#$'',9>% "$*,()"')%-(*!%'*"> "!='@%')0%( ()'='!*!)0>% -)'A

% # $ %! " # !"" $!

% )) ( ""

" ( "# " * + 1" 8

2 $!+ # "+ ))

2 # %$

$ "

" ! $

# 6B%$ # "$$ ##" )

) )" $( &! 0#$ + *$8$ # .6 + " 6B%$ #

" $ )$$.

C $ # $ ""$

# #" "+ "

%( #

%$"! "

"$( 6! +

""$ $ !

#$ #")"

)) )

$ # $ # )) D

"# )

""$

'?*!)%(-/!5,% '?')'*!5*#5'!)0$#%%)?!$'*,() ).!5(*)!$*,()(*)!4(**'4%() ("'> ' '* '@$*',,() ()' "!= >, %( #,'

, !) '@4'$%()

E) $(+ %" # ""#$ ##

! $ "

# %"

" $ # " "

(

""$

" "$ %7 # !""

$% $( $ "$( ;#$" ""

$"! -)# 7# ## $ * + ,?.6 .. .@

%7 (

= ""+ )

')# 0# '' $ + 8 9'?.

@" " % ! " $ ( %7

-0$(0! ?,.

/1/ @

"$ " ) $

! $ 3 7# ?, .

. 11 @ " " % !

) $ ;#" # !"" )

$ $"% $ " # " # !""

$ ( $+

%7 $"$ (F

"$$ $ # # )

94#$2, . . / " 1" 6"

) A

# ""

)) "

(

))

" " "!$!"

# #$" + "

1 ;A #"%"$"( #

# "

!" 6B%$ # % !

) $

$" "" " "

$+ $

;+ ) " # " $

"+ "

$( % " "( "

# " ( # ""$

$"! "# "+ $"!

1 7#"

"+ #"

"$+

"+ 7# "!$(

( + %) ) !""+

"$$ %"

"""

! " # A "

GGG GGG

& ' " )

" ))

" '

$ " ) )) + ")

# !+ (

# " ( ( 2

"+ $ "

)

"!"

( $ ( #$ "!"

$ ( )"$ %) 1#"$

+ 3=+ , ?$" ) + "

( ( ( "!"

" '

!" ##$$ "$

"$ " "" $$(

## " ;# 3=F

1""$ % !" 6B%$ # 8$ #!'! $ &7 + + 7! .

( !1$12 +,0 # ,

6 $

= !" %! " "+ " #""

$ "

"# $"

" )) "

" ) $ ;#"+

## "(

"$ 6! + "+ " !"%$

"@ $$ " )) "

(

%" '"$ " "

%"$+

!"( ))

#+ A " 7 " " "

!"(

) ) " !"

" $ # "%

)) ! " '"$ " "

# (

( ))+ "$ "

" ))+ "

$ " ! ( "

" )) " % $!

# > "$

"# # !" %

# " "$ ""

# (

" ( # " )" %$

%$"! " ))H

!"( H

""" ! "( " ! !""H

"! %"

)$"

") $

%"$H

! + %!" + + #"" "

!" $"7$" )) %"

!"" %$ ## " " %"

# "H

!""" + +

" %"

%"$

) ( "" $"

## "

# (

%"$ = !' ( #)B

# + 6"

"" ##$"" )"$

$ # " )) " "

1" 1" 2 '"$

% !"

!" ;

;

# !"

1" " " # !"

"# " "

; ( )"+ )

$ (

" " & #$"

"$ $"7$( 7 " !"

( + 6B%$ # #

$ %"$ = # # 0B

# + 6"

" 5"#

"" # (

#"" + "

# "

:& )7 )"

! ;

$"%"$"( 6B%$ # $$

1#"$ >! -"" )"$ 7"

" " "

) ( # " :

))

" ;"

" ( "# " % !

" ## # " 7# "

( (

* + % 0 1 2 B

# +

" = $"

$ 1 ;A

%" % ! 6B%$ #

!( $ ;A

! ( )) "

( ; %)" %"$

= 5# 41>

# + #"" ( # "

"" )) "%$

1" 2 '"$

" "

$ (

"$ $"7$( 7 "+ 6B%$ # "

##$$ $ %"$ $" $ #$

# 6B%$ # % <B

# +

" # ""

))

2 "

%"$ 6B%$ # $$

##$ )"$ 7"

" " " )

( # " < + )"$

)) " ;"

" ( "# " '"$

+ 6B%$ # )$$"

% !".

D<' !*' ,#*$*,'0 %( )(%' % !% ) ! 4!,' 5C' % ,9 % ' !$$'55!)% !,/'')0')'0% '/')'-%(-/!5!%!555' '5,9 )45#0)?% '?

(#*%!)0#5%"!%'5=9 '>!,-(*4'0 %( !$$*(!4 % , (#*%& ',' !*' % ' 4!,', > '*' ) )(*"!5 4(#*,'9 /'-(*' % ' *!5 (#*%,9 % ' !44#,'0 , (#50 ?'% /!5 #)5',, % '*' !*' ,("' '@%*! (*0)!*= 4*4#",%!)4',&E

1""$ % !" " &)

#!B + 8) & B + ! 21B + 91

0#B

1#1:B + 8:B + &# B

B + # 01B #( !B

, ! "

# " "

"$ %"

?" 9# 9 /

$"$

-! >+ 9 1/ $"$ -! > 9 = " >>-+ (

7" $( !"$

"$"@ ) $ =# ;

" ₹

%" "!" " ##$" 01 " "

$$+ # ;"

# "

) "

" #$ " 6! + $"

( " # "( # 7"

# #

)

"" $"%"$"( ;

!" ;

$! # !""

2 #$" $ ( )"$ " #"" (

( " <: ,"

" (

")( " # "

" " %! " ) "

$ " "

)) "%$ ;"

( $ 7#"

" + " ( $$

")" " " + !"

# $ "$$( ( $ "+ "$$

))""$ "+ "+ ( ## "

# " + """"

")$ "

" " ##

")" "7 )" %$ % "

#"" "$ " " $" $$

# + " " "$ $

" ""

2 $ %! " "+ #"" ! %

%( $$ ( $

# $ % " $"7

")" 9?

( "

)$$"

"".

( $$ #" "

## + ") (+ %)

$ "$ H

% ( $$ # "$ " 7"

(

( H

( $$ # # " !"

""""

# "@"

"$H

( $$ "# ( "

# # (

)" 9#" ( ! %"$ "

"!"

( $$ " $ ( ""$ "!"(

"" ( " ) %"

$ %"$

) ( $$ # !" "$ "

$$ "

% "$

3 ( %! "" $$

$$"

#""

$ % !" " %! $(

# ""

# #"" $$

;# " #"" " "

> ##( " #$ )"$

#$ !"