Milan Rani Saha And ORS v. Pranati Bist And ORS
1(a).
Smti. Chinu Rani Saha, wife of late Sunil Saha @ Sunil Chandra Saha 1(b).
Sri Subhashish Saha, son of late Sunil Saha @ Sunil Chandra Saha both residents of Town Pratapgarh (Central Road Extinction) P.S. East Agartala, Dist- West Tripura 1(c).
Smti. Sonali Poddar, wife of Bijoy Kumar Poddar, daughter of late Sunil Saha @ Sunil Chandra Saha, Resident of Melagarh, Rajghat, P.S. Melagarh, Dist- West Tripura .........Appellants -V E R S U S1(a). Smti. Pranati Shingha Bist, wife of late Quar Bahadur Shingh Bist 1(b). Smti. Nikita Shingh Bist 1(d). Smti. Gayetri Shingh Bist all are resident of 19/15 Faltu Line, Dehradun, Uttarakhand 1(c).
Smti. Bharati Shingha Bist, daughter of late Capt.
Quar Bahadur Shingha Bist, C/o B.R. Mahapatra House No. 351, Bileek Bihar,Banbaychak, Jharseegora, Orissa .......Respondents
1(a).
Shri Subhash Ch. Ghosh, son of late Purna Chandra Ghosh, resident of Netaji Subhash Road, Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, Dist- West Tripura .........Appellant.
-V E R S U S1(a). Smti. Pranati Shingha Bist, wife of late Quar Bahadur Shingh Bist 1(b). Smti. Nikita Shingh Bist 1(d). Smti. Gayetri Shingh Bist all are resident of 19/15 Faltu Line, Dehradun, Uttarakhand 1(c).
Smti. Bharati Shingha Bist daughter of late Capt.
Quar Bahadur Shingha Bist C/o B.R. Mahapatra House No. 351 Bileek Bihar, Banbaychak Jharseegora, Orissa .......Respondents
1.
Shri Tulsi Paul 2.
Shri Bijan Paul both are residents of Netaji Subhash Road, Agartal, P.S. West Agartala District-West Tripura .........Appellants -V E R S U S1(a). Smti. Pranati Shingha Bist, wife of late Quar Bahadur Shingh Bist 1(b). Smti. Nikita Shingh Bist 1(d). Smti. Gayetri Shingh Bist, all are resident of 19/15 Faltu Line, Dehradun, Uttarakhand 1(c).
Smti. Bharati Shingha Bist, daughter of late Capt.
Quar Bahadur Shingha Bist, C/o B.R. Mahapatra House No. 351 Bileek Bihar, Banbaychak Jharseegora, Orissa .......Respondents
1(a).
Smti. Chinu Rani Saha, wife of late Sunil Saha @ Sunil Chandra Saha 1(b).
Sri Subhashish Saha, son of late Sunil Saha @ Sunil Chandra Saha both residents of Town Pratapgarh (Central Road Extention) P.S. East Agartala, Dist- West Tripura 1(c).
Smti. Sonali Poddar, wife of Bijoy Kumar Poddar, daughter of late Sunil Saha @ Sunil Chandra Saha, resident of Melagarh, Rajghat, P.S. Melagarh, Dist- West Tripura .........Appellants -V E R S U S1(a). Smti. Pranati Shingha Bist, wife of late Quar Bahadur Shingh Bist 1(b). Smti. Nikita Shingh Bist 1(d). Smti. Gayetri Shingh Bist all are resident of 19/15 Faltu Line, Dehradun, Uttarakhand 1(c).
Smti. Bharati Shingha Bist, daughter of late Capt.
Quar Bahadur Shingha Bist, C/o B.R. Mahapatra House No. 351 Bileek Bihar, Banbaychak Jharseegora, Orissa .......Respondents
1(a).
Smti Milan Rani Saha, wife of late Krishna Chandra Saha, 1(b).
Shri Laxmi Kanta Saha 1(c).
Shri Shibu Saha 1(d).
Shri Ramdas Saha
1(e).
Shri Shyamdas Saha 1(f).
Gurudas Saha all are sons of late Krishna Chandar Saha of Shibnagar, Agartala, P.S. East Agartala, district - West Tripura 1(g).
Smti. Lika Saha, wife of Shri Bimal Kanti Saha, resident of Shibnagar, near Modern Club, P.S. East Agartala, Dist- West Tripura .........Appellants -V E R S U S1(a). Smti. Pranati Shingha Bist, wife of late Quar Bahadur Shingh Bist 1(b). Smti. Nikita Shingh Bist 1(d). Smti. Gayetri Shingh Bist all are daughters of late Quar Bahadur Shingh resident of 19/15 Faltu Line, Dehradun, Uttarakhand 1(c).
Smti. Bharati Shingha Bist, daughter of late Capt.
Quar Bahadur Shingha Bist, C/o B.R. Mahapatra House No. 351 Bileek Bihar, Banbaychak Jharseegora, Orissa .......Respondents
Shri Gopal Ch. Saha, son of late Gouranga Ch. Saha, resident of Netaji Subhash Road, Agartala, P.S. East Agartala, Dist- West Tripura .........Appellant -V E R S U S1(a). Smti. Pranati Shingha Bist, wife of late Quar Bahadur Shingh Bist 1(b). Smti. Nikita Shingh Bist
1(d). Smti. Gayetri Shingh Bist, all are daughters of late Quar Bahadur Shingh resident of 19/15 Faltu Line, Dehradun, Uttarakhand 1(c).
Smti. Bharati Shingha Bist daughter of late Capt.
Quar Bahadur Shingha Bist, C/o B.R. Mahapatra House No. 351 Bileek Bihar, Banbaychak Jharseegora, Orissa .......Respondents For the petitioner/appellants :
Mr. D. Chakraborty, Sr. Advocate Mr. P.Chakraborty, Advocate For the respondents :
Mr. M.Kar Bhowmik, Sr. Advocate Mr. S.M.Chakraborty, Sr. Advocate Mr. R.R. Dutta, Advocate Mr. Shankar Bhattacharjee, Advocate Mr. Raju Dutta, Advocate & Ms. A. Dhar, Advocate Date of hearing :
07.05.2015 Date of judgment & order :
27.05.2015 Whether fit for reporting :
Yes No √
! "
# $%$$
$ & %$$ "
# !'%$%
#
!
"
# '%%$$
$ & %$$ "
# !%$%
# %
! "
# %$$
$ & %$$ "
# (%$!! " # ()
! "
# '%$$
$ & %$$ "
# !&%$% "# '
! "
# %$$
$ & %$$ "
# !(%$%
"
# &)
! "
# '%$$
$ & %$$ "
# !%$%) *+ "
,
- "
# ). ) )/ *
/
) 0
/
""
2
*
/
*
* +
3 +
/
1
% +4+ 56
/
1 / " *
%( %7
!" # $ $ %! !!% & ' ' ' # $ (
& $ ) * ' & # $ * + 5'6 8"
* /
" * 1 /)
*
1 / 5(6 3*
"
1 /) *
) *) + :
) ;
*/
- ( %% %$!&
8<
( %$! 8< ;
# '!)/) =
"
=
%$!
= > = ) %$!)/ -
* * / / *
8< % -
*
) *)+ 9 :
) ;
2
- *
- % )8< ;(/ * ?/") /
/
2
- ) /
) 2
- ) /
#
/
) + 9 :
5&6 8" =>=
)
@
-"
;
) )/ *
A A "
"
< ;
< ; ) /
"
;
"
" /
;:
"
"
/
"
:
;
"
8"
<
)
) *
/ *
"
:
*"
*"
"
* ) "
/ <
*" *
"
);
# ';!) " 1
*
) *
/"
*
*
"
*
*
/"
*
*0
*
0
A # '
* B ")*
*
*
) / " 1
) "
)
"
/
*
* )
)
;
# ';!
*
/
C
"*
/ *
5!6
"
E
*,
A
F # ( /
# ( *
$ & $ "
7
,- & .& / * 01$2 3 4 4' '4 01$"( 01 $"5 ( 01 $"5%( 01 $"5 ( 01 $"56( 01 $"57(01$"5 (01$"5 (01$"58(01$"58( ' ' &
9:;9:$ 4 4 << '
: =
>& 01 $5!( $5 <($5 $5 % % (& 4 ? 56 *)
*
/
('
' = > = :
/ 56 :
" *
$ & $
)
# $) # $) # $$) # '$) # '%$
# '$ :*
!
/
3 )
/
7 <9 2
9:;9:$( !
<( .& & 6 $ : =
>&
1
& 6 9: ;9:$ .& 9 & @
9:;9:$( & ''1
$ 9 2 & 6 9: ; 9: $( & .& 2 ( A3 & ( ( & 2 9
2 & !! 9: ; 9: $ : =
>& !6 '9:;9:$ '1 '
: 9'( %!
0* '&
& : 9' &' & !! 9:;9:$'
: 9' ' &
9:;9:$( !
< %- :=
>& ' B@ ' & 4 2 2 $ & * & ' & C
& & ' 1 4'
-' '' '1 D
' *
01$01$"58 ''&
9:;9: $ 4 4 <<'
:
>& :=
>& 01 $2% 01$2!01$2 % %(D
> / ' & ' - ' & &
& D
> ( & .& 4 5$6
)
( & "
# %$!! 8< :)
& ! %) "
# %( 8< :
% ( "
# %% * G ?
+ 8< : /
D H=B +4+ #
/
"
# %$!!
:*
( &
8< :)
# %$!!/
B
( & 8< : 0
7 8 - 6E 4 * &* ' ' - F 2 2 : =
>( : > G A
(: A
: 4 G A
4 6 / /
01 ' : '
$ ' ' & %< 0
"7 0 01 $ 2 ' :=
> & 4 4 <<
70
$ 4 4 << D
$ '
7 - ' %/
$ > %% & & ' 4 012 '
$ > %% & C 2 :=
> 4
$ ' 4 4 << D
$ D
A3 7 $ ' * 4 &
$
!
' & * '
' F 2" & ' 6 !
$>-
.& 4 & .& 6 $>9 D >: &
9 :& 9 : $ 4 '
2 & ' - ' 01 ' / A
'' :=
> ' / ' <<! 7 $>( & 7' ' &: % ' FF A4 & ' : =
> # 01 A26 ' F ' '
FFA4 01
&
9 :& 9 : $ 4 2 2 & ' ' / '
9 :& 9 : $ EF 28 , ' 6 7( ( & 2 % ' &
( ( ' & .&
7 % ' 2 .& & 2 (( & ? < $ & ' H (
' ( & ' * ' ' & :=
> & - '& G ( !
$> - / A
1 H( '& ( &
& A
& F ( 4 A F2%( H > F2 ( F / >
F26 2 D
> / A
& 4 01 '
$'1 %<<6 !
$>H'& ( '4 & F ' & 1 F 2! & - ( '& ( F F A4 4& <7<" !7!$> &
A
A' (A (
$ ' 1 F% 4 A
A' ' 1 F A
& F < '
A F A
& F% 4 A '
&
A ' (A
$
%
' & ' : =
> 1 &
$ 4 !7 $> F A
& ' / A
4 : =
> ' $ F / >
( . H ' '
$A F% 4 A F 2 < 122 F % & '
& F A
& :=
>& F% 4 A F 1 ' '' ' $
$ '& 4 ' (& :=
>&' $ : =
>& 6 ' F / >
( . ( H > F%' ' F / >
( . ( H ( $ ( #4 (
A' # '
' 1 ' &
:
>&
$ 1 ' '
' ' 4' ' &:=
>&# F : =
> & ' ' ' 1 &
$ ' 4' : =
> ' 1 &
$F 2
- & ' F :=
>'1 & ' & 4' ' :=
>
H' :=
> &:=
> ' / A
- ' 122 :=
> 4 / A
-
' : 4 '( '& (
: =
> :=
> !7 $> 7 & : =
> 1 !78 $>
:=
>& (& & :=
> 1
$
F% 4 A ' :=
> :=
>$ 4& 4 4 << :=
> H F 2 % 4 & ' '
1 6 ' ' 6 4 & A F H >' 8< !"!$> 122 !5%< 4 '& ' ' 4 !
< &F%4 A F #
1' :
: !6 $> 1 * ' : : =
>4 H ' : 4 #
'4& :=
>' & 1 <* ' 4& !7%# & 1 ' ' ' D
A3 & ' ' : =
> 1 & 6 & F ( H > & > 1 ' % ' ' 4
1' F 2 D '& -( ( & 'F6 F / >
'
$ $ !
<5 $> : 6< ' ' &% $ ( "
A:A4
D D F ' ( # & D ' ' H ' ' 7 F 7 D
> ( >
$
$ 7<5%<< H <<7 !"! $> '
& " 8 4H'' ' ' &
*
& 6 ' '' 1 ' : =
> ' & ' F //> F" . D
F 2 6' 1 ' D
A3 ' & ' ' ' 1 & 01A2 01 A2 ! -& & ' & & ' $ F / / > 1 I2 D
A3 ' . 44 : :G' > ' : :G' : H
' : : G' ' ' A
& F" . D
& ' ' & & " '& : : G' & '' F FA4 G' : :G' 01 > ( FFA4 <7<" !7!$> 2 7
: 7<52 4 01A2A2 ' '
: <<52 $ & H & ' 2 !7!$>H1 01(A2 01A2 ! 01A2% '' $ C & ('& ( '
A 01A2 ' $
( !7! $> '
- ' !7!$> 01 A26( ' ' > % 4 H '' '
( A 2 '
!7%57 $>
'
' & > $ A4'
> ( FFA4 !7%57 $> $ 4 & >" > A4 ' H & >
'
1 01A2 > >7 $4 . > . A'4 '& & > FFA4- & & &
8 & - &
& > F - & F 7 D
> *
* & 1 4 & / ' 2 " 4 # & F ' F& & :=
> &
'
$ - 3 ' & 4 & ' & ! -& & &
9 :& 9 : $ & 9 D >: * /01 :=
>* & A - / & % ' ' & :=
> 4
& '' - # /4 - ' 01 A26 F 4 2 8' 9 D > : ( '& ( ' *
F - * ' ' / ' :=
>' - & 6 9 :& 9 : $ & ' ' A / '& ' /- '& ' ' ' ' & - * : A F $ & : F 9 ( $-: !"" F " % %< 9 D DF
9:;9:$ ' * & ' H('& ( &
9:;9:$ 2 & ' A
$
:
6 9:;9::
( !
% * 4& ' ' * H ' :
" 8 ' * 4 & $ 4 A ' :=
> * & 9 D >:
& A * & ' & & & F 7 D
> '
$
!"% $> * 1 4 -
4 .& % &' &
&- / .& & %% - E-&' - 6 - ? )0 + 5%6 :
" *
,
# %$!!
+ - ,
. )
# %(/ / *
- ,
) . ) :*
& ! % 8< :
/
*
7 ! &
& 9: ; 9: $ $( !"7 ' %" #( !"7 ' B @ ' B@ ' & &
&( F 5 %' , ( ,& ' ? ? A % ' & & & & & ' , ?( , & %< 9 ' ' &
' 3 & %
$ !
< !"7
$ $ %"<% !"7 %"<% !"7
% -
' 2
' ' & & A & & $ ! <
< $ !
<4 & --- $ !
< -J * <% $ !
< & & F J($ !
< &
F 5 6' " $&
& &4 " $ !
< , 4 '&.& 7 & 4 4 , ? 8 $ !
<
& ' :
4 ' :
!
' - 9 :& 9 : # 7 :
"%% :
!
%% = " $ !
< 4 &.& .& 1 1 ' ' 2 %
$ !
< ' ''
.& & 01 ( ( '
2%
$ !
<
$ $ !"7 , ? %"<% !"7 5 7 %"<% !"7
$ !
< '
$ !
<
$ !
< & $ !
<H 1 ' ' 1 - .& - 01 '1 01A64 01 ' ' 4 &
01A26 01 & # H@ :AF&: F $-: !"" " % %<
, '& ' ' ''& $ & ' & ' 5 C <G !7 ' # ( & ' ( (' & & ' ( & ? % - &
3A' '4
& &
3A & & F%
3 A & & %6 01 %
& 4 0&
4 ' 01 % 4 & & $ !
< 4
& 4 01 7( % 4 F7&
& 4 -&' & ' & * & 5 " 5%%6
& ! % "
# %$ /
*
)
# %$!!
G ?
+
# %% :*
% ( 8< :
/
"
*
/
% ( * .
) * 7 A /
' &/ % ' & 01A6F $' 4
$ '&
( '
& - & )0 + 5%6 2 +0 *)
*
"
/
*
% ( 8< : * G ?
+
# %%)
;
0 0# ' *
*0 0
# %$!!)
/ ?
/
8< :
: "
)
" )/"0
/
*
*
" "
8< :
8< :
"
3
* G ?
+
0 0# '2 +0 *)
*
/ "*
*
* " 1
;
/
5%'6 " *"
* *
/
G"
8< 8< *
"
*
,
# %$!! 8< : D
* /" 5%(6 3
2 2 A :/ 0)
<
# %
;
1 * + 1 /
/
+ / "
*
% +4+ <
H3 & F
' ( $-: %<< !
7) / 7 $ ' ' ' ' * ' B @* ' ( & ' ( & ( ' '( * 'B&& @ * &
* '
$ ' H
* && - '( ( && ( K & 4
'
& 5%&6 2 A:/ 0)
C & J
' A/ C ( $-:%<<6 !
)/ " 7 % ( H & & ' & &4 & & 2 & H (
& 1 & ' 4 2 & << F- &'(
H 1
( 2 4 & * '
<< F %6 - ( ' & & @ ' 0& &' 2 & & H &' 4 '
%7 H ' - '
1
' ' & (H ' 2 & &'' )0 + 5%!6 2 2 +0 *)
# *
# %$!!
( & "
# %$!!
& ! % "
# %(
% ( "
# %%
" *
1
?
" ?/") *
"
*8< :
8< : / *
;
0 0# '
0"
" * / 5%6 2 - )
# %
*
8< :
8< :
* G ?
+
% ( "
# %% 0 0 # ' / * - ) ;
# ';!
0 0 # ' "
G"
/A
5%6
) / "
"
B )2 - )
4D &D C ( $-: !
<F & 7" (/
E
"
0
/ / / / I :
D " #
D)
'(++%!%)
7 " $ 2 4
( ''& 4' ' ' ' &
4 1 & - ' & 4 ( 2 4( ' 2 4 H
4 ' & & 5%$6 1 " *
/
( & ) 8< : )
& ! %
% () 8< : ) "
"
/
* 8< :
8< :
*
" 2 - +0 *)
*
;
" ;
1 / 56 2 A :/ 0)
1 * 1 /
1 "
" * )
*
; ;
5%6 2 - )
/ * 2 2 A :/ 0)
*
/ B
"
8< :
: /
" *
"
);
# ';!" 1
/"
* * /""
*
*0
0
A # '
* B ")*
*
*
) / " 1
)"
)
"
/
*
* )
)
;
# ';!
*
/ 56 B
B / )
*
) *
*
*)
" "
*
*
5'6 /*
)
*
/ "
"
B ;
/ - 0 0# '*
* 8"
";
* *
* 1
%'!=>= )
*
*
G" "*
G" 8"
0 0
/
*);;
)" *
G" * "
%'! =>= "
*"
# %$!! D A
"
J 8< ) 8< %) 8< ) 8< ') 8< () 8< &) 8< !) 8< !) 8< )8< /"
"
;
"
1 *
*
)/ *" 5(6 8"
*
8< :
: / /
:*
*
- ) ;;
)
0 0# ' *
;
" * 5&6
+ )
8< :
:
< *"
# %$!!
;
/
" 1 / B )
<
$
: & / 4 0 A C ( $-:%<<8!78 * B
*<
* /"
"
;
" /
" 1 / B ) "
" *
"
)
/ - J & D4 $ !!! 7"
7 % ' &
H << F
'' ' & ( & & ( & 5!6 ?"
/
*
+
*"
/
"
*
/
"
*
" / A
/
) *
) /
"
"
* 56
*
/ / * " "
0 "* A
:
:
*"
* +
A
* < *
/ /
" *
* / *<+
:A F&: F 9 (
$-: !"" " %)/
/"/
/ / / *"
" * /
A / "
.
) *"
8< :
8< :
" " G ?
+
"
4
0 0# '
)
/ *
*
0
%'! + 1 *)
"
" * /
8"
<
B ) / F 56 * 2 2 +0 *)
*
# %$!! / 0
0 # '
0 0# ' 2")
< *
5$6
# %$!!)
0
;
)
@
-"
0
/
0 0# ' 2
) 2
:J) / # %& / )
"
1
,
( & 8< : " *
/* A
/
* %'! % =>= )
*
,
* A
G"
B
)
# " ;
)
@
-"
0 0 # '
%'!=>= "*" /
* 1
"
"
5'6 "
/
*G ?
+ 0 0# '
# " "
* G ?
+
% ( "
# %% 8< : "
;
)
)" 5'%6
8< :
: ) + " *
* 2
- ) "
"*
*"
)
1
* 5'6 B
)
@
-"
* 0 0# '
" * "
0 0# ' ?
" *
B " )
"
*/
"
/ 4* %)/ "
7 0& (
'( ' ( ( ( 1 (' ' 5''6
"
)
* 0 0# ') * /*
""
# 5'(6
/ 5'&6 -/
*
/ =+