Arun Chandra Dasand4 ORS v. Bimal Ch Andra Das And 4 ORS
1. Shri Arun Chandra Das, son of late Abhoy Charan Das 2. Shri Ajoy Das, son of late Abhoy Charan Das 3. Smti Prativa Rani Das, daughter of late Abhoy Charan Das, and wife of Shri Radhika Ranjan Das, all of Kacharghat (Daulatpur), P.S. kailashahar, North Tripura 4. Smti Pranati Das, daughter of Late Abhoy Charan Das adn wife of late Suresh Chandra Das of Chantail, P.S. Kailashahar, North Tripura 5.
Smti Joyanti Das, daughter of Late Abhoy Charan Das and wife of Shri Manik Das of Bazaricherra, P.S. Patherkandi, District- Karimganj, Assam ....... Defendant-appellants -V E R S U S1. Shri Bimal Ch. Das 2. Shri Shyamal Das, both sons of late Brojendra Das @ Brojendra Kr. Das, residents of Village -Bhagyapur, P.S. Kailashahar, North Tripura 3. Smti Parbati Das, daughter of late Brojendra Das @ Brojendra Kr.Das, wife of Shri Arabindra Das 4. Smti Jyotsna Malakar (Das), daughter of Late Brojendra Kr.Das@ Brojendra Das, wife of Shri Sudhangshu Malakar.
all of village Bhagyapur (Dhanbilash), P.S. Kailashahar, North Tripura 5. Smti Purnima Das, daughter of late Brojendra Das
@Brojendra Kr. Das, wife of Shri Sankar Das of Fulkumaripara, P.S. Radhakishorepur, Udaipur, South Tripura ......Plaintiff- respondents For the defendant-appellants :
Mr. A.K.Bhowmik, Sr.Advocate Mr. R.Dutta, Advocate For the respondents :
Mr.G.K.Nama, Advocate.
Date of hearing :
08.04.2015 Date of judgment & order :
08.05.2015 Whether fit for reporting :
Yes No √
! "# $ %& ' (
"
) *&
$ + %& (
' "
) " $, -
./ 0% %&
$ + % "$, -
./
2 3
%& & *
'4*
) ' %& 5 " 6 . % ! "# $ ' (
"
$ +
%
7
!
"
# $ % & ' & # % ( ) * ++, & ** * ** *% - .- *
/ * % 0 .- *
* / $ *% !
.- *
* 12 $ 2 3 *
* * * **
* * *
4 162 3 8 &
! " # $ %
%& !
/ % 8 / /
()5
*6
*8
9 ()5 & *
6 7
* # *8
/
94 1.2
/ % & & % 8 / & /
9 ! ) */:
% % /,-
8
;
5
% 8 /
&
% 5 % 8 / % 8 / /
%
/
/7 ()5 : /
& * *
6 7
* 89 ()5
* * ;</
;<= 2 ;< ;<$ ;<; 9
() 5 : /
*
*
*
9 2
% 8 / & %
% /
:
) <
= : 9
&
& > '
$ ( 6 ? *:
' /
) <
? = :9
&% / & *:
'
% 8 & = : 9
&
&%&
'
6 6? " ) ' < ' & ' % /
: / *:
' /
*:
'
& / / *:
' / % &!%& ' *
' &/
!*:
'/ )
;
& : & & *:
' /% &!%& ' *
' % / & > #6
% &*:
' !%& ' *
' & &/ &/ %& ! & / & *:
' *
'
& / &% & & &/!%& ' & & & % / !%& ' :
&*:
' & % *
) ' & & ) * ' !
) * ' " 6% % * *:
' % *
' % "+ !%& ' % " &
&
" 6 & > #6
@
& %
" & > #6
" + & > #6
12 '
& %
&
&9 = ' 0 &/ &9 ='A /
B
,=3=- &
% % !3,! 3 - /
3% ".6. !3%&
$
&/*:
' / #6
!
$ "
/
"
# 3 ) "
%&
!3 !3
/
& / *:
' 5 > #6
!
&/
)" $ # $ # 9 ) !
)"$ # $ # *:
' #6
&
" 6 & &
& 5
/ & / 1+2
!%& '
% ".+#
%
(
! / / % 8 & 5 %
" # + & *&
'% /
&
& /
"
# +
/ & &" # +@
& % &
: # & "
/ % &
% %
& 1$2 "+ &/ ? & & (
' "
) %
7 # *
*23 $
/ $ 2 $
&#% * +!0
23 $
6 7
8 ** * *
*
&# * +!0 #
* ** 6 7
8 > ** * 3
* *# "
&#% * +!0*
*
> ** * *3
*
*
*
%&#% * +!0 * < * > *
* *
2 '
$
/ $ 2 $ & &#% * +!0* * # "
% & ' # 8 ?= %
*
*
*
4 * * * 23 $
/ $ 2 $ *
&#% * +!0& * # *8/
* ** # *8
> ;<= 23 $
. ' @
&
% 0 * >
$
' ;<= % '
$ *
" ()23 $ * / $ ;<= ;<=- / $
& ;<= ;<= - * ** 2 $
23 $
;<=, + + # $ 23 $
/ $ 2 $ * 1>7$ * 23 $ * .-
2 ;<=, * # 6** * * *>7 $ #**# 6** ;<=, > 7 $ *
'
@
23 $ >7$ ;<= # # 6** % & '
*
* ;<=A # 6** $2 ;<=, > ' $ /#6 ' 7 *
* :
*
* ** * /
% 4 ; %
/ 2 */:
% %&
% & %& ' (
"
/
/ !
" +/ % / % 0 % " +/ & ) " "6# $:9 '% :/
*&
0 & !%& ' *:
' *
'/ % / !
/ / % % 9 )
9 )
)"6
/ )"$ # $ # /
%
$ ! 3 12 ?
%
>%
%
%
%& 3
00 =
/ /
% %&
12 */:
?>%5! ?>%5* ?>%5 ?>%5' ?>%5? %
%&
?>%5! // / %
%&!%& '?>%5*) / / !%& '?>%5?
& &//
%&*:
'
"
) ' % % 9 /
+ %
% %&
C = C = ! ?>%5'
> %&*:
'
+ % ?>%5?
& $ +
.3@ + 1 2 0% % " .+#% 5 %
" #+
/ ;
%& 9 */:
&
%
&
%&
&
162 @
& 9 */:
%
75 ,- : * ** <* .0
() : * * *
* **B .0 () : * *
3
* *
*
( ) * **B .0
() : * * *
B * 3 () : *
* **B
( )
* () :
. * *
* * ** () : *. * *
, - : *
* 1.2 */: %
%&
% &
/ % :
!
> 1 ()@ ()6
(
) # AA!
/
! >
& C% /7 +A- # -A @
>
7
- & C%
* 3*
&
?
* * * 5 * * 3* - / ' 8 D
@ *1 368 3 7'
* - $
2 / ' $
3#3# D- & * 3 * * * * -- * E 6*1# 7 F * * -, *
* *
& <
** 1 2 */:
! >
#*6
/ > > ( )- # ,-0 / % 75
* &
*
* *
4 & * * * &
* *
** 4 12 */:
/ %& >
&
/% /!:
>
/
> 1 ()@ ()6 %
/ %
& & %& * & C %
> 1 ()@ ()6 >
% %
% A
/
:
& / & #*6
/ >>%
%
! % /
/
/ &@
%
/
0
% % % 3
&
/ % ? %
*
@ /
/ & / & % /
5 & &
/
/
1+2 ;
% 0
& 1$2 / C=