Tapan Datta v. Anil Debnath And 6 ORS
!"! # $
% $ $
& $
' (
$
) %
* $
$
+
,
-
$
. /
0
1
%, * $23
1
45&-6&&6#+ 7 4 = √
( % , * $2
&
#66 ,,
4 4 2 4 #66.&669 3
6&:&669 $2 ;
4
' 4
0 4 $
8 00 $2
23
$
8 0<
!" !# " ! $%%!&&$"! '()#" '$* #!+!#,! " ! -!'#!! (. " ! (#/0/*$&1"#/$& '()#" #!&2/*0 (* $ -(')3!*" 4 /5/" /*$-3/,,/5&! )*-!# " ! %#(+/,/(*,(.!'"/(*66(." !+/-!*'!'"7
)
2$3
$
8 0 $ 4 2
4 #66.&669 2$
4 '&'
+#9) +#9-+#9.)-+&
)-+'% > $
$2 ? #':'.) #-6-#9@+
*
4
'6-) % >
/
4 3
32
$ 32 *
#).@
$2 3 $
0
0 $ $ 24 3
A 2 #99@ $
4
3$ 0 $2
&66.
3 *
$
$
?
&+6-&66.
$
$ 4 $2
?
$ 4
&):&66. 0 , 3 ;
4 ; 3
+
$2 4 0
4 3
0 4
0
#9@@ 0 * 04
.
3
A 4 0 4 $
. 0 8
2 $2
- ?
$ 40 4 0 $2 < C# B
$ D & (
D ' (
E 4
3
FE
D ) B2
D + B
4 2D - 7
0
8 2DG
.
A 7# 0
0
2 % * , * $2 $ A 7&
$ 4 3
2 *
'6-) % > HIA$#J 4
#':'-) HIA$&J
2
+HJ% > HIA$'J
2 *
#).@ % > HIA$)J 1
0
2 $
H 7#J % * H 7&J
2 7'J 3$ A @
2 0
3
2 4
6.69&66- '#:&66+ HIA$J 2 % * , * $2
0 '#:&66+ HIA$KJ 2 /
0 '#:&66+ HIA$J 4
0
'#:&66+ HIA$J
2
'#:&66+ 0 0
0 4
HIA$J 9
4 3
4
3 3
3 0 3
%3IA$0 0
. 0 * $2
$ 4 4
3
$2
#- $ 4
#6
44 3 $2 4 #-6#&669 3 &):&66.
9-,, ;
4
$ 4
6&:&669 2
4 #66.&669
0
2 0
4 4 <
*" !'(*"#$#2" !$%%!&&$*",,/-!3$/*&2#!&/!-(* " !,"$"!3!*"(.3"/8),)3$&$$""$9" !%&$/*"/.. (.61:; !#!/*, !$-3/""!-/* !#'#(,," $" " !$%%!&&$*",$#!%(,,!,,/*0" !,)/"&$*-$-+!#,!&2 *!$#$5()".(#2!$#,$*-(*" !'(*"$#2, !;$, *(" %(,,!,,/*0 " ! ,)/" &$*- .(# 2!$#, ! $%%!&&$*", ,/-! ,)53/""!- '!#"/./!- '(%2 (. '#(,,< !4$3/*$"/(*(.3"/8),)3$&$$""$/*61:
()#" 4"<(= " " ! ,$3! "/3! " ! $%%!&&$*", ,/-! $&,( %#(-)'!- '!#"/./!- '(%2 (. (#-!# (. ;/" -#$;$& -$"!- >?@ /* '(**!'"/(* ;/" 61:
()#" 4"<(
!2 $+! $&,( ,)53/""!-" !'(%2(." !%&$/*"(.61: ()#" 4"( " $%%!$#, .#(3 " ! ()#" 4"( " $" 3"/8),)3$&$$""$9(*!(." !%#/*'/%$&(;*!#(. " ! ,)/" &$*- ./&!- 61: $0$/*," " ! $%%!&&$*", .(#-!'&$#$"/(*(. !#"/"&!$*-%!#3$*!*"/*A)*'"/(* " .)#" !# $%%!$#, .#(3 " ! ()#" 4"( " $" " ! 61: ;$, ;/" -#$;* (* " ! %#$2!# (. 3"/ 8),)3$&$$""$".)#" !#$%%!$#,.#(3" !'(%2 (. " ! %&$/*"
()#" 4"( " $"
&(" (, :?B1:?@1:?>9 &$*- 3!$,)#/*0 @B $'#!, ;$, " ! ,)/" &$*- (. 61: " " ! ,$3! "/3! $&,( ./*-" $"" !,)/"&$*-(.61:/,$&,($%$#"(. " ! ,)/" &$*- (. B1> /* #!,%!'" (. ; /' " ! #!,%(*-!*" %#$2!- .(# -!'&$#$"/(* (. "/"&! $*- %!#3$*!*" /*A)*'"/(* 3"/ 8),)3 $&$ $""$9 " ! %#/*'/%$& (;*!# ; ( ;$, " ! %&$/*"/.. (. 61: $*- /* " ! %#!,!*" ,)/" (. B1> , ! /, $&,( /3%&!$-!-$,%#(.(#3$<-!.!*-$*"(>3"/8),)3
$&$ $""$ /, (*! (. " ! %#/*'/%$& (;*!# (. " ! ,)/" %&(" (:?B1:?@1:?> (. &$*- 3!$,)#/*0 @B $'#!, ; /' /, " ! ,)/" &$*- (. 5(" 61: $*- B1>3"/8),)3$&$$""$5!/*0" !%&$/*"/.. (. 61: ,%!'/./'$&&2 -!%(,!- /* !# '#(,,< !4$3/*$"/(* ()#" 45"
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
,%(*-!*"$*-" !%#(<-!.!*-$*" (, :9 @ $*- > " ()0 $+/*0 "/"&! (+!# " ! !*"/#! ,)/" &$*-9 5)" " !2 $#! *(" %(,,!,,/*0 " ! ,)/" %&(" (, :?B1:?@1:?> $*- $, ,)' " !2 $#! *(" !*"/"&! "( 0!" $* (#-!# (. %!#3$*!*" /*A)*'"/(* $0$/*,"" !$%%!
0 0
0
2 0 ## ( 44 4 8 4 0 4 4
. HIA$J 3
#& % , * $2
4
$
2 4
'' I3
#@.& 0 3
<
66 !&!+$*'2(.'!#"$/*!+/-!*'!.(#%#(+/*09/* ,)5,!C)!*" %#('!!-/*09 " ! "#)" (# .$'", " !#!/* ,"$"!-< +/-!*'! 0/+!* 52 $ ;/"*!,, /* $ A)-/'/$& %#('!!-/*09 (# 5!.(#! $*2 %!#,(* $)" (#/D!- 52 &$; "( "$E! /"9 /, #!&!+$*" .(# " ! %)#%(,! (. %#(+/*09/*$,)5,!C)!*"A)-/'/$&%#('!!-/*09(#/* $ &$"!# ,"$0! (. " ! ,$3! A)-/'/$& %#('!!-/*09 " ! "#)" (." !.$'",; /' /","$"!,9; !*" !;/"*!,, /, -!$- (# '$**(" 5! .()*-9 (# /, /*'$%$5&! (. 0/+/*0 !+/-!*'!9 (# /, E!%" ()" (. " ! ;$2 52 " ! $-+!#,! %$#"29 (# /. /, %#!,!*'! '$**(" 5! (5"$/*!- ;/" ()" $* $3()*" (. -!&$2 (# !4%!*,! ; /' 9 )*-!# " ! '/#')3,"$*'!, (. " ! '$,!9 " ! '()#"'(*,/-!#,)*#!$,(*$5&!
#(+/-!-< " $" " ! %#('!!-/*0 ;$, 5!";!!* " ! ,$3! %$#"/!,(#" !/##!%#!,!*"$"/+!,/*/*"!#!,"F " !$-+!#,!%$#"2/*" !./#,"%#('!!-/*0 $- " !#/0 "$*-(%%(#")*/"2"('#(,,<!4$3/*!F " $"" !C)!,"/(*,/*/,,)!;!#!,)5,"$*"/$&&2 " ! ,$3! /* " ! ./#," $, /* " ! ,!'(*- %#('!!-/*07 #' 1 $ 4 ''I3
0
0 $
3 4
2 3
4< H J 4 0 $0
3 H J 3
2 4 4
2 A
H J 8 0 $
2 4
$
3 8 4
''I3
0
$
$ 4 3 4 3
* 0 2$2 3
2
$$
0
2A 0
$ #) 4
4
2 3
4 8 B $
8 $3 2 3 '' I3
$
43
3
4$
2
0 *
3
B 4
A 2 $
2 $
B $, /!*$ #,G,8 $-$&;$/**# B B6@
A 0
4 '' I3
0 0
0< > ''(#-/*0"(" !%#(,!')"/(*'$,!9 ;$, " !,(&/"$#2!2!;/"*!,,"(" ! $&&!0!-('')##!*'!9 5)" /* /, !+/-!*'! 5!.(#! " ! "#/$& '()#"9 ! -/- *(" $" $&&,)%%(#"" !%#(,!')"/(*'$,!" ()0 ! ,)%%(#"!- " ! ,$3! /* $&& 3$"!#/$& %$#"/')&$#, /* /,,"$"!3!*"3$-!5!.(#!" !&!$#*!-$0/,"#$"! -)#/*0" !'()#,!(./*C)/#2)*-!#!'"/(*(. " ! (-! ! '#)'/$& C)!,"/(* "( 5! !4$3/*!- /* " /, '$,! /, $, "( ; !" !# " ! ,"$"!3!*" (. #!'(#-!- -)#/*0 " ! '()#,! (. /*C)/#2 )*-!#
!'"/(*(." !(-!/,#!&!+$*"$*-$-3/,,/5&! /* " ! '$,! (* $*- ,( $, "( .(#3 5$,/, (. '(*+/'"/(* (. " ! $''),!- %!#,(*, " $, 5!!* ,)53/""!- (* 5! $&. (. " ! $%%!&&$*", " $" ,)' $ ,"$"!3!*" /, *(" $-3/,,/5&! )*-!# !'"/(* 66 (. " !+/-!*'!'"9=>
" !'"7.(#, (#"
$," ! $''),!- $- *!/" !# $*2 #/0 " *(# (%%(#")*/"2 "( '#(,,<!4$3/*! -)#/*0 " ! '()#,! (. /*C)/#2 "3$25!),!.)&"(#!.!#"(!'"/(*66(." !'" ; /' #)*," ), H66
< +/-!*'! 0/+!* 52 $ ;/"*!,,/*$A)-/'/$&%#('!!-/*0(#5!.(#!$*2 %!#,(* $)" (#/D!- 52 &$; "( "$E! /"9 /, #!&!+$*" .(# " ! %)#%(,! (. %#(+/*09 /* $ ,)5,!C)!*" A)-/'/$& %#('!!-/*09 (# /* $ &$"!# ,"$0! (. " ! ,$3! A)-/'/$& %#('!!-/*09 " ! "#)" (. " ! .$'", ; /' /" ,"$"!,9 ; !* " ! ;/"*!,, /, -!$- (# '$**(" 5! .()*-9 (# /, /*'$%$5&!(.0/+/*0!+/-!*'!9(#/,E!%"()"(. " ! ;$2 52 " ! $-+!#,! %$#"29 (. /. /, %#!,!*" '$**(" 5! (5"$/*!- ;/" ()" $* $3()*"(.-!&$2(#!4%!*,!; /' 9)*-!#" ! '/#')3,"$*'!, (. " ! '$,!9 " ! ()#" '(*,/-!#,)*#!$,(*$5&!
#(+/-!-< " $" " ! %#('!!-/*0 ;$, 5!";!!* " ! ,$3! %$#"/!, (# " !/# #!%#!,!*"$"/+!, /* /*"!#!,"F " $" " ! $-+!#,! %$#"2 /* " ! ./#," %#('!!-/*0 $- " ! #/0 " $*- (%%(#")*/"2"('#(,,<!4$3/*!F " $" " ! C)!,"/(*, /* /,,)! ;!#! ,)5,"$*"/$&&2 " ! ,$3! /* " ! ./#," $, /* " !,!'(*-%#('!!-/*0 4%&$*$"/(*< '#/3/*$& "#/$& (# /*C)/#2 , $&& 5! -!!3!- "( 5! $ %#('!!-/*0 5!";!!* " ! %#(,!')"(# $*- " ! $''),!- ;/" /* " ! 3!$*/*0(." /,,!'"/(*H !3% $,/,$--!- =
#(3 $ 5$#! %!#),$& (. " ! $.(#!,$/- %#(+/,/(*9/";()&-$%%!$#" $"!+/-!*'!0/+!*52$ ;/"*!,, /* $ A)-/'/$& %#('!!-/*0 (# 5!.(#! $*2 %!#,(* $)" (#/D!- "( "$E! /" /, $-3/,,/5&! .(# " !
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
A 0
3 4 0 G $" !; G, G $#3$ ??:
@ 3 2 0
0 3$ $2 $
$2 A
A
* $ 4B $
0 8 * 4 3
$ $8 4 4
2 <H J 40 $0
H J 3
2
4 4
2 A
H J 8 $ 4 0 $
2
$
2 8 '' 0 $
#- 8
4 * '' I3
0 2
2 3
4(03
.0
3
.
$ 8
2 $ 40
20 $ $3
.
3
*
2 3 $ 4
0 $ 2 3
3
4
0 2$
* 4 A
3 ''I3
3
* 3
3
4 8 2 4 8 8
$2
A $
2 *
3 '' I3
0 4 3 HIA$J
4
4 #.
$2 4 IA$
4 2 0
4 0
4
42 4
#- 3
0
3 4
42 8
3 4 0 $ 0 4
$2
42 4
$2 #@
0A
$3 $
,$ 0 ?=