← Library
High Court of TripuraCMAppl(WA)/1/2015rejected

The State Of Tripura And ORS v. Debeyendu Das

2015-03-24The Hon'Ble Mr. Justice S.C.Das,Hon'Ble The Chief Justice Deepak Gupta9 pages

THEHIGHCOURTOFTRIPURA AGARTALA C.M.APPL.NO.1OF2015 INWANO.1OF2015 Appellant applicants: 1. TheStateofTripura, 



   ! " # !$%  % 

! '%! !'% 2. TheDirector, " # !$%  % 

!($(

  )( *+( ,+(-!(% .!&%,( !! " /'% ByAdvocate: ++0 Respondent/writpetitioner: SriDibeyenduDas, 1*2"(("!  3/ ! *)% (!)% (! % /"$ /)((! " / ('%!( (% $   4%  )!"  # !$% % 

! '% %  & $ # & / -! %!"(!%(! % /"$ /2 (3 ! " /"('%!  -  !# & / -! %(%!"!% / "$ /!" /'%  ByAdvocates:  ," !$ 

 



 WANO.1OF2015 Appellants: 1. TheStateofTripura, 



   ! " # !$%  % 

! '%! !'% 2. TheDirector, " # !$%  % 

!($(

  )( *+( ,+(-!(% .!&%,( !! " /'% ByAdvocate: ++0 Respondent/writpetitioner: SriDibeyenduDas, 1*2"(("!  3/ ! *)% (!)% (! % /"$ /)((! " / ('%!( (% $   4%  )!"  # !$% % 

! '% %  & $ # & / -! %!"(!%(! % /"$ /2 (3 ! " /"('%!  -  !# & / -! %(%!"!% / "$ /!" /'% ByAdvocates:  ," !$  BEFORE THEHON'BLECHIEFJUSTICEMR.DEEPAKGUPTA THEHON'BLEMR.JUSTICES.C.DAS  " (5 "$ 4% 5*  624thMarch,2015.  ((   : Yes No √

2

 JUDGMENT&ORDER(ORAL)    

        (         -((-  [2] '( -      ( 0%  

 7

8

4% ( %9: ;<8

= -(

 (   4%   (  

; <

=

(  %(  -(  ;

 7

= 

 (  %(    (   - .   ( ( $  (  $ (   

8



 [3] +    ( (  (   - ( ( -(- , ,/ ( ()% (# & / -(

/ %  (    (      ( %   ! ( ( -  ,     $     %

    ,  %  (    ( -( $     $  

    <!

=  )  !(  $% -( ( -;!

!<87;1/ [4]     (  ( ( 

%-- %,   %((4%-( ( % (    ( ;-(   ( $   -    "%     ! )% (!

3

)((> %(( - -0%   ;'(  /.   ;  -6/ ?+  -(@.

1>( ( %((  ( "%

 %

 "!$% $  >$(    / - %

 $ > (  ( (    (   /  -- % ( ,  ( %     !  - - ( / -'( -    % (    / -  %  

 ,   -    (  / -    =8       %!   (    (( -/ %A [5] '(   4%   %  (   ( ; ( ( (  

  - - ( (   -    ( ( ( (((( - %( (   ; %    % $ - % , 

,    (0% (4%-( (   -6/ ? #  ( ( !  '" 0% !  &  ( (%

((  -   %( B

 (  %(     ( - %

=8         (   -  % (! (

  %

 (   

  "  >C% ( (    %  ( (    %-(+%-(( %    0% !&-(((- %

    (     (  ,      %  *,%  !0% !&

4

 (%

((- % (%  

(  D( ($    (  ( ((( ($    % ( %  0% !  & (   (( $     %  (   '(  %

 (    0% !&A [6]   %  ( ( ( - ( (   $    (   '% (  

 (4%((   ( (( (   ( $    % @$   ,    ,%    (" (& $ $  (    % (   (4%    (  - ( $(E  ?0% !&(   ((  $     % ( '( %

(  0% !&A [7] '(  ( -(( % (  ( 

( 

0% (%%

 (

   %(( 

(& $ $    (& $>( %(  ($ & 

, (& $         -( (   (   ( ( % (.     ( %(  

,      -( (  (  $   (   ( '(.   (%(( %   ,

5

         - -( ( - %    ( & $   ((   ($ &- % 

  %( $  &  (    %/ ( ( $-  ( -( (   (   %     ( %  %    -   ,   @$

 ( ,  (   (   (   -    ( 0%  (  (           ( (   4%  ((   (0%  %   -( % %(- ('( ( ( ((& $ $ ( % (   [8] '( %(% -(((%-( (  -   % 

  +0    % 

 % '( %            ( ( (  ( C%

  '( %      (  %   % 

 ( "  -(   ( C%    '( %-     (-   % % ( ( @$(% %   %(     ( ( ($           *

  

 %( (  >C%     -( (

  ( C%

  '( %  % 0%    ( ( C%

 ( %  ( -( ( %(   %(   !(%-$ % % (C%   $  (4%

6

 [9] (---((        -%

  %((  %  % - ,    ( % ( % * = ;

 - (  (

 -  

!(      

 6/ ?

= ;

2  8/ ;/

 -( (    ( 2- "   ( #   $ % "  ( %  %( (    (  %A [10]   ($ % (   -( ( (  -   % 

  %   (    (           % ( % '(     (  +0 ( -     





8 ! ?   $  A  -(!    (

%   (" ! (

%     ( 2-" ! (

%   ( %!(     (%'(%-( ( -((  (  (F - $ (-((- ($  %   %    D - (% %          -( ( -   $ (-(($$ (% [11]   %($  0 (  

     %-($( (    

( %  -(    (     ( & $  $   ((& $ $ (   % (

7

  ( $ ((($ &D0  ((   .  ( % (    -& $ $  ( (    %

(,  %!-( (  %         %($( ;-( (  %/ %! (  / -  -( ( (   - , -        >  !  -!  - - -   '( -% %( --( '(    (   ( , %

 

 % (((,"(,    %-((  

  ( $ (    ,     (   G> % ,>!-(    $

!(& $ F    %(( -( (

,   ( ( % 

 % ( (-   [12]  >$- ( ; ((-   %  $ 

 ( C%

   % ( ( ( - % =8 -( ($  ;-    @$ (   (  ,   -(%!-

(  -(   ( %($ !   $- (  (( 

  (" - - (     ( / -(

 

 !"

   !$%9;:((  $( / -! ( ( ,    (  / -  ( $  (   ( =8

  -   

8

[13]    ,   ( - ($       ( (     %  (    %   (     ( %-- %($. (    '( 

( (            -  (      JUDGE  CHIEFJUSTICE

9