Anil Ch. Sarkar And ORS v. Sukhen Sarkar
!
"# $% " & '
(
)#
++**
,! ,
-% &
& '
(
)#
++* . **
/ 0) . ') % 0) (
"1 2 2324 5 *
" 6 - √
/ /
) **
" **
') %
) **
" ** ) 22 & 7
" "
8%"
929229
0
** -3:;<229 =8 (
) >"
'
" **
" = 7
# !"#$"#% &' (&#) *+ $"# ,%*(&-&*'- ./&0 0*)' &' #1$&*' 2 *+ $"# 1$3 $"# -4&$ &- 5/&'$/&'/6.#&'$"##7#*+./)89 **
0 "
0
= 8 8 = 7
" ** =
) **
" **
8 = 7 ?
=
" -3<22@ ) ) *
% ) "
**
*) ) ' )0 8* )
=
) ** *
4 ) )
8 A39**
) *
8
0
) *
=8 @A9 2 A9 B ) )
"=
" 342 ) ) *
* ??< 4@< @2?< % (
" 0 08 * 08 0 = * * @A4< @A4< @ *
* =8 "
" ==
C)* * ) *
* ??2 ?? ??4 / ) )
" 2 ) ) ) 0 ) *
* ??4 . *
C)0 *
* ?? 3 8 " = *
=
0
"
"
== * =
"* *
* )
) C == D 42422@
0 *
)
=
) =8 *
" *
* * = *) )
8)
=
) EFD @2422@ *
0) * = 8 8 )
* 9 =8
"
0 ) ) 42422@
=
* 8 = = ( "
'
) )
/0
" "
" **
) *
& )8 ) 0
" *
" / ) *
**
" 8 *=* A ))
" **
& )8)
D ** ) *
"
) *
"
"
0 EF ) *
" *
% ) "
)0 8* ) EF
2 '8 %"
2 2 229
>" >
( '
= 0 #
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
#+#'0/'$-/%#0&%#1$#0$*%#5*(#/'7-$%41$4%#+%*5 $"#<<1"#04.#*+$"#./'0&55#0&/$#.79 "
%"
) **
*
** ) A@&=
" ** -3:;<229
) (
)>"
'
'8
*"
%"
929229 ** =
" %"
)
**
) = 0 #
%*5$"#1/%#+4.-1%4$&'7*+$"##(&0#'1#*'%#1*%03 &$/,,#/%-$"/$,./&'$&++=%#-,*'0#'$&-$"#$&$.#"*.0#% *+ << /'0 << 1"#04.# ./'03 &' $"&- ,/%$ *+ ./'0 )"#%#+%*5 "# )/- 0&-,*--#--#0 67 $"# /,,#../'$= 0#+#'0/'$ "# 0#+#'0/'$=/,,#../'$ "/0 '* $&$.# *% ,*--#--*%7%&;"$*(#%$"#/..*$$#0./'0*+$"#,./&'$&++= %#-,*'0#'$"#*4%$6#.*)*6-#%(#0$"/$/..*$5#'$ /4$"*%&$73 3 #.*'&/3 *4$" %&,4%/ /.-* &'+*%5#0$"# *..#1$*%67.#$$#%$"/$/..*$5#'$ *%0#% )/- 1*%%#1$#0 $"#%#+*%#3 $"# *4%$ 6#.*) /.-* 1*5# $* $"# %&;"$ +&'0&';- $"/$ $"# ,./&'$&++= %#-,*'0#'$&-#'$&$.#0$*;#$0#1%##+*%0#1./%/$&*'*+ $&$.# /'0 %#1*(#%7 *+ ,*--#--&*' /'0 /.-* ,#%5/'#'$ &':4'1$&*' +$#% 0&-14--&*' *+ /.. $"# #(&0#'1#3 &' %#-,#1$*+&--4#* 6 /.-*$"#*4%$6#.*)1/5#$* $"# %&;"$ +&'0&';- $"/$ $"# ,./&'$&++=%#-,*'0#'$ &- #'$&$.#0 +*% %#1*(#%7 *+ << 1"#04.# ./'0 )"#%#+%*5 "# )/- 0&-,*--#--#0 67 $"# /,,#../'$=0#+#'0/'$ /'0 /.-*#'$&$.#0$*;#$*%0#%*+&':4'1$&*'+%*5$"#*4%$
#-$%/&'#0 $"# /,,#../'$- $* #'$#% &'$* << 1"#04.# ./'0/-<<1"#04.#&-/.-*,/%$*+<<1"#04.#./'0
)"#%# $"# ,./&'$&++=%#-,*'0#'$ "/- #-$/6.&-"#0 "&- $&$.# +&'0'*%#/-*'$*&'$#%+#%#&'$"#*%0#%/'00#1%## ,/--#0 67 $"# *4%$ 6#.*) "#%#+*%#3 &' 5/7 1*'-&0#%#0*,&'&*'3$"&-/,,#/."/-'*5#%&$9 .
)
)92A22@:$C=;
) =8 ** = * )
" ) 4
0
)A@2
) **
" **
=
= *
**
) ) )
8 /
8
* ) 8 )
" * )8 8 * )
"
0
)A@20 C)*) :$C=; ?
') %
) **
" =
8
" **
) ) )
" 0
= " ) * ) 99 0
)A@2 : 1 ); )
= C * 0
" *
)=8 * ) ) 991)* 0 # * -4&$ *% *$"#% ,%*1##0&'; -"/..3 4'.#-- *$"#%)&-# #>,%#--.7 ,%*(&0#0 &' $"&- 1$3 .&# *% 6# &'-$&$4$#0 &' /'7 1&(&. 1*4%$ )&$" %#-,#1$ $* /'7 5/$$#% /%&-&'; 4'0#%/'0,%*(&0#0+*%67$"&-1$9
-
% )
*) 8
* 0 =81) A@2) )
8
** 4 ))
"
8 **
( )
7 * =8 ) 0)