Doctor Debbarma @ Bishu v. State Of Tripura And 3 ORS

INTHEHIGHCOURTOFTRIPURA
AGARTALA W.P.(C)No.331of2010 SriDoctorDebbarma@Bishu 





  

 



 
 
 


!

"















.........Petitioner -Versus- 1. TheStateofTripura,

 
#



 #
$
 "  
%&

!

" 
 '

( 
!

" 



2. TheSuperintendent   


'

( 






 


!

" 3. TheJailor,   


'

( 






 


!

" 4.
TheDistrictMagistrate&Collector, 
!

" 
 
 '

( 

........Respondents BEFORE THEHON'BLEMR.JUSTICES.TALAPATRA )

"  :

*

*

+#
( & 











)


:

*

(
%
( & 







  
 & #
:21.01.2015 
 
,
'


 

 " 
 : Yes No √

[2] JUDGMENT&ORDER(ORAL) $ 

*

*

+#
   
""  
 
" 

- 

*

(
%
 

 
""  


 [2]
(
.
. 

 



"" 
!
" 
-
 



 
/01(




  


  
"

 




"#



+ 2333345




"# 

 
  "
"

/ 
#  
$
-
    


  
"

/ 
#  

 
67


( 
( 
#

8  



32 6336

 
!



2/ !4(

6332 [3] 

"  -




   




"" 


%
$
 
( 
9  
 
 
("" 

7:

6330



8  






  

9  
"" 
-
"


" 
-
  

 . 
 
 
 
!


 201
 !4(
6336

 
2/


;-
( & 
 & 
( 


 
6<


( 
( 

  




 
"

/ 
#  
#

8  


6:

633/








































































































































[3] [4]
!


"

#

8  


3/ 633:
"


 
("" 
 7:

6336
- 

 
"





8  


6336
"


 
!


 2/ !4(

6332

%
$
 
( 
9  
 

-

8  


 & 


 
/0<




 

  


"








 #
9#

 
- 

8  


 
("" 
 7:

6336
-
"




3/ 633:

" 


"

 
0>
#  
9

" 
-

 
 

8
$
-
 
#





3= 633=
"
#

(
 


!
201 !4(

6336
- 

  

 &



?

Upon hearing both sides I am of the opinion that Superintendent, Central Jail, Agartala is alsotofollowtheprocedureofSection427(2), Cr.P.C. Nodirectionisnecessaryforcomplianceofthis section. [5]
)
 
 


"

  
  

( 




*

*

+#
   
""  


"  

" 



"


"

 
3/ 633=

23 633=
- 

"  -
 
 

8
#
& 




633=
"

 !

201 !4(

6336
!
"  
""

 

 
 " 

 
 

 








































































































































[4]  [6] )
" "

 

"

&

 
1672

 
167
6








?

(1) When a person already undergoing a sentence of imprisonment is sentenced on a subsequent conviction to imprisonment or imprisonment for life, such imprisonment or imprisonment for life shall commence at the expirationoftheimprisonmenttowhichhehas been previously sentenced, unless the Court directsthatthesubsequentsentenceshallrun concurrentlywithsuchprevioussentence: Provided that where a person who has been sentenced to imprisonment by an order under section122indefaultoffurnishingsecurityis, whilstundergoingsuchsentence,sentencedto imprisonmentforanoffencecommittedpriorto the making of such order, the latter sentence shallcommenceimmediately. (2) When a person already undergoing a sentenceofimprisonmentforlife is sentenced on a subsequent conviction to imprisonment for a term or imprisonment for life, the subsequent sentence shall run concurrently withsuchprevioussentence. [7]
! 

#


"

- 

"


 #




  

"

 

  



 . 


"

 

 
 
"

 

"



 


>" 


"

 

- 


 
"

&#
  


 

 




 . 
  




#
-
 
"

&
   
"

&


-

"


-

 
  


"

 
#





 
266



 
 #

-



 
   
  


"

 


  









































































































































[5]


@

 





  


 
  # [8]


 

 
  
-


   

"

 


-

  




-
 

#

%
$
 
( 
9  
#

8  



3/ 633:
- 



 
6

 
167
"

& 

- 

"


 #



  

"

 



  



 . 



 
 


 

 . 
  





#
-
 
"

&
  

 [9]
!
 

 
-

 

*

(
%
 

 
""  
 

 







"

 

 
 
#

8  



3/ 633:

 . 

"

 
-

&
#

 
2

 
167





#

 
6

 
167




$
 

"  A
#. $



-

" 
-





   

-
  



   
"

/ 
#  
!

"

 


 . 
 

 





 
67 6330



   -
#
 

-
#

%
$
 
( 
9  
#
 
8  


3/ 633:

!  









































































































































[6] 

 
 

"

&


 
6

 
167






 . 

   



"  



-




#

 
6

 
167




(
 
- 

%
$
 
( 
9  
#
 
8  


3/ 633:
& 



 
/0<




  



 






#



 . 
 

" 


&
 
 
 

8


-


 
 

8




3= 633=
-
"

[10] (

 
*

(
%
 

 




" 





#  
5"# 

 
 

#
- 

8  


-
"



#

%
$
 
( 
9  
!

-
""


 

36 633=



 
6

 
167




-
"" 



-
 

23 633=

 




633=
(
 

" 


 
"

 


"


36 633=

3= 633=





 
"

6

=
#
)
 
 

 

" 

""

 

 
 

 



"
-
 #
B& 




 #
 



 


"

&
&







 


"

  


( 


""  
 





@ 
#









































































































































[7] &
 

 
>"



 

C-
 "  
$

 

" 


8  



3/ 633:


%
$
 


 


B& 

 


-


"
#

(
 

 

!

" 
( 
 


 

&


 
1676




-

"" 
'#
 

" 
-
 
 

8 [11] ! 

#
"



 @  
""

 


8
 #

" 




 
!
 



"
-
 #

-

8  

 
" 






  
  
&


  
 
Hindustan PaperCorporationLtd.vs.AnantaBhattacharjeeandOrs.,

"

(2004)6SCC213

" >
 

 


"
-
 #


" "

 

" 




#
- 

  



D 

(   62 



&


 - !
" >
 

 
 

Hindustan Paper CorporationLtd.vs.AnantaBhattacharjeeandOrs.


& #
&


"

&






- 
-


 



 


"  

- 
 


 

& 
#


&
- 







 


 

"# 
 

"

A
  










































































































































[8] 


"


 #

 
#
(  
62











- 
8  

(   
/6

660

" 



& 
#
"#
""

"


"  [12] $&





 






"#

" 


> 

+ <333345
+" 
#
 


" 

!




"


" 
-

"


1 

 
 # 
-

"
 
 



" 





#
 
E26F
"





D 

 &




- 
" 
 
-


> 


& JUDGE