Indian Oil Corporation Ltedand2 ORS v. Lrs Of Lt Rahul Roy, Pallabi Roy And 2 ORS
!""# $%" &'
$ ( )*+ !* , +&'
!
"
#
$ "
% & ' "
- ../ '
!
"
% (
"
))))$. 0
" 1 "(" # 2
)' *+ + #,
)'
+ &
& ,
-% & +./0
1 + &
+ 2 "
& 34- 3 "
% "
! ./0
% %-' 1' "
333 ..0 "
" - *4
) 5( )6 "!
(# &' 1 %,%-5 1' "
333
.
#0 "
7 87 * 9
+ 1"" :
" ++1 "
: 3 -3! 0
& -
! 0
& -2 $ +
: 78/.7/98 +$
,
: /:/87/98 ' ++
: $*6 $ ""
-
9// + !%!+
? ( √ $
79977//; 3
& "" ( 7. +7//<&
5
' "
!
( 7 2& $
79977//; $
78/=7//< 3
&- ( 7. +7//=& !
-
' "
!
( 9
+
+ " ++1
"
;< "" +
+
*
>
+ * !& = . "
/ ( ## + )2)+
+ #"" #2) .. + +>" / .
/ / / 5 "
.
(#
(/ "? !& = . "
/ ( ## + ) 2) // + > 0 "#(/ "
5" ) " /(# ? !& = . "
/ ( .
)
/ %/ /
;-< + &
> +
""
>
+ * &
" ++- &
* & "
"" * "
+ "
"
* %
&
!
"
& 9;:< ' +
""
"
!
" ++
+
"
97///*
+
" +
@ 3-A+
"
+
* ++
* ' "
5
+
6!
" & " ++*
& * + "
"
3-
0
( 1.8;7 "
+
0 0
5
"
+ + ( = 34- ! !
*
& , -
+ 0 *
0 + ( = "
& + 3-
0 * & + ( = 5
*
+ " ++&
" ++ +
*
0* 3-+
0"
( 99 97 "
*++ &
* &
+ 3- *
" ++ *
+ ( 7 + "
2 * 5 & + ( = * 0"
" ++ ++
+ "
+
+ +
"
&
++ "
+
& + +
+ + " ++ ;@< + " ++* * "
& + ( 97 .&+
* +
&
" ++* "
"
"
* % 9;:< ++ " " ++ * *
+ ( 9" " + & ! + ( 9
+ +
"
"
& * " ++ !
" ++ "
97/// +3-+
* ++ " 5
' "
+ "
"
*
&
0
( 1.8;7 +
+ 97/// + 3- +
" ++ + * "+
:/// + ( = =/// 6 *
/</:7//. + ( . "" ( .
* "" +
0 0
5 "
+ + ( = * 3- + 0
* +
& * &
> & +3-*
" 0 &* 0 & + ( 7 "" ( 7 *
;A< + * B B $( .( . % " ) . * 5"" ( 25 + $ #+ $
" ) . * 5" /
/ % 2+ " ".'
, 2( 9 $
5" / C( ) . " ) . * 5" (
# , . @ //, " )
. * . "# " 5 " 2) . / / 2
".
># .
( " ) . *5"% )+5
(/ ",
$ #+ 5/ " # /5 " ) . *,
9 .. 5 (
+ # $ #+
', %/ 9 $
. . @ .
5/ . " 2.
)/ # " "
).
D ;E< + ( = " & + * ""
* + + ( 9 7 .
* & 3- * 5 "
& + ( = *
+ + +
* +
&
*
& + 3- +
"
" ++
* "
0" * 5 "
0 "
" ++
"
6
* + ( =
+
"& & "
C + " ++
> * ;F< "
" +
"
+
*B B= .." + / # " "
).
?D ;<
"" " ++ * * 9D & 9 9D + "
+ *
& + ""
+
*
B B
/ (" * * , 2
)' .
..' " C(" 2"+ >2 ' % (+ 5" , 2) " , "
% (" + # 5/ 5" .
/
% #.
5/ ../ 22 "
% (" + # # , > F' " #" . + # 5" .
/
> 2) -" *)'-'" > 7( /
+ . *5"# E- +. > ) . + # .
5/" 2"
% (" #" .+ # # ,> F" ="
"" ># / ) " /" 5 /
2) % " ""
(/ +
. " #" .
% (" / / ' " "(/ + . .. #"/ " .
% (" / / 5 2
/2
/ 7""'
" .
# > E' ""( 2) . -.
#$ #+ $
C(" +
.. " , + 5 % $ #+ .
,+ 2/, /" . "# " + 2( 5" ' .. 2) "+"% "'5"## + )
5" 2.
% . " ) . * " * 5" .
# "
/,
5/5"../ 2) 5 .(
".
# > G $ ( ) *+ 2. . . "
C(" .. "
(/ " +5 , $ #+ .
( 2( .. " %/' ' , %/ " . . @ .
. /("+ "" .
(/ " " ) . - 2) "+ + # -- # , > - "
/ %)' C("
.. (
(/ " +5 %/ $ #+ $
2( " C(" 5""
// 2) ..D ;G< 2
+
* * +
" ++ * 00" + + ( =
+
+ & +
* + +
* +
+
"
+
6
"
"
+ " +
1
+
" ++ & - & & B
" A ) " # /
)+ 2(""" "
"
/ /
5 . " #)" + "
(/ #) % / , 0-AG E00-2.
. -",+ .
(#
(/ ".
(
" . "
# ) % / / 5 $.
% # . /
+ 5" #" "'2( /
) "
% (" #" / " # . "
) #) % 5"#)%/ ,
(#
(/ " .
# . - 2
(+ "# .
# $. @5"
" #D C +
1
B$. -2)"+ "' + # / ..
//" " C(" # 2 + %/C(" $ #+ '2( / " " / ) #" .
)# 5 " 2/, ( ) )"
.(" )D;" "" < ;< ""
+
*
"
+
""
B B= "" "(" 2) ..0
5"2/(" ." 5.( ' 5
"'5 .+" . / ( 2 5 ../ 5" H(" .?D ' ""
>
""
+
*
+
B B+ # 2 5
5"/ # .
(/ "5
"
.
# $ #+ + !9 & .(
"4"
(/ 4 / .
( 2/, .
(/ " $ #+ $
".
" 0 " . // 2) ..0
' / 2#".
" 2)
.
( .
(/ " $ #+ $
5" .
"
" // (" . .(" . // / .
(/ " 2)
"
@
" # .
#
.
" ("" // 2) "' / 2 # % / / 4+ # " "" ") ( / /
" 5 // 2/ #" + # .
' / % ) ".) 5" / / 4+ # 2 5 ".
( +2/, .
(/ " $ #+ $
# ) 2/(" "
/
(/ " ( 9 2"" . + # ' / 2 2 5 ) .
"
" ("" + +(#
..0
" 5 # ( / #, #". "
"2"" ).
" + # ../ % . .( . ../ + % ) .
(/ " " + 2/,
(/ " $ #+ $
" 5" / ( 2+ . ..0
' 5" 2 ) " 5 #/)
5 % " " ," , 5" + # + 2/,
(/ " $ #+ /"
. % ) " # / .
# .
"
"
(/ 4 C(" 4 / 4
" # 2)
C( + ..0
#2/,5
(/ " $ #+ D ;<
& "
""
99
0
"
+
* " *
+
&
" + "
( = *
& * "
" &
!
"
+
"
*
*
& + "
+
" "
*
*&+
5 -
"
& &+
3
"
"
+
++ 0 * +
"
* 6
+"
+
+ 99
0 A"
*
> &E +"
+ +
!
" "
* + ++ & "
* + 0 +
"
!
"
& "
* +
"
+
& * " "
;< -3 ! 0
&
"
99
0 "" +
" + "
"
0
+ " ++1"" *+ +
"
&
"
0
+
& C *
+
""
& +"
+
"
" 2 & &
+
" ++ & "
;-<
""
+
""
+
"
9D * " ++ +
* +
! 19D +
"
B B / /
" " "
2 "
"2 .
". (/ ."(
" " . ) #'
(/ " .
( / # ( + " 4
# . % ) / "+'
" % 2"
( "/ , 2/,
(/
.(" ,+2/, ."(/
(/ "/" ."(/ # "
/,'
"2 2 ) 2 / /
/ " .
(/ (" "(# C(% / " .
(/ #+ " ") / /
""2 "
"2 )
"(#C(% (2 . / " . "(/
(/ D
* !
"
F
00 "
G
& " ++ " ++ 0 0 "
+
& + ""
&+
+ 9D
+
* * +
+
;@< -3! 0
&
""
+
"
+ & "
$
*
"
+ *
$
& "
*
+ "" & +
"
"
3- +
+
" ++ 0
"
4
+ +
$
& ;A<
" +
&
" ++
1
""
" ++
9D * +
+
*
" 9
+
* +
* ++ +
.//=7//= *
/</:7//.
1
+
" ++ %' 9 " "
* +
+
+ ;E< +
&
+
& + ""
&
"
$
"
C "
$
79977//; ;F<
> + ;<
"" * *
& - * !+
* $ -&