High Court of TripuraWP(C)/397/2010disposed of

Sanjoy Sarkar v. State Of Tripura And 3 ORS

2015-04-29The Hon'Ble Mr. Justice S.C.Das,Hon'Ble The Chief Justice Deepak Gupta12 pages

" #$%& "'" () * +,%""

,%"&% $&",& "&%-".#" "## " ("$#$/ $"# #"% &' ( * 0#12$&",&-".#" ."$&324&% ,"&"4 5$&"4

7"&

-".#" $" )&"*#"

" +% +*" , -".#"8"& * 8"& $&",&-".#" $"- )&"*#"

" +% +*" 8)* -".#"8"& * 8"&$&",&-".#" . $"//

#( &%9- :( $,%9"1;"

;"$&",&$&-".#" < ")& 0"

#) 2 312 22 4 25 -22 6

23125 4 2- = "&%&& " > 5"

2837 ,& = "&%$.

3&$ > 5"

%'"2 "&4833

%" &

37"4

1#3&3*"3" %&%" &

"".

"& > > > .7 .7 8")

4 -52 , -2 94 &%$ ?"& .&& #3" 8"&,

&% $&&#&

:3&%.&& "?% ?$?

"'$

&%9 -".#" && $

"$% "& - ."43

" $$# .."

."& ?"& @#$% &% 3$,."4."

,33"?$&%245 3&3

8#"B& &%?"&.&& 3$ ."43

" @#$% &% 7$ 3$$$

"3" 3&3

8#" & &%?"&.&& 3$$$

"3"3&3

8#"A & &% ?"& .&& 3 $ &% ..& "3" 3&3

8#"& &%?"&.&& 6"3 "3 , #$ 5"

8 2

" &% .&& " 3 "3 833

%'"2 "&4

" &% &&"$.

3&$ -% .&& "

, &33 &%& % ..3

" &% .

- $ " ,& "4 ,33& 3 &" $,& ."

,$$ % ?$ ..

&3$

&%9 - 73

&&3&3

C8#"& &% ?"& .&& 3 % 1 3 &% .

-%" &" % ?$ $& & #3" 2$, &" 8 &" 2 #& A &%$ "$.

B $$#3 &, 3&3

8#" & &% ?"& .&& ?&% 3",& & $#2& %$ ,"& ,& $ &%"?$ 3."&&,& ?

#32&'$&% -%" &" $ "$.

B $$#3 &?

" "3"$ 3&3

$'&%.&& "& $#2& %$ ,"& ,& ?&% 3 3& ?%,% %$ $"7,?

#32&"&3 :&$&%,$

&%.&& " &%&%%$7"..3$"$"73,& "4,33&

"&%.

3&%&%$..,& ?$ $ " ,& "4 ,33& 3 $ % ?$ .#& & $#"."$?%%",73 &,3"3"$& $#2& ,"& ,& 6 3 $ & 2 & , #&4 3 &%& % 2 3 & D0.E , #&4 ?%,% $ *9 , #&43 &"",.&

&% &,%..3

" ,"& ,& 2#& % 33 & & 4 ,"& ,& "

&% , .&&#&% "&43&%"

"&%"?$ @#$&

%$$#2&& ,"& ,&& &%"$.

. $.

B &%" &" 24 5 3&3

8#"B & &% ?"& .&& &&3 3$,."4."

,3$&% &%

?"&,

,%"$>

!"# $% &'()*% + ,!-./#

0 1 0 02 0

4 4 4 0 52

B 6 6 1 10 2 7 8

*$2 0 ,9.

+ , !4 27

09 , 72 # 1% 702

9 % : %

2 420 1 1 702 3 0

+2 0 702 3 0

!"# $% & 2

202

!"# $%&'()*% + , $

!"#

;

3 %

% 3 0

0 + , < =

),.--)>,,)>, !/#

0 6 0 4 & 0

702 3 0

7 7 3 +& +2 0 0 702 % 3 0

!"# $% & 2

* 02

!"# $% &'()*% + ,

0 1

0 2

% 4 0

!"# $% & 0 4 %

1 0 57 ? 2

% 4

0<+

%,2

!"# $% & 2

202

? 7 -% .&& " 33 &% "&,

,%"$ , &3&%&%%$7"..3$"$"73,& "4 ,33& 3 &%& % ..3 $ " ,& "4

C ,33&

" &% .

3 &% :&"7? "3$,&3%$",& "4,33& :&% & ' $$#3 24 &% :&"7? 9 "3 %$ & ?$ ,"4& 3$+,& "48#"C$"$& &% ?"&.&& 8&&%3

&%3$,."4."

,3&% .&& " ",73 7$ 3$$$

"3" 3&3

8#" & &% ?"& .&& ?%" &% "$.

B ."

$3 & 3$$$ &% .&& " "

$"7, 3 $'3 % & ' %$ "."$&& &% .

$3.&4 -%.&& ", &33&%&%33 & ",74, .4

&%@#"4".

"&& '

,&7 "."$&& % ?7" % $#2&&3 %$ "."$&& 8#" & &% ?"& .&& $& &% ."

"3"

3$$$

2#& ?&% #& , $3" &%$&%"$.

B$$#3 3$$$ "3" 3&3

?%,% ?$ $3

8#" A & &% ?"& .&& -% .&& " &%" &" $#2&&3 .. 2

" &% "$.

2#& &% ..?$3$$$324 "3"3&3

.$$324 "$.

8#"& &%?"&.&& 9 :& $ #"&%" , &33 24 &% .&& " &%& &% #%%2 3& ",& "43%..3$ " ,33& 2#& ?&% %$ ..,& 3&3 C

C % %3 $#2&&3 ,%4& =4 $&"& "& ,& 2"

3#4

$3 24 &% ,%4& ,"&"4 3&3

+&&" %,%"" 2% ,%"&% "&% -".#" $&",&$% ?%$ 4$ , #&42#&&?$ & ' ? & % &%& %$ 4 %$ 2 & 3 $ , #&4 6 7" 7 4 $$#", & &% ","#&&2 "33#" "&"7?&%&%2 3& , #&4 "&%&%?$#2&&% ,"& ,&&"

:&$&%,$

&%.&& "&%&%?$$,&324 &%&"7?2 "3 &$ ,& "4,33&2#&$ " ,& "4 ,33& 3 &%"

" &% "3"

%$ 3$$$ "

$"7, ?$ 2$ #&4 ?"

3 , & $&3&%4

94 "1 3"

37&&%.&& ".,3

", "3 , .4

&% @#"4 ".

"& 3&3

A $#2&&3 24 &% :@#"4 *

," &% 3$,."4 ,33"?$&&%.&& "3&$, &33 24&%.&& "&%&&%:@#"4*

,"%$ 2$"73&%& &% ,%"$ "3 $& &% .&& " %7 & 2 732#&4&&%$,."48#&% "&4

#3%#&4

$, 3#,&33$$$3% "

&%$"7,4 :& $ , &33 &%& # C

8 #$ C ?%,% $ ..,2 & &% ,$

&% .&& " %$ & 2, .324&%$,."48#&% "&43%,&%

3$,."4."

,3%$27&&33&%3$$$

"3", &$#$& : -%"$.

3&$24 , #&"

37&

, &33&%&&%.&& ".."3&%$,& ,$$$",& "4,33&2#&$#2$@#&4& &% &

" &"7? % ,3 %$ & 2 ,& "4,33&3&%&%$% #327&%2 &

"$"7& 6 ,3 $#,% 2 & " "" & ,%4&=4$&"& "& ,&

+,%""=4

$324 &% ,%4& ,"&"4 +&&" %,%"" 2% 3&3

B ,%4& &$ *

," 3 &% ,%"&%9 ,'7 .&*

,"3%$ $$#"3 &%& % ?

#3 2 2 & ."

3#, &% ,"& ,& $

&%, .&&#&% "&4 :&%&"7?%$, "3 B "'$ ?%"$ &% " ,& "4 ,33& &% $& ."$ ..

&3 $, "3 C "'$ $ " ,33& % , #3 & 2 ..

&3 $"7, 6 ?$ , $3"3$ ,& "4,33& &%2$$

%$ $$#",7& &%%"

&%&"7?2 "3& $#2&%$ ,"& ,&&" 3,, "34%$ ?$.."

7324&%&"7?2 "3

"..

&&$ ,& "4 ,33& 6 ?$ &%" &" &,3 24 &% "$.

B& $#2& ,"& ,&3&?

"3"$ ?" $ 7 2#& % 3 & $#2& &% ,"& ,&

A 3 &%"

" &% 3$,."4 ."

,3 ?$ &&3 $&%3%%$2

#3#&4&%."

,3 :& $ ,"4 , &33 24 &% "$.

3&$ &%& &" &% :@#"4 *

," $#2&&3 %$ ".

"& & &% $,."4 8#&% "&4 , .4

&%@#"4".

"&?$$#..3& % 3 &% ."

7$ .#$%& "3" ?$ .$$3 24 &% $,."4 8#&% "&4 :& $ $ , &33 &%&

, .4

&%@#"4".

"&?$$#..3& &% .&& " ?&% &%" ", "3$

&% 3$,."4 ,3 3 % ",73 &% $ 24 7 ",.& &%"

-%"?$ &%?"

&%,& &'24&% "$.

3&$3$ &%?"&.&& $% #323$$$3 8& &% &

%" "3 833

3#,3&%."

,3$

&%","#&&2 "33&?

"$&"$

+,& "43 ,& "4 "

3 #3"0#"%&,&" 9

" &" & &% &%" $$#$ "$3 &% ?"& .&& & #$ "$& ?%&%" &% 3$,."4 ,3 ?$ , 3#,&3

? &% ,3#"."$,"2324? " & :& $ 3&&3 .

$& &%& &% , .4

&% @#"4 ".

"& $#2&&3 24 &% :@#"4 *

," & &% $,."4 8#&% "&4 ?$ & #"$%3 & &% .&& " &" &% @#"4 ?$ , ,#33 7 & &% $&

$3 ."

7$ .#$%& "3" $#,% @#"4 ".

"& ?$ $& & &% .&& " 24 &% $,."4 8#&% "&4 8 , .4

&% @#"4 ".

"& $ 3 $ 8#" & &% ?"& .&& "1 3"

37& * ."#$

&% $ ?

#3 &%& &% :@#"4 *

2$"73 &%& &% ,%"$ "3 $& &% .&& " ?" & ."

73 -% $,."4 8#&% "&4 ,, "3 & ? ?

#3 3$" ?&% &% 3

&% :@#"4 *

," 2#& &% 7&

$#,% 3$"& &% $,."4 8#&% "&4?$2 #3& ""7& 3?&%"$ $

" 3$"&3, #,&&%$& &%.&& "

-% 3$,."4 ."

,3 $& &% - ."$ $ #33 24 &% -".#" && $ $,. &"

"7, 3& $ &, #$ A

# B

&% $3 #$."$,"2$&%#$>

9 02 40 *$

! 2

# 1 73 0

3 !

0 77 # 2 @6 0

93 0 0 2

)2 0

1 7

0 &

4 3

1 ? : 7?

&% 2 7 ."

7$ $

&% #$

A &%."

7$ $

8#$"..,2 3$,."4 ."

" .

$ 1 " .#$%&

-%"

" &% ."

7$ $

#$ B 3 C 3 &%" "7& #$ " ..,2 ,$

3$,."4 ,3$&- ."$ #C

8 #$."$,"2$&%#$> 6!

# , 7

% 2

% 402 1 40 07% 7

A2 % % 0 1% 7

% 2

% 4 7

% 2

- A2

% 7% 7 - A2

- A2

% %

41 A2 0 21

0 4

21 7

% 2

% 4

0% 7

7 321 "3

? 8$ ." &% 2 7 ."

7$ $ &% $,."4 8#&% "&4?$2 #3&

"?"3, .4

&%@#"4".

"& ?&% &% &&&7 "$ $

" 3$"&

&% $,."48#&% "&4?&%&%".

&%:@#"4*

," & &%

7"& $"7& ,%"3

" %$ $#2&&?"&&"."$&& "$.,&

&%@#"4 ".

"&3&%&&&7"$ $

3$"&&, -%$$ "%&

&%@#&."$,"2324?& &, .4

&% @#"4 ".

"& ?&% &% &&&7 "$ $

3$"& ?&% &% @#"4 ".

&% $,."4 8#&% "&4 3 #" & #"$% &% $ $ 7 &

&% "%& #"&3 24 ? &

7& $"7& = " $#,% 7 &

&%."

?&%3$,."4."

,3 3 , $@#& "3"

3$$$

&% .&& " $ #3& 2%3$7&&3

&%"

" 3 &%"&"&72#&& $& $3 &% "3"

.#$%& ,#3 &%&

&% "3" .$$3 24 &% 8..& 8#&% "&4 3 & 3",& &% $,."48#&% "&4& 3?&%&%,$

&%.&& " $."&%."

7$ ."$,"23 #2#

8#$3&

"3 ..

"&#&4& &%.&& " & $#2& %$ "."$&& 3 &%" &" & .$$ .."

."& "3" ,, "3 & ?

-% &" ."

,$$ $% #32, ,#33?&% $ &%$ "

& 34 , &% .&& " %$ "34 2 3$$$3 "

$"7, &% #%?" & $&$3&% "3"$.$$324&% $,."4 8#&% "&4 3 &% 8..& 8#&% "&4 ? " &,3& .$$4 "3"& "$&&&%.&& " &% & .3 3$.

&% 3$,."4 ,3 "$%24&%, .&&#&% "&4 . 8,, "34 &% ."

7$ 3$$$ "3" 3&3

8#" & &% ?"& .&& 3$$$ "3"3&3

8#"A & &% ?"& .&& 3 &% ..& "3" 3&3

8#"&& &%?"&.&& "$&$3 3@#$%3 -%"$.

3&$"3",&3& 3?&%&% 3$,."4."

,33"?$&&%.&& "$." &% ."

7$ $ ."$,"23 24 ? $ 3,&3 %"2 7 3 &%" &" & .$$ .."

."& "3" ,, "3 & ?

3 &% &" ."

,$$ $% #3 2 , ,#33 ?&% $ &%$ "

& 34 7 -%."

&%","#&&2 "33 &% "$&"$ $#2&&3 24 &% "3 833

$ "&#"3 9 "&$& 2"&%" ?, $&$ -%?"&.&& ,, "34$&3$3$.

4 -22 4 2