High Court of TripuraWP(C)/88/2008allowed

Binoy Kumar Thakur v. Union Of India And 3 ORS

2015-08-17Hon'Ble Mr. Justice S. Talapatra,Hon'Ble The Chief Justice Deepak Gupta11 pages

!"#"$ %

&&& '(( ' )*'+ +) , #'

-"% ! "# $ # % & &' #'.'/('

'"0 ( ) *( )+ ( ( ! , &' 1 #' +2'/('

'"0% ( ) - $( %%% % .

, / 3 #'!!"

(% 00 ( ) /

& ! && '+2 -'

4 5 6 .

4 6 5 )! 7./&

.2 12

)! 7.2 #

((

789,:

# 3 7,;,: 4!7 <

.6= .

# ' ! & 5678906006-(6%% 7:977990 2 6:'! ;*:+ ( ( * ! # + :<0; " "#!''

"*(8 + ( ) >? ! 9:9=799> 9=9=799> ( ) ( "

! '

!00( )/

&! ! /

! 77977990 # !'

? 2 + "

/' + @A 0' , 0' : (#' '

("0 B0 'B/'+ '!2" 'B/' 0'+% ,89:% . 66. A99

#''@ CB' (/' ( 0 3,;18, D. * !" (#"( #+ +'B/'+ +#"00 +("

- ('! "('- E(# ''/( ! (#' -"(' 'F2 " 2'- ' ! (# ! (#' -"(' E#/# (#+ (/' + +'B'- % "+ (#' /"+'!"

@'%('

-''-(#! >1?

! ! %

! " " !!# ! 2

A::*7+(% !'

- ! ' '

(

00 ( ) "# '

:<9A7990 '

>3? !!

( !

"# '!"(43(&<:>07990" ' ! " ! "# 979>799B "

$ (

1 $' ! '

! 1

! !! ", 2&;;; 799B $ (

!! '

' ' "# :99=799B!"#

!! " #

(

:B9 ( ) "# & 56%69;6:B96%% A99:7990

"# &<7B 9=9<799;

( ( ) ! '

&=:8799> 7;9;799> '

! " :>B8:>=8:><8>>B8;9>8A9B % ( 7B 2 2 % '

! !'

!( ( 3 .

!!'

>:? !

! !!

! ((3 .

"#'

# !! " !2!'

! # !# '

; ( ( * ! # + :<0;' #

! # # ! >9? ! 1 ' '

! %

'' )

' 6 !

$ 23( ()(7 "#

1 :09A79::

& A<A 7990 2 6C 1

D $ '

D A9B8:>< % ( 7B 2 2 " ! " >>B8;9> % ( '

! "

! '

>;? . /&

!! ! "

' "

! " ( 7A9A79:; ! " !6 "

$ ( 9B9>799; ! '

# ! !

' # !!# ! !!E!!@F'

!! "#

!! !! .

1 " !

"!$ !"B+("(' "

-(#'+%! ,,81% ""#

! '

# !! # " ' E

"@ '

!! "

# '

E "@

# ! # '

- " *- "0"

" "

C"(#"

B+ "! "("

<"-"B%! 1,;8 "

!" !#'"D >? .

1 ( '

"#! #

# " "

' ! D

! >8? ) . 2 #

(( !! ! "

# !"

" ! '

. #

(( ! G'

- "*- "0"

" "

C"(#"

B+ "! "("

<"-"B%! 1 ,;8%

-""

-(#'+B+ 2"- G"

% ! ,, 1,3% ."

" #"

$" <"-"B B+

-""

-(#'+%!,, 189

.'B'

-" !"B+("(' ((""

/#"0"

-(#'+% !,18191$

!! ' " !!

!!!

! # !!

! ' !

@ %

" " ! ' !

! # ( #

! ' !

" # !'

799B799>2 " '

! 799B799> ! !

7;9;799> - ' !"

! '

" 'E!!@) ! "# !

( 7A9A79:; " ! " !

# "

$ ( 9B9>799;

9B9>799; "#

$ ( ( . &::007 799;

2 37 7;: 7990 ! ( "G 2 B+ ("(' 2 " *1 909079:> 4 *(+ >> 79:>+

!!++ ' 0/' "

- (#'+ B+ "

-2 !"% ! ,, 3 933

'! ! '!!++ '

0/' "

- (#'+ B+ "

-2 !" % ' "

!! ' !!++ '

0/' "

- (#'+ B+ "

-2 !" $

! ? , ' '+2'/( 00 "C'' E(# (#' .'0# C# ( (#"( (#' /"

/'00"( #+ /"

--"( ' E"+ 00'C"0% @ ( E' E+# ( CB' E 2 (#'!"((' ,1 #'

(#' /-'

( #"22'

'- (#'

'+2 -'

( ! +( #"B' @''

"@ (

'"+ "C' ( (#"( "C' C 2'20' ('

/!!( -+/'( +% - + /# -+/'( + /"

@''

/ - '- ('"00% (#E00@' (##'

"' ( 'F2'/('-(@'#"B' "+!"( '"!"

' "+ 0-' 2'20' '

/'% "22"/# +# 0- @' ( / - ' ! -+/'( + !"-' @ C 2'20' "(#' (#"

( @"

- (#'! "+ /! "0+ (#' '+( (#'0B'+ ,3 (#+ /

'/( % E' !"

'' ( (#' /#""/(' H5'"

*"0G'"

H */( CH+ B'0H'+6+'"@0'+H% E#/# /!!(( C " ! '

/' +('"0 C " 0" @'"- #+ # C "!0 5'"

*"0G'"

E"+ @"

-'- "+ " (#' #+ E#0'0'

,: #' !-' "22"/# +# 0- @' ( '! " 2'+ +('"- @"

- C #! "+"/! "0"00#+0' ,9'!"

"0+#''''((#'/"+' '0+# +( -'

(+ !'

( '- @ - .'

C #+@$H. ' /'++"EH ( "22'"+ (#"( +!' +( -'

(+ "0'+ E'' B' '

(# +"+(/ "@ ( (#' '0+# 0"

C "C' "

- (#'

E'' 2+'( @'/" +' (#' "- 2C"!!'+ E'' @' C @"-/"+( (#' C0+#0"

C "C'"

- ( '0+# #'

/"!' 2 ( - "

- B"-'- (#' C# ( #'

E'' - C 0( / ('!2(/ ("

-+'

/'- ( 2+ (#'' ! (#+ @ (#' C# ( 5 -C' #'

0'- "

"22'"0 @'' (#' (22'"0+00E C(#'"22'"0% -.'

C@+'B'-7 /!' E ( 6 "($ E'00H+ (#- 2 ( ' +"

+ (#"( (#' +'

/'+ E'' 'F/'++B' - ( (# $ (#'

E'' 'F/'++B'% "( (#' (!' (#'

E'' CB'

- (#' // !+("

/'+ (#'

'F+( C '' E"+ " -'0@'"(' ('''

/' E(# (#'/ +'G +(/' "/"+'E#/# E"+ / /' (#'+ ( E"+

'/'++" (#' G -C' ( +#E A - ( +#E ( "00 +( -'

(+ 'B' E#''A(#"((#+$ -(# C /"

( @' (0'"('- '( +( -'

(+ -'! +("('% (#'

20'"+'% (#' /" +'+ E#/# (#'

@'0'B' '( (#'! !"$' (#' 2('+(+ "+ (#'

E00 ( (#'

! +( - ( @ 0"E 0 !'"

+ "

- ( @ 0"E 0 (#'

+($'"((#'/ +'G +(/' (#+ 0"

-A"

-+2'"$@(# C0"

- -"0'+A(#'

+($'"((#'(+ +/'( (+'0% "

- (#'

@ C -E (#"(E#/#2('/(+(#'!(+ @ (#'!" ('

/'0"E"

- -' (#"( (#'

"' 2B0'C'- ( @' +( -'

(+ "

- ( +( - "

- 0B' 2'"/' 0'( (#'! + 22( (#' 0"E - (+($'(-E

( E E#"( + ( @' - 'I #' 0"E #"+ @''

B -/"('- @ (#' +'

/'+ E#/# (#' G -C' 2"++'- '- '+-"

0"+(E''$'#"+ +#E (#"( 0"E "

- -' ! +( @' !" (" '-%"

-E00@'!" (" '-

( (#+ "22'"0% (# C+ "' /#"

C'- #'+' +( -'

(+ #'' 0 C' -' (#' 0"E #'

#"B' "22'"0'- ( (#+ ( "

- +#E '+2'/( ( #'

#"B' "0'"-

+'B'- " E''$ 2+ - ( (# $ ( '/'++" ( $''2 (#'! +-' ( "

0 C' #'+' C 2'20' "' - " /! "0+ #'' + B0'

/'% -+# '+( B/' (#'! (#'/ (" %(#'' E"+ ! /# (#"( E' +# 0- "220" - #'

E+# ( - "00 (#'

( 2'+'B' (#' '0+# 0"

C "C' '00 !"

(#'

@' 2 - ( ( + (#' 0"

C "C'(#'@"-+A(#'2'(+ -(#'+ C'+A!'!'0- +@ " (#"

C# C0+# ( C '

#C#" (#( %(+# 0-@''J "0 "0'+ E(# C0+# #'

#"B' - 'E CAB' E CA C C ( (#' 'F('!' (#'

-- (% (#"( #"B C@''

+#E %(# $E'/"

% - +# 0-% +#E !'/ (#'! ' +# 0- 2'!( (#'! ( C @"/$ ((#'+( -'+%((#'2"'

(+"

- / ( ' (#' C- / +' E#/# (#'

#"B'+E C0 -+( @'- >*-'76+BE /',8; K ,,3? ,; 2 % E' +# 0- -+20"

(#' +"!' E+-! "+ -+20"

'-@ -.'

C , + "0'"- @+'B'- "@B'%

(# ('

/!!( -+/'( +% E#/#"'('

/ - '- >,? '

!!++ ' 0/' "

- (#'+ B+ "

-2 !"% !! !!

" '

! /

!! '

79#

'79# '!'"

#" "# ! #2'

" !!

! # ' ! " >,,? $

! 7:9779902 6:' ! !

" ' ""1 "#

! # (

00 ( ) !$ (

00( ) !&> !

' ! " ' ! A*+

#'! !# ! &> 4

! ! !!++ ' 0/' - (#'+ B+ "

-2 !" "

4 " ' ! '

" " 5 . 5