High Court of TripuraWP(C)/218/2011allowed

Sabita Choudhury And 4 ORS v. State Of Tripura And 3 ORS

2015-01-14The Hon'Ble Mr. Justice S.C.Das,Hon'Ble The Chief Justice Deepak Gupta10 pages

!"#

" #$$%%& '!

"( $ %!&'

(# !)* + ( ", -

( "!

" #$$%%# '!

"( ) *+ ' (! !"# (. (

( , , &/

( , !

" #$$%%0 !

"( , ! -.!# 1

* +)*

" #$$%%& !

" ( / %'!(!-.# 2

3""

4 + "

( 5

5 01!23 .. 4!

5!# 3 "3 67 3""43"'3(

7"3 " "!

*) #$$%%8 '!

" ( ..6!.!" . 7 4!

5!# 93( 7"3 " " !

*) #$$%%8 '!

" ( ) .- !.6 !# 3""3"'3( 67 !

" #$$%%: (

, !

5!. +.+4!. !"& ! # 3 3""!7+ !

" #$$%%&( / 7.!'.' 4'

# ;< 3(7" + 7,("

&&%%& 8 ..'!+ +.+4!.& ! # )*"+ 7 + &/* ="! ,("

&&%%&8

5 & $9& : * -

% $9&* : -

! . .

'.! ; *!-%& 2<2=*!%$

6.2

! .!.25 ' .'2 ; *! %& 2<2# 22# *!2

# + # *!$*> .!# 7 *! *> .!# 7 -. 4 .!

'?= -.+ 7.!" 4> ?.' ' ! .! ; ,/ . .!4 4 !;@

.5 ! '? : -*$= -

+ " " +!)3

3""!7+3" " 333 3 1 = "" " 3" 7

+" 3"7 " 3 )3 3 3""+ 3" +! )3 " ' )3 ( )3 3 !"" )3 &$8%> "

3 3""+ )3 3""+"" 67 167 "?> !3"&/ = ) &$ ! &$@$3 3 3 3""!7+

"" +!)3 3 ""A

!"# $ % " & '(&)#*( & & +$, -" %%$! $$ $. /0" )12 3 -0+-4 +$ , - - 4+& ,5%6 04& $! $$ $. /0+-$+5)$ +$78 !

," ,!+$ / !0 6& 0+-/ 1&& -$ % /+ % %4 $ $!" 92 %&+ -!& :4$+5)$ & : 1 - 5% 0 ! 3 -! & $ +$ , - 1 - 4+0 +- & 0& 5 4 -0+- $6 -!$ )+6 /1 - 4+ & ,5%6 04& $! $ $ $. /0 +- $+5)$ +- & $ + ' $ 05 /+: %6 9 4'2;<2"& ,5%6 04& $! $$ $. /09& 9 $ +- $:+/ 0-='2;=2, 6"& $ 4$ 1 %%9 ! 5 1 9 - & 9 0 0 4 $ +$ , - 1 - 4+0 :+>

-$+1)$6 $:+! - )-! 0/& , -! & -0+- -! $ )+6 0/& , & ,5%6 0 4 & $! $ $ $. /0 9& - $ ! +- & 0 $:+/ - $ 4 $ '2<2 9+%%

), +/ %%6 1 #)+! ! 16 & -0+- -! $ )+6 1 - 4+ 0/& , 0$ 4 $$ ! 1: ,"& $ 4$ "$ ?) 06)@+-!%61 +- 5+- 4$,& ,5%6 0/-/ $- !9&9 $ +-0 $:+/ 0-='2=2 1 9 -- 4& 1: , -+- !90 04$ +$ , - 1 - 4+ 0/& , 9+&+- - ,-& 4$, & ! 4 $ / +5 4 &+0% $ -!& 5+-0 3 $/+0 !16& ,, 65% 0 1 4)$-+0& !&+0 $!4$&9+&

05 /+, - /56 4 & 5+- $, +0 -/%0 ! & $ 9+& )$04 +&4)%%6"

-/%00 ! !72

A , ! " " " 3""+,("

"" 67 3 " 3 "" " + ! )3 = " 3 " " 73 0& %0 &$@@ " 7 " 3 7 9 = " " 3""

" 3" " + 67 " 3" /A& / /& %8 /%%% 67 3

7 7

" 3""!7+3" +!)3 3" "!7+ 33 3 7 3 7 7 " +!)3 8 =

"&$ ! &$@$ 7 /%%$/%&%

"67 73 3

/0 3" 7 " ! 1 = 33 " " 3 67 3""" )3 " +!)3 67 3

37 "" 7 3 )3 0& %0 /%%:

" 1 = 67 " "B " 3 " ""7 3 7

3"B=3"" 3 167 3 " 7

7 " 7 )3 = 333 " < 3 67 "67 " "

3 3 7 7 3 3 &$ ! &$@$3"33 " )3" "

3 " 67 "" < 7

3 3 """" 3" " " 67 7 "

7 3 33" "" "" " 3""+" 333 3&$@$ B C B 3 "

"67 3 3""3 "+ 3 /0 <7 " 3 "2"@&$$# 67 = 67 &$$# 7 " 67 7

)3 =

" (7" 3 D = (E <" 3 " ) 1 33 " " 67 0& (3 /%%- " 367 = ; < 3 (7" 3 ""A 8 8 D8

8 8 E D

8 D D"

D2'';;;' 10+ &5779999/!-+/+-

%=== B" % 4 3=='<(

2, +%0 /69/!C01-+/+- '2'7;;'2 / ,1 $"='";;<

$ F+-!%6 $ 4 $ ,6 % $ 4 : - -),1 $ !

! ';(;;<$ # $!+-#5& 0+-#)4& $! $$ $. /0" %4 $ 3 -0+- $. /0 -! ,-0$ +- $. /0 -!

10$1 & 5$. / ,5%6 0 +- -2#+-# : $-, - 5$#$ ,, 0 05 /+ %%6+- & : %09$+ -& /$ $+ 0+-/& $# 4, - -! &+%! : %5, -:+! ,6 % $ !

! 'B'';;< 4$ & 0 , 0 & ! /+0+- 4 5& 0+-# ) & 1: 5$. /0 9 0 @ - +- & , +-# 4

,,+ 4 /$ $+ 0& %!-;<;;<9+&$ 4 $ -/ & $ /,, -!

+-04& 35 -!+)$ 4$,0 ,,+00+-" & ! /% $%6 +-!+/ ! +- ,6 % $ !

! 'B'';;< 9+& $ 4 $ -/ & $ /,, -!

+-0 4 & 35 -!+)$ 4$,0

,,+00+-" & ! /% $%6 +-!+/ ! +- ,6 % $ !

! 'B'';;< 9+& $ 4 $ -/ & $ /,, -! +-0 4 &

35 -!+)$ 4$,0 ,,+00+-"& !/% $%6+-!+/ !+-,6 % $!

!'B'';;<& -6:

/ -/6+-& 0&)%!1 4+%% ! )5 4+$0 4$, & 0 5$. / ,5%6 0 -! )0+! / -!+!

00&)%!1 $ /$)+ !-%6 4 $& 5$. / ,5%6 0

$ 4)%%6 !.)0 !7 10$1 ! & : - 6 $ / +: ! -6 50++: $ 05-0 4$,6)$ ! /+0+- & 0 -9 1 - @ - & -$ % /+ % %4 $ $!9+%%05, +-#+00& $ 9 $!0& 0 $. /0 4 $ =';=;;

- & /+$/),0 -/ 0 +& $ & $. /0 $ 1 /%0 ! -! & ,5%6 0 1 ! /% $ ! 0)$5%)0$& ,5%6 0 $ 10$1 !+- $0+,+% $65 4 : $-, - 5$#$ ,, 0 & : $ :+ 9 ! & 0 )0 $ 5$4& 5$. /0 0-=';=;;< -!4)-!& -),1 $4:

/ -/+ 0 $ & $ +-& 3+0+-# 5$. /0+- 6)$ - !!++-"- 9 5$. /0 $ 1 0 -/+- ! +-6)$ &)0 0)10 -+ %-),1 $45004!+44 $ - / #$+ 09+%%1 :

+% 1% # +-09&+/&& 5$. / ,5%6 0 /)%!1 !.)0 ! = " & $ 4$ " 9)%!%+@ $ ?) 06) @+-!%6 #+: 5 $0- % -+-&+00)1. / -!, @ $$ -# , -0 /%0 !9-& 1: 5$. /0 -! !.)07 10$1& 5$. / ,5%6 0 +- & -#+-# : $-, - 5$#$ ,, 0 $ 50++: %6 16 =';=;;

4 +%+-# 9&+/& 9 9+%% & : / %++# +-0 -! & $ !,+-+0$ +: 5$1% ,0 0 &

-$ % /+ % %4 $ $! 9-* 1 , +-# +0 0& $ 4 $ =';=;;

< +&1 09+0& 04$ D 556 96 $" )$00+-/ $ %6" !72 :

$ &+ 4 /$ $+ 0 4 & 0 4 '

-!&$ $ ! 0&" 00 ,"= +& $"< ).

$ "

D $6 - "B D+, /& %$ ! 0&" H ,,) E F 0&,+$" F $-

@ " ( 8 !&6 $ ! 0&" ';

-+5)$" ''

8 #& % " ' 8+>$ ," '= # % -!" '<

$+00 "'

)-.

1"'B .

0& -"'G %&+"'

@0& !9 5" '( & +0# $&" ;

H& $@& -" '

$)- /& % $ ! 0&" +@@+,"= $+5)$ "< "

"B E0% -!

564$+-4$, +- -!- / 00 $6 /+- +

/$ $+ 0+-/& $# 4 4& 1:

0 ++ H E " 24$+-4$, +- -! - / 00 $6 /+- +++

3 /)+: +$ /$" 24$+-4$, +- -! - / 00 $64%%92)5 /+- :

$ A ! " " 7

+!)3 " 67 3 0& %0 /%%: "" )3 = " 3"" 33 3 )3

3" " 3" " " " 67 = ( " " 67 " 67 3 )3 = ( )3 "67 3 )3 "3" 3 33 3 + ! )3 "" 3 3""+ " "" " " "3 3 " 3 1= 3 /0 "" D E , -@ /%&& 6 <

" +3 3

3 , 0- " 7""A & $ 0 & 5 ++- $0 9 $ - : $-, - ,5%6 0 -!& 69 $ -/: $ !16& -0+- 1% )% 0 -! 9 $ 55+- !7 -# # ! )-! $ -$ % : $-, - /& , & -$ % : $-, - & 0 !+0/-+-) !& +$/-$+1)+- - :+ 9 4 & 1: -! %+,+ +- 4 4+- -/+ % $ 0)$/ 04 / !16& : $-, -"$ ?) 04& 5 ++- $0& 01 -/-0+! $ !1)& 0-1 - #$ ! 16& : $-, -A ) " 3 "

"3 3 3

7 "! &$@$ 67 " " " ;" 3 " 67 "

" 3 &$ ! &$@$ , 9 3 7 3

" ! 33 3"" 1 = 3 7 " " 0& %0 /%%:

!"" 0& %0 /%%:"" 7 1= ! 33 " "" " 3 "67 3"" 3" " "

= 7

" 7 " 3" " 3 "67 3"" 7 3 33 3

&$$# &$$# "" /%%: 3" 7

" " 3 67 "

7 " 67 67 3 " " / = 7 "" 3 "" "" "" " " 0% 2 /%&:

3 1 = 3 3 " 0% 2/%&: ""3 F&/G "" ""

8 33 " : - :