← Library
High Court of TripuraWP(C)/466/2012dismissed

Rabindra Debbarma And 3 ORS. v. State Of Tripura And 3 ORS.

2015-12-08Hon'Ble Mr. Justice S. Talapatra9 pages



 

              

 ! ! "#$  %"! &'!

("&)''&"*&+    

   

       

     %"!,& * !%!

,&+     !  

   

  - %"!%&.&/0& !)& &+  " 

 !  !#

!      

    %* 12 # & !)&#+ $  %   "  

" 

32(45& $ &   '   

#6 ( #$  ,% & "!67"&+

   (

 (

  $

 &

 )  

    

   *+ ,--../

[2]  ,%5" &"2 5)6&" *

  $

 &

 )  

   

  

*+,--../ - ,)!"5 " "&/ /!5+

      

   *+,--..0  ,1!

%5" &"2+ 1    "'

  $

  &

 )

  

   

  *+,--../   32(45& $ 2%

 '    

 ! ! "$ 8(2&97'/!+  !  

   

3  

   

  32(45& $ &   '   

#6 ( #$  ,% & "!67"&+

   (

 ( 1     "'

 

  $

  &

 )

  

   

  *+,--../  ,%5" &"2 5)6&" * 

 $

 &

 )

      

  *+,--../ - ,)!# "!5 :%##! 17(;+

    +   



 (4 29

[3]   ,1!

%5" &"2+ 1     "'  

  $

  &

 )

      

  

*+,--../ 32(45& $   5   '     

 ! ! "$ %* & !9&3!#<&#)'+ $   &  

   

 3

  

  

  32(45& $ &   '   

#6 ( #$  ,% & "!67"&+

   (  

 ( 6  3     

  $

 &

 )  

    

   *+ ,--../  ,%5" &"2 5)6&" * 

 $

 &

 )

      

  *+,--../ - ,)!"5 "+ 6!

3  

 &

     

 *+,--..0  ,1!

%5" &"2+ 1     "'  

  $

  &

 )

      

  

*+,--../ 39

[4]  32(45& $ 5 '   

 ! ! "#$  %"!)7/&/,&9"&'" !+       

&  !  5( 6 7 # !     +  

 %"!3!.2%&"*&+  5   



 89:



   

 32(45& $ &   '   

#6 ( #$  ,% & "!67"&+

   (

 ( 9

    "'



 $

 &

 )

  

   

  *+,--../  ,%5" &"2 5)6&" *

  $

 &

 )  

   

  

*+,--../ - ,)!"5 "%5,/(75& ! +

   + 



*+,--../  ,1!

%5" &"2+ 1    "'

  $

  &

 )

  

   

  *+,--../   32(45& $ 2%

 '   49

[5] 3     =38 1 %%       $.;0##.0<   '

(   $ >   

 $  )8: )

    $      8&: ;//  #.0#  8&: ;-,  #.0#  8&: ;-=  #.0#   8&: ;--  #.0<         ( 

    

  

 >   $ $    $   ?@       $ 

 '     '  ?0.?#.0# $       1=8#:@1*8":@#.0#   ?0.?#.0#$  )

   $ 

(

' 

   ?.-    &   *  

 

     <= (    /. (        

(  

  

  $  

(       "'

(  $ $ 

  <=(     0

#.0#*      (           ?0.?#.0# + A,!# #,&// &9 5  "* #  (&2  6"!/+& ('&66/!5&'/!

5&##  % &  4"

* *6/2# " !"!

; "& " ,& (&  &## !

 <,!5, % &  4"

* *6/2# <, &" &/"&(2 59

[6] #!  <7/( " !"   5*6/ !  , 6"!(  #75, B #!   #"4!5C  ?-@    $        

$   )  '  ?8 :   



'     

          

     '

(    $    

 $    )    '  '             ?0.?#.0#  $     "'

(    "

53&$  ?0.?#.0#$         A ?@ &       

  

     

( $   )  ' $              ?0.?#.0#   (    $   $      $ (   

   

  

     )    /. (      

    

(  *             

     "

7

(   /. (       %          

      " B&

%"!)<!.(&#,&9"&'" 24#, % &   "!67"& & (  ,"# 8        .=00#.00 

;.#.00:$     C ) C    

' ( ) *   ($$ D )  E  )  

7 )   69

[7] ?>@  1        %  2 %

         %  5            %  5        

  

   '           %"! )<!.(&# ,&9"&'" 2 4# , % &   "!67"& & (  ,"#  '  ( 

  

        ?0.?#.0#$ >  ( 

'       

$ 

     !

  #,    

   !  8   &  '   : !

  0-=/



 <# (         

          

 (  

 (#8$: (   <.<#(  

'$$ $      

   '   

   



'  

    

  *        ?0.?#.0#

'        ?0.?#.0#      (  0

 #.0#    

          

(            '     .0.;#.0#    (               ?0.?#.0#  $ (.0.;#.0#% '

  

' 1!</8:

' + "4!(( 7" ," ,&  & 4"

* #"4&  <, ,&# & &!

( , &;  ! 2D!;, 2&"#"'" ,!"# (&2  8&2+   & ( !#   B #!  !

#"4!5+ #,&// " !" "* , #"4!5  B6!"2  ,!# B (( 6"!(  #"4!5C 79

[8] 

' 

  (    

'  1!</8:$  + "4!(( ,&  & 4"

*  #"4& <,# (&   '!" , !# , !"#   & * ,#,&//" !""*#"4!5  , & "

   , /&#  (&2  , 6"5(!

; * ,   & &!

; , &; #!B 22&"#C ?@        ?0.?#.0# 

     

'   

 $  

      ?0.?#.0#             <= (    ( $               ?0.?#.0# ?

@ &       

  

        

    

 &

  

( 

           



'         ( '        )  (    

 

(    (

     

 5( )

   $ 

'

   ?.- & * "'

$    



'  $ '     

(           (   

(        ?0.?#.0#   

     

(   

(    

       

        

 

           )

'    )      (

           ( 89

[9]    ' 

    

     )

  4     4  %7''&"&27(7+

      %  $ 

     

 )   

   

 

'    

  '  + E> &5& &(5!#! # ,!#7" !  ,&# '

 ,/( ,&  , 57 D (&  !# !B( '2 , B57 !4 &7 ,"! 2 96!

; 4!< ,5 *!55 (! ! #+!

5!&/ 5 # "&!

# ( *& 2  ," &(*!

!# "& !4 (  ," (!

; 5!"57*# & 5# ,!# 7"  !# &/#  , 4!< ,& !B!

;57 D(& #!#<! ,!

 , (*&!

 ,B57 !4&7 ,"! 2& ( , 57"  #,7/(   "*&//2 !

"" <! , , !B& !  57 D (&  '2 , B57 !4 &7 ,"! 2 7 /## #75, "(" &66&"#  '   , &5  !  '/& & /2 (!#5"!*!

& "2& (&"'! "&"2C ?

@  &

     (    

              ?0.?#.0# B'        $       '       $   1 )     99