← Library
High Court of TripuraWP(C)/386/2011dismissed

Dilip Roy And ANR v. State Of Tripura And 4 ORS.

2015-11-27Hon'Ble Mr. Justice S. Talapatra18 pages

   

       

  

    

 !  "#$ 

%#$ 

&%

  $  ''

 (   ) * 

   (  )  $

 +$ !



  , - $ ..

'

 /'..

'

! $*  '

 '

 

   $  #  (    )  #'.



   

 !"  0

 

 .

''1    '2' 3'

 3$ -4  ' 5 /6* $ "&/6 .

#$ 

%  0,

  3'

 07   3'

 #' (1 ) '   3$ -4  ' 5 /6* $ "&/6 .

#$ 

% 08   3'

.

%  '   3$ -4  ' 5 /6* $ "&/6 .

#$ 

% 09   3'

 "* :%  '   3$ -4  ' 5 /6* $ "&/6 .

#$ 

% 0;   

   0< = '/'

*4'>     / > .



   0?  .:

6'    0  > .    

 



6 .     (.3$   3$  2 @3'  #$ 

"

#$  2 " % ) , / '

 > .



   7  6 

   (.3$   3$  2 @3'  #$ 

"

#$  2 " % ) 

"# $

" %   &%'

( ))



@  *:/*4 #3  @  *:A:

6' #3   $ *,70;,0910?0,09 3 A$' *+,

"   

     (-$./

0 $!$ ! *  '    4      3  $'' '-@8(,)#(1 )   <0 ,0  #5    4        -@,(9)#(1 )

(+ )   ,0,,0 #5 ,4       ' $   - <  ,,         -;      4     .  

   4 '

>$ $    .   3    (  )           ''

   3  '   3 # 

'

. 4 ' $.

3

 $  ''

 '   .    ' $     3     (  )   3   

  # B   

 '

 .3  4 .$ - , 7''

>$  $  ''

  '          (  ) 4 '

 $  '''$ '  3  4 '   .$.

  

  4  ' .6'

  2$ 45 6 3    

 .$ %() -7,?  ,0243  4 4  ' ..

 090 ,0 ..3 C  

     

  

 

        

    

        

      



 

    

 

 

     

    

  !! 

" 

   #$%#&%'#    

 

   ( "   "    

 

  

%  

 



 

  

 ") 

  * +,-      .

/0$01 

2   

 

 "  "

     

  2    

 

    

  

 

    

     

  



 %3

1

       

 

   #'  ( 1 )  3'     .  .

         090 ,0          #5 8  ;4 .

  >$4  0()

'  

'    ''

 .'

4  '    243    4 $3 .  

      '    $$3 .

   -7   

 

  #'  ( 1 )  '  3' 

 ,   '       -7            00<,0

 700;,0  '$ '

  $ 

''

  (  )' 

   ( )   3  1  3  #  ??   4   1 

3   ?? .

'' ' <0 ,0 4   .  $ .

  4      '' ' <0 ,04 .  ' $'' '4  . #5  4   * ' $'' ' - , 7 3''  ''



             

     -, .4     ;< 3   4      

3   '

.  ''

  .

  + $        ''

      '

 . $3 '       '$ 6  5     .   '  $    4 >  $  4 $                ''

     3   $    .    '    B  '

         1 

3 # ?? .#$  3 . .4 $ ''

  ".

   3  $  $   '

 .

  -@,(9)#(1 )

(+ )  ,0,,0

   . 3   3  1 3 #   .44$   $  :/*4       .'   $     ' $  4-9.4        1  3  # ?? -9.4  3 C

4      "   

     

      "  *,

       "   ( "  

  " *,     



   "     

    

   2

( 

  2

  

 *,  %3 2 : *4       .'    $ >''

         '     $  .    3     $    $$ -9.4 1 # ?? -,.4       3  ?;<  33 43 3

3  ?;<  '''' @        -,  $ .4     '

. C *',   

 2    )  /      5 "

6 

   )  /  "    

    

   "%3  $  3  D  E'

 ,     3   ?;< '             #$  : *4    E  4'

>$ $    >   ''

       3 $   4              3       '

 $      . 4         .    -;74 

    ''           3   ?;<   4   090<,00   4.4  -;7      -;73   :A:

6'      -9  -;

?7  .       -  9        -;     -?  7       3  $   '   4  #$       $    >   ''

   '

'  .

 '

           -, .4               ?;< ::

6'   $    $   .'  $   ' .

    $  $  $ . 

 4$  -9 .4        1 

3 # ?? '

34 3 8 9 # .    -7   $  6        .

 ' $ '' '   <0 ,0 : :

6'       .'    ' $   ,0,,0 #5,4  

.       '   4   090 ,03%()-7,?,0 

   B        . 4 $ >''

   '-,.4           ?;<  ' ' '  '  3 .

  -9 .4  1 3  #  ?? -9    3   4    $   3  .'

     '



'  '   ' >    

 '  '   '  '

 4 >  $  4 $  $ '  @'  3' '

   4            3

  3    (  )  #         ''

  !    $ $  ''

  #     ()  # ''

         3  .

  * 4$ $4 

 ''

  

      3   $    -7   4   ' 

$  '    -9      1 

3  #  ?? 4  3  3$  3  3   -,  $ .4              (  )    

   '    3   ?;<   4$  33F 3     3   ( )    4'

>$ '  3   ( ) 3  4 G3    3      $   '

 $4'

>$ '

3   ( )  $   4  $  '         ( )' 7 34 '4 34-9 3.4    1  3  #  ??     

$  3         '

   

         .      .   ' -, 3  3$ 7 E5    ( )  '

.  ''

  .6

' $.

  64 3. 3 $ >''

      3    *      $'   ''

    $4    3  $ 4 3    #    ''

G     . #      ''

       

''

.

   '$    % $ . ' 

   4  >    $  4   $ H  53      '   $   7 8  -  + 9 % % : +9 % * !;5,5&1' 5   C 2 

    

 2   

 "%        

"    

   %             

    "

 2  "      <            

    

  

.   

 %     





 



   



 "%3  1     %      =    * !!$,>5!' 5 .3 C    

 

 

 

  2 =



          (      %    2"    2      

   

%3 ,  :    % % %      * !!>,$$1' 5  C !%????:  "2    *  )  , 

   

" %@  

" 

 %

 

2 A A

 1  

      -      

         *   )  , 

  ;      "    

    

   2     

     "      

 %   

 

"  



%

2

 

 

2 A A

  



% $%  

 

              

            

        

       "  % @         

%  

 

  



   )  



 

"  



   

      2 

"   



  

      

 %    2 " 



 "   "        

   % 

"

"

      

   

    

 

   

 !% >%????%%@  



     

 

"

 %@" 

"

        

"   

" 

 %

   "             

"  "     

 ( 

 

  " %3       =  % B

       * !!1,  >1' 4  ' .    3 46   . C 

 C  

  

  2    

  "  



 

       

       

 

        %  

 

    

 2  <  <   <      

     



<%< < <    

  

" (   <%D

E 

A 



 - " 

 F % ##!G% < < 

  " 

      

   (         

  %

 2 

.

< < 

 

  

 2

       



   <  

 

"  



%< +   .B   @    H 7 % % (    "

  *'# ,!> # 5$     C ' % 

 2



   2  "B @   

I

 C  

  H%)%  

%   J   I

 C 

/ !;5*',7% 5!!

E <     

     

 

" 

  "



 %  

 

    

    

     

   "

  " 



  "  

  2 



"   



     "% @        "  

 

K 

     

            



     "    "  

 %  

2  

 

 

   "

"

    



   "%   

L

    

%  

     

  "%"    

          "   

 

   "  %H "

       2    

     

  "%

"2  "  

  "%      





     "  

     "  .

    %       

  "   

 

 

    



     

  

  "  %  

     

 

   2

 

  

            2  



   

 M  A  

  

   L

          

% 

" 

   

            "  

    

" 

 

  

    "% 4

  

     



     "           "  " 

    " 

    %< ''%@ 

 2

2



  2

     2 

 

  

        

               





   

 2    %4 "



  @         

     * ,

   



                "      

   L

" 

   

        

      " 2"   

%B  

 

 @ 





  B

 % '5%  B

    * , 

 

 2

   "  

       * 

=  

 ,2  .



     

    

   "

   

 

 

 2   2 

    %   



      

    



   

         "  

    .



 

    

    

    

    2  (     

2     

 

 L

  %4   2

  

E <78 -  %: 

"    

  

    

    

 2

%&#/ &#  

  

    

   "   "

)

  

 2

   '>N   

  2

    

  )    

     % >#/5##  

 

  

  "     %&#/ &#% B



   

  )    2

  2 L   

 2

   

    )  % 

 

  )  



"   2

  

   "    2 (%   

 

   <         )    

   "  2 < <   )        

   

"

2 "                              

    )    

   

 .    

  <    <   )   

 



 

   



 



 "<%



(  

    

             



  )   2  "/  /

2    

2 

       2 "     

   







   )  

  "    2        %   



  

 

 

    



        % 

  

    

     

 

         % 



      

  '&* ,   

   

  

 

 "  

     J       

 



  

 

 % :

  /

  *>,  

 '&* ,  

2    "  



 

 . 

   "     

 

  

L

       "  

      "/ /

%  /

  *1,  

 '&* ,          



 

   

    

 



     "/ /

  

      >#E>#%<  *    , '$%  -"   )

  %     8  / !&$*5,51

J  @    



E <%%%%%%%%%    

 

        2       

"  "

 

%B

    2   

 )

  

 "

.

 

 

    

    

  %   =   %* !1&,    78 - 9 % %:    9 % * !;5, 5  &1'  

 C 

  2

 

   

.   "   2                 " %

" 2  =  



       

  2    

  " 

  



   

  5#!   " .

 

 

 



  1' 

 % 2 

  

.

A A

 '5> 

 %*

@%%O 9 % %

%  C "9 % %* !& ,   #'$,% "2



  2

  .

 





C 

" 

 '5>   

        

  %4 

 

2 





 

  

 

  

.   "  

    "   

 

    

            

   %  

        

 =  .  " 2        

 "     % !##/ &##       2 )

   

  

   %%%%%%%%%%< '>% 

  

    -"   )

  2  

  B

    

 2

E <

 C  

 

  

       

  -"   )

  %     8    9 % D !&$G '   ;#5 2

  





   

 )

   

    -  J   

  )   

 

 



   

2"     "   

2 



  -  J    

    )   -  J  %

       2

  

  

 

  

.   "    

    )   "        



  

        

    

 =  .  " 2      

"  % 

   

 

   

2

 

% C

 

                 .    

    %8



 

     "  

 

  "/  /

     2

  '&* ,   

 %< '1%  2   

    -"   )

  B

        

   

    

 2

 

      

    



  

      

              

 

  



  %3   

 @  H7

% % (    "

 5  $''

$.



$4    '  4   4   $    33

'     $   .      '   33$        3           $''

     .            (  ).' ' 7  $  $  '

     .

     2

$   ..$4  34-9.4 1

3 # ?? ' ' 4  >   $  > #  

    .

   3            B'.3 3$ 

 $4'$ . #     #        ''

   ''

          ' $   4 . 3 '    ,0,,0 2  @   H 7

%

%  (     "  

     $ 

'  $ $  3.  C '!%9

" 

  

      

     

 

 

 2   

 E *,          (              2       

     

  "%      

   

     

    2

      "       

" 2    

%@ 



   /          

       

" /

   "

  

 M A       

" 

 

  % 

 2 "      

 



    L

 % *,: 

"

   "

 

     "   

  2   

 

    2

    

%     

   

   

    2   "     

   

    

"    

" % *, 



 2

 

        



 "   2          " 

           

"  % @  

   

   2

 

2% 4

 

       

 "/ 2             

"  2    

"2   

 "     2  %@  

       

 "/  2           

        2 

      

2    

" %

2   "               

              2

      



" % * , ) 

"  

             " 2 

      

   

 % :    

     

        

 2

   " *        "



  ",2        % @    

            

    



    "     

             

 "    2    %  

 

     

"

 



  " 



     

  "         

"      

         %



  

       

     

  2 

          

  

 %  * , 4

 

        

   

  "

   

% @ 



  

      



   

   

 2 "% * , 4

 

  





     



  

           "  2  "

 

"2     

 

 2   

   

% 9 

 

 2

 





        



  

"

   

.   

      

    

     

%3 

  $.3 .$  '4$  $C @  

      

    

 

    "     

         

"    2     %  

 

 

   "

2  



 "  

    2   

 

  "         

"      

         %



  

       

     

  2 

          

  

 %3     . $  '        '  '   3 . $3  $ $'  '    3.$3 ' $  4 '$ . '  ' @    

    3     '     '4  . .



      '.$   -9 .4    1 3 # ??  '.$     .       

 ' $  

.        $   

$'   $  >   3     .

:3    .   3  -, $ .4             (  )   

3  ?;<  ''''

  .$4'

> $ > ''

           ' 3    2   4     . .  '  $    '  '    .     ( 3 :*