← Library
High Court of TripuraWP(C)/179/2008dismissed

Yunuch Mia Sarkar v. State Of Tripura And 3 ORS

2015-07-16The Hon'Ble Mr. Justice S.C.Das14 pages

    

    

         

 



   

  



 

    

!    

! "   "# 



#$% & 

 '

& ()



   

#

$% & 

 *

 + ,

&  ()

 $  %

 !

&'(   $% & 

 ()  )  *   +  &

-  (

  $ 

+(.*, 

 "

()

 , -"

(  -         '    .  "$ (%

  ' 

/   0& $( ''    12. (#3

& 4$4



 )  /

/

0

% # 5)& .-  ./ 

0 6 '   ).1 



   23%+'1 4 ,%', 3#  ) 

         

#   )  / +, 

6   )      12   

 

  

       1

789+,*

:;998 9<8=2=  =99>;998     &? +, 

 6    )  

  &  @   #      

   #   8899

79A99 =79=7>><  

   

# "        ) 





&    @    &  #& 

    

"  "#  B C"4 ? +, 

 6    )  

& @   



"     "

  &

 

 "#    &  )  "# @ )   #        

   #   8899

79A99  =79=7>><

  ) 

 )#    



     =798;998     

"  "# B C" 4 

B

 

      " $        

 $(       0&     

  1 7 ; 

4$4 (#3

&    12



 $             

 

 (

 

    

   7;8 ;99

 7>9<7>A=  & # "

"

 (

 

 979;7>A2  



"

D # %   ;29 229  97927>A2 B &   )  

 (  =79=7>E;  

"

"  

=;8 <;8  & 

D  )

 )  



%  2=9 E89       &   <99 7229

 )#   9=9E7>EE   

 @   <;8   

  8<9 7=99

& <99 7229

%   7=99 =;;9

 4% +%  #,   7>EE

 )#   979A7>EA   

 @ 7E79    & 79#

 

 &%    #   7289 =A79   & =79=7>E>

1   979A7>E>    

 )# @   979A7>E>   7>=9  

  

%   8999 79=99



 4% +%  #,  7>>> 97977>><  # 979A7>><

@

  <>>9       "#     

    79+",  -   7>>> &#     ) "# 

&  @  )

1279 % 

18  79 

  ) 



   %  



%

&    @)



  " (& @

(      79  A #

    

 



  

 )

 & )

  %

&   %#

 

 & # "   )





  

 # )  &   )

 " 

"  

)            



<99 7229   

 &    $

  



D   % )) 3

 (  =79=7>E;

    $%  #  )   4

  (%

&  & +   4(,   =79=7>E>    

  7289 =A79

    % 

   8999

79=99

    -   7>>>     4(  8899 79A99  )  " )%   =79=7>>< " "# -  -     =99>;998     12 )%   "   7>9<;99;    =79=7>><   "# 

) #  %     @    #         

           )

8899 79A99 =79=7>>< 

&     

 " 

     

  % &  &  )&   "#

# 

% )   %   

"    79+",   -  7>>>B 





 )#@ =798;998    & 

 )#

#  

  "  )     1  7 ;  = "#  )  0   

 %          

 F 

)

  

 

(



+ &

#, 

   7;8 ;99  7>9<7>A=   



%    ;29 229     

 $% *&#



 +%      (

,  7>A8   #    

 @    -   7>A8   =92

   979=7>A2    

   ;29 229     

 3

   (  @ &     =79=7>E; (     $%      9A9=7>E7   

  

  (

 

  +B)

,  " )

"

"

%  ==8 <<8 =79=7>E;   3(@ &  B

 %   "

"  (



+B)

,B

 %  G "#  $%     $

 ) "# 

   &   9A9=7>E7 

   ) 

=;8 <<8 =79=7>E; 

@

  =A9       #   79    

   #  =;8 <<8  ';;+ ,+, F   

 $% *&#  +%   #,  7>E;  

 4%   +%   # 7A (& & , 7>E< # 

@ 8E8       #   ;8    %  

  8<9 7=99

   =79=7>E;    

)   @

 =79=7>E; &

<99 7229    @    7A(& & -   7>E<      

   &   -  7>EE   979A7>EA   #    

 @  #  7E79  979A7>EA     %  

   7=99 =;;9   (

 

     )  

  

&

    - 7>EE

 

B #  



 &%   @ B)  

  #   &   A #

 "   97977>>; % &   7A7;7>>;

 )#  #    

 @   =79=7>E>  7EA9  

@

 

&   %  

    -  7>>>   979A7>>< (

 )#   #    

 @   979A7>><   <>>9     %  

   8999

79=99      7>9<;99;   

 @ AA89     @ )  

   8A99 79A99

4( 

 %   79- 7>>>

  %  "   +,    

)

 ;  A (& & - %& 7>98;997 @  

  

   "

%   &  "#  (

  $ 



    =99>;998   "#    &

 &1" "

+,79-   

% @  )&#  %

%  

" &"  

 %

&  "#

#   &  )

   

3 4

4%  +%  #, 7>EE

 8+=, 

  97977>>>    #      " )"    %

&   '

&  

 G 

# 

      &   7A9;;998 &%& )

 

D  )) D 

  " 

&%&   4(+&,

 

 4% +%  #, 7>>> (

 )#   )  )  

       



 =79=7>E;   "   )   3

   ( )  &  " 

 4(    ) @ )  

   7289

=A79

   =79=7>E>

  )  %  

  8999 79=99

  4(4( B

    @ )  

   8899 79A99

   -  7>>>  & ;>#

   7;#

   & 4( 

   

   4%  +%   #,  7>>> % 79   %  +"", 

   4%   +%   # 7A (& & ,  ;997  % 

    7>98;997    

 )  @  &

8899 79A99

=79=7>><

" )  %   %  %   -  0     12  "#  )    %

      % 

   #   2=9 E89

&  HF  $

 

I  - 7>E; 

 &

   2A9 79;9    <99 7229

& "#     (     

 )# @ "#  B   -   <;8   % "  @ <99    97977>E; -  ( D  ) 3

 )    =79=7>E;

  ) #@  <99   ;8  &

 # <99 7229 1  979A7>E;

   '

&  -   9;777>E>

 )# @  ) #   @      - 

  E79      E28     

% 

   7=99 =;;9     #        979A7>EA

 @   7E<8 1   979A7>EE



&

@  #   7E79    

 +$

 

,  7=99 =;;9  

D  ) 3

 ) 

   '

&  -   9A7;7>>; 1   979A7>EE         "#         

  @ )

   7289 =A79    =79=7>E>  & A#

$

 

B

 @

   '

&  -  &   9;777>E>  -  &   =99E7>><   

   "#               $%    7>9<7>A=

 F   $

  

   

 

 ;29 229

" F   $

  

 

  $

 

  =;8 <<8  =79=7>E;  3

 ) (   $%

'

& C   7<9<;992

   &%&   )  

 

D  ) ) D 

  " 

)

 &%&       4(      

   )

    =79=7>E; 

D  ) 3

  ) 

 )

  =79=7>E> & A#

$

 

8899 79A99

&

" & 7>9<;99;

4("  & ;>#



 A(& & - 7>>>%'

& - 7>98;997(

 )#

@  



 7>9<;99;  AA89    %   ';;+,+ ,+;,

 A(& & -

   &          %  

 )#

 

    

 )# @

 

  @  

# &       "#         

    

   #   8899

79A99  7>9<;99;   =79=7>><   

  12  #% # )     @   # 

  =99>;998          F  



D &)



  &'

& 

#( #&)   =99>;998

" 

@

( @ 8    % /   0 

(



+ &

#, 7>9<7>A=B

F  $

   & B  )

   =79=7>E; 

 

=;8 <<8 &  $

 

B    =798;998

$

 

(   &       



    12        @     # &  &

 @ &  "#

  12    @ &     12       @        

 

#    %     %     #    -  &  



  

 "#  '

&  &  &

# )     )

 )

 @       

   12

 &)      =99>;998        F 



  -        @     

" 





/



H       F 

 "0 /    

   :  



(  / ';+=;

=88, ;992=;=E => ;= < ;998    & %   "%   

  $% & 

% 

 3( @ &     =7 = 7>E;    " @ <99   =7 = 7>E;    %    ' ;;+,+ ,+, 7 7>E;

 4+, 7>EE "@  7E79    E79  7 7>EA  7E<8  

   #   8899 79A99

 4( = 

&

"   &7> < ;99; &   ;> #

      7 >>

    $% &  % # %  ;

 %

&   =7 = 7>E; =7 = 7>E> B %  

"@



/ *@  )

 7 7>E; <99  

 2A9 79;8  1@ ) <;8 

3( =7 = 7>E; 

 <99 7229  <99 ;8 <;8 7 E;

<=8 7 E=

<A9 7 E2

A98 7 E8

A29 7 E<

AA8 7 EA

E79 E7999



2;7;9 '3

7E2<E ( ( 7;><9 

7<;99 7A9A2E



 Revised scale admissible Rs. 1300-3220 Under Graduate Scale Rs. 1300-3220/- Graduate scale Rs.1300-3220/- (as per Govt. order dated 7-12-92) Next stage - 15 Yrs - NIL 5 Yrs x1 - 1810 (1-7-87) 1-7-88 - 1865/- 31-3-89 (Rs.1450-3710/-) Next stage - 15 years - NIL 5 Yrs x 2 - 1865 (1-7-87) 1-7-88 - 1-7-89 - 1-7-90 - 1-7-91 to 31-12-91 - -  1810 FR 22(a)(I) 55(PP) 1-7-89 - 1-7-90 - 1-7-91 1-7-92 1-7-93 1-7-94 1-7-95 1-7-96 1-7-89 - 1-7-90 - 1-7-91 To 31-12-91 C.B with effect from 1-8-96 C.B 1-8-96 - - - - - - - - C.B 1-1-92 1-7-92 - 1-7-93 - 1-7-94 - 1-7-95 - 1-7-96 - 1-7-97 - 1-7-98 - 2520 to 30-9-98 As per ROP'99 Pay as on 1-7-96 - Rs.2385.00 DA - 3529.80 IR - 332.00 FB - 715.50 Total Rs.6962.30 Revised scale Rs.5000-10300/- Next stage- (1-7-96) 1-7-97 - 1-7-98 - 1-7-99 - 1-7-20001-7-200119-6-2002CAS-3 (Rs.5500-10700/-) 1-6-2003 - 1-6-2004 - (Last pay)



 %  "%#

D  @ & 

  

 



@   

 )#    3     & #"

"& &  ) %       )



&  

 %

&   % 4  

 #"&  & #" 

 '

& 

  

 &' & =



' & A 

;+ , % &#  3) & 0 3) & & ) 0 3) & &   "

   +

,     & #"   &     ;    0  3) &   ) #

   0  3) &   )"    &#          &  "   " 

    # &#   * / 3  :  #    (

  - &1? 789+,*  #;998 9<8=2= 22

=9 9> ;998 4#

   &  / :   



 ( J- 

F 

 K   (

  - I  



 

  "%



 )% "#   12 @ #     

 

 @     

)) %     

     &     0  0"

(



  &

#% 

F 

)

   &B

  )

   =79=7>E;

&%)

=;8 <<8 (

 )



   

 

#&%& )

" 

 )



 

"#'

&     

4(    @    #      (

 )      -  7>EE =79=7>E>

&%

7289

=A79  

    &%&   4(  " 

   

4(    ) 4(    &%& )

     )  3

 )        

    79+",

 4(   &%& 

 8899 79A99 =79=7>><  " 

4( 

      79  - 

& 

   %     79+,+"",





/

        

 

    ! 

      "#$%$"

& '

 

%$"#$"

& '

 ()  (     "%    

    4(  &   ;> #

       &    & 7>9<7>A= ;>#

&  #   7>9<;99; -   

   '

& C



 #&&

&    ) 4(

   )

     

 )%   )

 

  =;8 <<8 B)  4( =79=7>E>  



 &%

7289 =A79 B

 = 4(  # ;>#

    

)#   4(  7>9<;99;    &=79=7>><

&"#        )

 )    @     "# 

  

       )  

   '

& C  &&

& 

 &  & 

    @           &#    &)   =99>;998

"#   12

 

   "% #& 

 )#  &

  

 "

       23%+'