High Court of TripuraWP(C)/339/2009disposed of

Prabir Kumar Das v. State Of Tripura And 3 ORS

2015-08-14The Hon'Ble Mr. Justice S.C.Das26 pages

SriPrabirKumarDas,

1.TheStateofTripura "# $% #&'&

(#& )#$ # !

* 2.TheSecretarytothe )#$ # !

# &%

%'%+' 3.TheDirector,

# &',+' )#$ # !

-'# .")

/&+* 4.TheMember Secretary, $

('# " #

# &%

% '%+' * %-&

'# .")

/&+* 0000 1# &# :2 + %$# -23 % %$# 1# & #% :2 !23 % ) # & % % $ (#

%,# % :14.08.2015 && 1 # : Yes No √

!"#$

!"#$% # % # % # % #&' &' &' &' !&# #%%&& #%# &%

% '" * # ( % % 4 (

5 % & ( & $#

% $##6789:;<="

#&5 #* >

%&#:?8?:;;7 $#

% $# %&#5 # #&# # 5&(& &#

%#& %& # 4 ( 5 % & & # %# # # # &%

% ' # ( !& # 8=:8:;;7 #& &#5 # 5 %%&# % (# :@:8:;;7 & & $#

% ( % %% 8:87:;;<

% & &%

% ' %#6789:;<= !& # &

% & # % ( '$

-#:;9 # :;;< + & # & & ) & A& '#

% ( ## 3 % %% 8=8:6887 & 5 #5

#5%%&# % %%8:87:;;<%(& $#

% 54 &% #(# &3 % .%

#&5 # &3 %&$

('# %# #6?876887#&# #&#5 #

5&(& &%

%' &#

%#& % & & '# 5 % & & &%

%' # &# 5# % & 5 #% ( & # %

##&&#5 &# %& (# 8?8<6887!&# .%& #(# &#5 # %& (

#&5 # >

% & & $

( '# &

%& # &# (# % %% 6<::6887% #( # & # % 5 # % # &# (&2

(# &$

( '#( %%898:688@% #(# &# % 5&

5 % .%

#&5 # !& # & % #

$5 # & # % 5 3 % !& # & (% &

#5 B C

# ! %&''%(() # * + * , #

# #

- #

$ .#/'0&121)"3/%'12 456*7"8+" 9&! 0'%((6 # ,

- #

# ! ')9%((9

, :

* ,!

* + * , * , #

# # - #

$ .#/'%%'0 3/% '12 6"*7"8+"9&! &'(%((9

8 # 5

# # $ # # # ,

; //< 2. #% (

%$ #%% & & 5% %$ 4 ( # & & # % # & $% 5

% # # & ## & & 5 #% (

# % & & 3 % 5 % ( & A& '#

& $

( '# %&#5 # #&# /&# &#5 # 5&( & &#

% #

% % & 5 #$%% ## ( # %%

$% # # & ### & &%%#%%

( $% # #$ & & #% # &%

% '

# ( % & & $

( '#

& ( % & # %

& % & # % %##% $(

(&'#

3. > % % &% % &# &# #6789:;<=% & ( % & & # #% #

# ( # % &%

%' # (> #

% % && 5

%(%

( # % %% 8:87:;;< % & # % 5 &

% '$

-#:;9 # :;;< % ( 3 % %% 8=8:6887 &

% # & & ) & A& '#

+ &

#5%&5 #%# $%

#5B C%(/ #

# ,#

#$ # # *

# , #

, # #

# #

, * #

#$ #

# # '%/'%/%((1 # * 8#$

/ =

, > #

/ = ## ## /< > # % % & &#$# % % ( & A& '#

& $

( '# % &#5 # %%6?876887"

#&5 #*%&&#5 # %

#5B <?.34.=4 + 8?@5.:.=?3=54-A5 ::5*5= 5B *= =+@+*5A=4.B?::4== 45=?5 =3?57+3 5?3* !C? =54-A5 DD 5= + .#/%'12 456"*7"8+"9& EEEE%(() *F?7 A*.?=4

7F5 **// .#/)%2"3/G44 %"*?"*5"=7"&2&0 %)"0"'9&2

# *-/ //*"?*-/ , *$ ? */

7F5 *# $

*- / //*"? * - / //#//

-/?/5 H-* !7

=//

# # #*/

#,# #

/ .# ! =F53?5!

! > # #

# #$

, # #

# # ##

*/ *//-/ / F#

! # >

! * //- / , $

## , #

$ # "

> # # # # ##

# /4

# # * - / #

# #

# , #! >

/ #D

// '%

$ *

##7 # */

C? ! =DD =# *-/ *"?*-/ ?

-/?/5 H-* < > # # & #$ &#5 # & # %& (%%8?8<6887"

#& #*5& & %

#5B

I=# = :

* , * + * ,#

##7 */

C? =! / *! $#>

.# # .#/%'12 456"*7"8+"9& %1/()/%(() > #

# , , */

# # # # ,# , #

# , #,##

, # !4 , ##

D ('/ = ,# $ #

,# $ #

! # # #

##,# #

# / (%/ = ! ! ,# $ #

, # # # # @ 4 # # ,

, # #

# , ##

# #

# , / (1/ =

, #

## , # #

# #

# # # $

/ :

# # #

# / = #

, F# J * #

# /

(2/ = #

, #$

# ! #

, # # # # #

,/ (0/ =

# # # , */

, 4 7 # F# J F # !

/5/.#/'90#'99& ,

? (2/('/%(()! # # # , */

# # ## ,

# #

, #, 4 # #*/

# , ! */

# '9&2 # # #, >

## # ,# # # $ , # > # , , #

# , */

/ ()/ = , # , , $

@ # > ! 4 #

# #

/ (6/ =

! #

# # > #

# , ,*/

# # ! $ , # ,*/

, # # # ,# # C # # / (&/ = > ,

# F# J F # > ,

# # # # , */

, F# J F # !,#$

, # *#

.# / 4 #! # ! # $

# > , ##

, # ##,*/

, $ /

# # >

! 4 / ! B# , = (1 !%(() -5 455/ * *"?*-/ ?

!-/?/5 H! -/*/ !7

= 4 #% & &#5 ( % & $ &$

('#&

% ( & $

( '#(# % %%6<::68875& & %

#5B I?55 %&''() = * + * , #

# # # F# J 8 F # !

# 2'%(() /5/.#/'90 # '99&/ =

# * @ # $

.#/6')2"3/%2&0"*7"?"8+"(1 %&%((2/ = * @

# # %& ,!%((0

# #

, * -

! 4

? !

# # -# @ ! * @ / = 4

? , *-/

, #

#I, # ,<

# # H *

! # #

# I < # ,/ *#

, *?! * $ .#/)%2"3/G44/%"*?"*5"=7"&2&0 %)0'9&2

# # # # / ?

# # # * @ *#

# %1)%(()

# #,# #

, * @ # # $ ## , #

$ # "

> # # # # # #

# #*-/ !*"#+ /-/ #

/ -/?/ 5 H/ -/*/

! -/?/ 5 H! -/*/ #

$ ? ! : # ! /?

# *-/

# # 1 ! %(() # #

##,# #

# /

# #

, # # F# J F # !

/5/ .#/ '90 # '99& # #

# ## ,

#/F #

> ,

F# J F # # # # # */ #

, # *#

# / *#

# # #

, # # # * #

$ / = #

, # *#

# , * - / /

* # > ,

# #$ *

# #

> , # #

##$

, #$# , # *#

# / .# #

# #

# # #

# # # *-/ #

# # #* #

* .#/)%2"3/G44 %"*?"*5"=7"&2&0 %)0'9&2,*?

= ,

# # /

# , * , / = #, # # # # * -/ /< 5. % # 2 & # & %&.

# &#5 # &$

('#%%#/(4 (# & # & # ( % # & $ 4 ( # & 5& &5 %&( :;<=&

%5&# &$(4 (%

(#& $% % ) 2 23 % & % & & # & &#5 ( %% # ## #

# .&

# (# &5.%( & &# ( % # %% # ## # %%

( $% & & & # ##% #

#. # %%

( $% # 3 ( &

& $

( '#%&# % %#&$ # %&

&#5 ( & 5 #

& 4 ( # #%

## $% (&# 6 > & #

# %

! "##$%& '#

& #

(& %&

% #&# 5&#

% # & %#&# #& &# (

%(#&

%5#&# # #$&& %&5 %

(& #%# &%

# ( !& &#5 ( % ( & # & #%

% & % & &#5 ( & # #5& % & & 5

#.# # &

# & 5 .% ( & % & & % # %%

( $% # # &

& &%%#(&

(&&#5 ( & & % # %%

$% # & & / #

# . &

% 5 # 5&# & $

('# %> %#&5 #&# % % ( & $

( '# % # & $ &$

('#

7. % # & &#5 # %% 6?876887 5& && #%

%& %(&$

('# &&# &$ ## ( # & 5 5&

%$% # 5& & &#5 ( & %% #

#($% # # &

!&&#5 #

& &#5

# :6&# / & # # &

5& & #&# &5 #&# 5& &&

% # 8. !& '#

& # &' &% %& %

#5% #

(# ( & 97@<%; &3 %5& & %

#5B I0/ = -

# # ,

# > # * =

# # # #

# #

# # , # # / =

# * =

# !

## / # > # $ # #

! # # > $ # # # #

# $# # / = # ,

# # 5 /= #

/ = 8#$

8?:

.#/'26 %6(2'966 # *# 7

# 5

$ ? #

# # # *# # # => # $

# $ , #

/ 4 8? # > # $

# * =

/4 8?:

.#/%20 1()'966*#7

# #

/ 5 # # $ ,

, # / =

# ## # # # #

/ 4 # #

# , # * =

" # $

4# 8?

/ = #

# $ , ,

# #

# / =

# 8?:

.#/%&9 %)'''9&)!

# #

/ = # # ,

, $

# >

# #

/ = #

# # ,

/ )/=

* #

# 7 - # .#/9(6' # '9&% ,

# ## # # $ =

# 5

$ ? , ## /4 #

@ $5#!# #F 5#!

, 5$/F # #

# >#

#:*#

/ F 7 - # .#/))16#'969 #

## 1'''969 +/5$J # #

# > # / = # #

5$ # # >/ 7

# F # # # ##

## # # # #

8#$

# / # * # # #

# $

/ 7 # $

, $

#### # , # # #

> #

# ##

# # $

/ 4 # # , # * # #$ # #

/ = # #

#. $ =

": 5

? "5

$ ? $ # * =

, $ #

! # #

# # # # ,

# # / =

# /4

# # #/ =

# #

# # # =

# $ K # / =# $ :> K # #:

! # #=

!@ 5 5 , # #K # #

/B #

## # # ## #

- # #

# ##=7 , # #

# / =#

! #! # #!

/F #$

$ / F >

# ,

# #/4

# /= ##

# #

# * = LL,

## # # /4 $

,$ $ $

/ =

# , #

$ #

! # # $

# , # /= #

4 #

# / = , # # , #

# $ # # > /= $

# , # ##

# # #

# # K

/ 4 # # #!=

! ##

! #

# / #

/ =

8? #$# ,!

# ,

# # #! = / 4

# # F # !

# ## # *

# ##$ #

J # # * = /= #

# #: * : - $/ / #

! = #

! '992 ) * %2'!

, ##

##$ #

* = /= #

# '1*/%0206

#D 6/ =

# ,

# #

# , #

# #

, # $

#* =

$ #

# # , #

# / , #!

# #

/ # #

# #

/ :# #

# #

, #

,! ,

# # #,

# #

, * , #

/ 4

#,,

# /4 #

# # / 3# #

, #

# #

, #$! , ##

D '/ = # # # # # 5

$ ? , # # # , #

, # ? !=># : / %/ =

! # !

, $ ,

, #

# # H

# #

! ! # ,! # #

# #

# , # ,

, # #

/ 1/

# # # #

, * ,#

$ #

# # #

## / 2/ * 8#$

# , '

# ## * ,# ,# > # # #

/44 #!*#7 "= ">

7 !

, ! 444

# *

# # > #

# #

* =

? # >

! #

! ## # #

# #

0/ # # #

$ #

# ,*

-# #$ #-#

# #

# # /= 4

# # # # # #

# # ,

# # # #

# ,! #

# , / = $ #

# ,$ , #

# , #

# !

, /F # #

## # ! # ,/ F # #

# # #

/# #

#$ >

# # # #

$ # #! !# * =

# ###

## ,! ! # ! # # ! #

! # # # #

/ ,

# #

/ )/= ##

!# # # # $ # # #

# # L #

L # J# M #

# #

,# # , ! # #

, #, # # # $ # # ,

# >

# # #

# #

, # #, / = #

# # ,! ,! # #

> # # # #

# # 1( , # #

# # / 4

> # ## ,#

, # ! ## #

# " , #

# "

# * ,

$ ## , # "

" # $

# # / # , # # , # #

# ,

$ ## , , #

# # ##

! ## , # $

, $

# " / $ ## , # # #

$ $ #K #

, # ##

# #

# #/ 6/4

# $## # #

# #

# # # #

, #

$ ) ##

/ &/.# #

) #

" #

# # # #

/ 9/ =

# #

# , #

,,, #, #

# #

/ 4

* , #

# #

, #

/ 4

# # #

, #

" / '(/ 4

# , , #

! #

# #

# # #

# # # !

, - # # , #

# #

# # # ,

# $ ,

# ,

" " #

# #

# , #$ ! K #

* ,#

/ ''/ = #

, #

# $ ,

K #

%%)# #

# / '%/.# ## #

# ,# # , # /

'1/ = F # # #

# , #

# #

/ 4

! #

# "

# # " #

# , *

# #

# # $

K # $ '1)/ '2/ 4

# #

" "

# #

# > / 4 #

# $ #

! # #

$#$ #

# # $ #

# #

* # A # #

# , # #,! #-

/ '0/

## # , * , #

# #

! # # # #

# ,!

# # # #

# #

# # , ,

# >

/= - /# #

# # ,!

# , # # # ,## # # /

&/7 #$

# #>

! 8#$

# # #

# #

$ # / /! #

# # #

# $

, "

/ +

, # #

# #K $ #

## # # K

$ 2) - #

'2!'0!')!1& 19/ 9/ , # # F #

, #

! # , # #

# $ #

# #

/F # $ / *# # #

# , #,

# ,# $ #

* =

,! # >/ F # #

# # # # # 8#$

#,#

# / # , #

5 /%0!((( # ,

/< >

(& %(&.'#

7#$& %%/ ## (# & %

4 (#%&&

& # # #

#$& #%& #%%#

('& #5&#&

$ # ## (#

& %% %#%%

$% # # &

&&# &#/

$ $% # # & > #

%&$

('### %# .&

& & %& > %#&5 #& #/(&$

('#!& %$ % ( % # 2 # & # & # #% # 9. !& . %$ % ( % 2 & $ &

% & 5& & & # & %( $ % $5 # $ %

%&&# #/5(% # # & ## &

% & # & ( )

*& " + , # % %- % ./ "#%-$ %)& %&&# $#% &

#. % & # %## %($ # % & # &

& '#

&$& % # 5& & # % & > &

# % & '#

; # & 3 % & % & B C9/ # ,!

* + $ - #

, $ $ # # N

M! # # #

$ M

M # $

,$ ,

K#, / F#

$ * + $ - #

# > , $ #

$ # #

# #

/ 3## K

* M

# #

% 1 * + $ - #

! $ #

, #

, , # #

, $ # > ## , ,

/ * ,

# # # #

# ,

#$ , /< #

%# &3 % & 5 #%#& &## %&$ # &

& '#

&% %&&%$ 5& &&# $ %&#

%#%

% &(5

# %#(

& %$# $#

# & # & !& # $# 5 % ( & . '#

# & % (

#% % ## & # $# # &$ #

10. > % 5&# $## &.'#

5&# (%#5( # 5#

%># (5& & '#

(%#5 5 & 5

# # % % # 5&#

(%#5& # 5# %>& # & ( ) *& &' & '#

& # % %#5 ( # 5 #

#5% % > (

#% % ## & . '#

& $ # & & % # $# & & # 5

# % $% # & 5& & &( &$ %( 3#(% % &

#5%& $5# & &# # 5& %%#5(&.'#

& & !

% ' , &%

% !

$# #<"::*"*

#& 55& & %

#5B I&'' .# , #

, #

! # # # *

# * =

# ,

$ # # # #

* !# #

# , ! # #

$ ## /< 11. >$5# &%

#%#$&5 # %#%$#%# ( %& %%% -## % # # JUDGE