Mira Datta Bhowmik v. Nirmalya Dasgupta And ANR
THEHIGHCOURTOFTRIPURA AGARTALA
CONVICTPETITIONER: Smti.MiraDattaBhowmik,
!
" #$ %
BYADVOCATES: &
' RESPONDENT: 1.SriNirmalyaDasgupta, (
%
)" * " # ' +%++ ,!
" #$ %
PROFORMARESPONDENT: 2.TheStateofTripura, -# ./ %
( # " 0 !
" #
) ,!
" #$ %
BYADVOCATES: & &!.
:30.06.2015. "/ '
1 :28.07.2015.
- : Yes No √
'" /"
"# #234 # 56 # "" 86996 9 )' " !"
(: %
!
" " !
" (3;9<96
7 #/# # 56 96
)' "
#"& %
!
" (9:4=966= #:6 + )
"
'
7 #/# # ## # ' 666$ " + 2 * " # " &
'
" # "& # "$ ( "" " & ! .
(9$ %
3 % # " #" # ( 9
966= " # " ""
## &
"' "' > )?!
" ") "
"' $ 6= 6966=
# " ""
)' )' ## # '
## ## #:66:6 #25+ 4 +
"'> )? 6= 6966=+"
"
> )?6= 6966=% ""
"'
!# ' ) / ,0)$9, " ""@$
!
" # $
$ #% #% "
&
$ "& ' $ #%()
)
$
#%& " $ )$$ #% * + ) $
,$ $ ! ,$ ) ,$ & ) ) %
$-
'
&
$ "
+ &./////01 #% )
$ )
#% ) ) &
"
+ $ #% )
)
$ &*
$$ $
$ $ 2 ,$
$ $ $ $ ) & '
$ $ $ )
& , "
+ #% "
"
) & ' )
& * $ #% $
$ ) *$ 2& %$$ " 304 &, ) & !
$ $) $ $$ +
& '
$
5 & * 6 +
85 )
$
$ $& * $ $$
' "$ &* )
$ #
#%& 5 ) # "# A# ## 0 # 9:
)# #B # '
"
"'#" ) 6 +# " # " 0 "
# " 0 "' 9 " ) 2 ) + # # / # # " " / "" # @$ ,2
19: $ ) ,2
13:
$ + 5" /.&9/&3//. )
$ ) 6 )
& ,2
14: $ 9/&9/&3//.& ,2
1;:
$ 3;&9/&3//.& ,2
1<: $ $9;&99&3//. ,2
1.: $ " $ $ $ $9;&99&3//. ,2
1=: ) )
$$> 7 ! #" # / # ##
0 #2 2 ' #" # ' # / # #
"' ""
##
" " / + "" #" " )"' )
)"#
#"& ##"
"# / # # "" 7 " ##
"'
# :6 + # ' 666$ " ' + 8 !
/ ## " !
" (3;9<96
)'
86996 9 " !"
" # /"
"# 9 !
) )'" # "&
' '+
# " 7 ' # " %
)"# # ($./ ;(.< % # " 10 # " & ) ) "
"' #" '
)" # :6 + % #" "'
") " ) " ""
') # "
B ##
" " # ) "
/ " )' ## * " ) ) " /"' ## 7 ' ") "
)"# #" )' ## % ## " # ) " ""
""
"'#/# ## 11 &.
)
)' ## ) #" "' ") " # "
""
"' " ##
"' # # /" ' 7 12 " 0 # /"7 # # # "
"' '
)'
"'
# % B $ 0 $
# / # # " ""
/ ' / # ) # #"'
# ) / # 13 !" ') / "
##
"'> )? #
6= 6966= C
!) #"
## # " # " ) #"/ (. # "" D # " ) # " ' " # ' # )' ' #
" # ) 'D # " # " =66666$ (. # )" )' " D # " 0 #" ##" " ' ) # 0 )"' " # # # D # " (. A " # ) # "' / / # 0 # 14 ! ' ) # ' ;
< # ;9< )' B /" % , " # " #) " " ") " % " " # ' / + # #" "'") "
# # #") "
)
15 ,/ ' " /
%
"# ' C,/ ' " /
/ /" E!?
'
#
/"
)" ' '
) "
"
)"#
) # #
+ "
) 7'
/
/"/
/
/" # 16 % / > ? #,'" ' > ?
/ > %
) #
% B "
?
17 + # # " # #""' , #" #/ #
# " / )
+ "'
/ # "
# ' # " ( )
)"# # " " # %
)' ## ' # " 18 %
" # " &
'
)"# #/ '# (. #
) # ""'# )') " ""
"" 19 !
" # " &
' ( % ,0# #533+ ( % ,0# ""@$ Ninth Exception. ? * 5 $ $ $ 5
$& TenthException&?* $ $ $ $ ) $ )
$& 20
" ##
)"# # ## #
)"# % ##
# / #
) /"'" ## ") " #
)"#
21 # 6: ,/ # !# #) ) #" ) 0# # 6: ,/ # !# ""@$ 9/<& Burden of proving that case of accused comes within exceptions. !
$$
$
2 $ $ $ $ $)
,2$ * @;< 9A./B)
$ 2$ $ )
$
$ $ $ $ $& 22 +/ )/ / ## # / # # " # ' # "
# ##
)"# % #" "' " #" "' / # " 23 # " &
' # # M.G.PereraV.AndrewVincentPeiris& anr., AIR (36) 1949 Privy Council 106, /' #" " ' ) /
+ # # " # ## # " ) 0# # ) # # #" "'
)" #
# # #" # ") " ""
" ' ""' 3 7 )' /' #" # ""@$ C9DE * + $ )
F $ & !
) $
F & $ + $ ) $ $ )
$
$ $
$ ) $ $
$ $ & - $ $$ $ )
$
$ $ + $ )
F &* $ ) $ $$
$ )& +$
$ ) 2
$
$ 5 + $ )& F $$ $ ): $$ ) 5 $ $ & 24 # " &
' " # "# *
# Tarapada MAjumdar V. K. B. Ghosh & Co., AIR 1979 Calcutta68.% # # #" "'
)" # # + # ' # # #"
" ) # # ' ) #
" ' " ) / "" "
#" +'# # )'" # "&
'
'
"
# ## # ## # # 25 # " & # ChamanLalV.TheStateofPunjab, 1970(1)SCC 590,
"
)"# # " ) )" # % " ( ,0#
#
)"# ) ) / #
"
)"# 26 # " & " # SewakramSobhaniV.R.K.Karanjiya,ChiefEditor,Weekly Blitz & ors., AIR 1981 SC 1514,
) / " 7' ' #" /"
/ '
""
#
#A " ) ' ,/ ""
7 # -,0# " / )
)"# % B
)"# B # " ' " / # + ' #
# ' 7 ' " # # ( ,0#
# # #
)"# 27 + # +) "
"" ##""'
# / # # / ##
" ##
% ' # )"
"' ' 7
# " #
"' "# % ) "
"' ) 28 % /"
"# ) / ## "' " # #" # ' 7 JUDGE