← Library
High Court of TripuraWP(C)/366/2007allowed

Amiya Bhattacharjee v. State Of Tripura And 6 ORS

2015-07-31The Hon'Ble Mr Justice U. B. Saha20 pages

  

    Sri Amiya Bhattacharjee, Son of late Akshay Kumar Bhattacharjee, Vill. Nayapara, Dharmanagar, North Tripura, PIN-799250, (Presently residing at C/O-Dilip Kumar Choudhury near Yuba Sangha Club, Ramnagar Road No.1, Agartala-799002, West Tripura). ............Petitioner - V E R S U S - 1. The State of Tripura, (to be represented by the Commissioner-Secretary Department of School Education, Govt. of Tripura).

2. The Director of School Education, Government of Tripura, Agartala, West Tripura.

3. The Headmaster, Padampur Higher Secondary School (HS+2) Dharmanagar, North Tripura.

4. The Deputy Accountant General (A&E), Office of the Accountant General (A&E), Agartala, West Tripura. 5. The Employees Provident Fund Commissioner, Employees Provident Fund Organisation, near Bholagiri Ashram, Airport Road, Agartala, West Tripura.

6. The Assistant Provident Fund Commissioner, Employees Provident Fund Organisation, near Bholagiri Ashram, Airport Road, Agartala, West Tripura.

7. The Managing Director, Tripura Industrial Development Corporation Ltd., A Government Undertaking, Silpaudyog Bhavan, Third Floor, Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799006.

........Respondents.

    

        

    : Mr. S. Chakraborty, Addl. G.A. For the respondent No.4 : Mr. B. Majumder, Advocate. For the respondent Nos.5-6 : Mr. A. Lodh, Advocate. For the respondent No. 7 : Mr. P. Dutta, Advocate. 

         

 

 120

!"#$%&'%!(!$(  



   

  







 

 

        

      !

"

#$%&'("$&) #   * *#%  + , -    

.    

 +

    !

"

 #$%&'("$&) # 

#

    





 /0   !   2     

  

  

 ! -34 + 

55   -

 5     !   !6 

 

"

7! 5 

 

"

%'9 !  :

 

"

  / 0 .  + 

  

 ;        

<' = *

*#7 

 6

  5 .

    :    -

 >

      5 .

     1- -

    

 



  

 .   (  :



3



$  

&  ?



     

 

   2   

   220

  2  .   

**7 "





** $ 

& +  @  -      

 .    :

 

>

 

  

   -



9 # ** 6 

 

  

 .(:38 /70 8



+ + +.(:3  !

  9

 

  3  -  ''  3

  .   

 

 :

 

   :   -

>



 +     

+



   2  5 33-$

&2  *  /%0 .

  



  7 #

 

         

 

  

          9

  +





 2  5  33- $

& 2  *   

 +   

 .      !

 "

 '#$%&'(" $&) #     * *#*    :

    .    +6     



<    



       

 

  

 

!

   !   

   " #       320

  " $  !     "     

        %      

&     ' ())*      



!$ + ,  -

$ ./$-01.'  , 2      

!       " #    !       !         ! 3   4        !

    '4    !*55  

   " "

   6 7 ! %,8 6 ' ().7       97  

' ())1     (( (5 ()..   $  +   ! % :!!

; -

$ (5()0$-017    (( (5 ().. 

    ! !   ! % ' $ + ,     9* 5) ()./   %    "   !<$    !   3   4  

  ! 

  

   <$0,<$

       " #         

6 *( !<$6  %  

  !

  !      !

            !   ! %  $  + ,     9* 5) ()./ = /90 .  +            5  -   6

  +   

 

   

 )3      

 A

 

?

 

 $(((& +  2  2  .

  +

 

  +

 

  





$&   .      :

 3       * *#% .





  < 420

           !  "!#   " $% ! &#%&    '      '     (  " )*"

 ' + ,-    + &     # "  "    !  "#!  

 



    ! '"!# " $% ! &#%&             !     "!    (

 .  '' !  "          "  !   

       #   !       !"#  '

%

   (     . ' .            !   ( /    "    (." "#! 

   !     !!   "  0!  0  ! )!"#.!!! 0! !     "! " "!0     !" ""  "  + -- -   " 0  ! )!"# " 0!.-12, / 0 .  

 

   2  $3

  -  & 2 *9   +

 

   - .   ( !

    * *#%$+

 

&

   >?

 

'(( +  2 520

2 +



(+

  

+      5 +  



 + + B

 5     

    

   

 /#0 >?

 

'((+ 2 2 

+

 /*0 >?

 

'(((   2  

  

+   +

 



    + + 

   5

  

+   + +  /

0  5  6    .(:3 8

9

 

+ 





$



&

;       1 -

  -

 :   "

.   

"

 

  8  -  (     9

 (    

 

?

  



   2  5  3

  3 -  $

&2  *   $&$&$(&

   :

 

       * *#%    7



 7 #





   :32        

 620

/

0  5



 

"

    



 

  + 

*

7     



  4        +

1  ;  

  A

    

       A

 + ;

 



 / 0  .

   

7

7$>

 

& 

 "

  :  -

>

  .      

 !   :   .(:3

 "

   

     +     5  

;    +   

   3 5    .(:3 8. !  :  

"

 

;       

 3  .(:3 

 .(:3 ) 

+            +



   

 3 5   .(:3 / 0  (

   

   :  -

>



"

 !:.(:3    7

7$8 

&      

   3 

 720

> 

 

   =  A

 

  

> 



 =  A



;             

B  

   +   

   

  5 . !  :  .(:3 + 5

 3 

 

     

   

 +  

   35) 



 .    

   +  



 

 ;       +   



    / 70  .

 + 



 

7

% $<  

&  4    1   

 "

             +  8   - 

.

  

"

     

  

    

3 5 



 

9 $5

? 'C    

&     +  





4   

 / %0  .

           + 35     

7

7

   820

!  :  .(:3    +4 + 

    / 90  =

9 : 

-

 >



"

4 

"

     

+

   5



 

"

  :  -

>

+2  

%

4 

"

  4

  

    

    

     /

0  ,  

 

 5

  % 

   



  

  5  .

  .

+







 9$?&



  2% *97#)'1

 

 / #0  .

"

   +          2   $3-& 2 

     + +  

         +   + +     + +          

 +   



 ( 



?

   +4  



         3 5)  

 +  920

5  3 

 + 



 

7 #

 ;    +         / *0  (

 



    #











 

 

   

   

    %  

     

   

 + 

    1      1- -

          

+

       

       

 ;             35- +

 

    >?

  

+





         + 

  

     

 / 0  .

 "

 %   9    > 



   3 

     5  

  3 

 +      6  ' '



 

    !   :   .(:3 

   23-2= 5 

 

   

   +   

 

3 5         !   :    1020

 



      



 

 +  

   >5       

 +  



 ;         

 +  / 0 

 "

   !   :      

  

     

 

 +         1- -

 :    "

 .        :   -

 >

  





   . 

+       

 /0 

 "

 7   :

 5  

 $5D>&  



   

 



+    2

$7&  $3-& 2  

     

    



 + + 

+

 A

  +



 -  :

  





$+&+ 2

$7&  $3-&2





+   + 

 

 ? 

  

    1120

     

   

 

      + +  

+    / 0  ( 

+ 

  

  +     

 $+& +  2

$7&   2         :  -

 >



;   

7

$60( !!

 &        

   



  (  

  + +  

         

   

+   /70  ! 2   

  

  

              

 

     %  

       



  5  .



9

 1  



3 $&



 * *#% $+  

&    +   

    

          A







 +

   A

 +  +    + +    

   1220



 

+>?

 

'(((  2  

   +

 



    + +  

        

       +    + +  /%0    + 3 $&      * *#% $+ 

&

  +   

  

  >?

 

'(((  2  2   



 3 $&  

   

  

 





    ?

 3  $&    

  /90     

  

     ?

 

   %

    +

        

"

  



 

   / 0  

  

 + + %  +% 86 ?

@ 3

?

- "8  :



 695(A,9.7('

'

? 3   



        

  

 < 1320

3

    !   "   # ' "#!  # !  '  ""     '  "#!  " !   # "#4 #!  # . -156 7  !.' "" 8

     . ' ' 19#"#! "  # ! !    !"#!  !"'*'$! "   "#   .  !  #   -29" !!  !      !"# /  .""': /#0  ! -34 + 

55

  

 "

          +

 !  2        

   





  

  2  

 

+   +

 ?

      + 

   

+  2 .

- 

 +

 

+ 



?

      /*0         

   



 $5

? '(    

& ;     1      1 -

:   "

.   

"

  1420

 8  -  (    

9

   

*

7 / 0  .



  

 "

 7       



    

  

 / 0  .  ; 

       

      

           

           

    + +  

        



   

E 5    +            * *#% $+

 

& 

  

 

  

?

 

 (((  2  

 

   $3-& 2  +     

   +     E .





2   < ,- /'!  /   ;   .  !! "#!<

 ..' ! !      ;#  .;#  !."##!"!!    "   . '  1520

    "   + --     ======= ======= )*"4

/.' ""     '   !     ;# 4!"#.  .'#$.  # " '   #  !.   ! (.    0 + . -28>.  !  "'.  "  !     '     #.   '   

#       !      $ " ""!   # " '   #  !   ! (.    0 + . -28>. ' # $  ' "" "!     !  !$?'"  $        *  ? ! !    !     !"

 !" '."       )" !#.    .     '   

   )"    )" .' .           )"   "   

.  !       : 1620

/ 0    +  

   

 2    +          +  

  +  



5 + +







 + +

    

 

  5  

  

       +  

  

 +   + + (   

 + +  

       +  

   

  5  / 0  .

 ; 

       

 

5 

   5      

 9



  %

          / 70  "

    

 

  

       * *#% $+ 

'





F

        

     

   



   >?

 

'((( 2   2  + 



 + +  

 

 + 1720

 $&  

    

  



  

 / %0  :

 

  + 



+ 



  

  





 >?

 

'((( 2  .       3       $& 

     F                    

  

 +     +    

  



 >?

 

'((( 2 5   

  



$& 

    / 90  5

 >?

 

'((( 2   + +  

          

 

5   +      

   + +  

 (             

   



   

 5  .

    

9

 

        

   

;     1      1  -

  -

 4 

8  -  (       9

   

              +      1820



  

 



  5

     %  

   

( 

      5  

   3 

        * 7

7     !   :  .(:3    

 

          



 

 +   

       > 5     

 

         

>5  / 0  .       3   

"

  +        

   +  



      



  %  

 5      3   

 

   



   

  

    

  

 C   

    3    

 +  

5

?3   + + %  +% 86 ?

 @   3

 ?

 - " 8    :

' $ & 

   5

? 3      

    *G

 

         



     

 1920

/ #0  5  

"

           



  

  

 

   *G

  

 (    

   

   

        

     #G

 

    

 / *0  . 

   "

#$%&'("$&) #

#



+         

 

?

        

 (  +

   

    

  

    

+

   4   + 

 

 /7 0 (     

          



)  2020