High Court of TripuraRSA/24/2009partly allowed

Md Mamud Aliand 13 ORS v. Abdul Mannan And 22 ORS

2015-04-30Hon'Ble Mr. Justice S. Talapatra16 pages

! "

#$ % #&'

( ) !

+ !

-!*

)

% #&'

. / -!*+ "

#$ % #&'

0 $

1 $

2 3

-!*

#$ % #&'

5 )

* !

6 & 7 !

) !!

& & & 7

-!*

(

, % !-

#$ % #&'

! ) "

#$ - % &'

( & , 8

-! * :

. 7 -!* 0 ) !

-!* 9 1 /

2 !! "

;* -< % #&'

5 !

& 6 = ! = = >

( , /!

. &/!

#$ % &'

1 * / 2 *

* /

! "

#- / % #&'

5 )9 *

% #&'

6 3

* % #&'

> / &

(

$ % &'

???'

>' 8 / !9 " @ / " >' &

066.

: (66,6. A'

! '' 66 8%8 + & √

C6,C665 " '' &(0662!9 )

* ! **

(61665#

;< A*'' 8 '

)

'" D , (8%8

> '' 8

" "

! '

9 3E! 3E! 3 '" !9

'' F ;< A ' '

''9 "* 3E! 3E! 3 F "$# B ! '' !9

9! '

! 2;% <C661 * !9 ' & : & /

''9 !9' 9 '

! !

' 9

!9 '' "9 8

! '

!9 ! *'!

* "# ''9 ! !

6;*9</ (;<

;</

;</ ! >

' * * @

(;< *" * *

! "%# > *

9 ) > *

9 )

> *

9>7 )

& !

& -!

;*<

' & !

' &

9 & ' &() G

*& -! ;*< ;<

& * " ! ;*<

) & -! )

-! " ! ;*<

&(;

<A =

&(;!<

9) !

&(;<

&(;

< / / -!

&(;<

& (;<

* "&#

9 >7 *

" ! *3

&,;

< *

&,;!< $

&,;<

&,;< *

9 $

&,;

< " *

9 )9

& ,;

< ,;<

>7 " !

9 & 7 ;<

& .;

< !

& .;!<

&.;<

9 !

* " ! *

9 -!

&.;

<;< % ! -

&.;

<;<

&.;

< .;

<;< >7

&,;

<.;

<;<

* '

& .;

<;< !" '' " ''9 ! >

'' ' "'#

' ' * 9

* !* $ 9 * ! " !*

# ()*+,--. -( ) C5

7 C5 )

-! C5

7 -! C5 >7 C5 "/# ' "C5 ''9 ! >

' " & !

-! ,; < H; </ * '

!9 &5(,13

1) (,13 " E !9

) * 9 66;* < ' * " ,; < H; </

* 9* ,; < H; </ ! !

$ '

E >

" ' & !

;< H; </ ;66 < !

!9 & 50(

616152,E !9

9 & 7

< 66

!9 & 1(

,6252, ' 66 !

'' ' ! ' '

'' ' ! !9 "

B ! E

I * "# >

!0C0C0C(0C,0C. 0C0

) ' " ' A ) (66(521 ' ! ""

(666* *

) "0# -

9 ' 9

& ,;

<,;< '

!9 ! "

9 ! !9

& , !9 ' * A

, " # 1(2 -(, 34(3 ().5 6. . ,- +(,- *+ 3+73(7, * (8 98 48 ! (73 -9(73 *+ 3+73(7, *132 +.63 ( :,.,.*7 (;(.7, ,- :7, :6(.7,.++ (73 *,- 9+* ,- 3 (73 *664,*8 *,- .:( <(.6((-(8 +* 4*4,.*7 *+ ,- 6(73 4*3 =-.4- =( 6+, 9>

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

?A ?..*7AA0/8 A % *+

4, 0& (73 (+, *9?.7; (66 6;(6 +*)(6.,. (73 -(.7; 9*,- .3 (73 4*7.3.7; *,- ?.374 ,- 3 ! *664,*8 *,- .:(8 <(.6((-( :(3 (7 *3 *7 0%A00A (73 ( :*3*+,- 3 !*664,*8*,-.:(8 <(.6((-( ,- @-(,.(7 *+ :7, ., 6(73 =( ::(389,,-:7,:6(.7,.++::.7;,- +(4,+.63,-:7,.,B "00# ' ) .;"<

* *"' &

'"9 "

" 8"

" & '

' '"

" ! ' '

@*" ! !"

!9' * ' !9 ! !9 & ""

* "" !9

!9' * 9 /

/ !

* *"' & @ !

" >

!" "0# >

9 !

662662 " 2;% < 661 -

" ' '

'' 50 8%8 )

9 !

* ! '' ! '' &(0 662 '

& * ! ''

&(;

<(;<

'' " 8

" 9

' 9!

!9 ' 8" ""

* "9 '

' ! !9 " '

/ ! ' " J " " ! 9 7 !9

' '' '' -9 '

6,665 '' * * # C - :6(.7,.++ .7 ::*, *+ ,- 4( 9).,,3 ,- 4,.+.3 4*:. *+ <-(,.(7 * &A08 &A8 &A$8 &A8 &A% (73 &A& (73 ,- 3*4)7, -(? 97 )(@3 ( D-.9.,E . - :6(.7,.++ (6* :*343 ,- (6 33 3(,3 0$0$' (73 ., -( 97 )(@3(D-.9.,E0-(?4(+66>;*7,-*;- ,-D,.(73+.73,-(,@-(,.(7-(?97 ::(3.7,-7()*+ (-6.(73*,-8.8 .7,-7()*+,-6;(6-.*+6(,<(4-.)6.7 *3,*3.43.,,-3*4)7,,-3+73(7, -(? 7*, +.63 (7> @.73 *+ ?.374 +* 7*, 4*7.3.7;,-D,..7,-.4( *),- D,..,4(79-63,-(,<(4-.)6.=(,- *.;.7(6*=7*+,-.,6(73(73,-8,-6;(6 -.

*+ <(4-.) 6. -(? .;-, *? ,- ., :*:,>8 9, ,- 3+73(7, ( 7*, :(>.7; (7> :*7+*:(,.,.*7*+,-.,:*:,>-8.7 )> 4*7.33 *:.7.*78 ,- :6(.7,.++ ( (96 ,* :*? ,-. 4( (73 ,-> ( 7,.,63 ,* ;, ,- 348(:(>3+* *7.3.7; ,- 46(.) *+ ,- :6(.7,.++ -*63 ,-(, ,- :6(.7,.++ (6*7; =.,- 3+73(7, *0,* % ( 7,.,63,*;,,=*E7.7,-1A2-((4-+*),- .,6(7334.93.7,-4-360*+,-:6(.7, .3 ,-. -(8 ,- :6(.7,.++ ( +,- 7,.,63,*;,6(73)(.7;+*(73-(6+@(7.8 =-.4-,-)*,-*+,-:6(.7,.++;*,+*)<(4-.) 6. 9> =(> *+ ;.,3 33 3(,3 0',- 5(.,-(8 0$' 0 -(? :3 ,- 53;)7, *+ ,- 6(73 .?.6 3;1 .?28 *,- .

:(8 <(.6(-(-( .7 3,(.6 (73 +.73 ,-(, ,- 6(73 .?.

3;17.* .?..*72 +(.63 ,* (::4.(, ,- ?.374*74*3:*:6>(73-.+.73.7;.7*, 9(3:*7;**3(*7.7;(73(4-8.,.6.(96 ,* 9 , (.3 (73 (44*3.7;6>8 ,- 53;)7, 3(,3 0// :(3 9> ,- 6(73 .?.6

3;1 .?28*,-.:(8<(.6(-(-(.7( * .,6 ., 0/1 (,.,.*72 *+ ' . -9> , (.3B

9' 9 '

9 E C5 ''9 * ,; < H ; < / *

!9 '

/ '

''9 !9 ! * ' ;*< "0$# -

" !9

6,665 ' '' ! !9

G ! E ! B * !9 3E! 3E!3

" ''

9$3E! 3E!3; <

'' ' *

"0# 8 / !9 '' '' !

* (;<

-! " *

66(5.)9

-! " !

6(6,5.2 - E " )9

-! E !9 )9

-! " !

/ 3E D

&,;

<,;< ,; </ *

( !

((13;3E!3<

(;

<(;< -9

(((;3E3 <

(;</ *

-!!9

(((3;3E!3<D * *

& ,;

< ,;< .;

<.;<

(;< / 3E! ,; < / 3E!3 ' (;< / 3E!3 6;< / ' ,; < ! !

' '

! ,2( * ! !

* >

8 / !9 !

* / ! 3E! 3E!3 9

! !

'' * '

/ 3E! 3E!3 !! * "0%# > &

'' " !

!9 '' 3E! E !9 " )9

-! * ' !

! 3E! (;</ * !9)9

* * )9

! ''9!

"0&# 9 ! 3E! 3 ''

-!'"9

,; </ (;</ $ '' 9 ! 3E! 3E!3 '

''9 * !E ''9 * ! !9

-! "0'# !

8 / !9 E ! 3E! 3E!3

! ! '

' C5 ''9") ' '

'' !9

" ''

! >

''9

! 3E! 3E!3

' E !

' ,; < H; < / * E " ''9 &

-! ' " *' '" * !

# ) C5

C5 )

-! C5

7 -! C5 >7 C5 ' * C5 ''9

E "0/# 9 '' '

9 * ' & . C5 ''9 * ! "

! 3E! 3E!3 !

/ 9

' '' 3E! -

E !9) '

/ '

''!9 ! * ' (;<

9 * * !

* ' *' * ! !9/

' G

!9 ! * !9 '' "98

*8*