Dhirendra Ch Pal v. Chitta Paul And 2 ORS
Sri Dhirendra Ch. Paul, son of late Sashi Bhushan Paul, resident of 8, Mantribari Road, Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District - Tripura West .......Defendant appellant -V E R S U S1.
Shri Chitta Ranjan Paul, son of late Bhupendra Ch. Paul, resident of Mantribari Road, Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District - Tripura West.
2(a) Smt. Jyoti Paul, wife of late Binoy Bhushan Paul 2(b) Miss Ishita Paul, daughter of late Binoy Bhushan Paul, both are resident of Mantribari Road, Agartala, P.O. Agartala P.S. West Agartala, Dist- West Tripura 3.
Agartala Municipal Council, represented by the Executive Officer, Battala Super Market Complex, Agartala, at present by the Chief Executive Officer City Centre, Paradise Chowmohani, Agartala, Tripura West .......Plaintiff -respondents For the appellant :
Mr. D.R.Choudhury, Advocate Mr. D.Deb, Advocate For the respondents :
Mr. S.M.Chakraborty, Sr. Advocate Mr. T.D.Majumder,Advocate.
Mr. D. Das, Advocate.
Date of hearing :
26.02.2015 Date of judgment & order :
08.05.2015 Whether fit for reporting :
Yes No √
!
" # $ %& "
' (
)
"
# *
+ %
!
#
$ & ! (
'! )
"
# , - .
/
*
1
23. 4
5
5
,6- 7!
5
&
!1
23.4
!
"
" "
"
#
$ % " ! " " " & '
" &
(
&
) *
& +
&, -.
# '
&
&
'
& /# " & !
"
& # &
!
"
"
!
"
" "
"
#
$ % " ! " " " & '
" &
(
&
) *
& +
&, -.
# '
&
&
' 0 ,*-
!
8 1
23. 4
5
& ! 9 !
% 5 & 1
23.4
& &
.
% & !
!
&
1
23.
& &
"
& 1
:..4
"
%
1
23.4
& "
& #! &
5 !
! 8
121 3# # 4
5'
%5$66)7(($8& !
#
!1
23. 4
&
9 & 8
&
#
&
, - & ! & !4
1
23.. !1
23.& &
&
&
! 9 #5!
5 !1
23.4
8
!
; -. 7#
!
" #
& "
&""
&
+ # "
&"" &
+
+
## &
9
-&.
"
!, -. %
7
" &
9
##
- . * +
&
9
## "
9
-.
& 9
& ## 9
: #
&,7
&
" &
&
" &
9
&"
##
9
/
7 ,%- .; ; #2
7 1- .&" 5 $66-).7$<$ 8
5
8
& 7
#
!
<" = " 0%
& ! & ! 5
&
5 & 5
!
5
&
& & 5 ! 5 &
!
! !
7
5
& 5
5 "
5 !
! & & 7
8
! !
!
&
5
!
& 5 5
)
7
!
.
7
5
& 5
&
> !
& 5 " 7
! ! & 5 & & ? &
5 5
& 8
!
& 7
! ,0- . !
7
&
&
7
7
! ! & 5 #
7
& 5 ! !
&
5 ! ! ,+- @ !& 5 & !
7
& 5
& ! ! 7
& 5 & A & 5B
8
!
.&
&
5 ! 8 5 &
; ; # 2
1- .
, -
&
1
23.4
.
7
! ! & 5
! & &
5
&! 5 !
" 5 &
& & !
. !
&
5 5 & &
5 ,- &
& 5 75 !
&
5
5
7! C
'
4
&
5 & 5; -. *
&"
"
&
#
#
= -&. *
/!& / /!& +
# , = -. *
> &
# &
9
&"
#
7
$?
<8
= ,- @ & 5 &
# ?
#
& # $
! (
'!
# )
" ?
'
!
&
?@
D 6 E E 0F '
&
" 5
& # < =
# % &
& # ?0 + 0 % "
' <5 = "
&
?" 5
E & # * 6
C ? " #
&
& " 5 "
# +$"
&
?" & 5 # 5
0% &
#
?@ 5 E *'
EE
?
D 6 E E 0F '
&
?@ 5
5 ? # ! E 9 , -
#
5
!
?@
# &
& !
5
!
1
6 # 5 & & 5
!
5 9 .
#
# 4
9
5
?
& 5!
# ?
& 5 &
?" 5 5 & & @
<5 =&
&
?
@
&
" &
?
?@ G # E *'
5 5
@
EE
?
!
?@ ?
&
& 9 " C *
5
C
5
?
& E# *6%+ C
# +$" )
# * 5 5 !
& ? #
?" 5
" E 9 ) @ 5
&
G # ?
?" 5
% G
# #
5 H 9 5 @
5
?
5
? #
# ?
&
" ) @ %% " 5 60 @
?
?
" ?
"
& !
?
? # !
!
! & &
5
; -. *
' "
> @ $= -&. %
&= -. +
#
A= - . % " & "
@ $
@ &" & "
= -. % "
#
"
A &"
@ = - . % "
= -. %
# A
# "
A
'
@ " = -. * >
= ,6- # 8 55
5 ; /!& :
" ! &"
# *,$ /!& $ :
" ;
@ )8C( 7 @ 8
@ $
/!& ( :
"
@$ /!& ) : D
7 &
@$ /!& 8 : 1 !
/!& < :
"
@ ,(6( $E68CEE ;; @ ! &"
,*- ?
8
5
5 ; /!& :
" $?6EC8( /!& A : 73
/!& 7 :?@
" ;
#
/!& 3 : $@ #
" )6) )6CA7 /!& / : D,
$(<< /!& G7 :
" ;
#"
#
&
/!& 2:
" ;
@ )C$<
@ /!& +,7 : $ @ ,
" & @ $C 1(?CA7 /!& %7 : # 1 ! " , - . & H8& H ?
%%5 H8& 7 5
?
C 60 @
6& #
! & 5 # @ '& !
#
"
"
'
# .
# 5
0 %
! 5 & 5 # H8& * ?
"
& 5 #
0% 5 @
"
.
H8& * ?
?
! !
&
@ # #
!
5 & 5
& "
5 # & &
H8&
! 5
" C
# +$" )
# * C 8$ ! C + H8& % ! @
5
& 5
# ?
E E
&
5
! &
5 ?
#
& @
& & 5 ,%- ) ! &
?
& & !
&
')? #
') 6! 95 ! & #
# * '
) & 8
H8& H H8& 7 7
C 60 @ 5 5 & '
) C C D 7
C CD 7 95
5 C C D 5 5 9 &
#
5 5
!
& &
H 9 5 @ & ! H8& H & $6
" & ! H8& 7
&
9
# & # # . H8& H&
& .&
&
C60 @ 5
5
9
# 5 5
5 5 5
H @ & 8
.
#
& 9
& &
8& 7 . &
H8& H H8& 7 & !
" ?
5! ! & ! ,0- I 5 !
&
! 5 8
1 #1 @
F
%5 C<< 7 E(? 7
&
!
! 75 !
; # 3 "
F %5 C?< 7 E6? &
& !
!
5
&
5 5 @
! ! & 5 95
& H! &
!
95
& 5 &
5
&
5
!
! 9
! 5& !
;
#
&
! 1 +
' " % /!& /-7F. /!& + -7F.
@$
"
% @ "
#
"
&"" /!& /-7F.
/!& + -7F. @
#
% #
/!& G
@ ;
@)(<E0 ,+- &
& # !
@ &
?
?
!
%
' (
)
& " # $ % 55
"
' (
)
"
# * @
0
&
5 ; # #
#
*,
@ #
"
@
"&
&"'
" " &
&"
"#
7 3 @ ,?8E? $(6?C<$ -/! &
HA. ! #
@ $ " +
#
" " &
"0 , - .&
H8& H C 60 @
@
?
5 < = ?
<H8&?7 = @ . 7!
& !
?
?
" H8& 7 5
5 5 ?
.
!
&
<'
)?= 8
<H8&?@= ? #
# ?2E 9 .5 C 60 @ 5
<H8&?7 = 5 8 ?
# # .&9
&
& 5 9
7 H8&?7 & & & ?
!
I
&
& !
! & ?
!
& ?
, - H! 5 E & # *6%+ ?
& # +$ 0 5 ! 34J34"5
5 &
? # #
&
, -
'
4
& &
& 5 ! 5
!
" 5 ? # # 5
7
!
! & &
5
&
1 5
!
&
! &
& 5
& 5
<H8&? @=
<H8&?7 =! & &
& 5 5
! !
I
?
& !
<H8&?H=
H8&?7
5
&
! & &
& 5
H8&?H H8&?7
?
!
! & &
@
! 0 5"
% 3" .5
?
& !
.
& & +9# 1 + %5 C)< & $66 H8 & # & 8 5 5 ! & 5 &
& 5 & .5
5 ?
& ! .; #3 "3
F
! &
1
!
& 5 ?
!
. 8 &
& 5
! & 55 8
" & ?
!
?
,
- "
5 C
C 9 & 5 C '
' "
! 5 & 5 75 !
& , 6-
5 34