High Court of TripuraRSA/41/2008dismissed

Shib Sankar Pal v. Ms Chakraborty Auto Industries And 2 ORS

2015-06-08Hon'Ble Mr. Justice S. Talapatra16 pages

!!!!!!!

# $%

& '

) * +

)

* %

!!!!!

" -,

( ,

0 ,

, 1 !!!!!

34,1 5

(/ 6768-6#9

C : √

! 3 34 ,1

(

( :#

& $ %

& '

1 &,

( : -

0 ,

#66 %% ;

(( &< ( -#69-667 5

& :6#-66# &

+ (

( % :=

( & :#

& 1

& &

( & :7>$#??7 @ $ %

& '

( (

?-666 1

(

B ?-666

B 87-6- >9D 1

-6#6#??9 0

=8666

(

) :#

*1 (

=8666

(

( & 5

: # )

* :-

:#( 5

(

06666

(

#8666

( =8666 1

( &

(& 5 1

: - & #=6?#??7 (

#-67#??7

(

( F

&1 & & 5

:#( 5

:# ( 5

(

:- &

:# 1 &

( & 5 (

0 1 & & #=6?#??7& 5

(

:#( 5

(

&1 5

:# &

(

& 5

0 & 06666

&"1 1

;

3 ( 5 &

( &

:# &

(

5 1

& ( 1

(

$ %

& '

(

( &

(

-768#??9 &

1 1

(

% 2

( 1

(

" #$% %&%'( #($) *+ %#( ,'$&-% .(-%&*-&-/ "#0&

(*'$' #$0.$1 ,0*,0&(%*0 *+ #$20$3*0%4 5%* -)5%0&(1 *$)1 .%$'&1 .%$'&1 &%0&6%7 8(% 0&,50$ -(() %* 3( )('(%() $-) 53%&%5%() $ +*''*9 ":#$20$3*0%45%*-)5%0&(1 $,$0%-(0#&, &0. $0%-(03(&-/ &!#0& (*'$'#$0.$1 *-*+0& $. $-$.#$0.$; &&!#0&#$20$3*0%4#$0.$1 *-*+#0& (3-$%##$0.$! &%5$%()*- *$)1.%$'&1

.%$'&1 &%0&6%78(%0&,50$< #$%$+%(0,$0$7*+%#(,'$&-%%#(+*''*9&-/$0( %*3($))() "#$%:#$20$3*0%45%*-)5%0&(1%#( ,'$&-%&++ *+ %#& 5&% & $ ,$0%-(0#&, +&0. #( ,$0%-(0$0(7 &!#0& (*'$'#$0.$1*-*+#0&

$-$. #$0.$1 &&! #0& #$20$3*0%4 #$0.$1 *- *+ #0& (3-$%# #$0.$1 3*%# 0(&)&-/ ,0((-%'4 *- *$)1 .%$'&1 .%$'&1 &%0&6%78(%0&,50$ #$% #0& (*'$' #$0.$ & ,0$6%&6$''4 %#( .$-$/&-/ ,$0%-(0 ( #$ 3((- .$-$/&-/ %#( 9*02 *+%#(+&0.< 8 '

1 6-68-666

( % + ( % :#(

1 1 & #>69-6661 5

"*%# %#( &)( 0$&() -* *3=(6%&*- %* $.(-) %#( ,'$&-%$-)%#(90&%%(-%$%(.(-% *3*%#%#(,0$4(0$0($''*9()< 1 1

1 1 &

1 '

1 1 "#$%1 %#( %$%(.(-% .$)( &- ,$0$ *+ %#( $,,'&6$%&*-%#$%:#$20$3*0%45%*-)5%0&(&$ ,$0%-(0#&, +&0. 6*-%&%5%() 9&%# %9* ,$0%-(0 -$.('4 ! (*'$' #$0.$ $-) ! #0& #$20$3*0%4 #$0.$*0%#$%$%%#(%&.(*+,0(,$0$%&*-*+%#(,'$&-% %#(0( #$ 3((- $ 3*-$+&)( .&%$2( )5( %* .&5-)(0%$-)*+%#(&-%056%&*-/&>(-34%#(,'$&-%&++ 0(/$0)&-/ %$%5 *+ %#( +&0. : #$20$3*0%4 5%* -)5%0&(*0%#$%)5(%*3*-$+&)(.&%$2(%#(%$%5 *+ %#( +&0. #$ 3((- %$%() $ ,0*,0&(%$04 +&0. $'%#*5/#&-+$6%1&%&$,$0%-(0#&,+&0.*0%#$%5-)(0 %#& 3*-$+&)( .&%$2( %#( 5&% #$ 3((- &-%&%5%() &- %#(-$.(*+%#(+&0.%$%&-/&%90*-/%$%51$0($'' +$'( +$30&6$%() $-) .&'($)&-/ $-) %#(0(+*0( >(#(.(-%'4 )(-&() $-) )&,5%() 34 %#( $-9(0&-/ )(+(-)$-%< > ,&

(

1 $ %

& '

1 "#$%1 %#( %$%(.(-% .$)( &- ,$0$ *+ %#( $,,'&6$%&*-%#$%:#$20$3*0%45%*-)5%0&(&$ ,$0%-(0#&, +&0. 6*-%&%5%() 9&%# %9* ,$0%-(0 -$.('4 ! (*'$' #$0.$ $-) ! #0& #$20$3*0%4 #$0.$*0%#$%$%%#(%&.(*+,0(,$0$%&*-*+%#(,'$&-% %#(0( #$ 3((- $ 3*-$+&)( .&%$2( )5( %* .&5-)(0%$-)*+%#(&-%056%&*-/&>(-34%#(,'$&-%&++ 0(/$0)&-/ %$%5 *+ %#( +&0. : #$20$3*0%4 5%*

-)5%0&(*0%#$%)5(%*3*-$+&)(.&%$2(%#(%$%5 *+ %#( +&0. #$ 3((- %$%() $ ,0*,0&(%*04 +&0. $'%#*5/#&-+$6%1&%&$,$0%-(0#&,+&0.*0%#$%5-)(0 %#& 3*-$+&)( .&%$2( %#( 5&% #$ 3((- &-%&%5%() &- %#(-$.(*+%#(+&0.%$%&-/&%90*-/%$%51$0($'' +$'( +$30&6$%() $-) .&'($)&-/ $-) %#(0(+*0( >(#(.(-%'4 )(-&() $-) )&,5%() 34 %#( $-9(0&-/ )(+(-)$-%<

1 1

1 &

& -86?-6661

"%#(5&%.$&-%$&-$3'(&->&(9*+%#(,0*>&&*-*+

$0%-(0#&,6%?< ?

( 5

(

1 1 5 5

#-6>-666 1 1 (1

E 1 1 B

15 #867-666 & <

( 1 2

& 0667-666

:# B

(

0 & 1

& 1

1 & < ( -86?-666 315 #-6?-666

: -

0 1 1 B

- 1 1 "B

(

1 ( GE1

" %#( 5&% .$&-%$&-$3'( $-) & %#( 5&% 3$00() 34 '&.&%$%&*-?<

*0 %#( $2( *+ 6*->(-&(-% *+ )(6&&*- 3*%# %#( &5($0(%$2(-%*/(%#(0$%#(&5($0(&.&'$0&- -$%50( $-) +0$.() $3*5% %#( .$&-%$&-$3&'&%4 *+ %#( 5&% *%# %#( (% *+ )(+(-)$-% 6#$''(-/() %#( .$&-%$&-$3&'&%4 *+ %#( 5&% *- )&++(0(-% /0*5-) #( )(+(-)$-% * 6#$''(-/() %#$% %#( ,'$&-%&++

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

$-) $'* A3% 0(>($' %#$% %#( )(+(-)$-% * $-) @ #$>( -* 6*-%0$6%5$' *3'&/$%&*-9&%#%#(,'$&-%&++#()(+(-)$-%*&-#& 90&%%(-%$%(.(-%,(6&+&6$''4$-)6$%(/*0&6$''4%$%() %#$%$,(0#&$)>&6(%#()(+(-)$-%*.$)(*.( ,$4.(-% %* %#( ,'$&-%&++ $-) $ ,(0 #& 53(B5(-% $)>&( %#( ,'$&-%&++ #$ -*% %$2(- %#( ,$4.(-% +0*. )(+(-)$-% * +*0 $- $.

&%0&6% 6*-5.(0 *05.1 8(% 0&,50$1 /$0%$'$ >&)( %#(&0 =5)/.(-% A3%! $'* (A,0(() %#( &.&'$0>&(9*+#$>&-/-*0('$%&*-*+%#(,'$&-%&++9&%# %#( )(+(-)$-% * &- 6*--(6%&*- 9&%# %#( 3*)4 35&')&-/*+%#(%0562 % +50%#(0 $,,($0 %#$% %#( ,'$&-%&++ +&'() %#( 5&% *- CDD1 $-) %#( )('&>(04 *+ %#( %0562 $+%(0 3*)4 35&')&-/ +0*. %#( ,'$&-%&++ 9$ %$2(- *- EDDC *1 &% $,,($0 %#$% %#( ,'$&-%&++ #$ +&'() %#( 5&% 9&%#&- %#( ,(0&*) *+ %#0(( 4($0 +0*. %#( )$%( *+ 6*.,'(%&*- *+ %#( 3*)4 35&')&-/ $-) )('&>(04 *+ %#(

$.(%*%#()(+(-)$-%**1%#(5&%&-*%3$0() 34'&.&%$%&*-#()(+(-)$-%1$+%(0$.(-).(-%*+%#( ,'$&-%6#$-/&-/%#(,'($*+%#(,'$&-%&++%#$%0& (*'$' #$0.$ & -*% %#( ,0*,0&(%*0 *+ #$20$3*0%4 5%* -)5%0&(1 35% %#( #$20$3*0%4 5%* -)5%0&( & $ ,$0%-(0#&,+&0.$-) (*'$'#$0.$$-)#$20$3*0%4 #$0.$$0(&%,$0%-(01%$2(-%#(,'($%#$%%#(5&% *+ %#( ,'$&-%&++ & -*% .$&-%$&-$3'( &- >&(9 *+ %#( ,0*>&&*- *+ $0%-(0#&, 6% #( ,'$&-%&++ #$ -*% %$%()&-#&,'$&-%9#(%#(0%#( $0%-(0#&,+&0.: #$20$3*0%4 5%* -)5%0&( & $ 0(/&%(0() +&0. *0 -*%$-)#*9&%9$+*0.()1&(19#(%#(034>&0%5(*+

$0%-(0#&, (() *0 -*% 5% )50&-/ %#( 60*7 (A$.&-$%&*-*+%#( 871#(%$%()%#$%#$20$3*0%4 -)5%0&( & $ ,$0%-(0#&, +&0. ( $'* %$%() %#(&0 +&0. & $ 0(/&%(0() +&0.1 35% ,0&*0 %* %#$% #( #$ 53.&%%() ,$,(0 %* ,0*>( %#$% #( 9$ $ *9-(0 *+ #$20$3*0%45%*-)5%0&()50&-/%#(0('(>$-%%&.( *+ B5*%$%&*- $-) )50&-/ %#( %&.( *+ 3*)4 35&')&-/ *+ %#(>(#&6'( 0*.%#(&)(*+%#(,'$&-%&++-*)*65.(-% ,0*)56() $-) ,0*>() %* #*9 %#$% : #$20$3*0%4 5%* -)5%0&( & $ ,$0%-(0#&, +&0. $-) &% 9$ $ 0(/&%(0()+&0.,(0,0*>&&*-*+(6%&*-CD*+%#(

$0%-(0#&,6%1-*5&%%*(-+*06($0&/#%$0&&-/+0*. $6*-%0$6%*06*-+(00()34%#&6%#$''3(&-%&%5%() &-$46*50%34*0*-3(#$'+*+$-4,(0*-5&-/$ $ ,$0%-(0 &- $ +&0. $/$&-% %#( +&0. *0 $-4 ,(0*- $''(/() %* 3( *0 %* #$>( 3((- $ ,$0%-(0 &- %#( +&0. 5-'(%#(+&0.&$0(/&%(0()$-)%#(,(0*-5&-/& *0#$3((-#*9-&-%#(0(/&%(0*++&0.$$,$0%-(0 &- %#( +&0. (6%&*- CD ! ,0*>&)() %#$% -* 5&% %* (-+*06( $ 0&/#% $0&&-/ +0*. $ 6*-%0$6% #$'' 3( &-%&%5%() &- $-4 6*50% 34 *0 *- 3(#$'+ *+ $ +&0. $/$&-% $-4 %#&0) ,$0%4 5-'( %#( +&0. & 0(/&%(0() $-)%#(,(0*-5&-/$0(*0#$>(3((-#*9-&-%#( 0(/&%(0 *+ +&0. $ $ ,$0%-(0 &- %#( +&0. - %#& 0(,(6%+0*.

%#(&)(*+%#()(+(-)$-%6&%()%#(6$( '$9 0(,*0%() &- DEE @@C **-2$0$- (%#&$ (%6 0 >$- *#- $-) *%#(0! 9#(0( %#(&0 *0)#&, &- %#( ,(A *50% #(') %#$% (6%&*- CD & .$-)$%*04 &- 6#$0$6%(0 $-) &% (++(6% & %* 0(-)(0 $ 5&%34,'$&-%&++&-0(,(6%*+$0&/#%>(%()&-#&.*0 $6B5&0() 34 #&. 5-)(0 $ 6*-%0$6% 9#&6# #( (-%(0() &-%* $ ,$0%-(0 *+ $- 5-0(/&%(0() +&0.1 9#(%#(0 (A&%&-/*0)&*'>()1>*&)-*%#(09*0)1$,$0%-(0 *+ $- (0%9#&'( 5-0(/&%(0() ,$0%-(0#&, +&0. 6$--*% 30&-/$5&%%*(-+*06(0&/#%$0&&-/*5%*+$6*-%0$6% +$''&-/9&%#&-%#($.3&%*+(6%&*-CD *16*-&)(0&-/%#(+$6%$-)6&065.

%#( ,(A *50%1 $ )&65() $3*>(1 &% $,,($0 %#$% %#( ,0((-% 5&% *+ %#( ,'$&-%&++ & -*% .$&-%$&-$3'( $/$&-%%#()(+(-)$-%*$-)@135%%#(5&%*+%#( ,'$&-%&++&-*%3$00()34'&.&%$%&*-$)&%$'*$,,($0 %#$% %#( 5&% *+ %#( ,'$&-%&++ & -*% .$&-%$&-$3'( &- >&(9 *+ %#( ,0*>&&*- *+ $0%-(0#&, 6%1 D@ 66*0)&-/'41 %#( 5( * F & ,$0%'4 )(6&)() &- +$>*50*+%#(,'$&-%&++$-),$0%'4)(6&)()$/$&-%%#( ,'$&-%&++$9(''$&-+$>*50*+%#()(+(-)$-%))' 5( * F & )(6&)() $/$&-% %#( ,'$&-%&++ $-) &- +$>*50*+%#()(+(-)$-%< #6

( 5 &

& =8666 1

H ##D

( -8#6#?77, 5

:GE

: GE

(

5 1

' : GE

' :EE' :GIE

( 5

(

' :G2E

5 2

& ## (

< ( -86?-666 5

& :7> #??7 :#

$ %

& '

?8 %%

( & : 6# -66#

(

% 5

" - 6$0(+5' 605%&-4 *+ %#( 0(6*0) &% $,,($0 %* .(-(&%#(0,$0%4#$)0$&()$-4B5(%&*-0('$%&-/%*

%#(+&0.*+%#(,,(''$-%6$--*%.$2(*5%#*9%#( ($0-() *50% 3('*9 #$) +0$.() %#( $))&%&*-$' &5((.$)($%#&0),$0%46$(9#&6#9$-*%%#( ,'($*+$-4*+%#(,$0%&(%*%#($,,($'< #-

5 &

1 5 =8666 1

(

5 =8666 : #

& 5

H#-D

1 -8#6#??8

& :7>#??7 ,

(( 5 & < ( -#69-667 5

& :6# -66# #0

( 1

; 1 1 & -86?-667 " 8#(%#(0 $- 5-0(/&%(0() ,$0%-(0#&, +&0. 6$- +&'( $ 5&% &- &% *9- -$.( 6*-%0$04 %* %#( ,0*>&&*- *+ (6%&*- CD *+ %#( -)&$-

$0%-(0#&,6%1D@? 8#(%#(0 $ *'( ,$0%-(0 *+ $- 5-0(/&%(0() ,$0%-(0#&, +&0. 6$- 5( &- %#( -$.( *+ ,$0%-(0#&,+&0.?< #= 34 ,1

(

1 1 &

1 & (

( < (

( #9

( ,1

(

( :#

5 06 # %%1

5 "-4%9**0.*0(,(0*-6'$&.&-/*03(&-/'&$3'($ ,$0%-(0$-)6$004&-/*-35&-(&-1 -)&$!.$45( *03(5()&-%#(-$.(*+%#(+&0. &+$-4!*+9#&6# 56# ,(0*- 9(0( ,$0%-(0 $% %#( %&.( *+ %#( $6605&-/ *+ %#( 6$5( *+ $6%&*-1 $-) $-4 ,$0%4 %* $ 5&% .$4 &- 56# 6$( $,,'4 %* %#( *50% +*0 $ %$%(.(-%*+%#(-$.($-)$))0((*+%#(,(0*- 9#*9(0(1$%%#(%&.(*+%#($6605&-/*+%#(6$5(*+ $6%&*-1 ,$0%-(0 &- 56# +&0.1 %* 3( +50-&#() $-) >(0&+&()&-56#.$--(0$%#(*50%.$4)&0(6%< , 5

( 06 # %% ;

(

'(1 &

(

( 5

; 1

(

& 5

(

& &

; 1 ;

(

5 1 8?'

#?0- 1

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

*5&%%*(-+*06($0&/#%$0&&-/+0*.$6*-%0$6% #$'' 3( &-%&%5%() &- $-4 *50% 34 *0 *- 3(#$'+ *+ $ +&0. $/$&-% $-4 %#&0) ,$0%4 5-'( %#( +&0. & 0(/&%(0() $-) %#( ,(0*- 5&-/ $0( *0 #$>( 3((- #*9-&-%#( (/&%(0*+ &0.$,$0%-(0&-%#(+&0. @! #( ,0*>&&*- *+ 537(6%&*- ! $-) ! #$'' $,,'4$'*%*$6'$&.*+(%7*++*0*%#(0,0*6(()&-/%* (-+*06($0&/#%$0&&-/+0*.$6*-%0$6%135%#$''-*% $++(6%17 $! %#( (-+*06(.(-% *+ $-4 0&/#% %* 5( +*0 %#( )&*'5%&*- *+ $ +&0. *0 +*0 $66*5-% *+ $ )&*'>()+&0.1*0 3!

6%1 DD @ *+ DD! *0 %#(

0*>&-6&$' -*'>(-646%1D G*+D! %*0($'&(%#( ,0*,(0%4*+$-&-*'>(-%,$0%-(0 !#&(6%&*-#$''-*%$,,'417 $! %* +&0. *0 %* ,$0%-(0 &- +&0. 9#&6# #$>( -* ,'$6( *+ 35&-( &- %#( %(00&%*0&( %* 9#&6# %#& 6% (A%(-)1 *0 9#*( ,'$6( *+ 35&-( &- %#( $&) %(00&%*0&(1 $0( &%5$%() &- $0($ %* 9#&6#1 34 -*%&+&6$%&*- 5-)(0 (6%&*- GC1 %#& #$,%(0 )*( -*% $,,'41*0 3!%*$-45&%*06'$&.*+(%7*++ -*%(A6(()&-/*-( #5-)0() 05,(( &- >$'5( 9#&6#1 &- %#( 0(&)(-647 %*9-1 & -*% $ 2&-) ,(6&+&() &- (6%&*- D *+ %#(

0(&)(-64.$''$5(*50%6%1 G*+!1 *01 *5%&)( %#( 0(&)(-647%*9-1 & -*% *+ $ 2&-) ,(6&+&() &- %#( (6*-) 6#()5'( %* %#( 0*>&-6&$' .$'' $5( *50% 6%1 E D*+ E!1 *0 %*$-4 ,0*6(()&-/ &- (A(65%&*- *0 *%#(0 ,0*6(()&-/ &-6&)(-%$'%**0$0&&-/+0*.$-456#5&%*06'$&.< #8 B &- **-2$0$- (%#&$ 0 >$-

*#-1

DEE@@C1

(

( 8?

( 5 I5 &

(

5 & ; ( '

(

*..&&*-(0 *+ -6*.( $A1 $4$'$2#.& &6( &' &'' *-%0$6%*0 *1

DEG & '

& 0(.'$%$ #$0 $ #$.$- $'

DDG E & B @

( &

)0* " )#*

)-* 8? ( 1

(

( B

5 & "

)0* " )=* 8? <

( 1

( (

& "

)-* 8?

(

& & ( #>

& (

1 5

1 1 &

& ( < 1

(

( 9

1( I5 1 <

J 1

& 1

? %%

( &

( 1

(& ( < (

315

( (

% 1