Srimanta Kr. Bhowmik And ORS v. Mrinal Kanti Paul And ORS
!
" # $ %&
'(
) (
!
" * + &
'(
(
, +
!
" ------- ."" /01 2 /
(
$
&3 4 5 '
!
" #
( *
.+
$
&3) '
!
" 6
"
3 % &5
" 3 '
!
"
7
&3 3 '
!
"
" .
8 +
& '
+
(
%
9
5
9
!
" :
;
9! & <
"
$ '
!
" = ) &
'
(
%
9 "
& ' & 39 % '
!
"
.
!
" # $ %&
'(
) (
!
" * + &
'(
(
, +
!
" ------- &
'.""
/01 2 /
(
$
&3 4 5 '
!
" $
#
( *
.+
$
& 4 5 '
!
" 6 "
()
0 , & 4 '
!
" 7 "
()
0
+>
5$
!
"
&
'.
? "" ( ($ + % ; ($ + % ; ? ( $
; ( $% ; ( ;
9@
A#A:#A7 " 9 B 3 √ " 9
( ( $ + % +%($ + %;
( $ + % ""
9 "" ( $
+%( $% ( ""
9 # "" + 9 377 #AA= 378 #AA= ++ 9
" +%
)
&
' +% "" .
" +%
)
4 "" "" C8 $ $ D 9 ) " &
' "" 9 "" 3=#AA= ""3C #AA=
" +%
) #=A:#AA=
)
9 "" * "" + 9 AA $ $
+%
+%
##AC#AA= < 377 #AA= 9 + D !
!"#$"#%&'(#$"#(&)%$*#(+,%#*%-."$/$-$+#,'* -'$#%#0$&1,2,%$3&4#%,2,%$-()+,%+,'*/(,'$"# (&)%$ ,.,-' 5,6# ,'3 *#(+,%,$-&' &1 $"# 0,5# ',$)%# &4#% $"# 0,5# +,'* -' 1,4&)% &1 &$"#% 2,%$3-'$"#(&)'$#%7(+,-589 < 378 #AA= + D
!
- :"#$"#% , (-4-+ (&)%$ (,' *#(+,%# $"# %-."$/ $-$+# ,'* -'$#%#0$ &' $"# ;,0-0 &1 2%#0)52$-&' -' 1,4&)% &1 , 2,%$3 !-$"&)$ ,'3;,0-(*&()5#'$8
-- :"#$"#%,(&)%$(,'2,00&%*#%*-%#($-'.$"# $%)# &!'#% 1&% ",'*+-'. &4#% $"# 4,(,'$ 2&00#00-&' &1 $"# 0)-$ +,'* $& , $"-%* 2,%$3 ",4-'.!-$"&)$,'3$-$+#89 "" 9 ; % % + D
9
+ ( ($ + % ""
9 ""
%
+ D 6 5 ""
"" + D D
+ . + D ; ; ; E + D ! !"#$"#% $"# 2+,-'$-110/ $"# ,22#++,'$0 "#%#-'/ ",4#$"#%-."$/$-$+#,'*-'$#%#0$&4#%$"#+,'*,0 *#0(%-;#*-'$"#("#*)+#*<&1$"#2+,-'$&%&' $"# &$"#% !,3/ !"#$"#% $"# %#02&'*#'$0 ",4# 2%&=#($#*,'3(+,-5&4#%$"#("#*)+#*<+,'*89
7 <
" ""
D
9+
+ " " FG
+
" !
7 ' 5&)=, #+&'-,/ (&55&'+3 6'&!' ,0 #+&'-, &!' )'*#% #+&'-, >/ 6",$-,' &?/ ",+ 2+&$ &@/ @/ @A/ @ ,'* @B ,'* 5#,0)%-'.A,(%#0 C &%$"7 %-',+ ,+ &$"#%0 &)$"7 "#2+,-'$-110 &$"#%0 ,0$ 7 "#2+,-'$-110 :#0$7 "#2+,-'$-110 &$"#%0 8 " 9 "
) 9 "
FG +
""
"
% 9
;"
;
+% " +%H % ;
H ;
> "% " "% $ (9
+ +% ;
+
" ; "
;
; HH 5 % "
%
9 H H
+% "% $ (9
+% "3#8C" 9 3##*8
)
9 9 < "
.
+ 9 3*7#AA8&
'
9
;
" 9 " 3#8#*I::88 "
3#:C ) %
?
"
" 3 #AA8 ""
9
2
% +%
9
9 +
"
9 " ;
FG
.
;
+ % 9 "
% "
) ; FG
9
) " + 3#AA8 3*7#AA8 &
' ""
""+ 9 ""3=#AA= ""3C #AA= % + "" ; +
+% ) #=A:#AA=+%
, 9
" 4
9 )
""
+ ; !
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
K :
9%
""
;
; % " ;
9 AAA# "
%
1; 9
) + 9 +% "" % + "
;
;
+% "" %
%
; " 3#8#*I::88 "" 9 3#:C ) =
"
"
%
< " "
;
% ++;
"
) ; HH +% "" % D
C ?
)
9
" "" + ""
; FG
;
9% % + 9 % " "" ;
+
" ; FG 1;
9
"
) " "" " HH +% + FG " HH 5 ""
%
FG
" HH " A ?
+
9 HH " +"" HH " "3#8C
" " " FG
" 4
9
+%
""
%
9
;%
; FG
$ D
% %
"" "
) ; " "
FG
;
9
9
""
% 9 "
)
+% "" " + 9 3#AA8
9 " ;
" ; FG
" % 9"
) " FG 9
9
+ 9 " " "" ; FG ""+ 9 377#AA= ) " "" 3= #AA=
9 ) " 3 #AA8 "" + 9 378 #AA= ) " "" 3CI#AA=
9 ) " + 9 *7#AA8&
'
9 +%
""
" 9 "
) ; FG + ;
+; ;
9 ; % " +% % ;
""
"
9% $
5BI "