Bijoy Kumar Saha v. Union Of India And 2 ORS
! "
! ""#$% !#"#&!'(" #$ $ % # )*#(#+ # % %& '
"
'#, -, .!!#,
/!-
01
2! 34% !" #' #(( $# )* (&% %# + ,-. +#" .!!#,
4 5(#!- 1',$
!#
01
2! /%
6)! 5'
2! !%6(!%!# 34% !)" 7"" #/ % '# $/ 0 1%2!*3 " 1#
#!
5 ""8#$% !#"#&!'(" #$ $ % # )*#(#+ # % %& '
" & ( -, .!!#,
/!-
01
2! 34% !"
# #(( $# )* (&% %# + ,-. +#" .!!#,
/!-
01
2! /%
96:)! 5'
2! !%6 4 5'
34% !)" ''(%33 // % #%&*/$%3/4 # $ (,-.
/#'1*'
.
$ +*$% $2 /"8"
"$" 8
-1!- " " " 1'%;
."" "6(!%! /%
<!%=)> " 7"" #/ % '# $/ 0, ,
,50,6 7 ,8 / !!
! "
/ ! "
?
?
.""<"6!#4# $0 -" .""<"
#
$0 -" / #'
# ? ."$"
,61 "
! %!0,
@(1
" !
'
! ?
?
9: 7 86, 4 8, 4!'!!
#=('
!#'
#% # !#% #(1!##!
%- (#%
#!#" A % - (#% ." "<"6!#4#
'!!
!
%- (#%."" <"
#
!
"
$%# % ."$"
,61
#'
#! 4!'!!
#" -'
!
%4!0 %0! -## - !# - !# '##
!#'
#%
4!'!!
#" : 6, !%! 4! '!!
# # - %% - >""
'## , ''%% !(%
/ ! 8;- 34 % ! ! ''%3 #"
B
$;() 4! '!!
4 )( ''%% !(% !- 4! '!!
# '
#! C
'%,1 (!#'-
!#'-!0''%" & !
- !# $!!
% 11!##!
(# 1#%8;-!#$@(!-! (
!, /8 $ !1'
# '%,
#" ) ('# - #!;, %= ! -#
4'<(1 )('# #!;, !0 %= ! -#
6!@ , <(1 ( / !8;- (%!
$- B> "& '!!
# ' ''%
''%% (
!, ( / ! 8;- (%!
$- % 4! #' ''%!-!
#,
'!
- ! ! !-!% - !!
!# ! 4!%%
-(# (( # !' 1 !
, E(! ', , 1 ( (
'%, -- ! 1 '%,4#(@(#%,!1'
#" #!#
#(- ',
# ''%% !(% "B"
D '## !-! # '
#! DC
'%,1 (!- ''%4! !D,# 1
'##! 4! ( !-!
!%! #
''%4!%%!#1!## (% "6 #- %% , !%!3 ">
DF
D 4!'!!
#4 !#'
#
,- '##,#!%5(
( ! A! ( F""
D 4!
%% 4! #0!
?)
!!"
#
$ # #
%
&
# #
' #
% #
( #
#
#
% # # ) ; 20!4
0 #'
#4 #(''
# - #! '
( !-!% #(#
D # # ' - 0!# -!
D
/ !8;- (%!
$-" < 2 !# 1! '
#!!
#'
# - %%- !-!% #(# '
'!!
# 1 2- 1&;'1"$- ',
'
! #'-
4' <(1
#;#$;(4) #!1!%- ',!#'-
6!@ ,<(1
#;#$;() " 9 2 !# !0-
# ''%%!(%4!
(- #!! !-!%#(# '
#(1!, 2- 1&;(
!,!#'-
'!!
# '## !1'(
>""
! ''%# ' , # !-! 1 '
#! C
'%, 1 ( 4# %%, !, '## 4! # 1 ; (#- #!!
" & %0'
!
'##, ''%%!(% >""
##
%% 4#?)
*
*
+ , ,
# * # *
-
% #
*
%
:
# ' # !&
# . *
* !&
#
/! # #
) $!
0 1=#!-% ''%% !(% ;1! !-!% #(# '
- %%- 1 2- 1&;'1!#'-
# ( ! - #! - #
'
''%! 4- #!!
'
#1, 1!'(% , %-= 1 , !# ! 1=" 2 # %# #0 ''%%#
0 - 1 ( 1#%0#
! - - !-!% '
#!!
" 2 !# ;'- ''%% !(% 4 (% '## # -! 1!%# '# % !# ;'!-
#!!
!-
!(%" !% A! ( # '## 0!
, '
( !-!% #(# 4 !% !(% 4# %# '%# - %%- '
# 1 2- 1 &; (
!, ! #'-
!-!% #(#
'!!
# !(% 4 (% = ! - #!!
'
- %%- 1 2- 1&;(
!,!!#% #'!! '## '' '! " !% #1 !(% !!!%%, '## !-! ''%%# !"" # ! ', DC
'%,
> #('!#!%, - %%-! !-!%#(#'
!(% # !-# 1 ( C 4 !%#
!-!%#(#'
#'=# 4!#"80 !(%:#
# #'= ! -%%, ( !-!% #(# '
- %%- , !(%
'##! !1'(
" $;()
#
4# 2- 1&;
!-
3 "
$%'
(% !- 1
4' <(1
, ) 4# #"
F >)G
, )
D 4# #"
)
, D) 4#
#" B)"& %-#
4' <(1 # #(1!
####1 ,
D) #
4! ### ' '!# 0%( #" > D> BF"> )" !1!%%, $;()
! #'-
6!@ , <(1 #
4# '
#(1! , 2- 1 &;
!- 3 "
F"F"
(%!- 1
, ) 4#
#">F )G
, ) D4# #"F F)
, D) 4# #"D >)"& %-# #
4# %1 (
###
#"D > D)" - (#% ." 6!#4# ."
# ''!
# #(1! '
!-!% #(# - %%- , #'
# !#% #
4#
;
F # 0 !-!%#(# ',C
% '%, 1 (
- #!!
! ''% !1'('##, ''%%(
!, !!%, 4!
( - #!! !-!% #(# '
- !!#%!% ! E(# " : ."
, 61
#(1! $!!
% 11!##!
% 8;-!# 4 !% ;-!#! '
4 ( / ! 8;- (%!
$- !1'
# ( '%,
1 - !!%,# -!1!%#- %%- (!!E(!,"A #- # 0 ! - %%
#('!
!(% ''% # !% 4 !- # 1! ',1
'
'%,4 1 (#
(% '! !# !#-!
''%% !(% ( 1, ! 1%%, ! !#-!
!(%"A #1'
!-%%,#(1! !# (! ;-!#
'
4($!-%
#!(!
! ! !(%:# !#-!
! 1, - ( !-!%4 #" - 0!# #(-!
-!
D
/ ! 8;- (%!
$- B> '#-!# (#) H0
+
<
B
#
# 1 # ) ; 2 0!4
0 ' 0!#!
''%% !(% !# ;'- - #! !-!% #(#
''%%4 !%!-! 1 1=',1
' '-
'%,1 ("$1!%, !(% !!!%%, '##
!-! ''%%# '!!
# ', DC
'%, A! ( '## - %%- !-!% #(#
# '##'' '! "& !(% - %%- !-!% #(# '
#
1 2- 1&;(
!,#(- !-!%#(# #
4 # 0#(- !-!%'
#!!
1= ',1
#(- 1 ( # -! , !(%,!# >""
!4!%% !!%, -(#(( # !' #" !% !(%
# !% ;-!#!#@(!#!-!
!@(!-!
(#1 4 !%!!#;-!# !1
!#
-!!I !-- -4! %4 !!%, !# (
# @(!#!-!
! ! ! # ! ! " 3 (!!#!#-!
!(% -!# 4 1 ( #
(% !; ( 0, !#-!
# ;-!# 4! # # 4 !% !#-!
# -'!-!
(#%,;-!# !- #! ,
%4"
9
<
!= ! ' ' ! !
>""
-- !%, !# # #! E(# !(% #'
3 "
!# !- - #! '
#
!-!% #(# - %%- 1 2- 1 &; (
!, '## '' '! !#'-
'
#!# 1, ''%%# !"" #!#'-
!''%
''%%!(%" 9 & 4!'!!
#-- !%,#!#'
#
" !# ! 4- ##" 7 8,