Dy Chief Engineer Nfr v. Upasana Roy And ANR


 

 





























 
 

 

    

  



 

 

!"

#"$ "

%# & ' ()*  $)'*"# 



 !  
"" 
   "# 

























 
 

 

    

  
#
$   
 

!"

%# & '     $)'*"# %



 !  
"" 
   "# & '( )
)(*+&

,
-$.

$&
)
.*
&()
)  
"/+ "# #,") ""#-+&(.& / #,") ("$# #, "$0 #'-0112
$$""-34*



 



  "$"#" ' # ###)1 ""$#   ' +"

0 # " )",#    ' "$)"

)"2"$ ) #))"#

#"# "$ )"''"0 #' 
3# + "#  # )"

 $"  *
    +(.& / #)"

$""# %
 $)  '4 1 # "  #) # $" #" "$ $"" -   !")"        "#
" 5  )1 #657)"$ )"$# #"
"8827 8829 882:

882;

882<#8828"$=
"9:<5  >62 ) "$ # # &"
" 88;<  88;;

 88;:

5>7<6 "$ =
" 679>: # %# +"

0 "$ %

*(," " "  "#*)'  $"   " "$ )" )" "$
   " # #     ,# #)"
"8.</*?

!@ AB

8; )  #?4* #  B  "$    C B  "  ) "$  )'*"#    !")"  '#  $)   "

 $) "  , ' ,  # "  "

# $)" #  ## 5 8:5 *    76 7>6 * ),

  )"'" $"  )1 # # # $)'*"##'##6>$" )1 ##1 "


5
"#*)',#  #"$  !")"'#)" )"6<"$ ) #  '  $# "  )")#  D # B  ")# )"6<  !")"##,' ""#)'"$$"#*)')"$   !")" $"   D #    #  1 " )"  )"'#  " )"'') # # " ")#'#1 " #$  $"' *% ' "# # ", # ",   #  " "#0)"
!3#@  D + ( %'#3"# ##'+)!"# $)#)) ') )")" ##'"

"$ 26 >>> *$")1 ## 2
*
  ",' ##)' "$)'*"### !")" #'#', "$#1 "#  #  $    )#  ' ,  "$  # #  1 " $"' 26 >>> * " 8> >>> *   % ,#  #' #  # "$  #  # 
  $#"

( !$?.!"/"$
   6 + "#   $"  #  ' # #'# # ' !")")"## , $)" #  ,  "$  "

  # #'#', ## #  # "

  )#   ## '"

 $"'  >>> *"8> >>> *3""#"




# D #0 #'# #)$) #  !")"##")"'' "

"'"$ # "$ )"'"
" "     "#*)' $# " "# ) )")""$,', "$ ##"##' '""$"$ )"'" ##3 '# D # )#   # #     !")" "

  $  ") " )"' #  7
"# +(.& / '# D # )#', "$#1 " ## )1 #$" ""$)" )""$  " # #      "  '    ' "$ #'""$', ##!"

"  "$" )#)1 # 8 %$" #)#     "

#  " $"  !"

"#) $#"$# D #""$ )   )#   "$ )"'" "$  )1 # # $"' 26 >>> * " 8> >>> *   B  $"'  #'# #' ## D #"#     E
 
  
 

 
 
  
 

  




  



  

  
FB"#   D #E 
  
 

 

   


    
       
 
    

 
  
F B  " )""$ # D #)#  ##'"

$"'26 >>> * "8> >>> * ?,$ 


!"

)"# ""$)1 """"#"   D # #)#$) )"6<"$ )"1 "'"$$4' , ## )""$#,"')"4) ## 0
% '#)"$#',   )#")"#""$)"#  "$ #0" #  ' #,    "  "$ )"' #   ,  '

  $"

#  "' "    '"#  "     )"' )  "   4)#""$"'##")C  '"$

G  )  )C# ,       ' ,  ) ,#"'" 4)""$"'     %     )  "  )  " )"' #   "# )#    "#*)' #,",#)#  )"'$"' # # !"'" )"  '# ' " ) "# "))'"$$ #,"'"$ # 1 H" " "

  $# "$  #  D # #)"#"',$"!"   !"

  "$  )"## ""   #  D # )"''#")', ## )     '$ )' "  )") "    !")"##")"'' " $4', "$ # # +" "

#' #  # #    #  D #  "    # ,   '  "

 ,#)


 ))"#

#' #  # #    # D #' # # #"## # !")"'# ", " #

##"  !
-$9