High Court of TripuraWP(C)/562/2010dismissed

Tapati Dutta v. State Of Tripura And ORS

2015-05-08Hon'Ble Mr. Justice S. Talapatra16 pages

" # "$ % & # ' #

! ""

( &

)

*"# #

+++++++

,- , .

/ 0 "0

1 !

!1 !2# '

%334.45

)

*"# &

)

*"## & # ' #

)

*"#&

)

*"#8"

(

)

*"#&

)

*"#

& )

8 : ;

!< # 1

! 1 !2# '

%334.4 = < #

)

*"## & # ' #

% ""

: 0 &

)

*"## & # ' #

++++

? 0 " ? ?

" >

" ?

" ? 1

: 0 ""!

# 6= 64.; "# )" 4@ 4;

64.; '

$ √ A

!! #"

" $ = " %

" "!

# " # " 0 !

.7;%;7%444 ! # "

9@44 0 "

! " $ > .6/65*B'B644@B9=34%4. " .6 4;

644@ 2*

" " $ > .6/65 *B'B644@B;3.%363 "

" 74 4;

6443 2

2 # 0

1 644%

E 2

0 " "" "

&" " $ > .6/65*B'B64.6B.66779% " 4@ 6447 2&

.7;%;7%444

# "

;=44

0 "

" $

= "% "

< #

" ""

: 0

" $ = %

# " 0

! 1 / F1G

5 ""

" $ = "%

< # 1

" !

.4=;4 76;.;@;4/

" !

.7;%;7%444 # "

9@44/

0 "95 ! #

0! !!

& .6 4;

644@

" $ =

" $ %

" #

" ! 1

: 0 "

#! 0 " "

" .6 4;

644@

6443 2* " 2

" $ = "% " " ! "

D E 0

)

*"#

0 644%

!"0! " ? "$ > 9/=95*BB644; 4@B3;."

"63 4.

644@ 2

"0 # ""D E

644% "

" 0 " # #

!! # 0

"63 4.

644.( !"#$%$&#'()&*+#,-./##/(*)(.&0%1/)$2%'&23 )()$%&-(4%2%.&20#5#$%.&+#,-./))$%#&.%/* 12/)/*' )( )$% ""/6% (" )$% ,*3%2#/'*%3 1/)$/* 7#%4%* 3&+# "2(. )$% 3&)% (" 2%6%/8) (" )$/# %.(2&*3,.9 ;

644@ "

;/ 5 1 !"

H #

! 0

" "

!! 0 A ? " " $ > 9/=95*BB644; 4@B74="

".9 644@ 2

!! 0

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

%.&20# 8&##%3 1/)$ 2%'&23 )( "/)*%## "(2 82(.()/(* )( *%:) $/'$%2 '2&3% &'&/*#) 6(; ( = &*31/)$2%'&23)('2&3/*'&'&/*#)6(;(>$&4/*' -%%*)$%(4%2&;;&##%##.%*)(")$%82%#/3/*'(""/6%2 "(2 82(.()/(* &2% *() )(,6$%3 )( %:8,*'% )$% #&.%9 #

D E " 2 #"

= '

0 &" " $ > .6/65*B'B644@B9=34 %4. "

" .6 4;

644@ 2*

< #

" $ =50 # " "

" 0 "

! .4=;476;.;@;4 /

! # "

" $ =

# " %

"6@ 4;

644@ 2

" 0

0 " "

" 74 4;

6443 2

! ""

: 0

" $ %

" 0 " # "

! .7;%;7%444

# "

9@44 4.

4= 6449

" "

!! #" 0

0 "

" $ =

" $ % 0 I ! "

)H2& *

! /A95.7;%;7%444

# "

;=44 ! #

0! !! 0 " "

" 43 4@ 64.. 2$

"74 4@ 64.7 2&

!! #"

!! 0 2

" # #

" "

" $ = ) %

!" # 0

)H2 & * "

" $ =

" $ % "

"# " .4 ? 0 ! " !

! #"

0 !!"#

D E

? 0 ! " !

" %4 ,)) ?# */(* (" *3/& 2# " @ @ 7 " -$/A/) $(#$ &#)/3&2 4#

*/(*("*3/&&*3 2# " B > A "

!0 " # # !I

" # # " !1 "

! /1 500

( !)$&#-%%*$%;3/*&*%0&&*3$/4 */(*("*3/&

B7@ >@ )$&) &2-/)2&2/*%## 4/(;&)%# 2)/6;% > (" )$% (*#)/),)/(* * (,2 (8/*/(*5 )$% *(*C6(..,*/6&)/(* (" &* %*)2+ /* )$% (" & 8,-;/6 #%24&*) /# &2-/)2&2+ -%6&,#% /) 3%82/4%# )$% 6(*6%2*%3%.8;(+%%"2(..&0/*'&2%82%#%*)&)/(* &'&/*#) /) &*3 82&+/*' "(2 /)# ,8C'2&3&)/(* * (,2 (8/*/(*5 %4%2+ %*)2+ /* )$% **,&; (*"/3%*)/&;

%8(2)("%4%2+%.8;(+%%,*3%2)$% )&)%51$%)$%2 $%/#/*6/4/;5A,3/6/&;58(;/6%(2()$%2#%24/6%%:6%8) )$% ./;/)&2+ .,#) -% 6(..,*/6&)%3 )( $/.5 #( &# )( %*&-;% $/. )(.&0% & 2%82%#%*)&)/(* &'&/*#) /)5 -%6&,#%*(*C6(..,*/6&)/(*3%82/4%#)$%%.8;(+%%

(" )$% (88(2),*/)+ (" .&0/*' & 2%82%#%*)&)/(* &'&/*#) /) 1$/6$ .&+ &""%6) $/# 6$&*6%# (" -%/*' 82(.()%3 (2 '%) #(.% ()$%2 -%*%"/)# (2%(4%25 )$% (-A%6) (" 12/)/*' )$% 6(*"/3%*)/&; 2%8(2) &*3 .&0/*'%*)2/%#/*)$%./#)('/4%&*(88(2),*/)+)( & 8,-;/6 #%24&*) )( /.82(4% $/# 8%2"(2.&*6%5 4/3%

)&)% (" 4 D&.,*& $&*0%2 /#2& BB7 >

7 %*6% #,6$ *(*C6(..,*/6&)/(* /#5 /* (,2 (8/*/(*5 &2-/)2&2+ &*3 $%*6% 4/(;&)/4% (" 2)/6;% > (")$%(*#)/),)/(*9 EH

0 0 "

( !4%2+ %*)2+ &*3 *() .%2%;+ & 8((2 (2 &34%2#% %*)2+ 2%;&)/*' )( &* %.8;(+%% ,*3%2 )$% )&)% (2 &* /*#)2,.%*)&;/)+ (" )$% )&)%5 1$%)$%2 /* 6/4/;5 A,3/6/&;58(;/6%(2()$%2#%24/6%%:6%8))$%./;/)&2+ .,#)-%6(..,*/6&)%3)($/.51/)$/*&2%&#(*&-;% 8%2/(35&*3/).&0%#*(3/""%2%*6%1$%)$%2)$%2%/# & -%*6$ .&20 (2 *() 4%* /" )$%2% /# *( -%*6$ .&205 *(*C6(..,*/6&)/(* (" &* %*)2+ .&+ &34%2#%;+ &""%6) )$% %.8;(+%%G# 6$&*6%# (" 82(.()/(*(2'%))/*'#(.%()$%2-%*%"/)5-%6&,#% 1$%* 6(.8&2&)/4% .%2/) /# -%/*' 6(*#/3%2%3 "(2 82(.()/(*(2#(.%()$%2-%*%"/)&8%2#(*$&4/*' & H'((3G (2 H&4%2&'%G (2 H"&/2G %*)2+ 6%2)&/*;+ $&# ;%##6$&*6%#("-%/*'#%;%6)%3)$&*&8%2#(*$&4/*' &H4%2+'((3G(2H(,)#)&*3/*'G%*)2+9 EH

"F ..

D E .6 ? 0 ! " !

" )&)% (" 4# D&.,*&

$&*0%2/#2&&*3*2 " BB7> 7

0 0 "0

2 %

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

.7 ? 0! " ! 0

" 0

2 )&)%(" 4#D&.,*&

$&*0%2 /#2& &*3 *2

!" " "

# "

" 0

$ !

# 1

0 " 0 #

# 0!

2!! " "

# !!

.9 ? 0 ! " !

,0$3%4 /*'$4# */(*("*3/&&*3 2# " =B

2 "" "

!! "! !

# "

"" 1 &;/'&.4# 2&-$&) $&*32& &/* " BB == -$/A/)$(#$ &#)/3&24# */(*("*3/& " B >

!!:

,0$3%4 /*'$4# */(*("*3/&

" 0 *"# A

&;/'&.4# 2&-$&)$&*32& &/* */(* (" *3/& 4# &A(2 &$&3,2 /*'$ " =@! 0

2 >

0 0 " ,0$3%4 /*'$ 4#

*/(* (" *3/&

0 I 0 "

2 %4 ,)) ?# */(* (" *3/&

" "

" 1 0!

5 .;

< # # " !0 " "

2 K K2&/8&0 4# */(* (" *3/& " BB

*/(*("*3/&4#,;#/ &. &)%; " B@ = =B@&*&2&&*04#?K1&#)$+ "

= )&)% (" &$&2&#$)2& 4 ,-;/6 (*6%2* "(2 (4%2*&*6% 2,#) " 7 = @7

0 !!" %4,))?# */(*("*3/&

1 0!

0 "

0! "

##" #"

.% " .@ %4 ,))?# */(*("*3/&

" ,0$3%4

/*'$4# */(*("*3/& >

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

3%6/#/(*(")$/#(,2)/*&*%0&&*3$/4 */(*(" *3/& B7@ >@)$&)&2-/)2&2/*%##4/(;&)%# 2)/6;%>(")$%(*#)/),)/(* @ $,#5/)/#*()(*;+1$%*)$%2%/#&-%*6$.&20 -,) /* &;; 6&#%# )$&) &* %*)2+ 1$%)$%2 /) /# 8((25 "&/25 &4%2&'%5 '((3 (2 4%2+ '((3 .,#) -% 6(..,*/6&)%3)(&8,-;/6#%24&*)5()$%21/#%)$%2% /#4/(;&)/(*(")$%82/*6/8;%(""&/2*%##51$/6$/#)$% #(,; (" *&),2&; A,#)/6% 4%* &* (,)#)&*3/*' %*)2+ #$(,;3-%6(..,*/6&)%3#/*6%)$&)1(,;3-((#))$% .(2&;% (" )$% %.8;(+%% &*3 .&0% $/. 1(20 $&23%29 .=

# # "

%4 ,)) ?#

*/(* (" *3/&

# !! !"

" # #

! !

!!" !

#! "

0 # "

! #" "" "

! 0 "

.% ,0$3%4 /*'$ 4# */(* (" *3/&

!! 0 "

" !

( !*#("&2 &# )$% 82%#%*) 6&#% /# 6(*6%2*%35 1% &2% /*"(2.%3 )$&) )$% 88%;;&*) $&# &;2%&3+ -%%*

82(.()%3 * 4/%1 )$%2%("5 *()$/*' .(2% /# 2%<,/2%3)(-%3(*%9 .@ ,0$3%4 /*'$4# */(*("*3/&

"" !

" # :

!# !

0 !"

" 0

!! 0

"" 0 "

! "

.3 ? 0 ! " !

!! ""

" $

"% >

" ?

! " !

" $

6 ;

0 "

" # #

0 ? " "

" .9 644@ 2

!! #

" !!

" $ %

"0 "0

" "

" 74 4;

" "

" ! !" 0

" 0 0 I !

"0 ""

"43 4@ 64.. 2$

# "

" # "

" 0 #

# "

" 0

! "

" !66= 1

< # # " !

" 1 1

0 "

" 2

0 "

" $ = "

" $ %

0 " "

1 !" 6= 4.

644@ 6% 4.

644@

"" ! #

!< #

" A

0 0 "0 1

0! 1

" 1

H 1

" $ % !" ..

6443

.6 6443

"" ! #

! A

" ""

: 0 /

" $ %5 A

" A

" 0 1 " " !

D "

! 1

! 0 1

" !!

*"# H 1

! # " # # " 1 644%

1 0 !!"

"0%4,))?# */(* ("*3/&5

" !

#0 "

,0$3%4 /*'$4#

*/(* (" *3/&

! " 0 "

" # #

"! "

0 #

"0 2

"0 " #

2 #" # ""

! # #

" 0 & "

0 " 0 !" 0 !!

< # "

# "

" $

. ;

!!0 "

""0

" $

6 ; ?

! " ! " !"