← Library
High Court of TripuraCrl.Rev.P./49/2006dismissed

Raja Miah Forandon Behalf Of Accd. Alek Miah v. State Of Tripura

2015-01-29The Hon'Ble Mr. Justice S.C.Das20 pages

  

  

    ShriAlekMiah,  

  



  

  

! "#     $  % ""!  &   '&  % 



  

           

    TheStateofTripura ((((

     !

    ShriTajerIslam@TajuMia,   

) %   

 

! "#      "#$  

    TheStateofTripura ((((

           *+"  )

+  , -./001: 

  

 *+"  )

+  , 2./001:    )3  *+"! %"!! : 

)  % *

 



 

:17.01.2015 

+3 4 ' 5 :29.01.2015 6$  

:   %&'() * %&'() * %&'() * %&'() *+ ' + ' + ' + ' Yes No √ 7+ !



" !8   3    " !   % !

 !

"  

!  !

 " '

 !" 

 )! ,  

 ////00/ 8 %  ' 8  

3    3 



   !   %   ! 8 !'

!! %3 !"'' & ' %+ !



"  !! 2. 9   " !  

   

     )

+  , -./001  " !     )3      )

+    , 2.  /001 * !    *

    

)  %     !  3. !"  "! !     +

  :2 0;

/00/   :1 0;

/00/   3  ' ""!# ! * 

   & <!

' 

! &  

 8    ""! $& *

  %     "

 !3!'   

" )          

" )    '

")3!   ! 

 



'! ''

!"

8 "8 '!! = !

 

""!!

 3.1.  :1 0;

/00/62 7  !)%#< !" 

")  $< %)

   

 3 '

%.

00* 8! %3 

3 6 6

") "!   ' 8 %     ''  3 !   

" )        3 "!      8 %   

    %1>% ! ! =% "

" 8 )

/>//00:8'

!!

   

   8! +    

'

3 +  "  ' %! = !8

% '  +  "

 3.2.  )

      ""

3 

!

     )! , /:>/00/   " ! -2>   ?;0  <) 

+!

 8!   3.3.   :;

0;

/00/ +  "      8! ' ! "  !

 

"  "!   8!     '

!" !  !  !    ! = "%    

 !' ' = !8 ''

!8 "8! = !  "!!

 ! 8    8  !       

"   3    !"  8!     "! 8 %  ! !8! '8



! 3"  !  "8!!'

!!   %"!

   ' !! 8! %       !   8 8! 8  ! %

 * +  "  !" !%'



     < !  "!   !"     /2 0;

/00/  %.

00* ! '! ''

!8  !""!    '""! & <!

'   $= *

   *   8    

 83 '! ""

3%3! =

!/2 0;

/00/ ! '!   ''

! 8 " 8 !  '  

" )   8! =%3

! =

! ! "

 8 !!!     ""!    8! !  /2 0;

/00/    /1 0;

/00/    %!

!  !" ' 6/?)% 

"!< % % ! ""!$=*

 &<!

' 38 + 

" 

           ! ""! !   ""! *   8! !   0:

0.

/00/  *

      !'   ""! *      ! 8 "8! '

")   8! =  "   ""! *   '  ! !    

! "@!% A"8%8! !! ='%!3 %"!



")    0/ 0.

/00/%:002 !

 

3.4.  * "'    +!

  

" !%'

 " ! !""!$=*

&<!

'

!&  *       3.5.  )

= "8!  %!

!

"   "!    " ! 8 '  ! $= *

 &<!

'

!&  *   " -2> " ?-<) " ?;08 " ?-<) 8 "3   

3 "

'%       

   

              

!   3.7.  +" !!" B'

/-8 3 8 !!! ' 3C:6:  %   7"& 6/     ! 6?   % 7 !8! 6- '

*!

% 62 7 % 7!  !61 & !8'

6> 

 36; '  !6. ! '  !6:0 , '  6:: % 9!!  6:/    6:?   6:-      6:2    &  ! 6:1   '  6:>     7 3 6:;   % )%3 6:.   ,  )%3 6/0      6/:   '! 6// 7   %%'6/?  % %  6/-   &'



8 8 !!! 8 B'

 ! ) 6 !!

' 3C)6: %! !' 3 )6/     3.8.  

B'

   ! !!! !"  !+$< %362! =

!  !    ! "  ""! *   ' DB% 2 ! =

!  @!% A"8% "+   ! "  ""! *   ' DB%   =

!  '!  ''

!"+') % E +    '

  ' ! DB% - + ! !'   6- " %3 <  ! DB% : + ! !'   6/: " %3< '!DB% ::+ !!' 6:?" %3 <  ! DB% > + ! !'   6:. " %3 < ' ! DB% :0 + ! !'   6:>" %3 < ' ! DB% ; + ! !'   6:; " %3 < ' ! DB% .

  !'   )6/ " %3 4

!$ !) !!%! !' 3)6: " :1-2))! !% +%3)6:'!DB%F : !

)6/'!DB% ::

! ='! ''

!+% +!DB% /! !

3.9.    )  4  

!   " !

    ""!$=*

&<!

'

!&  * 

 

3  "''



  " 

!%    " ! -2>  ?;0  <)   !  " '  ! <   3!   "  -2>  <)     ! <   3!



 " ?;0<) "%!  "!!

  " "    )  4  

! "G  ""!    '  "  +   !  '   " /:/<)  4. *

 +""!*  ) '

* , /.?/002   )    !!

! 4        %3 '

 & '   :1 0?

/001

  !!

! 4  !'

!!    

 %3  ""!  " + "  !  " *""! & <!

' 

! &   ! +

 

 +) '

* , ?0?/002 )

  !!

! 4         !!

!4 %3 '

& ' :1 0?

/001 !'

!!         & '      " + "   !  " 5. 6

 B"

!

 & !

"    "  ?.>   "  -0:  ))  ! ) !  !  "" !!

3  3& ' !!%3   )!    3"

!  !)  G   #B'

   #"

  + "   " 

!!  ! 

   +!

3   "

   + " 



6.   " !    

      )3 "

3     "

"'!  + " 8 "  !" 

 "'   )'"

"

3  +   " !

  

   ""! ! !  !  "'8



) !

 3 " !

+ " "  +8



   ! ) ! G   #B'

  + "  "  !&! "  7. < !   %3   " !    

  ""

!"   ! 

+! '

")   8"+'! ""!*   " %3""! '! %! ! 8 "%)+!"! = "

3 !  "!   !"     0/ 0.

/00/  @!% A"8% 8! "+ '  %! %   

" )   8 "8!! %

 8 8!   !  %  + %3 

 + "  

 

!"+3  " "! !+ !""!*   8.   " !     )3 ! !%'

  "  '! 8 ! = ' &%     /2 0/ /00/ %   + "   ""!  ! 8 !!!!

! !3 !' ! !   ! = 8 !!! 8 "

 !

 %3  !"    8

  "   ! = '! 

 

''

! 8  "+ '  !!!!

   ""! !3"

% 

3 9. 7    " !     !  !%'

 :1 0;

/00/$< 8! % 3



8! 3'! ''

!8! '  

" )    ,

 8!  ! !   %"!

 8 8!   8%   8!"

3 :;

0;

/00/  !" "! ! !! !   "

 % ""  " + "    ""! !

7  " !  !!'  !

 " !" ! " ! 8 "<   

'  !"!!

!

10.  *

     %   ! !%'

 

")    !     ''  3    +  "       " %' :1 0;

/00/  :> 0;

/00/6288! %#< !"

")8!%!  ! :;

0;

/00/

! "!



" "!+  "     8!      8!     '!   ''

8!  8!)  



8

"  %3

"  

 !8  %"!   3 

'!

3  8 !   ! !"

 !""! !  ""!  9  ! !%'

   ""!#" + " $= *

 

 3 + !

 !& ' " + "  !  "     !    3    ! "G    ""!     9 ! "      ) ! 8

 !  

 ) +3 ' " !

3 " !

 + " "  ""!! 

 ""!# ! 

3" !

  ! 

  + ! =   ! "  ""! *   "  % "%3!" % !+ "!8 ! = ! "6!:::/ /: " ""! *  ' !! ! =@!% A"8%DB% 1 ! %  + 8  +8 '

 + "  9 !  ! !%'

  ""! $= *

 & <!

'   *     83'! +

! '! ''

 '

 &%  !8! = *""!$=*

 & <!

'      83 "!!

   +  % 8 38"!%3

"3 !"%3 &'

 +%38"  8    "      

  "

"'! "! ! +  !"  "! 8  

 " 3    "  & '   " + "  !  "! %'  11. <+" !

!%'

!!

!  " !  % !

   ' " !

3     '

 & ' !! %3    )  4  

!    

 )A! & ' ! !! %3   !!

! 4  < +  !

    + "   "  ! !3 '3!  ! 



8 ) 

) 3"

 + "  $'  + "  6! :  .    + " 6! //  /- ! +8 '

3 !%

!    8! "''

        

" )   

+

  :2 0;

/00/   :1 0;

/00/   3  '  '

!" !! 831>% !! =%  '!   ''

! '     <   $<   :1 0;

/00/ 62  ) %#< !"    ! ! " !  ! 1>% !! = %   '"   " !% 8!  3 !   $<    +  "  8  8! '

!!

 3 ! 8

% 

< + " " :> 0;

/00/8 %' !' 3  :;

0;

/00/ ! "!

 

" "!+  " 

")   8!  8!    '!   ''

! 8  ! !  '  8 !)   8 "8!  " 3 '

!" !! '! ''

!%

 "8 !)    8!+ 8!"''

 "  !8! '

" )     3!"  !!%!G 3  !!!!

   3%3  !  !'  !  % 8   ! !  8

8

!8! 3! 



12.  38 !!"" " 6?88! ,

)'

!!!8!+3 !'         "  ' 

 '  

8

3"'  8!   ""   

" )      ,

 ! % B'

'

!" !   3          "

!

%     ) %

 % 3     3    %"!

 8 8 8 " 8! %       ! 8       %"!

!! 8! !%

 !"

 '

!" !   3   "

!

%  %   !8 8 %"!



")  13. ! !!!' )6/    9 8! " %  4  

! $ ! ) !!)6: 

 "! +!

  '"

!'  

 "" 

"" "  !'  !  %  !   3 '

  "!!# B'



    !'  ' %3    8 " +!DB% F: DB% F::!!

8!H I  

                        

 

    

                    

 

    !

   "

    



#            

    

      $           %       &'        

    

   

  !                  

       $     %                    $   (

  

  

   !

             

                    !          "

  # 

  

                  !

  )

 

 % !           

    %

      %     "

           *        

      

          ! 

  



 &'         +

,        !

  "

   $  - +       ( - + . 14.  %+ + "  )6:    !! ' 3 !  ""!# !   ""! $= *

  3  8  + !'

'

 #

 "''

  %%3   

" )  6

  %+ + " ' !  !   "   + " 



" ! %"' "'

"  +  " !  !  ""!! !

15.



! =  !  ! "  ""! *   ! <         !  8 ! =  0:

0.

/00/%:/-2!

!""!*     ! "

 6! :: :/   /:   8 !!!   ! =  6/: 8! "

 !

 %3  !"     + !!' !% '!DB% ::

 + " 6!:::/ /:8 " !!%3+ !!' 6/:'DB% ::'! % 3"

   !  8 " %3  ""! '  ! !   <  ! 8 ! =  7 ! <     + "  

 '%362 3 ! 8! !! ' 

")    %! " 3!"+ "  3  ! '

")   "+3  3  ! '!""!"

 3!

++ " !!"

<!'

++! '"!38 ! !!!!

    8! "+ '  !!!!

  !'%3 !!'  " ::- !+

%  ! !!!!

!  !  !  !  8

%!

6

  + "

   ! ! = 3    !  '  !!!!

   ""! !   3!

++ " !""!*  

 

 ""! *   8! !   0:

0.

/00/ 6

8! "!3

"'!'  @!% A"8% 8 " 8! !    '  "''

!!

  %

8 88!  %! %"!

 

")    8

%%   *""

3  8!      "   %"!

  

" )    0/ 0.

/00/ %:002!

%    @!% A  ! "   8 !!!   8! ! = +!DB% ?

6!:?:- :.8 !!! ! =@!% A ! """!*   '3 " !

 

    )    

 ) 

 3"

+ "6!:?:- :. <

 !"  "+3  @!%  6! :? :-   :. 

 +  !

! ! =

! '6!:? :. 8 "

 !

    + "  6! :? :-   :. " 8 DB% > DB% :0!< +"+3 @!% A ! """! ! !"

"'! "

!+ !""!*  "+@!% A 8 "8!! "''

!!

 " 16.  B !  "+3   ! =  '!  ''

!

 73 ' !  ! =

!  /2 0;

/00/ 8 " '!DB% -

8

 !8! =H /0  +1      

&2 & 34 

  5&4 



/0+1   6  7%7 54

 

    /0           $$&834 

378  /%0 2    6              

&'353 " 9('32     

   +" 334  

   /%0     3

 

  24

 :'87  /%0  6 :87  17. 6! :0   :1   8 !!!  ! =

!  3 +! =

! ! = !'!DB% / ! !

 6! :>   :;   8 !!! 8    ""! ! ''  3 %  ! =   8  

 83 7  ' 8 "

 !

 %3  !"     + !!' 6!:> :;+!DB%!

; .

18.  < !  !  8  + "   !

 8 !! !  % &" 

      + "   !

 8 !! 8 " ! "% 8   8 !! 

!! 8 ! % '3%""! + " -  8 !!8'!  !' !  '! !%!'!   ) ! %!

8" ! ' 3!"8 !!  '

3 !  "% + " !" 8 !!

 6 + "  !" 8 !! ! "% %3  '!  + "     !'    !





!!'3%""   "' !

' 3 %"!8 !! !"

!

 ! + "! 

B"

  83" !



<   "!    6! :>   :;    + ! !' ! " %3 <  !  3    ""! ! ! 

83'!8DB% /! !

 '! ''

!8  8! = *""!& <!

' $=*

  83' 38 ! %3 6/?   /1 0;

/00/ 8

 3 8 %  "!! '  + 3&' 8!



"% %3  "  38 %%  "!3 *

  "

"'! "! "  8   + "  ) 6 !! , / 6!:0 :1!8

!+ "6/?< 

!G "

""!! !&<!

'$=*

 * 

8 + + "''

!!

" '!

 '! ''

!'DB% /! !8 %3 '! '

 !   3" '+  8 3 

"8 !"

 ' 3   

3 %      83 '  ! 19. < !  +8 '

3 !%

!   ""! ! ! "''

 ! %

 %3

 %3  

  

" )      

" )  "''

'! ''

!  !

6





"



  + "   "   )  4

!!" !%!+ :/& ' 8 " ! % +  G !

8!H I;;;;

     % 

                        <                    *    =      '

=       ,                 >           %                   =   =           

              

       ,    

        

=   

)    

        

%         

    

  

          

                ?          

     

  <          

   

                       

,     %        -*  @ %  '          

 

        

    &'

5A4   ( * 4    %       '               

  "                                                

         "

  !

      #               

 &'

5A44 

        $     

   

              B= 82 

  

   

,             

  !

      

< ;;;; . 20. < + +3 "

3     '

 & ' !  !  + " " '3 " !



 "! "

"'! "!8 "%   " "

 3 !%

!  "   ""! ! "''

!%

%3

 "''

 ! = ! 

"

"'! "!%  "  3!

! 

""! " !

! 8   

" "    %   "

"'! "! %   "  "< ' + !



" ! ""

3+ !



" !! !'

!! ""! ! ! "!+!  "

 

21.   %"   )  "! 

 8   "3   & '     JUDGE