← Library
High Court of TripuraCrl.Rev.P./79/2006dismissed

Sunil Chandra Hrishidas v. State Of Tripura

2015-04-27The Hon'Ble Mr. Justice S.C.Das23 pages

  

       

   

     



 

 ! "   ###   $ %   "  ## "      

 & " '()* + ,  ( -

  ( .  ( / ,  ) 0   &  "  '( .    )

  

    '12231245

 06 7     '   !  "  '    

    0  ""  389

+   :24            0 

 12421225 "

 .6   .

0  7  (   ; < 7(=>* + !  "   

 ?  @:  1221   .6 -  

  

 112A122A "

 .6    )







 7 * + ! "  )"" ?5;:> 1225 1    7( .6 " -  

12421225   " 

6      

        :A@:94:12  /        /  + 6   "

6     4222      "

 

 /  B    

   "

.  :A@/    /+6 "

6  522   "

 /    

"

.  :94/  

6 /+6 "

6   4222   "

 / B   

   "

.    :12  / 

    

 06  )

 

 7  .6 " -  

112A122A

""        0 "

.6   7( 3 & 0    0  "  

 "    "  0  "" 

 -    0  :

   () * + ,   "     )

   (  

.      " 



5 6  " 

    "   

 +

 +,

 "

    & 0""   )   0   "    ""    (

, B

 6 4881  4A2:4881  .6  "  

6C ; <C=>

 B

    $0,

  

6 ;D1

> 

 ; <$0,

 =>    ? +

 CB A8A@1        "

(

,B

 .6+ 

21234883  .

  " (  )

  

  &  0 ""  E   )   ;  



< => " 6 "  

  *"   " 6  "

 (

, B

 +

"   "  .6     

 2A444883         "     +

"   " F .6   

182@4889 54     0   "     (   + ,

 1:414888 +   +

   

   G      

 +

   G +

06 

"   +  

 .

   )

   ( ,       (

, B

    6  4881  "        

  11241222 .

  



 )

  ( ,           )

 (    6C G   B

 

  +   

 

6  B

 51     6 C .6 

 4@211221       

""     (

,B

 6 4881 $0,

 

 B

 0  ? CB A8A@1  

  +     6:9

,       B

   ",     B



+0  )

 +

 . 53  " 

    6 C  ;

!4>+  (* + ;

!A>  &/    " 



 6 !A    &/  29251221    

 "  

   6 





 ? 351221 +

     :A@:94:12/  0  +

 ,"  " +

  0    (   +

+ B

    + H  

6 /

.

       .

+   H +

 ,    +



"

. :A@:94:12



/ +    "

6  .   A  +    "  B

  42 +



6 !4

 . ..

  !1

") - "6E(   

  !3 - *  ,  C !:?6

. )



  $0,

   !5   -

    "6    &  0 "" "

  0   "  !A  

.  ?

 .

0  * + 

 !9

* " /  

+  

B "

0   !@  6 . "   /+  .

    

!8*

) ,  "6 6C !42 )-(  , 

$0,

  9

 B

      +

 " "0  +

   '   

 

 

  



   !" #$



  #%

 & %

'$

 

(( )   * + #$

   & % 

 '$

  ((

   

 , #$  #

 "

% & %

  

% & %

 



-)  . 

  

    

  /    

0



,-1##   

/+   2

/#3

  .(45) ,-6

  



/+   3+  7((.) ,- 6

  



 / +    83+  ( 4((5) ,- 6 $

 / +     

.((.

 # 

 3+

% # '$  ) ,- 1  # $      9 "  

: (((  3





$  ;/  

/+  ) ,- 

 3



   : 

   / +      / 

% 1 + <' 

<+

  ) ,- 

 3



   : 

   

 $< =9   

    " 

 / +    #  '$

 

 ) ,- =

% '  

 #

/  $ / +  ) ,- =

% 1 +  #

/  $ / +  ) ,- 

 

 $<=9 4

 3



 

%  / +   

$ %  :5      %  #/   

 )



,- 

 /  / +     



   3



 " / 

%' 

1 ) :<: >:

* ?/



.

" %/



6@ 6@5)   * A&  %  $ 6@7 " 

  

6@5) 7* ?/

 

> ) 5 * 

  

 $< =9    !  

5

) 5 *%/

 

 $<=95) 4* ?/



5) ( * !





    

  

 $< =9/

?%6@( ##  "=/ 

 

/

 '$  

   $  ((

= / + 

   * + #$

 =/  

 

/

'$  

((

= / + 

 @ )  " 0  +

B

     343        

  

 6  0   

     ""   (

,CB

4881

B

  

 

6    0   (      "   

 .    6    (  +     "0

  CB. 3  ;

  ;0>  B . > 



8     7(     0      6       

 .    -       0



 .   .6      )

  

 7  ""  "  .6    6



  0  ""  42  ! B 0  -

   

 

 6 ""6 -    "

 .6           6    "           6 G   B



  ""    0     

      .6    .6  ""     . "0          ""   ""  

.0 "

 -   0  44  /  

  "        

 +

 +,

 "

    

  0   "    ""      (

, B

    6  4881

 B

    $0,

   

     ? . +

 CB A8A@1  /  

  "     

.6+ 

21234883;

  ?;0>CB. 3  >" 6 .  0  "       "

 (

, CB





 "    "6  (   )

   +   " 6     "     +

 "      "      2A444883 ;

    ?;>CB. 3  >   " 

F  182@4889;

  ?;>CB. 3  >/    "    "+

, .6    .

   ( )

  

 6  .

   (  )

  +   +    "

  ( 

 . "0

 ?;0>CB. 3  )



 ?;B>CB. 3   )

  "0

 41  /  

 "   ( 

 ( 

  .6  +  0+ "  6  6/    

   ( +

  0   $0,

  43       (  + ,

.

  ( , +   "0

 ?;0>CB. 3

  +

 0  .6            $0,

   

6 

 (

. 

 +    0   "

 3A     

   .6 $0,

       "   

  6  " 

     +     " 

 .    6 +   .6 + 

4:241222

,     "      )

   (

 

   )        (  + , " 

     "0      (  +

   

  

 4:     )

  

.

  !8

"6 6C"     .  

  "

  "6   



 .

,

 CB. 42 +   +     6   :9

,  + 

  (  +     "   .6   +  3:9

,  +       (    6

  . "0  .6 CB. 1   "6   

   .6 $0,

  45 

!

: 42+ 

 $0,

  !: +

 B

  .6        



   2328122: 49241225  +

 

B

   21291225 !42 +

 B

   49241225

!: "0  CB. 4  CB. 1  CB. 4       !:



    / ;

!9>  +   "6    0  "

  

(

,)

 ( ,  6 4881 83"

 52 54CB. 1   "6 0 "

"0 .6 !: !42"       

  B

49241225

 0 "

 52 54"6+  +

,

CB. 1+

 "

 .6   (   0 6

 "

 54      CB. 1 +

     CB. 1       "

  52  54 +  

 



  2:9

,  (

, CB

 "  . 60  

 4A       (  + ,   "

 3A      .

  

 (

. 

0  (   

.B .

+  +0  .



.  

/ 0 6B

       6 4881 0.

 "

 31  ) "

 3A         0 .

    B

   

 (  

   + +

   

""   (

,CB

 4881 +  "

   ? . &  =  ?

 "=   

6 .   "  )

     

  (       "

 :4

" 6    6  4881  "

 52  54 +   6    

    

  0  ( 0    

.

       (  + ,    

(

.

     0  (

  "    "" .       B

 343  "6G  ?44 6    0  (    "                      

   ( + ,       

6 



(

. 

 0    (         0      6 " 

   +  6 .

0  ""   0   49   + +         (  "   .6        

. "0   I /      0      

 +       6 C  43241222 +   +

"

    4:241222 G     6 CB

 )

 (  

    +    +

     +      6C.6

4@211221; ?;B>CB. 3  >      6  :9

,     (

, CB

    (    .  +    

       +

 

    )

 +

          0  +      0   C  ( , +

 4@ 

!:

  $0,

      G   / "   "6  "

  52  54     

    (

,)

 (     6  4884 83     +    

 6  :9

,     B

  !:  6

    +

 "  (     C       (   +



.   +  +

  .6      . )



(

 +    6+   " (

 "   .6  

 .   !8  

"6 6C

"    .  

" "6 

. +  

,

CB. 42/ 006 6   0 

!8  /   0  !8  6  6    

 +  ""      (

, CB

    6  4881 0  ? CB A8A@1

 611

,    "322

,

 4

, "322

, /  " " ;

6   " 6> 6 45

, 122 C0.-C 0 ;C> 8

, 422

,  822

,  

6:9

,  48      (  +     B .

  ?;0>  CB.3   !8    C



  +

)  !8

 (  + "H         6 C     "  (  +

   "H (    " . 

?

 &  =  

  ? ?

   

, .  +  6"  +    6" +   06    .

B

   



12    0 6 G  (   +

  "  '  !  

                                

    

         

   !" #   $     %

 &  $        '   !

' (  !

     

    )  

  *     &  $ '   !

   

   )        

    $  (     



  $        +   #        ,-     ,  

$ &   . "#$%&'$&()(%&$*+"#,$,(-.%/,$,(- / 0  .  

 " .  (   

     0   * 1,  ." .  ,

  "

   2 & .  

1#2  

  4566  %      

 '          2&  7#8 2     2   &  

 1 #2  $ # 

  #                                                     9

  '   

    2   *   (     5::/ *   

  (            ;    

2     )    & $ '    #  ' 3 < '  

 

'   !

   %      

    *        '  < ' !

'   

 & $   

            

  $    !

     5::/         $      )    *  5::/       5::/          ) (    # ' =     * $   *       2   %    5::/        ,- 8



14     0   !8

  .

,  6

  "

:: -  

.

0   6B

  ( " 

 

+

 6     

  +

+" . +

6" .6

 6" +

 6     "H      )

  

  7     6 B

 0  "

4: -  .

0 '  75> :    

 ;%     )        5::/ $      

   ?  @ 

 

  >A  $ 2   

;%          



 



  

   )  ;      '    

' !

'3 < '& $ 

    >A         $     

           ;      $

  

   #2  B#< * 

 2  $

 B#<

B#<;2 B#< 

   #2  $

    2   

     $ 

    $         %   * 2             

         2   :   

   ; $          

 



 $      

    ,      & $   

                 

  >A  $         ,'        * 

    $

   >A * 2    

 

               ?C 56@'     $  

& $ 

 

   $       :   $ 2  

%  D        *    ' <     ' 

'

   '  & $   

      $  $  *

   

 

        : $   

 

    #  ? 56@0 #         

       $        $



    %   ;  

     $ 2    - 

  ;% # :     

       ' $            $   

*

! #(#'=   



  )  ;             

  %         $         ;   

 *

! #(#         

  

'   

      #  (  2'        $  )     

 ,        ,   

 D  #       

#(#'=   +  

             %      



      ;    2   :  2  

   

     *    

   

  0  #          

     

     2   $       8 11         ""    6 ( 

/  .

  0       0   6        "" 

0 

6 0   / 0 06 6 B

    (

   B

    ,  6 +         " .  

 + 6"  +    "H    !8

, "       (      B

 ""

      "

0              "  +  .6        !

0    6 +   



,                 (    0      .      ( + 3:9

,

   .6    +

  0  

      6   :9

,     B

+    

" ,  .   "0      

,  (  



   (    .       

B

  

 0 "    

 G .   " + +

         +    "  +

+  

  0  6 .  +

   6"   .   +   +

 "   .6        .

   

   (  + ,     " 

     "0        . 0  6

 13       (  + ,

  

.

   

.""6B

    343            . 

.  )   (  + ,       

.

 +"  .  + "   

      +

"0   0 "" + 

  

'01$"1 $0+/$"2 $%-#$#( 3 ""$45" 6 78   

 $%9+-:$/$9#$#( 3+1$-5" 68 /  "  + B

   343        

6 .   G  +  +G     . B

 .    "   0  G     6 

   0  



1:   "     (    B

 

    343    /         0 42+

 "

6

 48 G    . 6    "

    0 + "  G  /  6  B

  343  ""6     

  '01$"1 $0+/$"6"',-$8 $%/ $%9+- :$/$96"',-$8         +    

. "-    6

 .    " 6   .

      B

   343  15    0           '01$"1

$0+/$"6"',-$8

.

0  "" B

  343  

 + G  ." 

/ " 

/     (    "   G           0                G   +  " 6"

  0  

  $%9+-:$/$96"',-$8

6     

 "" . " 

 1A       (  + ,

  

     

  +

  " "

  " F   



6 1A411244  " "

 

      

6 . 0   . 



 3A2         :    .

     )  / ""     

 

    

+#1'% (0%$#1#$#( 3 -+,'-$5" 6

8  19     )

  

.

   

     (   " 

.   6  .6.  "   "   F  . ". 0 

       .0 .3A2  :  .

  ) 1@       ""     0  .3A2 :  .

   )           

 +

""   +

 .   0 

    0   .        3A2 :  .

  ) 18   

  +#1'% (0%$#16"',-$8  6

 B? .     ""    

 6 

 .     

     " 

 +     . ". 0  +,

 "

  6    "

 (

, B

  "    (  /  ,    0   



 .0 .3A2    :    .

     )   

 

 

+#1'% (0%$#16"',-$8+

03:4 315 /       

 

.        +#1'% (0%$#16"',-$8  /     

""6            

    "+ 

    ""  + + +,

". 0        0 60+0    . 32       (  + ,

  

       "

    :A@  / 

  . "0    "

    :A@/ +

-   34  :A@" . "

6  ""    + <6=  :A3 / +  

  '  7>E   F G 2     

              

        ' $  

 

   &H'

  

  ' 

      ' 

 

 $   ' 

 

      

 '  $  

     

   

'    8 31   :A:  /  " .

,     

 +  

  '  7>E>(  

 FG+ 

 

        3 F$       

 

?@ ' '   

   

 I ?@                      I ?@    G      H

       I ?

@    

   

       G      H' $       

   2

  

   

 '        G      H $  ' '  ' '  

               $    $       $    $

  '  '   '    I 



 $ ' $  $    '

       '     

$'   

                '     '  $ G      H         

  '$   2        I  ; $          

  '  '      

       

 G     H       $

    

      

 

' 

       ' 



 $ 

  



               H8 33    " 

 "0

     (

 +      "        "

(

, B

      6 "     

   "

    " 

 6   + "     "

  +   0    " 

  "          

   



     .  6  6   6 "          

""    6 .

0     

  "

.    :A@  /        0  :A@/    0 6 3:  :94/ " . "

 

         "    ( 

     .     (   "



6.   6    :A@  /      G   . " "

6 :94/  35   "

 :12/ /

  "  " 



6"0       "

 .6"   (       

  :45/  "0   0      06  ""6 .6     0  "

    :12  /  .      

 . "0

  .."  :49/     "

 +  .6        .6  

""      :12  /    0      :49/        /   6    "

6     4222      "

   /      /    +   



   7      06            



6 .   0  +



"

   

+

  / ,        6 

    

  -  3A  ) 6   0 

"" 

    -       0   :A@/    -     0     :94  /   

  -    0    :12   0    :49  /   

    /   6    "

6     4222      "

   /       

  6    0 "   0   39   .

, +

+  "6   -