Indrajit Debnath v. Bablu Deb And ORS
!"
! "
# #$%
& '
$$ %% ! '(!) %*
+
$ %
&
'
! "
, % &&' !$- ./%-.+
$(
)* + , - ,
- ! "
0 12!* +
$ +
.) / "
! "
# -&-/
& ' !$- ! 3 314 356 3
0"" 7 + +.*
,1 0 " + 2 ,1
-& 8
%2 .-& *8/ - 7 7 9 9 :
& &- $- 8 1- 6 531 ; 3 !
""
34 5367 / 6869:663 " *
! "
+ *
8 :66;
" 5 & "
' + *
8$6; .
<
) 499576$ 2 " = 56> "
"
"" 5 :& 5 :'
" " 8 9 2 * " 8 9 & " 8 9'
*
"
/ ""
1*
) 499576$ 2 56>
2 1 1 "
5 :
" ""
0 ( 1
" " " !"
" "
5 : " 8 9 " " 6755:66?
" , "
5 @ / " 8 * )* 2 "" , * " * 2 , *:655:66?!" " 2. 56
2 5567:664 5:67:664 2 " 2 2
"
2
"
5 :
, " * "* .
*$
* 1
"
,
" 2 * 5567:664 5:67:664 2 * " 2 2
"
:567:664 2 2 "
"
* " " "" "*
@ / "
5 " 2 "
"" 2
* " "
"
5 : 2 "
*
:567:664 "
1
) ?3?666$ ""2 * "
"
* ) ?3?666$ @ *"
5 :
2 "
5 :
"
1 * 1 " ) 566666$ "
:567:664
* "
) 43?666$
" * "
" 5 : "
, *
*:66;
2 , * * , * "
,
, *. " "
*
"
) ?67:6$
) 566666$ 2
"
:567:664
) 93576$
"
1 "
5 : 2 ) ?3?666$ A ) 93576$ ) 499576$ @ * "
"
"
, *.
2 .
+
B@ 1
!(535 "
" "* .
!"
"*
2 1 2 "
1 "* .
* "
! "
"
6:67:66;
+ +
2
" 1 "
C *
.* ::67:66;
) 499576$ ! "
" "
6:67:66; 2 "" 1 * "
::67:66; ! "
<
2
" =56>"
9 ! 5 :
*
2
"
, * & %D (' 2 "*
@
* "
5 : "
2 +
. 1
"
* "* !
5567:664 5:67:664 * 2 "
:567:664 * " "" 2
*
) ?3?666$ " * !* 1
2 * " "" .
2
!* 1 :567:664
) 566666$ 2 " * "
@ "
" " , * 1) ?67:6$ "
" *
!
" "*
< ! " 8 9
*2
= ! "
5 : "
C *
>
" 2
2
*
E 5 @
"
" F : @ *
F 8 @ "
) 499576$ F 9 ? , " * $ F @ *
&@ 9 @
) 849666$ F' 2
2 " 5363:667" * @ "
D
-5 D
8&' 2 "" *-: -8 1
&" 9' -9 & "
' ! "
"1 D 2
E 3? ' !
!E ,1 G
6:67:66; ::67:66;
3? 'E )"* ,1 G
* / /,1 "
3? '0 E ,
+ B@ +
:46;:66; "
3? ' E ,
+ B@ +
5667:66; ,
"
2 * 3? '9 !
!E " , 3? '< E , "* " " 2 3? '= E , "* 2 , *D
*"
" : " 9 3? '> ! E "* 5567:664 5:67:664 & . HD
/ / ' 3? ' E ,
1 :567:664 " "" ) 56$ & D / / *
' 3? '7 , . ,
56678 "
* B@+
3? 'E , . ,
56678 "
* B@+
3? ' E , . ,
56678 "
* B@+
3? '0 E , . ,
56678 "
* B@+
3? '!
!E7& '
. 3? '9 !
!E ! 1
, & %D (' 3? '<E,"* ,1
6?63:66;*,1 / / "
3? '= E ,
1 * -8 & 9' "
" 3? '=@E
-8 HD 5; ! "
5 : D
1 - 5 : *
*
*1
! /
1 "
*
0 0 1 "
" "" (
+.*""
" 1
2 2
"
" "
!
* 1
1
* "
! "
D
* " "" 2
. HD 3 *
2 ""
) ?3?666$
! HD 3 2 . D
/ / !
D
*
"
"1 *
"1 * "
"
HD 7
+.*
2
" "
2 . D / / !
"* ".
" "
"
2 2
@ "
) ?67:6$ , * %2
"
2 , * !
. HD 56555:58 59 1
"
-:
2 *
-9 ! 1
-: 2*
"" "
-8
"*
. HD 5; "" "
-9 "
"" -: -9 "" -: !
+.*"
"1
2 * "
/ " *
HD 32
"
1
* HD 56555:58 5? " / 2
1
9 (
+ 2 "" "
2
5567:664 5:67:664 D
-5 *
2 HD 7
5567:664 5:67:664 1
@ *
"
"*
* 2
* 1 1$
"
"
"
"
+ 2
* . *
"
, " "
I "
G 5567:664 5:67:664 2 :567:664 2 "
"
" *HD 32 ""2 "
) ?3?666$ 2 " "
!"
1
2
2
*2
1
"
!"
* 1* 2 "
" 1 "
2 "
"
1 .
*
1
"
! *
""
< ) *
1
*
+ .* "" , @
1 "
@
2
@ 2 "
"
, * * "*
, * *"*
1 / " @
"
2 "
"
" , *2 2*
! 2 2 "
" , *
, * 2
* "* "" "*
(
+.*
" " 1 "*
@
2
" 2
= @ 8
2
* 1 "
!"
) ?3?666$
"
:567:664 2 "
5 : 2
) ?3?666$ 2 " * "
*HD 32 2 !"
"
1
HD 3 2 " "" ) 56$ 2
2 " "
2 D 32 ""
! 1
22D 3@
2
"" "
"
1 * 1 "
G ! "
"
D 3 "
5 : " 2 1
* * .
2 D 3 2 "" "
HD 3
"1
2 + "
.
D "1
! 1 "1 *
"" 1
!
"1 * " 22 1"1
"1
H1
, !"
D
* D 3 *
2
D 3 "1
2"
"1
> ( 2
*1
! 5 D
*
2 5567:664 5:67:664
2 2 2 %
1
5567:664 5:67:664
. D 7 ! "
5567:664 5:67:664 D
"
" 5 -5 *
5567:664 5:67:664
2 2. ! HD 7 . "
.
* . "
! "
D 7 22
"
!
2 " "
"1
"
) 499576$ 2 " "
* ! "
"1
2 " * ! "
D
2 " " %
1
2 2
2 22 "
"
! . "1 * "
*2*"1"
1
." " + "
2 .
2
"1
2
( 2 *1
- :8 9 2* *
"" "
-: D
"*
12 *
," :66;
-9 -9
@ / 2/ & ' . ) ?3?666$ &"
' "
%
2 2 * -9 2/ 2 2 " "" ) 56$ "
2 * -9 - -9 " 1 *
D
*
*-: 1
-: "" "
*
-8 2
"1
2
. HD 5;% * "
) 499576$ 2
"
1
-8 "" "
@ D 7 2
" "
"" * * ,
"2 *
"
D
*
" 2
"" !2 2D
* "
1 "" @
"
* 1
""
"
@ 1 1
2 *
8
1 "
2 *
! "
"1
) 499576$
2
"
"1
"
,
*"" 2 0 ! / 6869:663 " *
! "
+ *
8 :66; @ * "" 9
. ( 2 "* / 6 3