Howarun Bibi Alias Howarunnessa Khatoon v. Md Abdul Matin

INTHEHIGHCOURTOFTRIPURA AGARTALA R.S.A.No.43of2010 HowarunBibi@HowarunNessaKhatoon,
                     ! """"Appellant -Versus- 1.
Md.AbdulMatin,     !

              ! 2.
MostafaMiah 3.
ManaurAlialiasManourMiah 4.
EmadMiahaliasEmadAli 5.
MashabAlialiasMaohabMiah 6.
JakirHossainaliasMonaiMiah

          #              ! ............Respondents BEFORE THEHON'BLEMR.JUSTICES.TALAPATRA $    :    
%   & 

'(!  &   $    : ( () 
 !* &   (  * :25.03.2015 +!%   ,      : YES NO √

 JUDGMENT&ORDER(ORAL) -    
% &!  * '(! &!    
  (  ( ) 
 !*  &!       [2]     ! &  .//   ))
 %    
!  0! 
1 (i)WhethertheRespondentcouldbeallowed tofilesuitsaftersuitagainsttheAppellanton the same cause of action and if did so whetherisallthosesuitswouldnotbebarred under Order A2 Rule 2 of the Civil Procedure Code? (ii)WhethertheSuitforperpetualinjunction of the plaintiff (Respondent of the instant Appeal) is dismissed on contest on the ground that he was not in possession of the suitlandhadanyrighttofileafreshsuitfor recoveryofpossessionofthesuitlandandif he did so whether would it not attract the section11ofthecodeofcivilprocedure? [3]

  
%    &!           )!      &  &*   &   !   0!   
      .   !   &               !2!&    .&%    %!/34&&%  $  & ! 

       !   %! /.3 &   &  & & !





         .     *         5  6 -
  %  $  & ! &   & ! &  &&      .  !      !   &  &%   &0!     !2!&         5 6 $ &

& & !     . *   &  &           5 6- &% 
   !  

$! & !          *  
    %    *        .&   7



   


  


 
    8    -
!

  *          .   !  %   &  
& &%

 
   -
   
%    &!  !      9&      &   ! : *    
 !
%* )+!+( 1 (1) Is the suit is maintainable in its present form? (2)Hastheplaintiffanycauseofactiontofile thissuit? (3) Whether the story of possession and dispossessionistrue? (4) Is plaintiff entitled to get the decree as prayedfor?





 (5) To what other relief/reliefs the parties areentitled? [4]  )+!+(   !    2!%    53/;5//6     !  4/  5//< &  !  !    2!%    53/;5//6
    465//6

)!  ( & +!  ! 
&  &!  %
    &!     ( &  +!  !   ( & +! 

    !  *  &!      !1 Since the plaintiff has brought this seeking declaration of title over the suit land and on theotherhandthedefendantisalsoclaiming hertitleoverthesuitlandonthestrengthof 'kabirnama' so in my considered opinion for fair ends of justice the amendment petition filed by the defendant should have been allowed. Since the amendment petition has notbeenallowedbythetrialcourtIamofthe view that the defendantAappellant has been seriously prejudiced. Both the parties should be given all opportunity to set up their respectiveclaimoverthesuitland. [5] - !       *    
 
   2!

%    53/;5//6   ! 4/5//<
 %  %  &     (      !     
 % *   &!  
!    %  2!%   5//55//= )+!+(  2!   &   ! 
 % 
 !







     ! *       &!  * 2!%  5./35//=   465//6 &! %  & & ! 
 % [6]    . *  2!%    55/55//=     !  4/  5//<     ! &  =6  ))  &!  

 ( &  +!    !      465//=   
* % ! 2!%  54/>5/./*& ! &          %!/5; &!

 =46  .3;;.3==.4//  .4/.?5/;6
 &0! !  % %  &  &        $ !     &!  *&@!

 - )! OnThe DeathofNagenHazarikaHisL/RKanchanHazarikaandOrs. vs.MonoramaSharma,  2007(2)GLR403  1 "Title" is a broad expression in law, which need not always be understood as akin to ownership. The expression "title" conveys different forms of right to a property, which canincludearighttopossesssuchproperty. Lawfulpossessionofimmovablepropertyina situation where ownership in an absolute term is yet to be established confers good title on the possessor as against the whole world except the true legal owner of such property.Such"title"hastoberecognizedby thecourtsagainstallexceptthetrueowner.





 [7]          &!           
   * 
 !      !  2    * & 
 !    ! *    #  & ! %!%!  
  

 %! /34 &    -
!           %!//6&*

    &&*

         &    %! /5;&  
 &       & &*     %  %! /.3 & 
&   @):  !            !           2!&    
!   & A

      &! 
 !  % * !    !* &%   &&!      &      *    & *
&   & &! 
! &   !    ! %!    && &   !   &&        * &  0!  &  !       !     !&   
!  !  2! &  & !%  &   &2!*! [8] - !   )!        
 !&     % !2!% 





   54/>5/./ 0!  &  !     2! &  
!  %!  & *     &&*

% !2!%  54/>5/./ 0!    !   %  &    &!    ) +! + (     !    %    %% *     
    %  :   &  !      &!    %  !    !        & $  & !

 &! %*%  ! &!   ! %         %*  
    &  &   &     ! *       !   &*     &*

&&*     
   9    &     &&&*


 B)'   JUDGE