Binode Bihari Chakraborty v. State Of Tripura And ORS

 





 

   
 

 ! !" "#"$%&'   

  !"

##$#  %&'()#   !% %

! *+&)&,

!%"%!(  )*"' ' )- .

/

'() /)0(/- "1( (2#$#3)4  %&'()# 
!+ ,% -%."/ ,%"%!011!-% &'()0&- #$#%&'()# 2
!+ !-%("

!- ,0!%%1!3!

%' .

/

'() #$#%&'()# 4
!+!)*%&+ !-%' ! - !&5 .

/

'() #$#%&'()#    6## !,) !

%,

 5

56 5.

7  5+   8 9##9# 

 #%!/ -#   &( !& 8 9#0##"%!/ -# 0

5 !/

4)! !$!#   

(  22
  




 7 +.5 0 +5  

:!!#- )&#9# 



 (  ! ! - )& 9# 0## "

  *&( !&#  '-&

( && 1

 )!  !"

# % !1&! 

 /)0(.

'() 

);

(- ! %-<)&   -  & '()

  ( 

#

=    # >#

> !  

 );

  $

- & 0&-   ) :  ( #
 !    

)! 1&
 >  &< # (&

?&2 &#



&! &

# '1&(! ( @ &#>=*( 


#

=#' &!1&/&!! ( /&  

 &#A

* (   1& (!# ' (  <)&! &( ! "

#

 &  !! A#

  2    ! -- !   0&- /  &)! & ( 9 !!

?# > %2)*   &&&&!   @
C - / &#B? B* (   %2)*B  

  ( 

  
>#

B# D &  /-

(    &( !

 &&) 9  !!



A A# =#

 ! 9  !! 
#
#

 %2)*  ! %2)*>   &(-/  ) /!- -)& 

( 

 
>#

B( 1&@ &#B? B* (   & &&&&!

 ) -  & 0( ! 1 


C

/&! )

 &#B? B*&&&&&!

0&-/ # '( 

( !

<)& 9 !!

# =#

 ! 
#
#

 %2)*  ! %2)*>  &(-/ !( !

!- &( !& (

( 

>#

B@
C

/ &#B? B*&(%2)*B## 9 !!

* *

>#
2 &( !&- !!&(9 !!

?* *
>  0&- /   1   )(       /  &  !

  !

!(

&&&&

!-& 1

 )! &   && ! 1   ) 2!

!

  !(# D &  - 

&( !&( /& 

 &#A

*1& (!  ( 1## #

! ) -  & 0( &&&&!   @ &#B? B* (   !  1& --(!

  !

!(!!

!(/ ! &&) 0&-/ 

*&&&&

2

B

#D&& - !!

&( !&& (7- 1 )&

=E2-)/E

 ) -  & 0( & )     &&&&  

  )! ! -- !    &  &&&&! !  !-&

 .

/ )-! ( /!%2)* !>## !! # =#

!!!
#
#

#' &  1  ( !

!(  1!& ( !-1(  & )! !&&&!# 4 D &  !! ( &    )!

 ! ( 1!

&( !&

&(- ! %-<)&   -  !

 :  ( #
#'& !&()!( 

@ &#>=* (  

  ( 
#

   # >#

># '    1& ( /&  2! @ &#A

* !  (  !  ((-   0&-9& 2 !-- !  0&- /  

 9  !!

* *

> %2)*B  2!@ &#B? B* F
C - (  

  ( 


>#

B#  '

&&&&

 )!(-

 ! !  (-

)!

    

4

&! #') - &0(-&&&& (-

 )! )

&&&&

(-

1- )!-! /)0(& ( (!( //)

!! ((&

()( &9 !)!!?9 > %2)* 1&&&)!

.

'()   ) -  & 0(# ' &! 9 !)!&&

 1&8* 

    
  !"#
!$%&
'(
 "  
)

*&  "

+#
,-" "%"#
.

/"0#12 /
3
/
4
5
,


6
/
*!$7
&+!
-"+-
8"


 "


.!((


$
.+
$0

+ "  (

(! (((

"%%
"%
+(

.(
-"+#
.

  !"
."(
$
%"(+

%"0
+9
.
%%9-
&+!(

.
! (


8"


 "


.!((

$
.+
$0
.

 "  (:

.
;!( 

"%!"


 .
$!%+-
 (+

$
.+
(.!%+
$
(
$0
.
<"+
 .
 " 
&&+

.
38&!


3-
"+

.
( &
/"-( "


"+
%%& 
&&+
.
( &
/"-( "


"+
%%& 
(.!%+
""-

"%!"


 .
%"+
%+
"+
!(.
.
("


.
&&+
38&!


3-
.
"%!"


 .
$!%+-
(.!%+
$
+
"+
.
 .%0

 .
$!%+-
(.!%+
$
"((((+
5= $ $0

.
3--
4

&(
 .
!$%&
'(



.
 "((((
( 
(.!%+
$
9"++
$0
.

&(
 .
!$%&
'(
 "  
.
<"+


.
 "  &&+

.
9


.
3--
4

&(
 .
!$%&
'(
 "  
"%!"


 .
$!%+-
&%!+-#
&(

%"+
(."%%
$
("
"(
.
9(

"&&+
 &.&"%
("& (


+ "%+
( "

(

4
&

( "+"+

"(((( (  
.
!$%&
'(
 "  .
<"+
 .
 " 
(.!%+
- 
9 .
.
9


.
.!(
 .
9
 .
.!(
(
9%%-

%
!

.
.!(
"

 .%0


8&+-
.




? "((((+
$0
.
!$%&
'(
 " 
"+
.
("
(
9 .
.
9
 .
<"+
 .
 " 

.
.!(
(.!%+
$
.+
$0
.

 .
9
 .
.!(
(

9%%-

% !

.
.!(
"

.
"



 (
"((((+
$0
.
!$%&
'(
 " 
"+
.
<"+
 .
 "  &(+(
."

.-
 .
$!%+-
(
(( "%
.
&"(
(.!%+
$
 +

.
( &
>%



&(

!

+
"(
!+

"((((
 "
 
.
.!((
( &
/"-( "


)
%%& 
 .
( & &+
$ .
38&!


3-
( +

.
( &
<"+
;!" 
 .
$

."

38&!


3-
( +

( &
<"+
?!" (
.
8&!


3-
9.
9%%
 ( .
!$%&
'(
 "  #

.
&


9%%
$
+&++
$0
.
.
3-#
!$%&
'(
+ "  


.
( &
>%



(."%%
."
9


"%(
.
&"((
"+
((!
.
"

"(((( &

&"


"'-
 
&(+"


.
"%-
"'
"



%

-
!

(%"
.!((

.
%&"% 0
6%((
.
"%-
"'
"


(
.-.
.
 "((((+
$0
.
!$%&
'(
+ " 
(."%%
$
.

"
 
.
.!(

*+ *
@+"-
*& "0

.



 !"#
!$%&
'(
 "  A
8 ' &( !&   - ) 

!/ !!   -  

/  !) !   &!    !) &  --!   ! !#  !)&&)!

.

'()1& 

-   &&&& !

  0&- /  ()&)     !) -    !1 ( 

 )!!

 0(

.

'()# &&)!!

# =#

 %2)*    !  !!
#
#

%2)*> *

8

= &( !&&((&&

&&&&

!

) - &0(! )&!   ( &(&&&&!

0&-/ #0&-/ &2(

!

 !  &)(

!

 &&&&

  

  (/ )! !

  .

/  &&&& !

 &(/ /&&&& !

 E2-)/ E

) -  & 0(# 9 !) !! ?# > & 1&  E2-)/E

) - &0(& &   

  0&- /   ! &  1 0&-9&!E2-)/E

) -  & 0( 4   &&&&!      &! (-

!&1&(-



)!  &&&& & (/ /   &( &&&& ! 

  E2-)/ E

) - &0(# 9 '

 D 

 - &!! (     !! * =*

  %2)*    !  !! 
#
#

 %2)*>    1 (  &&)!

  0- 

 ! - !& ! ! /)0(

.

'() - / 

-! &&&!!<)&!#

9

>  '( & !   &&&&!

  0&- /   ## 9 !!

* *

> %2)*B   @ &#B? B*()&
C- /&! )

( 


>#

B#    

/

&/  ! !-   1( &!&!&( &!

#    7 +5