← Library
High Court of TripuraRSA/15/2010allowed

Pinki Royand3 ORS v. Mira Malakarroy And 4 ORS

2015-06-09Hon'Ble Mr. Justice S. Talapatra15 pages



 

    

1.

 

   

  

        

  



 !

" 

  

   

 # $ %    " &'    (% 

   $$ 

" 

)*

$  # +* &'    (%    

" 

 

 $  



 

 "% 



 

, % 



 

 %    , 

   

 (

) -

.

 /    

1

          %%   $1 ) "

2!

3  %  $ + 

2!

3 1

 *'   45464, - 

%         7 $ 1  ) "

  3   %%

%%  " $ + 

3  %%

 %   89 : %%    3     3 "  

  %    ,+   %

 " 2;1  <4 44 0      <4,44   %%    %        , 3  "3%

 3+ =+ %      %%  3      %  

 

 %   89 1  %3

   %%   %%  %    %  %3

 > %%3 &??:::

"3 ,

 + 

 + 

  %

  3     + ( ,

 44@   "3   %%    

2



 %

  3  

  3 %  

3 % +$2%% ,

4, (  3 %   %    *   +   %%     %   

 3   

%

3 % 

 8 9 (+ 3 "



 +A

3  33 %    &

 

  +( ,

44@

3 

+ ! %





3 !

 32  "3  33   %

"  %



+    , $$ 

 8,9 (     , 3     "

           %        ,   ! "  3     % 3 "  B=% :     +

 % 

3 !

32 " + "

(   ,    %       +   "

3   3% (   , 3 3     

  %



  <44< 

 +3

%%



  !!%

"  ! %



 ! 

3

869     ! >   1!  (%  3   "  +   *  3  <445 + ! C                

      

        !   "# $  "%    

 

     $  #      

 &  '$  #           !     

        % 

  !  "%  #  '

(    

    #      

(   ') 8@9 (     ,    %      % %%3 56

  3 

1 3>  (%   %3        %



   ++ 3  8<9  ! %3

   %

" + +     (  %%  +       , + (2   4

 445   + 3 +   % *    <444 +   1 3 > !   ! %



"

+ !  % 3C

4

*  

    ( 

 +    "  

     

       "% %   

 

 ,  

#  

      "     (      -.% / % #  & (  #  /(  %  /#  /( %- # /( %   /#(  

   "0  + *   /# /( %"# 

    

%  

 % +   

    #   *   

  #  

    #   #  /(  %           1 #/ 2 3"

4  (   #  /(  %       (  # 567   *    #  #         (  #567       / 8 #

 #  /( %  (  %     *%       "%      96:;;997        3    

(      

< ((    "

       #   = "

$ % "%%  ((  (  >  >0    %(  %(  ?0%( (0%( @(0% (#  "  # 

    

 /#  /(  %    ::95;997     (  %     *     "    "%



    #

  /#  /(  % /         

    

  %       /   ;AB<:         #  /( %     #          %      

              

(    #    :9:9:BCB "% #   & 2 3"

54     /          ( * (     

    /#  ,   

       "           

       "%     

  

   

5

     /#  /(  %    

            - #

       - #

  %       /# /( %1        

    "      ' 

#

 ?%  (("

      "%     /#     



    

     *   "        

     % 8 (  (  %               "% #  /( % "% #   &  /        ( * (     

 

  "%      :797:BAC     

3   >#

  *       "  /# /( %/ (>0   "   # # /( %  "

$ %( > >0   'C

 0 

( (  %  %   &  :

:79   ;'9:;997 2 3"

-4         (     (  ( >  >0        6C    *= D=   E % (         

       *  

  #   %   &     /  :996 (  % %  # /( % # %  #     (  #567 

      " # 

     #  /(  %        

  'C  0        (  >  %2>0 4 * (    

      %  " 

#  

% :BCB"       "%# /( %*

  %"   "%( #      # -%   

     #   

     "    =         

       "  ( @  ;99B @@ :9: ( :; 

        (  " (  

 

6

  

 

 ? 

    #

 % 

    +    (  "% (              

    #   - #

     *%        "  #% # #    %      

   - #

      +;99C@@'A9  ++  " (@       

  

%      

 

 1 :9:9:BCB #  /(  %      "    

 ( 

 



(  (             *   

(     %  (   

 

   ( +   

    "  ( @     (  

(      ( 

(          :; %

  "    +      3 @     (  

     #     

% (      " 

 #      ?

 # 

 

    $ %  

  ?

    (  " $     %  " %   3           

   +  (      # # /( %  = % :BCB    #   "%   

         %((  ( # /( %    ( (   %   0    

     "% %#       0#    #   "   

 

   "

       *    "           ( 

   '  #  /( % = % :BC5

 # /( %= 0 # 

  (

#   6 %    

(  (      %  

   /#  /(  %        



 $      

7

 "%% 



       

"%% 



 -    .#(              

 

   

     %      (  

               

     ? 

      1%    0

       "# 

  # #          

          "%        

 "%   "    

  



$     

   "%%   

 

 

( # %    "  

  ) 859 )!+   + 

  %% 3    %%  3  44

   + +  + %

2

 



  %% 

 " +  A 

""

C 2+4 ,    #           % "%     



         % 

"  "  % F 2++4 ,    #    

       

     

   

      

  F ::: %   "

 $      "  (    

    #      F 

8

849  :  +               3  

 B=% % 3    % 

        %%  *3%

+ 3  *3 +3  

           3 3 )  "    ! % 3  %%3  + ! %

 % !! %



 %=A     3 

  +  % 3% "  3      3   2% 

  !     %%  +   %

  3  44

            % "   %     (

                            %    ,    " 3          %% 2   

 B=% % 3   + %

         3  =        3

 %  + A%%  89 : !"

         3   % +$2%% ,

4," 

3 %  +"3

 "

C

9

:*  *  :' ;99A     @ G# & /  0#            

 2    4     " :    ++   +++     %  

    9'C      "        

(      ' H> >0 2%4I ; *         %   #  

 

 (%     :  6  

    = 2/4    (         ((        3  #    : 6 5*       "%   '  : 4         "% .#(    :7::;99B # "     (% 2:4       

    

        %    

( (  >  >0 2%4  "    6( > >0 2%4##  "%  

 % 

   

    #  "%  &

  G# 0   *;9 ;99B*      .#(     *  @    (

   "%.#(  ;995;9:9 '* 

 

  "    "#@ & #%       : H(  >  >0  2%4I ("%

   (      

                2   #   " "4   "   "%      

       (   # ( (          ( (          "          : (  >  >0 2%4       #  ( (   #  ( 

10

2:4*  *  :' ;99A"      @  G#   &  /     

       "  ( (  %    * ;9   ;99B 

 "%  &

  G# /    "%    "%    (  >  >0 2%4/      "    "   2;4 *           :7::;99B * :' ;99A  

".                          +  ++   +++       ( 

  <    

   % 

   "   "  <" 254 8             " % + ++   +++   " " 23    4#    % @ &=

++ "

&  /   >. =3(  /   ;AB<: @? :55B2"04J:C9'24@? :565 2"04J:C9524 @? :5692"04J:C9'24@? :56: 2"04J:C9:24 @? :56;2"04J:C9;24 @ &=

++ "

&   /   >.  =3(  /  ;AB<;

11

@?  :5;C :;C7 :;CB :;7' :6:; :5B:<;9:5 76; :55; :9CB 2 "04 

#  :'6A :'9A :'9C :'9B :C67 :C7'B77:''6:65C24 @ &=

+++ "

&   /   >.  =3(  /   ;''<:24J;AB<52  4 @? :9792"04J:6;'24 * 5 567  @ &=

 "

&  /   >.  =3(  / ;AB<: @? :55B:565:569:56::56;2"04 

#  :'B7 :C95 :C9' :C9: :C9; 24 *  9'C  89  : %%  3

  + !   %

   +    3

 3 !

3=2  %% %       ,    %      (  %       %%  !    %  33     3+   3 :

 ::  ::: " !   %



 +   %3



  %

   %

   %

+

% 

% 3%   "

  

   !     3+  

12

3 :

:::::

%  !



  %%

  %

 +  % 3%  (  %     ,  33     89  3  

%  %  %%3 

3

3 %      

   +! "  "

 

 (

      +   +   



   !3  8 9  7! + ! 

     3  

  3 %      %%

  %

 ! 3A  +  % 3%  !  %



  " 

      "

                3+   3 C  + "

&   /   >.  =3(  /  ;AB<:@?  :55B24:'B724:565 24 :C95 24 :569 24 :C9' 24 :56: 24 :C9: 24 :56; 24 :C9; 24 :5AC 24 :CC7 24 :5;A 24 :'': 24 :5;7 24 :''9 24 

      

 - (  #9BB 

13

 ++ "

&   /   >.  =3(  /   ;AB<;@?  :5;C24:'6A24:;C7 24 :'9A 24 :;CB 24 :'9C 24 :;7C 24 :'9B 24 :6:; 24 :C76 24 :5B:<;9:524:C7'2476;24B7724 :55; 24 :''6 24 :9CB 24 :65C 24 

           (  # ;:;   +++ "

&   /   >.  =3(  /  ;''<: 24 ;AB<5 2  4 @ ?    :97924 :6;' 24 

       (  #95C  * (  #  + 9BB   ++ ;:;   +++ 95A  567  8,9  (           "%



  ! 3+ 3 :

:::::

 3     ,    %            !2=3 "3  C

14

  "

&   /   >.  =3(  /   ;AB<:@?  :55B24:'B724:565 24 :C95 24 :569 24 :C9' 24 :56: 24:C9:24:56;24:C9;24 * (  #9'C  - "% K   K-   >0    D

K #? ,

E% @ % D>( 869  (%%

%

 

 

+     "     "%





   2  3    

      

+    8@9  1"  3 33   ( *  %  +$2%% ,

4,% 

3  %   

%

3 + 

%!!

3 3  8<9 %%3  ".    

15