Numan Miah v. Inspector Of Schools And ORS
!
" # $$$$$$$##
%% & '
#" " ( #
!
" # ) !#*'
#" "+"
( #
!
" # , # # * " *-" -. +"
!# ( # / 0 !
" "+"
# * " *-" -. +"
!# ( # / $$$$$$$# 1
!.*("
1#
.
* !
/ &34,)4&5 6 #
/ 7 √
8 !. * "
/
.
* ( ("
/# )
" &44.
.
/ &543)4&4 (
* ## &9)44: *!
";/ #
, <* &,&))4&&
=
/
> =? @ A 6
/ " #(B
@
A 6 #
/
= 2
" =
*( "B
= / ( (
*
> =
/ 0
!. * "
/
*
> =8
"
> =
* 5 # "
=2
/ "
2
= /
/ = /
" #
" *('
#
= " /
/ " 4&40&33D
= +E- " *
/.
/ &&9)444 =
" # = +(
"
* " #
* #
D / (
"#
-
"
/ "
=2
(
/. / *F))44 1 "(* *9= / E &G4044
* G
* "
/
* = *
/ &D4&)44: (
* 4&9)44G
* .
( ;/ !
( #
/
' # "* " &44 .
.
/ &&9)444
=
/
/
/ #
: "
/
#(
((
< > "(* " "
#
/
=
" *
C
" 4&&)&33:<*
/ &543)4&4
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
' #+%5$*+ *) !05-$#*2( *+$, #.$ B*2%( <-#&-.,-,-+ 02!%+ +-2$ 2 #! 5,%"% ,% $%20+%)*+%24-4%"%2$*)$,%$%-5,%+.6#&&7%)*+ *2% '%-+ *2&' +*" $,#. %"*+-2!0" #$ #. 5&%-+ $,% $%20+% *) -//*#2$"%2$ #. *2&' *2% '%-+ ,% /&-#2$#))3-//%&&-2$-!"#$$%!$,-$,%6-.-//*#2$%! #2$,%'%-+11;*(-./%+$,%%"*+-2!0",%#. .0//*.%!$*6*+:0/$*11C 0+$,%+5*2$#20-$#*2
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
$,%+%-)$%+2**$,%+ -//*#2$"%2$ &%$$%+ 6-. #..0%! #2 )-8*0+ *) $,% /&-#2$#))3-//%&&-2$ ,% 5*2.$#$0$#*2 -2! )025$#*2.
+%3%5*2!-+' 5,**&. ( 0&%. 1 6-. /07&#.,%! 7' $,% *8$ *) +#/0+- -2! $,-$ +0&%. -+% -//-7&% #2 $,% "-$$%+ *) )025$#*2. *) $,% -2-4#24 *""#$$%%
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
* " * /
( "
* ( " "
/ " *
" " (
*=
*( *
&4 1 .
* ( ("
/ #
#"
*
" = =2 =* / "
2
= #
# =
"+E) "
/,5
# * " / 8=(
*
# =
* / / " = "
= ( ##
(
.
* ("
=
" 6)
*
;
H
6)
"-E
? *"-2#-,4*$/-'.*&*24,%6-.#2.%+8#5% #2$,%*:$-7)$%+$%+"#2-$#*2*),#.F*7,%#. 4%$$#24 2*$,#24 $ $,% $#"% *) 5+%-$#*2 *) $,% *:$-7 $,%+% 6-. 2* -..0+-25% )+*" $,% *8%+2"%2$ $,-$ $,% *8$ 6#&& 4#8% )#2-25#-& -..#.$-25%)*+#$."-2-4%"%2$G < 6)= ( -E
&& "
#
## > ( " *
##
"#
1 ## " * #
"
E
-
-" @ *
(
"-E
A8
&443)44, (
",9)444
/ &&9)444 = * # =
/"
/ .
/
2
=
"
*
" #
I=2
"
" " # " #
'
=""
# =2
2
+( " =
=2# = " "
*= # (
" *("
#
1 +E) =
/ )D43)44, ( = =2
/ # * &333- )444 )444-)44& )44&-)44)
)44)-)44, = ##
#
=2
/ #
E
#-"# = *
" *
/.
" - 6)'
# " = ("/
*#
( "
*#
"
# * -* " *. = &) (
/ " = "
" " " =
( *"
/ H = ""
" # * "
*
""
/*
. = ## "
7