← Library
High Court of TripuraRSA/2/2011dismissed

Anup Kumar Das v. Abhilash Das And 4 ORS

2015-06-24The Hon'Ble Mr. Justice S.C.Das25 pages

THEHIGHCOURTOFTRIPURA AGARTALA          

        



  



        

         

       !  "  



 "  #      $ 

   %       & & '(     )    *    +      

   ,       -  .

* $    $     /"

0

  

  

 #

0   ,$ 

    1111        

        



  



        

         





     ! 

 "



 #      $ 

    %       & & '(     )     *    +      

   ,       -  .

* $    $      /"

0

  

  

 #

0   ,$ 

    1111            

       



  



        

         

      !  $2   "  $2  #      $ 

   



%       & & '(     )     *    +      

   ,       -  .

* $    $     /"

0

  

  

 #

0   ,$ 

    1111         

        



  



        

         

       !)     $$  #      $ 

    %       & & '(     )     *    +      

   ,      



-  .

* $    $     /"

0

  

  

 #

0   ,$ 

    1111             



  



        

         

       ! .



 ) & 



 #      $ 

    %       & & '(     )     *    +      

   ,       -  .

* $    $     /"

0

  

  

 #

0   ,$ 

      1111



         3   :" $   4 

   (   3  :"".

0 &

    (    "$   4 " .5  (   

 *  :!%67%6!/

(& 8* , :24.06.2015 93  *: Yes No √  

 !"#$"   (     (  !66..(!:6;2  *               ((   < 2& 

    *4*  *(    % )     "  $   4  

            "  " .

0 & 5!  " .      5% +  -           5/



+

 56!  %6!!    &      



  **    4*      !-!%%66:  &     8* $  "&    56%  %66: 2    

 8*    4*      %%67%66:

& .(8*8 ($ "& 56;%66=

 56%  %6!!    &  



   **    4*      !-!%%66: &  8*$  "&    56+  %66: 2     

 8*    4*      !/67%66:

& .(8*8 ($ "& 56+%66=

 56+  %6!!     &  

    **    4*      !-!%%66:  &     8* $  "&    56-  %66: 2    

 8*    4*      !%67%66:

& .(8*8 ($ "& 567%66=

 56-  %6!!     &  

    **    4*      !-!%%66:  &     8* $



 "&    56/  %66: 2    

 8* $     4*      %/67%66:  &    .( 8* 8 ( $ "&56-%66=

 567  %6!!     &  

    **    4*      6:6%%6!6  &     8* $  "&    567  %66: 2    

 8* $     4*      !66:%66:  &    .( 8* 8 ( $ "&56/%66= -

56!%6!! * "&56;  %66= 2 2   &    5!    "   >   ?  @A       



2   &   5- >    ?  5-@A     5/ "

0

 2   &    5/ >    ?  5/@A     5%+ -2  &  5!%

+ (&

 56%  %6!!    *  "&  5 6+%66=22 &   5!  

>   ?  @A        



 2   &    5-



>      5-A     5/ "

0

 2   &    5/ > 

    5/A     5% +  - 2  &  5!% + (&

 56+  %6!!    *  "&  5 67%66=22 &   5!

  $2  >    ?  @A           



 2   &    5- >    ?  5-@A     5/ "

0

 2   &    5/ > 

  ?  5/@A    5% +  - 2  &  5!% + (&  

 56-  %6!!    *  "&  5 6-%66=22 &   5! )   >   ?  @A        



 2   &    5- >    ?  5-@A     5/ "

0

 2   &    5/ > 



 ?  5/@A

     5%+ -2  &  5!%  + (& 

 567  %6!!    *  "&  5 6/%66=22 &   5!   .



 >    ?  @A  



     



2   &   5- >    ?  5-@A     5/ "

0

 2   &    5/ >    ?  5/@A    5% +  - 2  &    5! %  +  (& /     & 2     & (*   *&

     &  %66/ 5.. 2     20  $ *  $ 3*            5/ 2  * * & 5..    20   

  ( *     202 (&2< & 2< &

  2     20   &   4    2 2   20   &*

     & 2     2

   2   *  90     2     (  *  ( &   .



    (  *  ( & 0     2  * &  5..         *    20       5/!+!!%66/ *  3  2  .

*  )&

0 



  **    %666  0 0 *5 6!!7!%2  5/020*

 20   3 $ .

5!67B%66/   !-;B!-:B+:/B/67  . 2  *     



    5- 2   2   *(*  *(*   



          (*  2     2  5- / 

&  *2   & 5- *   

  !-;B!-:B+:/B/67.  2  

. 2 *    5%!> B$A%667         8* $     2 < &     8*2(    3 2  & 5/  5- * 2 (* *

  & 2  (2              ** 

* 

  *  

*     2   7  5!-&* 42  *   3 *& 5/  2 *  (* 2  5-  



  2    2 (*         

  2   !7!  .. C0 *        2 

  *     

   3    * *       2   4      &  

     

2     2   +%6  ..    5-    &*        5-  

    *   2       &   =    5/     & * 2    *        * 

( ( 0*3

  * 

&  2 ; .*  * "& 56;%66= 

2*D E





               

     

               

       

    

        





  & *   *     "&  56+  %66=     

  2* D  





        

             

        

         

    

          

    & *   *     "&  567  %66=     

  2* D E 





       !



        

    

  

   

        

          

 

          "    

          

   &"&56-%66=*  *        

  2* D  





        

             

      



 

         

    

          

   &"&56/%66=*  *        

  2* D E 





       !



              

  

           

      #  



  #  

     

   

F :     2           &(  & * 4*       (     

*& !6      "&  56;  %66= 

:;=66B  5- / &

 < &  "&56+%66=   -7%66B     5-  /  & 

     < &  "&  567  %66=      -!=66B     5-

 /  & 

     < &  "&  56-  %66=  "&  56/  %66=    



 -:%66B          5-

/ &

< &    !! **(&4*  5+ -    ( "&     

      !%  )       & 

  5- !+      (      2*      < 2D E $  

  %    %             

         &         % 

      & !- 9 **    " $   4        5/ 2   & *  3

0*   *   *  0       2     2  *

   2 2 *(*      (*     G



  2         !7!  ..  2 * (    *     222 

2

  *   



2 *2  2 2  5- /  *2     

 2      2  

     5/        2    & &*   * *  

       2   

  2 2               2      ( &  * *  *& *  2          2      &    (  (  2** !/     " .

0 &  *    5!         8* (     5 / *    3        & (*         *  2

(* 

     (        8*     * &   

  2  5/ (     8*   *     

   0    *2   (*

       *  )      5/ < &  *



2 5-

   ** 4*  5/    5-= %6!!-;%6!!-:%6!!/6%6!! /!%6!! *   $'

 )*.  

  (    &    * 4*    '

  )* .      &   4* 

 5-=%6!! !:6:%6!%    & ".

0 & *   & 5/   

   &     &    )        (2    2  &  5/ &    5/  5-    *

  &    

&          *   2 *&      & 2   &  2 & 

     (   2  (     2      (*  2   2 4      4*   &  2   &      !7     "  . 5   *   5%-     (



* & 4*  &      !=        *   * .   . .   & <  G

      (      G         < 2  2  *   !;     " $   4       & 2         *

  *    0    (**(  &           *    &   4*    %76;%667  &      8* $      .

 5%!> B$A%667 !:    7   4*      4*(D  '  %        (       )  

   )       

 *        '+ !          

      



  ! %    )   %   % &,+-.-.-/*  

     

    01 2       

  



  

       

% 

  ,         2*    

   $   



         2 ,  %   %    %         !               

 )   , % 

    

      %       )       

*    )     )  3 )   

  , (    % 

  

   

    )  3  



                  %6    =   4*      8*(D E, %      %  

 

   *      

       *    2



       



   %  '   



        % 

 *       ,  

     %   0     

% F %!  &       *   4*  &  4*  &  8** &(&  8*     2*

 *& 5/    2* (*   &   5-   

     2   *   &    &

* (      5/ *  3       

  (    (   0 ( %666 02(2      2    &       (  



        * 

   3  &   5/  5/

 &2    ) *  3       

(2   

   G

 

  2    2 

  "



5 

  

4&2 

         2 2

*&  &   5-         5-                  !7! .. 2    *        2              . (    * 2   3 *& 5/ 2 

& 2* (*   &   5-     (      .  2     .  5-         *

 2

0 &          *  2     2 5/ %%  "

   

       *

* 

 2      

     &2*&* 2      *    (    2    2     4  



  &

     2  (    @  (      <  (  

*        

      (DH !   2  &  %  *  2    (    +    2   *  2 & 4    -    2   2

      2     **   2    2   2 2  2*  /   

*    & &  & %+            2  &   5/ & 2 &  **  3   5-&2 &* *        (  2(  

 2* 3  2  * &   5/   2*  *  2   &   5-  *     8* ( *&  9* 8*  &      <  (    2            *       &  

*     



(2 & 4 2< & 20$3* 5- /

     *    5/ (*    02*      

    ( *3 2 (  *  02 (2   &    5/2( *3    *  3 *&   

   ( 2

&  & *  %-  5-(*  )   22 *&

   *     2    

  2 G

 &   5-    (*           *     5-

/22 (2        2 &  5-       & & 2       *&&2    & 2 2   &   &  (

&  &2 2       (



(  &(2   (2 0&    2  &(



%/ "

         <      *  (  

    *  &  &    (    (        4    *(  4(

 * ?

@2

 

 ( 4*      2*      &           ( &

 $   4      ((  

     *& &     (



  & 0             4(&          4(        0              &         4 &  0*               ?  @ 2              

  ?  @2  

&  *           &      *    @ *     *       

     

  2 *    (  

    (            



   * 2  ( &   ( 

<      

2

&     *2 (  & & 

   <       

   (      0       *   



&  <  & 

&            & *  2   (( ( *     (    (& (    * 2             *   &              (  

 2 (        &      (      

  *&       (   

       



&   *&2 (2 *        *    & (  

    2           2   * 

 

&  (2 (   ( 

 





%7            ( 

 &    8*    2* 3  2  *

(* &   5-  2*    (      *  2     < 2   2

<  2(   2*   3  2  *   (*  2   2*    * 2   

 & & 2     2   &   &  (  (& *    0      *          ( *   4  2 < &  20      2             5/   5-    *  *      &      2    %=   "$   4   

*    2        &  

    5/        *4*   .   &   2  * (2G

      *         .

2   .*&  *    *2  (   2  &   &  . 2



* *

   &   ( &  %;           2  %:   02. *2  & 4*     JUDGE