Pran Krishna Das v. State Of Tripura And 4 ORS
SriPranKrishnaDas,
!
1.TheStateofTripura, # "
$ $
%
" &'
%( ' )!
* 2.TheSecretary, (
&!
%( + " !
' 3.TheSecretaryandCommissioner, (
&!
!
"
" %( ' )!
4.TheDirector, &'
(
&!
' )!
5.TheDeputyDirectorofHorticulture,
!
,,,, + " :- '
( - '
( +
:- %.
$'
' & :16.06.2015
& ( $ & /
0
:28.07.2015 ) +& 1"
: Yes No √ !"#$% !"#$% !"#$% !"#$%& !$
& !$
& !$
& !$ 2
- $
- & "
'
'- %.
$&
2. 3
$ "
%
$ ( & & % 333 "
5 ( 5 (
( &
(
($ ( 6$ & 7879:8;8" 5 % - 1 &
( && ( !1 8<7 & && & 2
!
=
7>7?:8;8 +
& 5 .
" & 2
& '
& (
&!
2 % 5
$ + " 5 5
$ :87;>77@# 5 " * 3.
6
" & >77?79 (
& !
+ " - 7@7<>779# 5 " *
$ " " $ & A ( & 1)% ) . 5 ( " :B#( * $ & ( <:7<>77? ( " & (
& !
"$ & - 7@7<>7795 " & (
&!
5 (5 " " $ 7:7>>779 ! " " ( $ & ($
& " ( &
&5 C
" 6$ & :87>>77B# 5 " *+ " & (
& !
% ) . '
" 5 5
$
" $ & $
$ 5 . >@7 $ $
"" $& 5 4 $ & 5 .
$ & " $
$
" 4. + 5
6
" & $ >7797B + " $ -
:;7@>77B# 5 " *
&$ ( & A & 1)% % 5 . :?#&& *$ &(
$ 5 <:7<>779 ! " " && $ & ( % ) . # *5 A 5
A $
4 $ & 5 "
&6
" &>77B+ " - 7B::>77B# 5 " *
4 "
" & 1)% +C $5 . 5 ( " :?#&& * $ & ( <:7<>77B
5 5 "
& + " & &
A (1"
? & $5 >9::>77B# 5 " * &5("
@5 5 . 1)# *1)%
" && & "
$ &2
!
!
& - 7B::>77B 5 &
A & ( & " % ) . # *
( &" $ & (
(&& " $ &"
:>@
? %
&
< !
"
" & A & ( & " " &
"# * " &( ?> ( &:7? "
" && ( & " A $
&
7>7?:8;85 $ .
1"
@ $
7978>77; # 5 " *
<& &
""
( & " $ &
&
%
5 ( " &
5(5 "
& 5
"
" &
+ " 35
&:7?
& " & ?>
5 $ (
%
5 ( " &
" "
(
$5$ & A " $ "$ & <B77B:77
!
5 $
@ & &
+ " "
" & (5 & !
"
" ! &
&
&
< >9::>77;
?
:;:>>77;# 5 " *5" D!"" # " $% & " #' % () * +!, - + +" .
"/$ 01 2%'0E 5 $ & " 5 "
>:9B 5 =
# *#%*
&
&
" ! &
& $ &
5
" 7:7:>77B " & "
" & '
$
@ ( - 7B7B>778# 5 " * 5 & " 5 " >>;B 4 $ 4 & 7>7<>77B
?
7?7<>778# 5 " *
@ &
&:>1)%
! ) . 5 5
& + " 5 & :> 1)
" && &
? &" 5 : 5 1)# *3&
$" 1)# * $-
" 5 5 . && &-
5
A " & #
"*
"$ &
"
C
5 " " 5 A " &( 4 & " & ( & && $ 4 <:7<>779
& " $ & (
$ - :;7@>77B#* " "
7<7<>77;# 5 " 1
@
$ & $ ( 5
$
- >@7<>7:7# 5 " 1
@ $ 5 ><7@>7:7# * &
&
$ !
"
" "
'
"
" & "
( " $ "
$ $ " C
' "$ &
&!
"
" " &
5
A ( & " ( & " "
"
" & 5 " .
A (
& " $
:;7@>77B # 5 " * 5 && &
5 " :?#&& * $ & (% ) . # *
&
"
$ &
< "" " & 5
"( && $ 5$ & C & !
(
(1 :8B8 5. 1"
$ &
&& (
" 5 $ %
(
( 55 . =
2 5 5 . %
! '
" $ "
( "" " & !!
"
" $ " & "" " & " &
( '
" ( $ &?>
" & !
"
" & 5
"
( & !
(
( 1 :8B8 " & "
" & "" &
" 1 ( " & 5& " $
$ "
&
" " $(
( 5 $ &C"
( B7 " " 5 &
<7 " 5 & "
" 6
"
" 5 & "$
$ %
& (5
"
! & !
"
" "
4 " & && & "" " & $
" 3
$
5 " &
A & % ! ) . $ 1 ) . " &
5 . &
( (
( "
( & 3
" !
"
" &
" $ && % !)1) &
( (
(! & &" & A & ( " & 5 " 5 " A
"
(5 A &
( & (
( 5 (
"
& !
(
( :8B8 6. 3
"
& " 5 % ) . # *
&
( (
( !1 8<7 =
7>7?:8;8 ( & 7879:8;8 # 5 " * +
& " 5 . && &
? 3
"
" " 5 $ %
5
5 &
( (
( 5( (
( 3
"
& % ) . # *5""
( $ + " 5 $ 1 ) . # 5 " *3 & ( " 5 $ % ) . # *
5
5 &
( (
(
5""
( $+ " 3
"
& (
& !
+ " - 7@7<>779 #*
A $ 1 ) . % ) . 5 ( " :B#( *$ & ( <:7<>77?
" & " " :B#( * $ & ( '& 6
" & >7797B + " & (
& !
-
:;7@>77B
- 5
$ 1 ) . % ) . % ) . 5 ( " && $ & ( <:7<>779
A - :;7@>77B ( $ ( 5
.
& & ""
"
- 5 & 5F D$ 3 /134$/51 /1 5678!$98$&63&!4:! +8!&98$&6334$$;8 +- ' 0 0 9896!$+:9 <)=">!'? #@"# +!,#;# ;
', # 4 #" "% %- 0 A-' < "0 %# - "# +!,#"#"
'
# "
"-) 0 3" + % % 0 + %# - ""
-' "
% - "
% 0 %# - "# 0
# #0- % 0 + %# 9% -% # ##- % 0 3" + % @- $ 3 /134$/51 -- B#' 0 "
"- -%#@+ %
'" #> 1 +!,;#;
'
# 0@ ) ''- % )## - - %#
0 0 "
"" 3"+ %- 0@ "
% - # #@" #
0 0 % () # %
# ' - , # - . # .
% 5-#
&"0# - , # ''- - << - 0 <"0%# '%%# #0 - ) "
#-- '? # %#"0- 1!B% '# !"%!# ) -%- )- 0 # '? 1 !B% -" B" # !"% !# ) -%- # - '? /
") 5 + ##1 4 "#
+!,- "
' , #
0
% # )' %- ' + B- -" B" # B- - "
"- !!%#)#-)"
"-- %#) ##' %
% @18" '--" B" % - /1 0"# @!"% !# "-' #@ # 0@ )
- 0# "## '? @1!'? "#
#-"- 0 " #-# 0@ )"
#--'#5 +
## # "@ 0-" B" @1 <)=" % ) @ "
- # 0 ')
# ) @-- #" 0 @ '- 0 '? 0"0 " % #C .
@ "" 09% -%
"## " "## "+!,##0- %0+ % - )@" 0 0"#-##"
-0@"
- & ' 0# " ""
+ %# %- 0 9% -% # #"?' 0 "
-# - "# 0
#
# %# - "# -"- 0 #"0') '? &0# #
- @ 0 #%%# #-# &0+ %#0 B#- # ' " -#" " '#
"# # #) #"0 -# #0' "
" % &0
% 0 #0%-0#0 # # #) ' 0%#@# ##- ) "
"## "# 0 "
"-
# @" "
-# ) ' # '? "
"- -"- # #" % % 0) @-" # <- /<2!
1 ;
%%## *<" 0 @% & D 7. (5 & ( -
& (
" %
7>7?:8;8 " :?#&& * $ &
( %
# *
5
A
"&&
@
?!
4 $
:;:>>7:7# 5 " * 5 "
# *#%* ! 5 " $ " & " & A
" & %
# * - 7B::>77B#
5 " * 5& 5 "
&6
" >77B " 5 .
" & 1)% +C $ ) . 5 " :?#&& * $ & ( <:7<>77B
"
? $ 5 >9::>77B# 5 " * &5( 1)% +C $) . 5 .
? 5 & " 5 : G( & " H ( 5 A "
- :;7@>77B
5 ." "
2 ( "
@
? & 5
( &
A ( $5
5
$ &
@ A ( & " "
- :;7@>77B# 5 " * 6$ ( H "
A " &
$5 "$ # " *
" &
$!
"
" " " "
( & !
(
( :8B8
'
" $ A ( &" " & 3
( &
(
(
" "
( &!
(
( 1 :8B8 ! " 5 ""
$%
# * 5( 5 (
( %
5
5
&
&& &
?
( &&( &
?
&
"
6 $ " 3 &
5 $%
(
(
5
5 &
( (
5
& &
( ( $ " " & 5
"
$ ( 1 !
(
1 :8B86 " 5 $"" %
5 A
" && (5 & - :;7@>77B
@5 A (
" " ' " !
(
( 1 :8B8
@ $ A ( & " " & 1 >> & 1 & :8B8 " 5 (
C $"
( &1
" &
C &1 $ 5
"
(
& ""
$
( " & C & 1 ! " "
$ & C &1 $ A " & 3&
& ( &&
C & $ "
$ $ "
$
$
"
$ " & C &1 ! 5 ( " & '
" & (
&!
( " &
'
" 5 ""
" " 1 & :8B8 &
C &"
( &1 A ( & " . " "5 $
(" 3&
& ( $
C1 5(5
A" 6 & - :;7@>77B
" " :?#&& *$ & ( <:7<>779
5
A
"&&
@
? !"
(%
5 A (5 &-
:;7@>77B
@5
A
" &&
? 8. '
$ " " $ 5 1"
@ A ( & "
"&&
&" $ & (
+ " ( -
:;7@>77B 5 ( & ! C " 5 @?#& $&(* $&
$
9. ) ( (
5 "
" & 5 JUDGE