High Court of TripuraWP(C)/43/2012dismissed

Pratap Sinha v. State Of Tripura And 3 ORS.

2015-12-14Hon'Ble Mr. Justice S. Talapatra10 pages

! "# $# $% $ &'()*(+ ,'-.

"' ( )+ )

!) - )+- )(/

++ "' ++(+ +&0 ++/+/'-

--(( + +-+ -+ + -+ "' 12 .) 3+("' 4 ++'$ (+/ + +) )/+"#51 1/+ ++'$ (+/ + +) )/+ + -+ "' 1

.) 677 (/23+("'

-- & ! "'+#)+($# $% $ &'()*(+ ,'-.

1 ,'-.

(((

-- & * 8'1/+ ! "'+#)+($# $% $ &'()*(+ ,'-.

1 ,'-.

!"#

! $ %$& ' ((

++ + ):+;

& /+ ++( &+ ( ):

;0 &&) + + . )*+, + &+)+ <'&.-+ ), &1&+

'-#./

0# # ! -+ ( ( = +

+ =

0++ = ; .( +)& + ! "#$# $% / ))+ .+& +-+- &'-&+&44 +>'+ =+

&+&+&44 +>'+ += +

&+ &+& 4 +>'+ + = + & &+&+& 4 +>'+ += + ++ ( &('+ + =( /++&+& ' &+ &+-+ ) /++& . / -- . + ' +& -(/ &'/0 +-+- &'-&+&44 +>'+ + = + "

+ =( / .+& /+ . '0)/ '( /+' &+ )'+ /+ )8'

= )+ +=( +:()!? -+((-;+ . // & . +&(/) '

('/ / ( +@'&/) + .

& &+ & &(/) + + )+( ' &+ +/ & +/ 4 + "# / 7 +/ +"# / &+((' &+A

-)) +/ 4 +(& / &+( A ! "

# $

+ ' +& 8' $ 8' 1/+ ('0-+& ( +

)& . + ( / --+& . ((-(/ &'/0/+ .'0)/ '( /+' &+ )'+ /+ )8'

:() !? $ ( 0++ )( +& + & / B( + 0(++& + =( / ) ( - +-+ !(+& +(&+ &+&4 +>'+

+ = +

( ) ( . ' ( -+ &+ &+& 44 +>'+ + = +

=( (('+& + (& &+-+ ) /++& . 0+ .

4 "

( ) ' ( -+ - (+& + =

)& .

+ /+-+ + & ++=

'/'-')+++/ + =( .+ ' 0 + (& &+ &+& 44

+>'+ = +

-;+ ++(+ ( &++ /+ + . &(/) '

= +-+(')+& + + ('0-+& ++(+

44( . '(. ' &( 0@+/ ( ('/ ( &+ ) ')@'(/+ +&+ /+( +'0)/ '( /+ & . = + &++ /+ ((( +/ "

+ &(/) '

&& '0)/ (&+ +(&++(+ &(( + ) &+ &+& 4 +>'+ + = + 0 / - . + ( ) &+ &+& 44 & . +( ( &(/& . + . ' &( / ))+ .+ $ ( 0++ 0(++& (& ) &+&+& 4 + /+-+ = / +))&'+

644 ( ))0+=

+)& + & ++=

' /'-')+++/

, + )+& +) ' &+ #')+ "' + #)+( (/) +

) +/+

& ( +/ #')+( 7 ++'$ (+/ + +) )/+1 +))+'

! &+&+& 4 ++))+ '

&& & - &+ ((+& 0 (/) '

(/ )) ++) (0++ &(-((+& * : +;

)+ +& / ' (+) + . + + ( ('0-+& ++ ( . (( ) /)+( ')@'(/+(&+(+0+ .(;+&0 ++ + )) = . -+ ..+ +&++ /+((( ('/ )++=( . +& *+ + =( (;+& / (( +>- + = +((+( &&'/+ = +((+( ( &++ /+ "

: )+ +&/ ' (+) (('0-+& ++ (0++ ). ) #')+ +"'+#)+((/) +

) +/+

& (+/#')+( 7 = / &+( A & '( ''$ $

) *

% 1 : )+ +&/ ' (+) (+- /))('0-+& +/ &( & 0++ +(+ +& +/ 0 +))+'

((+&+ (' +('0-+& (-+(+ ))+. ( )/+/ )) =(('0-+& /+ . '0)/ '( /+0 ++ += / (' ( 0)+' &++/ 47C + $ "

+ (& /(+ + &+& /8') 0 @'&.-+ & &+ &+& 4 #

4 7 4 ((+&0

+<'&/):.(+

"' ,)(

9 - +(&@'&.-+ & &+ : )+ +&/ ' (+) +++& 0(+ -&+ 0

+ <'&/) :.(+ = / ' ((' &+A & $+& + ,

% .

)

. / % $

) )%0

% ! * &

) % 2 : )+ +& / ' (+) &+ (

= -++/ ( + /++& . (('0-+& +/ -- =( /++& / + 0' + ))+.+& '- ' ;& . +/)- += - +/ )& & 0++ ;+ =0 +)+- D+ &!

+- + & + D+ & !

=++ ;+ : ' *+ ( ('0-+& +( )' &+& 44 & +&0 +3+(,-/

E)).+

--++= ')&( & (

= + &+( )+& ++ +&& / -- '0)/ '( /+ :()!? 47 4 + +=( )+&&+/) &+/) ;& . / )&*+

+ (& +( )' &+& 44 =( &'/+& &+-+ ) 8' +(-+=( / (&++&0 +$ 8' 1/++ /+ // & . : )+ +&/ ' (+) ++ + /++& . ( 0++ +& &- +(

= + /- )/ '

( .+ /+.

/) & . ( + &' ;+ +((

+ + + &+-+ ) /++& . (

')& + .+ -/ ( & . + +@'&/) & . + 9 - +(&+ :

;0 )+ +& &&) (/+.

/))('0-+& ( /+ .+ +))+/ ' + 0) )+ ' &+ +/ + "' + #)+(

/ 7 (0++ / ('+&('/ / (') ( = + + -+ ( 0++++& +)+/ ' ( = +& +(&/ +> (('/

++( ) +-( #')+ + "' + #)+( (/) +

) +/+

& ( +/ #')+( 7 + ( ' + ('0-+& -+&/) + ( /+.

/)) 0(++& + && / ('-+ + )8'

+ +)+ & & -+ :

+ + + +=(+(+&0 + )/+ : ' &+ 47 4 /+ .'0)/ '( /+:

;0 )+ +&

&&) ( / + &+& ++

+ )+& ++(+ 0' + && &/+ + -+ + &++ /+ ((( !' +=(.+ ++( 0)+ ' &++ &

-(+)"

++ + +))+. ) . + ')@'(/+(

+ 0)+ 9 )) :

;0 )+ +& &&) / + &+& ++( - +-'. +& &+( &( ('/ (=+ -+( ' +/ (&+ &()0)+ 0+&(-((+& : )+ +&/ ' (+) ++ + (+)+&

+= &+/( ( + +> / ' -+) 1 ) " % 2

" 0) 3% 2

4.%-%5 + +& 4'6675 8 +"" 86' "

( &+/(

+ ' /+& +)=( +-+ 0/;=.+ ++ & = + ++ +=(+- +& .0++ / /+& /- ) /(+ # " # !) % +

# 1

49 # 5 + +& $&'66:+" '7(8 +8')) +)+ /+ + +(+ / +> "

+ (-+

0(+ ( )0)+ 0+ -&+ +(+/ ; ) 0 ) %+ . + +& 4'66:5 < +"" =<= = / . &+)( = +.')? +('(+ ( + &$ (0++ 0(++& ++ /8')0(+& ('/+ +&+ /+ /- )/(+ + &+) 8'+ ( ' -/)) + )+& 0/; =.+( + ( 0+ +( & + / (+8'+ ) 0+ +( ( + (+-+ = ++ +('(+ ( =( &++&+ & ./- ) /(+ "

+ / -++ '

( +- =++& + ('(+ ( + &( (+ &'+ )) = . + /)+( ') @'(/+ $ ( /(+ 0 + ) &+ &+& 4 ('(+ ( + & (0++ ++&( &'"

+' ( -+ ( / +& =

)& . + /+-+ +)) &'+ 644 =

' /'-')+ ++/ + +/ . + ) / + ((+& +-+ + .

+= 8'+( (

(+ )) / (&+ (

'+= + + ++=( ) /)+( ')@'(/+(('/'+& #')+

#')+( 7+&= #')+ +"'+ #)+((/) +

) +/+

& (+/#')+( 7 & 4= + + ++( +&+ /+ /+ .'0)/ '( /+

&' ;+ / & 0 + ( ( &+ /8') ((+& $ ( + + +/ & + / '(+ 8' + &+) 8'+ =( .+ ' ;+ ( &++ /+ ((( & ('0- +&++ /+(+-+ = ('/+ -+ +=(.+ ' +( + ..+ (&++ /+((( $ +-( #')+

#')+( 7 ( +.

+&+) 8'+ /+ / (( +>- + += +((+(( &'/+& 0 + +(+ . /+ *+ + - / (( +>- + ('/ = +((+(+ +((+. / (&+ ('/ / ((

+>- ( +8'+&!' ++/ & = ++ (0++ )/+& + (+& 0@+/ )) = . -

' / (( +>- + += +((+(&+(+ (+(+ /+ +&+-+ ) /++& . +8'+( (+-+.+&( ++( +&+ /+( +&' ;+ +(( /+ . + '( /+ & (

' (0++ '.+& + +/+ ++&+ /+"

+/8') - + /- ) (+/' ( & '0 ( -+ +)+ /+ (-'/ ( ++>/ ' " %.%- $ %0 .3% + +& 4'6665<+""=:6

0(++&(' &+A !

% $

%>!

&* /

- / -

% !

&* / &* /

% !

* %&

? ?

% <@% +

% + (& ')+ ( ('0@+/ '( &( .'( . / ( $ ( /(+ + = +((+( ( +>- +& + /- ) /(+ -+):& ',+00-3 &, / +00- 3 4 =++ + = +((+( /+& +>- +& &+-+ ) /++& . #- ' & +00- ,@ :

:':

+00- & -0

'& '=+++>- +& +&+-+ ) /++& .0'

(+= +((+(=++ = +((+( +/- ))"

++ + +&+/( " %.% - $ %0 9 .3% / 0+(8'+))+& (/(+ , . +.& ( (+/ + -+ & 0(+ /+ (+-+ + = +

= +

( 0++ +@'&/+& 0 / (( +>- . + = +((+( (

'( /) +& //+ 0@+/ ++=(&+ ) /)+( ')@'(/+3 (/ &'+& +('0-(( : )+ +& / ' (+) ( (

' (

')& + +/+ ++&+ /+G=(=+))(+)+& (+.&$ .0 @'&/)++= + +/ +&+ /+( +-((0)+"

(/ '( 0) '( &+-+ ) /++& . + ( &&

( + + &+ /+ + 00)+( -+ . + +(+ . /+ ( (&&)+& = + &' 00)(+ 0 +&+ /+ + / .+ ( 0 '.

. ( &+) 8'+ /+ 3 + + & /'-+ - ) + -+&/) +>- + 0++ / ))+ .+ + . ' & ( .+ ' + +(( + 8' /+ / --+& +.') +/ . + (& & /'-+ :

+ + + / & //'-( /+( ( &(/) (+& 0 + = +((+( + 8' ('/+ ) 00)(+ /(+ /+ . '( /+ &' ;+ (+3 + ++))+'

(+/+& ++&+ /+ +&0+ & ++ ( + ++( +>+/(+ +++ /+ + & .((+' +&0 0 + 8' /+ & + &(/) '

+ + +) ' /))+& & + /+ 0@+/ ((+&( + 0)+ . +)& (

+ = + ( &(-((+& "

++ ( ))0+ &+( / (( ' 3 :!