Swapan Barman And 17 ORS. v. State Of Tripura And 4 ORS.










   

 



   ! " #$"

 %&   ! "' $(##)
 ' !
 ! &+,-." /'!-"$0$/ "$ & 
&'" 1! " #$23 %"21! "' $(##/
&+#! #!
4"$$#! &+,-." /$#!-"$0$/ "$ & 
&#&-++ ! "  5 -++ ! "' $(##)
02!
 ! &+,-." /'!-"$0$/ "$ &
 1&71! " #$ '71! "' $(##)
02!
 ! &+,-." /'!-"$0$/ "$ & 
2# '71! " #$8 '71! "' $(##)
02!
 ! &+,-." /'!-"$0$/ "$ &
:$$ -++ ! " "2&%& -++ ! "' $(##/%#'"

!
 ! &+,-." /'!-"$0$/ "$ & ;

<+ -++ ! " "2 2 '-++ ! "' $(##)
-2& 02!
 +=! &+,-." /'!-"$0$/ "$ &

 11! " #$$ $21! "' $(##)
 ' !
 ! &+,-." /'!-"$0$/ "$ &


> +&#71! " #$%2 '71! "' $(##!
)
 ! &+,-." /'!-"$0$/ "$ &  "2 &71! " #$  #71! "' $(##)
-2& 0!
 +=! &+,-." /'!-"$0$/ "$ &   $&72! " #$272! "' $(##)
02!
 ! &+,-." /'!-"$0$/ "$ &  7 $&72! " #$272! "' $(##)
02!
 ! &+,-." /'!-"$0$/ "$ &  2 71! " #$%2 '71! "' $(##)
02!
 ! &+,-." /'!-"$0$/ "$ & 6 272! " #$2'72! "' $(##)
02!


 ! &+,-." /'!-"$0$/ "$ &   5 71! " #$8 '71! "' $(##)
02!
 ! &+,-." /'!-"$0$/ "$ & 9 %$&71! " #$ #71! "' $(##)
02!

!  !&+,-." /'! -"$0$/ "$ & ;

 5$-++ ! "  +2&-++ ! "' $(##)
02!
 ! &+,-." /'!-"$0$/ "$ &


 &'2'+ 21+$3! "  '!"' $(## 2  &! %23 &!
4"$$#! &+,-." /'!-"$0$/ "$ & ???????
$$ @("@  2$$ &!  " $'+3$20$3$$2 - $  $A"$!.$  &! 2. $"0$&12+"$! %& 5+ !
 $# #B! &+,-." /'!-"$0$/ "$ &  27  -0$! - $  $ &A"$-.# $
# $$  $'!.$  &! 2. 2"0$
+23 ! 4"$$#!&+,-." /'! -"$0$/ "$ &  24B0&$.-0$! - $  $ &A"$-.# $
# $$  $'!.$  &! 2. 2"0$
+23 ! 4"$$#!&+,-." /'! -"$0$/ "$ & ?

????

"

$"  5$2"2! " 7$3 532"2! "' $(##/ ' ! $#!
"$$#! &+,-." /$#!-"$0$/ "$ &  - 1 2&'2&3! " 
 $& 2&'2&3! "' $(##)
/ ' !  !&+,-." /$#! -"$0$/ "$ & ?

????

.$"

$"









 
 



  
A$2 "  7  1-+!'.0$ 7 % 3!'.0$ A$2"

$" 
 7"

 '2!''#    -$2 )'
 ;

;

 

2$2$ $ 

E"










√




 
 8'7  1-+ $27 % 3!# ' 0& "#

 $2 "" ##"7"

 '2! # ' ''#  .$  '.0$ 

   $2 "

$"

! ' 2 " 2. #' $ $1 "$ "   $2 "

$"   6  '  '"

$

& &" 

$& $" '' $ $2   ' 2 0  '0 + ""'+3$2"0&$!0$ $22$"

  C$ 

" $2$ $2  

 $' " $2 1"   0 $0$&# +"" D
!6   $2 +3$27  -0$! &A"$-.# $
# $$ $'

A-
$'

 
6

 2"

$ !$27  -0$ A-
$'

""&' '.$"  $ 9  ;

2 "''.$"  $'""& '/ !""#$%&'$()*
&+,
$)-$',.
/(+

'0,)'1
/$-,
&%2$),
",+&'(+*
$)



'.
2&-$)3
45&#$/$%&'$()
()
'2,
/(##(0$)3
'+&.,*
/+(6
+,%(3)$7,.

"&**,.
()
'2,
/(##(0$)3
'+&.,*

,%2&)$%

&+",)',+*

#,%'+$%$&)
3,8
,'0,,)
9
'(
:
1,&+*

1,&+*
+,#&;&'$()
/(+
< 
%&).$.&',*
2,
,)3&3,6,)'
0$##
=,
()
"5+,#1
%()'+&%'
=&*$*
>
*?@<8
",+
6()'2
$)$'$&##1
/(+
(),
1,&+
2,
%&).$.&',*
*2(5#.
*5=6$'
'2,$+
&""#$%&'$()*
0$'2
&##
+,#,-&)'
',*'$6()$&#*
'(
'2,
5).,+*$3),.
()
(+
=,/(+,
9:A
2

2. 02## ' $2

 $  $"  $2 "

$"   6  '   $ 2.  $2 F&"$ F&#0$  " #0$' +3 $2 "' '.$"  $'$'9  ;

2$02## 0

$+ B  ' , "0&$ $2 " "

0$  ".0  $2 $0   $2 "

$"   6  '  2$ $!$202## "&" & B # '#$02"

2 " 2. $2

 &$2 $ $2 '.$"  $ '$'   ! 202 " ""&'  ##  &  $2 .0 $ "$" $2A-
$'

 0#&' 
50$&'


 00'  $ $2 "! $2&$ &#"  $2 ".0" "&02 '.  &# 

 $  $"   $2


"+& '$+.#$.$0#"6!> $2 "$$&$ C '   7  -+! # ' 0& "# 

   $2

"2""&+ $$'$2$$2 " 1    $2 A-
 $'

 " $2 1" &#3   0 $0$&# +""

A 

B&,
G0##0$.#3$$2 $ ! $ $ "

" $2$ $2 " "' $2 $"$"  "$ $2 0&$  $  "  " " " $2 702  $"   $2 H" &++ ' A0$3 $  '  2" $"$" "' .&"'$"    $9   7"

   '2! # ' ''#  .$  '.0$

 $2"$$2""&+ $$'$2$$2 '' $ $1 $   $2 "#0$ 0""  ' $23 2. 02## ' $2 '.$"  $ '$'    $ $2 "#0$

 $  $" 2. + ' 2

 $" $ #'' $2" 0'  2&"$2

"+& '$##$2&2  ;

2"0&$'" $ ' 3" $ $

$2$2'.$"  $'$'  !

B&,
G$ $2 $

 " "&02! $2 3  F&"2  $2 '.$"  $'$'  "$ '"50$'


9

2# "+3 ##"$$#'

20 $0$&#

1" ' $ 2.  3  '"+# 2$ $ 0#  &#"$

 &$! ' $#3 $2 #2$ 0

$ + #$ &

$0'

 2 "$$ 2" 0$  "

"+#$3 $ .  ' ' #.#2' $ $2 0#""  1" 2  "

'    $+# ,"$&$ $2&$  +$$ $ 

C$2" $+ ' '+3$2"

$"$2$ $2  1  " $2 I 1"H & ' $2  & A"$ -.# $ )
# $$  $'

 C$ 

"   $2  " $$ " 

B&,
G 0##0$.#3 $ $2 $  $2$ "   $2

". 1 "$20$3 1"" 0 >> > 8. '$$2$"

0$$2 $$!$2 "

$"  '0$' $    "02  $2  $2 "&0"$&#"$2 "  2"' 

 " 0##3 $ $2" +".$ ! $2  & A"$ -.# $ )
# $$

 $'! $2 "

$   " '0$' $ B # $2 "$ "&$+# "02   ' $ $3 $2$ "02  +3   9 2$! $ "$2$"02 $2 ""2##+ 0 "''$2&#"$

;



$2$2"+".$  ''0$ !$2" "$ '"'"

"'  


*E