Bindu Debbarma v. The State Of Tripura And ORS

INTHEHIGHCOURTOFTRIPURA AGARTALA W.P.(C)No.139of2015,W.P.(C)No.146 of 2015, W.P.(C) No.147 of 2015, W.P.(C)No.148of2015,W.P.(C)No.149 of 2015, W.P.(C) No.150 of 2015, W.P.(C)No.151of2015,W.P.(C)No.152 of 2015, W.P.(C) No.153 of 2015, W.P.(C)No.154of2015,W.P.(C)No.155 of 2015, W.P.(C) No.156 of 2015 & W.P.(C)No.157of2015 InW.P.(C)No.139of2015 SriNababrataRakshit,





 





 







 

"
#$$%%&


TheStateofTripura,

3.



TheAddl.Secretary,

TheSeniorResearchOfficer,

SriAnilChandraDas,

2 
 

"

7.



TheHeadmistress,





*

'



+

InW.P.(C)No.146of2015 SmtManikaDatta,

  

' (



  
 
 
  

'

 






" 

TheStateofTripura,



3 3.




TheAddl.Secretary,

TheSeniorResearchOfficer,

SriAnilChandraDas,


 

"










7.



TheHeadmistress,






*

'



+

InW.P.(C)No.147of2015 SriParitoshChandraDas,



8 
 

  







 

"
 
 !

"#$$%%&



4 TheStateofTripura,

3.




TheAddl.Secretary,

TheSeniorResearchOfficer,

SriAnilChandraDas,


 

"










7.



TheHeadmistress,






*

'



+






















5
InW.P.(C)No.148of2015 SmtBinduDebbarma,



1
1 (


(
  

1
9
4
  




"
 
 "

TheStateofTripura,

3.




TheAddl.Secretary,

TheSeniorResearchOfficer,

SriAnilChandraDas,


 










 

6

7.



TheHeadmistress,






*

'



+








































InW.P.(C)No.149of2015 SriSudipBiswas,




 
 
*/
  

+ "




*(


"
 


TheStateofTripura,



7 3.




TheAddl.Secretary,


#$$%%3
TheSeniorResearchOfficer,

SriAnilChandraDas,


 

"










7.



TheHeadmistress,






*

'



+




































  InW.P.(C)No.150of2015 SriUtsaDebbarma,


(
:


(
  
* 
 
/( 

*( 
 -

 
"
 
 "
#$$%%3



8 TheStateofTripura,

3.



TheAddl.Secretary,

TheSeniorResearchOfficer,

SriAnilChandraDas,


 

"










7.



TheHeadmistress,






*

'



+




































9


InW.P.(C)No.151of2015 SriKallolDebbarma,



1


(
  



1 
; 
1
  

 
"
 
 "
#$$%%3

TheStateofTripura,

3.




TheAddl.Secretary,

TheSeniorResearchOfficer,

SriAnilChandraDas,


 

"












10 7.



TheHeadmistress,






*

'



+



































InW.P.(C)No.152of2015 SmtAnweshaChakma,


1


(
  

1

1
*
; 
  

 
"
 
 "
#$$%%3

TheStateofTripura,

3.




TheAddl.Secretary,


#$$%%3


11 TheSeniorResearchOfficer,

SriAnilChandraDas,


 

"










7.



TheHeadmistress,






*

'



+


































InW.P.(C)No.153of2015 SriNilopanDey,





 
 ,
+ "



(
 (



(

<
 
 "
#$$%%&

TheStateofTripura,



12

3.




TheAddl.Secretary,

TheSeniorResearchOfficer,

SriAnilChandraDas,


 

"










7.



TheHeadmistress,






*

'



InW.P.(C)No.154of2015 SriBarunKumarDebbarma,


(  

(
  

,
' 
*

 
-

"
 
 "
#$$%%9


13

TheStateofTripura,

3.




TheAddl.Secretary,

TheSeniorResearchOfficer,

SriAnilChandraDas,


 

"










7.



TheHeadmistress,






*



14

'



+






























W.P.(C)No.155of2015 SriManmohanDebbarma,

4 ( 

(
  
+

(
*
 
*) 

<
 


TheStateofTripura,

3.




TheAddl.Secretary,

TheSeniorResearchOfficer,



15 SriAnilChandraDas,


 

"










7.



TheHeadmistress,






*

'



+





























W.P.(C)No.156of2015 SriRupakDasGupta,




.


  




 
3$








'
<
 
 <
#$$%%&

TheStateofTripura,



16

3.




TheAddl.Secretary,


#$$%%3
TheSeniorResearchOfficer,

SriAnilChandraDas,


 

"










7.



TheHeadmistress,







*

'



+





























W.P.(C)No.157of2015 SriKamaljitDebbarma,



1
 


(
  

 1 
; 
1
 
 




"
 
 <



17 TheStateofTripura,

3.




TheAddl.Secretary,

TheSeniorResearchOfficer,

SriAnilChandraDas,


 

"










7.



TheHeadmistress,






*

'



+































18


























































BEFORE THEHON'BLEMR.JUSTICES.TALAPATRA






+ ,







:18.09.2015

( 
=
 




  


 




: Yes No √ JUDGMENT&ORDER
4 
'
()
*)
 
  
 


  

/ 

'

 
 
  
 ,
'

 
 
  

'
*
 
 
  
 


 "  

'

 
 
  
 


  

2
=
#

[2]


 
/
 

  


,

((
)

( 
( 


 
> 

/

++

 
/
 

57
3&$

?%39
57
3@2

?%39
57
3@#

?%39
57
3@A

?%39
57
3@$

?%39
57
39%

?%39
57
393

?%39
57
39?

?%39
57
39&

?%39
57
39@

?%39
57
399

?%39
57
392

?%39

57
39#

?%39
[3]

  


 
/


* /
4 
 ,

/


.""

 
 (


.""


  
?%%9

  ,



19 .+ ( 

 

  
+
 (

 ,
/ 

 +


  +

 

?#33?%3@
/ 

 
/

 
,


  
 
 ( 


-




  
/ 
(

 B ,
  
(


,

   

+ /


 
 ,

 


-



'
((






  


 B ,
  

?#33?%3@

 > 
  

/
,
?#33?%3@


  "
/ 

 

 +

  

,


,
/

 (

  
,

  
 
 


 0
(


  
+
 

 
 

 ,


 +

+ 
 


 

 
  

?#33?%3@

 "

 ,
  
( 

 "

,

/ 
,
(,
  
( 
(


,
 B ,



 
/

 

/

+

 
C
3# 
!


 (



  
/ 

+ 
,
/
 




,
 
?#33?%3@

 "
/ 
 

 + 


[4]
()
*)
 
  
 


  



(

 

(
 ( 
. 
4
 
/



  +


(
)  
+ 



 
 

Arunangshu Royvs.StateofTripura&Others,
 

2000(3)GLT 

20 446
  

/

 +







 "
/ 


,
 

/ 
+

 ,


.+ ( 
(,

   
D 
 

 




 
 

 /
,

 0
 

B.D.Guptavs.State of Haryana,
 

(1973) 3 SCC 149 / 



 

,
 

 

(,
,

( 


 

 ) +
 

 ( 


  +


 ( 

 
+

 
 
 
 ,

(
 

/

 

 
!


  
  +

Arunangshu Roy vs. StateofTripura&Others

 

                         

         

         

  

 

 

 

  

          

           

 

 

  

     

     E

(
 
+

/

 



. 
4
 

Tapan Majumder vs. State of Tripura and others,  

(2007) 3 GLR 444
-+ 

 





PradipBhaumikvs.StateofTripuraand othersF)

( 

 

%2%&?%3@

57
39$

?%3&G
/

(
 
!







)

( 

Arunangshu Roy vs. State of Tripura & 

21 Others



( 


/

 "


 


 
+
+ 
5; + 7
  
3$A2




/ 
 


 


 
?@



 



(

 "

,

/ 

(,
/
  
(

 +
/ 





 +

/ 




 + 

 +
/
+ 


 +
 

 (
 "



 

 
?@


 
+
+ 
5; + 7
  
3$A2



 
 
* 
 "


 

  



  
C3# 
 

 /

Arunangshu Roy vs. State of Tripura & Others
+

  ( 

 
+


( ,
/ ,

(  
 ,
( 

 "


  
(

 > 



 


(, 
/  


/
 

 +

/ 
 

 + 

 
/ 
 


,
 

  
 

 "


 ,

(  
 ,
!
 
 
+ 


/




  

0
/,
 
  
 



 "

,
 


( 
 


[5] 
 
 
  

,





/ 
 




  ,



ArunangshuRoyvs.StateofTripura&Others, 
( 
 

 "
,

( (

(
 

C395?7"

-D.!

D?%3@

?$33?%3@
 0  "D2




22 /
 


 
!




 


(  
 ,




,E
,
(

  

+ /



( (

(

?$33?%3@
!

 

 


  





(  ( (

(

?$33?%3@



/ 
/



 

 

 


 

> 

( (

(

?$33?%3@

?#33?%3@

 "
/ 
 


  


  
* 

  
/


 ,

  
/  

  

?#33?%3@
    "


 


,
 






  

 + ,

 
 (

  
  

,
 
 

0

,
[6] 
> 

  


,


,

?#33?%3@








 (


 ,
 
!
 
 


 /
&%
,
(
 ,

(  
 ,

  

,


  


 
!

  




,

 


( 
 


 ,



 ,
 


-


-+ 
 

  
+

> 

 ,


 + ,



 ,


 


-

 

+
,
 ,


+ 

 + 


  
 

 

( 
( (

(

?$33?%3@


 
 > 

  

   


23



( 
( (

(

?$33?%3@


>  

  
  +

 
 

 > 


 

 

 


 + 


) 


 

  ,


/
 

/  

4/ + 
 



 






 JUDGE