Dr Manik Saha v. State Of Tripura And ORS

INTHEHIGHCOURTOFTRIPURA
AGARTALA W.P.(C)No.166of2015 Dr.ManikSaha





 
  

 
 

 
 
 

 




!""##$














.........Petitioner -Versus- 1. TheStateofTripura, 
%  
%&

  &
 

( 

)'&
  
*+ '




,

 
-' .


,
- 
-' .
/
%
 
 

 1
!""#$#
2.


Society for Tripura Medical College and Dr. BRAMTeachingHospital, 
%  
%&

- '

-
2

3

 
( 
(
%1+1
3  
 

  

!""$4#



3.TheChiefExecutiveOfficer,
 &




- 

3

 
( 
(
%1+1
3  
 

  

!""$4#
 4. ThePrincipal,

-
2

3

 
( 
 &




- 

3

 
( 
(
 
 


1!""$4#

........Respondents BEFORE THEHON'BLEMR.JUSTICES.TALAPATRA )


:


0
 
+





)

$
: 

- % &

*
)

54
2
6


:




 
+ 

 + &

:23.09.2015

7 '


2
/ 





  
 : Yes No √

[2] JUDGMENT&ORDER(ORAL)
3&
'




,
  
& 


,
  
 



'
'
'


 
, 
#$#85#$$
 

#$$$5#$5




-
2
3

 
( 

&
 



' 

+
 

[2]

 

' &




5




-

( 
 
%&

 &
  &




-
2

3

 
( 



 &

 %  &
 
%&

*+ '


  
,
 +


* 19



  
 

,
 



'


 
 
 

,


 
 


 
,
'


 


 


,
 


 
 

  
 
%&

  
 
#8#:5##8



%


, 



'


 
 
 
3&

  
 
56#85##!
 1;8


,
  

*+ '









 

 
<
 
%

 






'




 

 


 
%
 

  

 
 
/
#=#65##=

,
 





  
%&

5















































































































































[3]



,
3&


    

#:#85#$$

  

+
  
>  


,
%&


- 



-

  
 
%







 
 
( 

 

.  
  
%






'






 


%
 


> &




 
 

 

' 






 

  
    

5##=5#$$

;"


,
 

 


'

'
 
$5#=5#$$

' 




 






'

'
 
4$#45#$5
 

' 




 

 
%&
'
 
#$$$5#$5

,






 


  
  
 % 

,
'

 ?
(i) The elevation should be purely on temporaryandprovisionalbasisforaperiodof 1(one)year. (ii) The contractual remuneration to the elevated post of Associate Professor will be Rs.80,000/E(RupeesEightythousand)onlyper monthwithstandarddeductions,ifany. (iii) If the performance/service of any concerned Faculty/Doctor is found not up to satisfactory (sic), he will be reverted to the originalpostofAssistantProfessorwithoutany further correspondence nor will he be allowed to continue to the elevated post after completionofthestatedprovisionalperiod. [3]

+ 
'

'


4$$#5#$6
 1;$=


,
  

, 
 
















































































































































[4] 
, 
, 




 
, 


& 
, 
#$$$5#$6

'

'
 
#$$$5#$5
<
 
, 

3&
 
'

'
 
#$#45#$6
 1;$"


,
  


 
'

&

 

, 
, 
#$$$5#$4

'


'


#$$$5#$5
%

 


,


'




[4]

(+
' 
%&

 

 

 
 
'

    


-  
@.

+
/ 



 . 

 


 
   






 


   
%&


    
 #8$$5#$6
 1;5#


,
  
@+ 

#=$$5#$6



-  
@.

+
/ 



 &

 

,  
 
, 


 
 


$"$$5#$6
%&
 
    
 1;55


,
  


- '



 &

 

'





'


4$$#5#$6

 



+
 

  
:


 
 
5##8
/    


 
 
 
$8#$5#$8
 1;56


,
  
  


-  
@.

+
/ 
>

 
+ &















































































































































[5] %

+ 
 

 + 


,

-
'


[5]

0
 
  
  
 


 %'


 %
%

 &


,
'&

 



'




 
(


 
 

% 

&
 
  

 

% 

%
% &

 '


+

 
$6


-  


 [6]

 &


 
  
  
 


 
5

6

 %' 
,


  




 


  
 
, 
% 

 

  &
 




 
  
  

 
 
 
  

  
+  &

4##:5##=
'



%


  





%


, 
 &


  
%
(+
  
+ 11 
 
%&
 

 
 
  

 %' 

$5#$5#$$
 

% 


 

 %'
>  
 

'

-
'

'




' 

+ 
%&
-
'

%


 
 
   




 

'















































































































































[6] 
 
   

'
 #$$$5#$5


  

,


 


& 

 


+
&


   
(
,
+ 
 % >

 &



   

 

& 
3
 


 ' ,

  &



  

   
,
  

%


 


+ 11 


+ .&


'

- '



  &
( 

)'&
 
  
*+ 


B
.' ' 



% + '




 
& 
,

  &
@+ 

'




>

 
 +&
, 




  

 '
 +  



,



[7]  
0
 
  
  
 


 
,
 %&
>  

 




  
( + 




&
  
 

 %'
 


 


)

  
   


  
 5##:5#$#

 '  
'

4A

B
& 





   
%
, 

%


 
+ 

 
,


  ,


'

 &

  



'


(, + 
 
  
  














































































































































[7]  


'

%&

'
 
4#$#5#$4
 1;5"


,
 








, 

 

& 
, 
#$$$5#$4

 '

 


'

'
 
#$$$5#$5
/

%



'

4#$#5#$4

 
  
  

 




  
 '  
,
% 
% 



 

 -
'


1"

 
 
 + 
'' 
&
' 

 +   +&
, 




  

 
 '
 +  


 + 
 


' 
, 
,
% '

[8]   '






'
%&

'

'
 4#$#5#$4
,
 &


& 


 


+
&


   
 

 

 , 


 
,    

  

 




' 


 
'



' 

% 

 


%
&
 &



 '



 '

 

+ 





   

- 


&
  

 

,

 



  
 


  &
% &

  


  















































































































































[8] '


'

 

+ &
 


%


 &

,


' ;

&
  &; 

 

  &

, 
% +


 
 
,  &
   

, 

%
, 

 






' 



 

 

<
 


'
,

 
  &
- 1

'

 


#$$$5#$5
+ 
, 

'& 
 
'



 






-  



 

 

+ 


   




, 
 
,
 

  &




'
%&
'


4#$#5#$4
,


& 
(+



 



 

'

  


 
 + ,


%


 
, %&

 
,





,

 , 
%&


  





'




,
  


'1 + 

&

'


' 
(, + 
%

 


 


JUDGE