← Library
High Court of TripuraWP(C)/193/2014disposed of

Binoy Bhusan Debnath v. The State Of Tripura And 4 ORS

2015-03-25The Hon'Ble Mr. Justice S.C.Das9 pages

   

     

      SriBinoyBhushanDebnath, 

       

!

         1.TheStateofTripura, !

" 



# ##

 ! # $ % 

# !

 '

( )%! #!*  + !

   2.TheChairmancumManagingDirector,

!

, "



#!

- , -   + !

 3.TheAdditionalGeneralManagar,



, &

  

 

  

!

 4.TheDeputyGeneralManager,



, &

  

 

  

!

 5.TheDeputyGeneralManager,

$, &

  

 

  

!

  ....          /

!

 :0 - %#1-&

  /

2 :0

- - - /

3 4:0 

1" -&

  

 

 $   :11.03.2015  $& $ ( # 

:25.03.2015 + /$

!

: Yes No √   !"#$%& !"#$%& !"#$%& !"#$%&' "%

' "%

' "%

' "% 

" $    %  !

 -  335 $  



$ 6   !

   

& %  " $

#  #

$ )  3723 %

& 



 

!

"$



  "%$$ $

#)  3723

    2.  #  1 !   #

 $

  

 3. 8  

 0  - %#1 $

  !



- -0

- $

2 

0 

1" $

3 4 4.  !

   

    &

2 9

   #

$ # 377:  $ 

 !

#

 !

$ -

  ,    %    !"

    "

$ 2:4;4:;777 %  " $ <477   !



)

  7;72372:= 

     %  !

> +% !

 

0  

,   &



72273723

23:7!# % 

   1



 ,   &

 



 

% $$%     # 

" #   1 #    $$     

  & 

  (

  %     !



# &#!

"8

  $$ $

#73273723 74273723 74273723  !



 72273723

< 

<



% "#!" 1# *! %"% $

# "$

#7:273723 74273723-$ &  %

  74273723  !

#  !"

74273723= 

  % !

> !



 # !

"  $

 & $  !

# 73273723  74273723     & !!

 % 

 " 

< 1 #

# # 4.1.  6

"!

"%     74233723

 ) <  1 #   !! $

  # $ 6 ?

"  ##

 7;223723 

%   #  %  &%

" " 0#   357;372:= 

     %  !

>  %

$

$

# 

,  &

$$ $!

"  0  ,  &

6 $ 

" 

 

          "   (   % !

337@372: 4.2.  6 



<"

 0#   7473372:  1 #   *!  



A 

$

# "%

$  *! 

!

% 

#6 $!



<%  

! " 

"

%

  

A 

 0#   7473372:  $

3;7@372:% 

% 

"

< %" % $

# "%

 

A

 % 

 $ $

$ 2@753B

 

 

  3;7@372: 

*  

    

     % !

 4.3.  6 $!

$

##

)  3723  "     %    

&  " $

   #

  % $$  $

# )  3723   

  !!

  

 $

" 

 !"  " 8   

# 

 $#

$-

3723 

    %  

! " !

   % ! 

 #

&% "8 

#

!" $ "

# 1    8!

"$

 

!" #

"



 )  3723 

 !

" $

  

#%   #

" " 5. 

 ) 2 

# 

 $$& 

3 4

#(

$$&

   !

#

$  !

 %

% !



%  !

# 

 (

  % 

 #     !

   (  

% 

 #    

 

    

#  8 %

    "  377<

  $

#

 %    $

" 6 

 " 

# 

#"!

%   & !!

 %

$

     &

  (

72273723%   

7@2737238

# "&!!

! $

#7:273723 74273723

  

 

! $

#7:273723 74273723% 1 *! 





! 6 

"



74273723!! $

 $&$

! $

#73273723 74273723  (

 $

#   

 & 

   

#



&!!

!

" $

 $:7"



& 22273723 27273723% #

$ $& $

! 7:273723 74273723  $& $

  !

# 7:273723   74273723 %  $ ! 



# "#  %  



%  $

$

! $

#75273723 27273723 1   "#!  !!

   & !!

% 

 #%

% 1

# #%

"#  6  



 1  ?

##%

  % 1 # !

$

 ?

##%

"!!



# $  ?

"      !!  $

   ?

"  

" 6 

"

 $!

! # 

# &



 !

%   $

#  " %

 !

#

   

"    %    $

#  " $

# 7:273723   2@7@372: %     

 !    

 %  " #  

   

!A

&

 "

#

&!!

 !

$

#8%  & $$  $

#"

 !



   %   

 %#     

"#

 

##

 #   &  

  # 

  $$ !



 $"   & "#

 & "

#

C /

 

&

   %  "   !

 " 

< !

1 % 

$ 



 $

# $$       

 % & "  !



&!!

$!

#

 & &

     

 

 & !!

%  0

277:372< 



0

       

$ !

 

#   :25"

&75273723 2@7@372:% (

$ 6   

   !

 (   $$

 ) 4   !

"   0   , &

 ) 6 $

 337@372: 

# 337@372:  3:75372<

$:75"

%

1

"277"

$ 

 277 "

 BB "

" &   !   # "

$$   ) 37  :274372< 

    1 

  # 1 "

"C " $:27:372<% ! #  

 

"C "%! #6   $

!

 "



# 

A"     

 $

 

  2:22372: 7B23372: 7374372<  2;75372< %  

#"

4

$





# *!

"

  

$

 !

# 7:27372:   3327372:   3<27372:  :772372: 

 

 

     

 !

           "   

 %   "  

# % 

##   !



 

! " !



 &    %  $



A



!

&   !

 

     $ !

"$

 6. 6       !

    

" $

#  #

$ ) 3723 6   &  $

# 



! $    $

  !

# 7:273723  74273723  !

 # !!

 $

 

 &  !!

% 

     ! % !

 ?

"# "!!

 !

 

$ " 

 

$$&  

$!

# "

$$ ! 

"!

"$ ( $$&6 

& $

# !

$3723 $$ $% !

!

%  $

# "

$$ ! #&!!

 

&!!

%   

( 6$  & #

   $

#  " %

  

"  #

 

 #



 

  #



 

! "  

"   

   1 

 

  

 &  6$  !

 %  $ ?

"   $

#  " %

  "  

"

 $

#  !!





" 

 %



 

 

  !

 

 %      " 

! " 

 $

 #



   % 

"+  "%

 !

$%#

!

# %  ! #

 

 & %  &   * !   !

$ % 

 %

  %  !

 $

"  

 $

#  "



A" 

   %   %

#1!"# $ "$

% % %

  1 /

#  ! $ 

      



!

% $

# "

$$ ! !

# & !!

 % #    

#  %  #  $

!



&    A " 



 



  A&!  !

 



 1!  !  $

 !   "%!" $!

  !

 



# !!

 & !!

 $

  $



  $! $

#7:273723 74273723   

 $

 !

 %  !!

 &!!

  $ 7.  %  !

 

   

$ % 

  !

# !!

 & !!

$

  !

# 7:273723   74273723   

 $

! $

% &!!

  $ 

    A! $

$ !



 % :7= ">"

# " $  #1 !"# "    !

 $

  $

#) 3723 !     JUDGE