Golam Mustaffa And 2 ORS. v. Siddique Miah And 3 ORS.

INTHEHIGHCOURTOFTRIPURA AGARTALA CRPNo.80of2012 1.
SriGolamMustaffa,
 

  2.
Smt.KawcharAkhtar,  

    
 
      

       !  " #    $
  % &'

 
  '
  '(&'

 3.
Smt.JanabBibi,   

 (   
   ) %  " #    $
  % 
 &'

 '
 '(&'

 ............Petitioners -Versus- 1.
ShriSiddiqueMiah,
   2.
ShriAbdulHaque, 
   3.
SriAbdulMaleque,
      
 
  )  *  " #    $
  % 
 &'

  '
  '(&'

 4.
Smt.AmenaBibi,  

* +  
   )   " #    $
  % 
 &'

  '
  '( &'

 ............Respondents

 BEFORE THEHON'BLEMR.JUSTICES.TALAPATRA , '  
 : $-.

 ! )    , 
' 
 : .$
 )    $    ) ! :09.04.2015 /

        ' : YES NO √ JUDGMENT&ORDER(ORAL) 0   $- .

 !   
 ''     '  
 
   
  . $
   
 ''   
' 
 [2] &
 
  '     

1    .. +
   !   1 12

2 )   
 
342


  
567&8 12

9 !   56  .  7  .) /

 / $)
   
&'

8 [3]   '  
  '  6  

   3  42

9 '

  &    

  2

4   
' 
 


 (       6 !       :; ..  
.
34

 <!   '

    
  (  
    !      3  42

9 )     &    

  2

4    6   &   
 


'

    '

& 


2

4
    

   
'      !   '
  !





     


   
   
!  ')

 = The result, title of the plaintiffs No.1 is declared overthesuitlanddescribedunderschedule1.Also thetitleoftheplaintiffsaredeclaredoverthesuit landdescribedunderschedule2and3oftheplaint. The possession of the plaintiff No.1 is confirmed over the suit land described under schedule 1 of the plaint. Also possession of the plaintiffs is confirmed over the suit land described under schedule 2 of the plaint. The plaintiffs No.1 and 3 are entitled to recover the khas possession over the suit land described under schedule 3 of the plaintbyevictingthedefendantstherefromandby removal of all obstructions created by the defendants therein. Also the defendants are permanently restrained from interfering the possessionoftheplaintiffsNo.1and3overthesuit landdescribedinschedule1and2. [4] > 
 ''    
       
 


'

        '



 )   
   <    

 



2 3 
 (! !  '
     
>
    ( '' ! 
    '  
 !  <    
 
 )    '



    !  

   '




 )     



2 3 '< 
 !
    !    '



  ' 
  )  
  


 2  '   
   

!    
 &  '
     2 )             )    
 '



   
     


 3 '! )      
   !  )
 

     !    






 [5]   6  
' 
 !
   
 .  
 
          
     
 !

! 6     '
  3    )  '



   


  3   '' 

    '     '

'
  
  6  
 

  !   '
 '  
 "  ' ) ' 
 '  ) ' )           
  

   '



     
 
       
 '

   
'  :     
   ' 2   
 
          +    
  !    
 

 
  >

;

4 3 ?2

    
' 2 # 3 "   


 ) ' 
   !  6      
'
    (    !   
' 2 # 3

 :; ..
 = "Hence, the JDDpetitioners have become joint owners of the decreetal land along with DHDOPs and thus, the decree dated 31.08.2009 is no more executable."  [6]

 .

 !   
 ''      '  


   6    '




  5)    
     ' 2   ' 
'  :     !   < 
   
  !    
 

    
'  2   3 )   
 
 
  )    
   
  !    
'  2 # 3 &  
' 
  2#3 (

  
  '



!)





 
 )    


 3    6  


 .

 !    

 !
     '  
        +
    
' 
 2 3)  

 


 3 [7] ,    
   . $
   
 ''      
' 
 

           6     )   
 &
 
   
        
 

     


'



 
     0   
  
      ! 

 
 '

 ) ! '



 

 


 3'' 

 ')   '
     3   '  
    "     


      
' 2   3 )     '





 
' :)   

    
'  

 
' : 

 ' 
 ) ! 
  0   
   !     
     
'  :     ) !   


 3
  '


 
   !
  
   
' 
 2 3  
    
  
 6  @    


  3
 '   

   
'  
'  :  
'   '        


  3 &  
' 2   3  
'



  





 '
)     )   
 '

'
  ) !  !)   
 '    &  ( 

 :; .. )    +
      6 
  '    )       !   '

          

 
   6  @ [8] <! '

  1 12

2  6  
  = "AquestionwhetherthesaledeedvideNo.ID00718 dated13.06.2011isvoidornotistobedecidedby way of a separate suit and this court has no authority to view that the said sale deed is void untilandunlessitisdecidedbythepropercourt. ThusitappearsthatthecoDsharersAmenaBibisold out undivided shares to J.D. petitioners out of the decreetallandwhichcannotbeascertainedbythis Court being the executing court and without ascertaining the portion of the shares of the J.D. petitioners out of the decreetal land it is not possibletoexecutethedecreedated31.08.2009. [Emphasissupplied] [9] " 


  ( 
 !' !

    
 6  &
  
     

   )  
 6'

 !   6  
 
 
  
   !' '      &       '
     3 
    !  !    !(    )   ! '

   >
  

       6 !

  3    
' 2 #3





   

)  '
  3 
 6  
   
 6


           
' 
  2#3) A 
 B 
' :  !)  '

 
 !  
 

3 ?2

 & !  )         
'  :   )      

  
'  ' )   
   
     !    
' :) 



 ' 
 ! 
 

3 ?2

)  ')
 ::   &
   '' !        
      
  

'  


'
' > '  '  
    )  '



'     
'    
  
    
'  :    
' 2   3     ' 
' 
 2 3
)   )      
 
 ''  
 
  
'

 


 &  
 '     6  '  
 6'


! 
 '

  )        
)    )    !
' 

   6 
   )  JUDGE