Subal Kr. Dey v. The State Of Tripura And ANR
THEHIGHCOURTOFTRIPURA AGARTALA
PETITIONER: ShriSubalKumarDey,
!
"# BYADVOCATES: $ %& '( $ RESPONDENTS: 1.TheStateofTripura, #
) *+ "# , (
" ( #( 2.TheDirectorofInformation,
" ( #(
BYADVOCATES: $&
+ * $
)
* :17.07.2015. + - . :18.08.2015. Yes No √
/ # :
JUDGMENT&ORDER & ' # # 0
#+
123 "#
*
45562
7 !8 '# 3
#
(# 9
6455 #
)
* : 2 3 ;166 45562
7 ! '# 3'
) # ) # (
#
# 0 (
< =
## ( <
=
## +
(
## # # (4
$454 ' (# < =
# # ## ) (
2. :
$ % & '(
)$ #
+ *
)
*+
+ $
)
3.
'
# #)
##
( <
=#
#)
(
& ,
( + # # = ## # (# ( #) #
#
(
#)
) *+ ' +) ## +
,
) # 6>? # ' ( )
#
# + #
' @ < = <&=
< =
@
#
) ; 4156>> # = ## A
A ' @ <&= &; 41566> ' # ' +
#
#
# 2 3;?58666
' A () A
2 3;?4666
<"## = 2 3;B 666
' #
'
) (( B58455> ' )( )
@ ## )
) 4551455
)
;4 2
7 !? ' # 3 # = ## ' @ < ,=' 4?4555
)9 )(
(
4. !
) ;
4554556
"#
*
4556 +
+ (554556 #
4556 0
7 !8 ' # (
' (
*
4556 ) 0
'
)( ( ( ) ) 554556 2
7 !6 ' # 3
)( ( ) '
654556 2
7 !5 ' # 3 &
'
)
'
B45562
7 ! '# 3 '
=
##
;4 )
B4556 ( =
## ) @ <&=
#
( 5. :+ + 2 3 ;166 4556 ) &
* :
&
: ) 9
4551455'
'#
@ ## A
A < = # 4556 *
"
# + ' # ;58 455
) 9 6455 + ' # '
(
"
# 2 +3 ; 1B11!1B145 '
4551455
2 3 ;1664556
6455 + ' ;58455'
# (
# + # ' ' C!
! " #
$%
& ' # ( ) * ' ' ) *
$%+ ' ) * , %
- , * . -(- , -
/ %
.
+ 6.
)
65?454 2
7 !8 ' # 3 #
# = ## A
A(<&= < = #+ , ( # # = ## ' < = ## 7. , +
( A
% AA () A
= ## A
A @ < = "
)
(
0 ) #
(
( ( < =
"
", )
( ( < =
) 485451
,
;4 ) ' 155451
7 !> ' # 3
' ( ) #
< = '
'
C! ,
, 0, 12 31&3 4& 31&4 0 0, . . . 41567 36541 % ' 32829 36519
$% 9575 36795+ 8. + #+ ( (
#
' 155?451
7 !6 ' # 3
(
0
) # ##
;4)' 658451 ( # + ' 123
*
4556 ' #
)
( # = ##
(
# + *+ #(
# ' ( #
A
% A A () A
# ' ( ' (# ## A
A 9. #
# 9 #
) + &
* : # (1988)2GLR(Noc)34, DainikSambad&anr. V.TheStateofTripura2
7 !4 '# 3
( ( *+ ( ) *+ (# (#
+
6
10. &
7 # 9 44454 #
) 2 3;??4552
7 !44 '# 3 #
# + ) 9 ) + 9 ( ( ) +
## # 11. &
+ )
) &
2
< & =3 < =
'
( + A () A B8B15A
A >5>
A
% A 165 ,
## # ' (# ' #
) ) =
##
# =
##
)
(
! 0
# # ) 12.
) +
A
A @ < = )
' #
## A
% A
A () AA
% A
A () A +
)
*+ ) +) # = ## (# ,
)
#
' +
"
*+ ,
"
#(
# 0
#( ,
)
# #+
'
"#
*
4556 123 ##
( # ( ,')
# + ' '
#
) +
#
## ,
(
# )+ *+ #( (
#(
# ' # A
% A A () A () ( # ( # ( # ) #
) 0 ) "
' #
) *+
#( 0 #)
# # ##
(
7 !
"
# (
'# 13. , ( # =
## A
A @ < =
## , ( # ' < = A () A
A
% A
7 !> '# ,
;4 155451 # )
'
#
# ( 5B5?454151451A
% A 15>8 (
# A () A 4B6B? ( #
A
A ?>8> ( # , #
' ) 0 < =
14. "9
#!4? + C! 39 $ &7 /
, : 3118 &4 # 0, ;,' % , , '
0, ;' ' :
, (;<= ) ) ( )+ (;0; (>(+ '
' '
* ' + 15. , +
,
" #( 7 #+
123
*
4556 )
# ( A () A
A
% A
+ *+ #( ( 0 #)
( #"
#
) ) #
'
# ' 9
'
123 "#
*
4556 + 0 16.
$ & '(
)( # ' + ) 9 44454 2 3 ;?? 455
7 !44 '# 3) + 9
## 9
# ) ( 17.
+ * )( '# # + ) 9
#
' #
)
( 9 '#
7 !44 9 2 3;?? 455 ## ' # 123
*
4556 '
)
) #
' ' )
- '# , #! 9 C! &6 '
, >
- ,
* ( &6 .
;
$
, , '
, ' , '
*'
? , ;
,
( &6 , ( &8 &# .
' *'
)* ' ' *' ',
' +
, #45 9
9 ' ' ) + C! 31
? '
#
' ,' -(- :
&887 36 && 3111
-
,
, ,
% #
@ *
, '
' ' , &A
#
, - ,
, ,
, ;
' @
, &A
# '41 31&6, + 18. , +
' ) #
) ) #
'#
) +
' '#
#
' #
+
123 )
'
)
' '# 19.
123 "#
*
4556
'
C! &4#DisplayAdvertisement: # 0
,
;,' ' : % , , '
, : ;.(
,
+ 20. #!4 ' #
D "21.
&4 # ( : 3118, ' *' '
'
% *'
,
' &4 # '
( &6 &8 411?( .
;
'
.558B57 &4 #
( : 3118 ' '* ". 21.
+ #46
' #!4 ' # ' '
( ! "29. $ 3& / ' : 3118 + 22. ( #
123 "#
*
4556 )
++ 6
155!
(# #
#
*
4556 23.
$ & '( 123 ++ 0
+
) #' ( (
+ * = ##
'
) ( ) (
) #' ## ( # !
7 7 + #' + ( < = ## + ' '
#
) + # #
#
#
6
, ## # )
) # ) )
## (
+
,
0 # '
) ) 24. + &
* : DainikSambad&anr.V.StateofTripura, # (1988)2GLR(Noc)342
7 !44 '# 3
( ( *+ ( ) *+ '(# (#
') ++
62323
( + ) + '
'
C!
?
'
( &6 .
;
, ( &9
&2 ' ,
,
;
' '
' ,
' *
'
,
'
,
) , '
' , &893# ; < 251 . % ,
' ' ' ?, % - , ;
, @
', %
' % ,
:
, ' : ,
, ' (&6
&8 &# # .
;
,
,
@
( &8 &# #
' ( ' :
@
, ' + CD
:
, ' : ,
, ' (&6
&8 &# # .
;
' @ '
' $ . ' C
@ , '
; ,
@
: ' ,
,
, )@ @ , ' ' ' ' ' . @ , '
, '
. , '
, ' % ' ' : , , : ' : , , '
, '
%
, + 25.
)
123 "#
*
4556 ( # ' )
) *+ ,
" #( # + ' '
#
) +
# ## 7 + #' 7
( #
( )'
( #
( #+ (
)) #' # # ' + # #(
#
( ( #+ '
( 0
( )
#
# ) ( ) *+ 7# #
#( ) # )
#
+ ' ) #
, ( 123
*
4556
#
#( 7 9 '
#
) +
# "
++
6
26.
+ *
##
)( # ' ##
( #
Budhan Choudhury & ors. V. State of Bihar, # AIR 1955 SC 191 : ) + # 7 #!? - '
'
C! 9
( &6
.
' . ' ? -.
< D ;
- (; &89& . 6& (#E ? - > ' C 0 >- (; &89& . 4&5 >#F ?
- /> ( ,( %-(;&893 . 79- .#F ?- ,
- (; &893 . &34 #E -<
, > '-(;&893 .349 )#
?-G H ' - (; &894 . &92 C#
?- ''
' - (; &894 . 357 :# ;
( *
; , , ' , ( &6 ' ' '
;
, ' ,
'
# '
'
,
#
' ' ' *
'
'F ' % /
' @ ', '
' (
; , ' ' . (&6
'' ,' ' , ,
, ' , . +
) #
, ( #
)
1BB
1 , ' ) 15 $ '
) )
#
) : '-
&
+ '
'
-
-
+ ' (#
) )
( 0 ) '
#
( (
0
0 #
"
#
0 : < =
' ##
*+ 0
( ) ( # =
## (
'
27.
7 # *
(
'
(
) ( ) *+ ,
" #( '
) # (
# 123
6
,' ) (
)9 #
# '
' )
( 7#
'
'
) ' #
( (
( ( 7 '
(
#
) + *+ "
( 7#
#
) )
) # #) 2 ,681 5B3 28.
+ * ( The State of Jammu & Kashmir V. TrilokiNathKhosa&ors., # AIR1974SC1.& 9 ,
+ 9 ## 29.
+ *+
#(
# '
# ( A
% A A () A
# )
) 0 ) ' #
) "
123 #
)
) # # #
#( ( 12)3 # ) #
)
)
,
" #( #(
) ( #
)
) *+ ,
"
#( #
#( #
9
(
)
# 30. #!1
+
CD 4
; 4 I(J 0,
% '
$%
( ( > . (>. % ' 27241
% 65165
6&481 ; ,
'
, '
" ' , * ( ( > . K ' 31&6 4 0,
@
% (
@?3436
39 + 31.
7 !41
&
# A () A
7 !4
&
# A
A
7 !4?
&
# A
% A 32.
)+
#
) &
A () A
A
A
A
% A
+ * (
A
% A ' '
A
A
' '
'
A () A ( A
A
'
# = ##
)
( '
'
) #+ ( ) *+ # # #( 33. , + '
( )+ 123 "#
*
4556 ++
6
+
)
)
( ) ) +
( ( "#
*
4556
123 '
)
# 0
## ( (
) ' ( < () =
<
= 34. ' #
) '
JUDGE