Smt.Kuheli Sinha v. Debashish Sinha And ANR

 

 

 

  

 

 



 

 

 



  !   "# $   

 #% &

!

"#$ $

% 

 '!  (

   !   "# $ 
!

#$ $

 



   !   "# $   ) $ & ' $ ()  ) *+() )) ,  ) ")) 



)*+() ,  )"  * !! +  , -.' ."/  (0 " * , ( +  . 1 / 2 '(0 " 

 

(!0-

('(3(   

  + + + -
.   
.  /$  , ")* 0 ")  1
 
4

$ ''

!!("

 5("
677(1" 
6

*'!-



 


  "
6 9   ("(    (' ( (" (( : 

 

( - !( ;( *'!-  ! "  $<0 "4:= 6   0 ( !( "

 !   , - .'

  !! ( !( "

 !   . 1

   
 $ 1     !



2 , (  
     <  ' (     4   !1  '

 -      ( " 
>

  5("
677 

!(;(*'!-  !  $ ?(

!

 ' 1  !!     (

(!- ( "!- 5 -(  !!  
 <  ' (    (  
4   

 (0 " ( !

 -( 

 <  ' (    ( 

4   (0 "   !!    (  
  !  1  (  (!- 1 

     3

 ( ( "'

      1

!'@( 1  
 ! 
7
66A 5(   (   - !0( ( "

 (   

(



 

> ( 1    ''

!  ' 

  (    '   (   1   1 1 ?  "-"-( 0

$(-01

'!-  ( -

.  
!!( -   

  ' ' 2("1 "

'!!(   1 ("!(  !   

    - 9  1   

(   ( "     

7  

?  1  
1"!(  "5 '

##!1 !

 1  !0 1 ' "  ( 

 1-    (

  ##!1   -

7 "(-

1 1  !! !0

   
"'  

     " !

 1 1

 ( (-B

(-1  (  


"

 0 "C"$ (



(( - 0 ' !! "  ,

 

( 

'  "

# 0

"- ( ((   '? 
1

  (

 '" 
1 

  

    ! 

'"

# 0

"- 1 ( 

( !

((



 2

9 "!(  !( ('(8!"

!  ! ."





 (  
    !'!- ( (  ! A 
 1  "!( 1  (  ! ( (!0

  

  $   "

# 0

"- 1 "

( -

 "-( 
 1  '(  (

  ( "

#

0

"-$ "1 '(   -  (  
 $     1

0 

' 1  1     0  "'  ! 

(

 ( 10-'

 

1 "  ( !'

 0- (- 0   ( 

 1 !(  

 !- "(  1  
(  ( 

   $ 0!!  1 !

 "

'!

" ' 'B

  


 (  $  !

0( 
 "' # 0    "!(   "

  (  ( 1      ( "  'B

  
 1 

  


"' 0- '"   ( ( '

0 1     "' 0- '" "!        (  "

!(    1 !-



 3

7 !!!1   '

(  "

!(   '?  

(  !!  " 

 1    ' '      (   "

'   !   0 ((   "

?

(

' !-(1 "

 !!" ! 

1  (  
 ( 

 

 9=7 -    !    "

!(   ("   (  !0  (!-1

( ((  !- B!"

 1

3(-  0 1    "'       

(   (

 1  !

"?(  '  ( (  

? -    "? (

 (

(

  ( "

' ' 

 $ !

"' ? 1  '

  (  

 ( "

'    

" ( -

( '   "

' '  

  

  !

 

'(     1 

-(    !"

 1 ?  

  (  ?-  ( ( "

' 

    (1   "!(  ' $  (  
 (   ( 1

 0"!( -'

"-"!

!

 (1  

' -      D0  ((   ( !  0! !?   " 1 



 .

A      (   "

  "

'

     $ 0!!

0( !!  "0

   (  ( - "' 0-  -(  (

 'B !

"!- $  
 1  0- '" !" 

0-

(  ( " 

(?

(  E  $ (  
!

(  1 !( ! !

"'! "    '   1 !( ?!! ' -



(36 6 
(  "?    1 F( E      ( (

" 0   ( 0 ' 

    $  !

!!( 
" ( "

(  %

'



(!

(

' (1

 !' 1#'!((

  



(   !

  '

  
  0!! ?E1 !

!( 

 6(

! 1 ( ( (0      -    E 

 -$ 

 (!0  

 E  0 (  "

'


 $   !

  (  "(    !"    ! 

 1 0( $  !!( ! 1 ( - (  
 (   1    

!   !0 1 



 4

: (#1  $ '!  1 ' (  
 1  ? (  1    ""

  5 !

 -(

 " (-

  "!( 5

(   1    "

!!  "

0"  ! 

(0 "50"

( ((! "0

 
(!

"!-B" (

'5

-(

(0 " 4 , 
 "

 (   - ! 1 ' 

"

(    

!(   '? !

 !!    

   !!(     ( ' !1-  B"(?!"

 !"   ( "?  C!

 "   '   "

' !"

 ! 1 -

("('!

 

1" '!-"1 (  !

!!(  

(  ( '?"

''  "  (- ( 

  '!-    !

  1       '!-

    ( 
    "

(  "

# 0

"- 1       

  ' 

"-    1   2 0 '!

- $

  '(  1  
 ''





"-

  1   *   

  "

# 0

"- !



@( "

!!", > !?  '! ' B1



 -

'

-1!!" '"

 

!  " "

!( 

('

-  !

1 '!-''

 ('!(- "!    (    ((   ? - "

  !

!!("

# 0

"-1        1  -

       

 1   

  ( "

# 0

"-$  (  !- !

 0    (   !0 1    " !!-   

( ( 1  $   "' 

01  !( '

-  ' E   (   !

-

 !!" !  1

1 "

?(!

( 1    

!  ( (   F ?E 

 6 (  !!    '( '! (   !!( ?("!( "("

( ( ( !01'

 ('

(

"

"

'3
6 6

 6# '    (   '!- ''

 "?(C!1 
(

!((( 0 1"!(  '   ?1- !( ' (

!

!

 0 - '

'"  ( !01"!(!



 

6  $!! '( - 1 !

( 

 -(

( '

!

  - ,

 !

!(  1 ' (-!!!! "!(

!!

'  "

# 0

"- (  (   (   !!" !  1  
 (   !!  '(   ' 1 !! !

 5   !

(   1     !! "C( 1  
(  !

!-'!"(    $ ! 8  (   !(

    '(1 

 '!-G


  ' !H


  !( ("

(0 "H 

 "



     B'( '

!

 
(!

B'(7< 04'

1

 '!-     ! !I >   ? I

9  !  I 7   ;

- .  (

A( (! !C
   , 
   !!  !

B'(  !

   
 ( !

 B'( 1  '

 1

  '!-   ' '?  ( > ''



 



   $ ! 8  "

(  0(" "

( ("((

  

   0 

    ( ("( (

!

 '    (

(!-

   0(  1 # ( !(    !
2   $ 

(

!

'   (

 (!-

   
 1

(!-''

!!1 

 "!  (

 (0 " (   ( (  "

 ! B! "

 1  '( 

( 



 B(

"

' " 
><
4

  5(  "  "  ##- '

!' ( 1 

    "

''"'

   " '-     ( -

( 1  (

!0( - ("

(0 "  ( -G <4     

!' 

  ' ( 0 !- B! "

  1 - 

   I)))))
3   " 

 (!- '-    !1- 0! !. "  ("0("

(!- D0  

"

 (" 

 (!-  



 


 ""(!""'

!0("!!" '!!-  B"( '-  0  " $ !- ! !     ""'

"  '  "  !(!(((('



 !(  ' "

"! 
.   ("

 !, -.' '(     (   7 ( A   0 (  - (    
 (   "

' '  

      " " !(   

" (   ( ' " !

( - 

1

     0("

 

 1

  "  "( 1 !



 ' " (  ! 8  

!(   "  5   !

'(   0(" (("( 

  !!( ' !(

 6(

!!   1  (0 (     !0 1   (#1  (    E  !      ! (   !! "

?(

- (    ( - 0(" $ 1

 B'( - !! 1 "?1

 (-'( ( '
4   3 (!("

 !. 1 (1

 B'( - !! (( 1

  0   '

- 1  ( (0>'



 (# 1 "

B' ('( ? !!



 



1



 (-0 '-1 

 1

  J( " ""'

"      

!! (

!00("

  "

(!  !

   
 1  ( 

-   0'"!

!-  0("

"

( 
  !

!-(  "  1    !((      5 "!!-

( (-

(

 (  "!

 - "! !  5 " '    

 ?"

B' 5 !

(   

 (  

'( '    ( 

 ( "

'    

"((  'B 1   1  ( 1  0 1 - "! !  DB" (!        "

B'



  

  (

 (  

(     

     *  !  >=9 -   (  

     ( ' ! 'B5

('

  =! '

?'

 "  

 "

(   ? (   (

  

''    "

(  "   (  - ( !!" !  ( - (   

 



 


> !(!- !

!

"!-3  !1 !(  

      '

 '   (  "!(  "

! ( 1 !( "

' "?  

 5

1'

!0 '

?'

"'

DB" (!        "

B'  ( "(

00("

 
  

>    (

 ( 

 !  >=9 -   (          'B 1 !    0- ' ' "  !-    (    (  ( ! 

 

0" 

 (   1   (    ( !

     1  "!( 3   1 (       "

'    

     

" ' 1 

=
3E"!

"?1  "'   '   

'

 E  "!!  '-

"" 

( (   ?- 

 "!( 1-(!

( '   "

'    '  

!!

1 (1  

 1 !    

"

    ''  

(  1       !(?-   ( !1 !(

(



'1 !(  (

' -  !((

"  

'' -"

 $- (  "

  !!" !    



 
2

9 1

 "

!(!@  !- (  !

 ( (1 !



' (  !

 ( 'B 1 "    0- ' ( 1 '1 0"!

"!!(!- ! DB" (!      '!   "

 B'    ( "(  

0 '

  1

  

9    (

 (   (  52 @  1 (     1 "-(



(   

  . '- "" 

(1

 '!-' !

  

!

1'  

'  '' 

(



' (

'((

 1  "!

(  '  ( 5 (  0 "  '  ( 

'D0 (-

(



'"

' 

 ' - =!(' (   1 1 !-?<!

"!!-"!!(F'"E4 * '" '( '



' 1"

'  ' 

'!!!" 9 

(-< ( 4!1- 'B(1"  !

"!-

''1"  "

'

 1 * ''B("0  -(!!"! 1" 



 
3

7

 "

B' !

B"(!(

    !

 
  

7 (   1 ?(   

 

 = K-   '( 0(

 -( 



A=:'

 '    1 !(  (  ( ! 

 

0" 

 (   1  !  !

 1 !( (11 "!( ' 

(        "

'   

   (   

     1 ! 

  

"

    $- ( - "! !  $-

''  1 !( ?  (

 !

"?(  '  (

  

  C ( !    !0 " !!" !  1        ( $  ( 

 "  -   ! 

(!   $

00("

 1

 !

 

 ?"

B'    

A    (

 (  ( ;- ( * -    "(  1 ?   

      (- !

     '

!( 1 ?

     1     (  1 ( -   

 "- ( 

!= "

  

   '  



 
.

A  (  (  ( ! (1 !("

'    0-0!

:= (- 5 1  (  (!

11 "!(  ' 1 (   0  E  !'

0-(-( 'B11

  0-'1-!'

1 !(-- ( (  3(-


+'

1 

'



  "

!!"(? 1

 '    

(

 (    ( 1

      "

'' B! "

  1 "  $- 1 (

(  ' (

'-'(  ' ( '  - 

   1 ! ( !(

 1    "

! 5 

'(  '   

 

 (  5

 ( ( 
7= (-

  1 ?

   "

 B'    0(" !

    ? 2   $0("

 
 A"!!-0!

   
 1  !0  (!- 1 


  
 !

(  (> ('

$- '!- (  !

!! 1 '((  ( ?!"

 !(" 0("(("( -



 
4

: (    ( "(  !!

 (!- '(

!

    1"    0( -  0("

((1

 3   $ " "!(   

(   (    "

' ' 

 (1!

(!(

  

    (   

'(   

!1-  ( "

'    

"(-!

(' ' - "! !  $  !(      -

(!-( "   0( -((" 0(" (    ( "(  ( - B'-1

 1 (  ( - "!!  .   8

 '! ""'

" !

 !(  "

(( $   !!(  

 0 (   "   ( 

(

'"

# 0

"-, 
   1 '   : "!!- ('( 

'

  "

# 0

"-  :  
 ( G


 







 

 
 

 











 


 





 !
 















 !


 



 
-

 
" #





 



 





$




  
 
 
 





%
 

 
 

 

 
 




&

 

 #

'




!


 
 




 


 #

' 
( )***** 
+(
 
'

,





 
-





$





.







 
 


 


 #




 











  




 

 


 


 

 #
/





 
 


 




 

0+,

 
 

 0
 
 
.

 
  1


   

    1

' "

'!!- ((  " 

   0 

" 

 (

!

'  8 # 0

"- (  

'

 8 # 0

"-  !

 ( 

    0(  



(  '! " ,

 !

(    1 ' ( "C"1 
1 
 ('(  "   1  

(

  8 # 0

"- ( 

1   "-

  8 # 0

"- $ " "!!-     "

      (

'(  8 # 0

"- (  - "' "!

   "  ( 1!  " "!



   

"

     
 !0(  (!  !  1 

 $ !!



 


6 (!- 

   "!!-   ! ( (  !8 !-!( 
1 !0 (!-(  ( ("((

!

 ' 4    (   

  !!       ('(("

(0 "

( -!8  -   $!

 ( ( '

(   

   1"

   ( "?8"

( !

1"

-

 ('  , ")) ,  )