High Court of TripuraWP(C)/361/2012dismissed

Dharambir Payaing v. Union Of India And ORS

2015-11-23Hon'Ble Mr. Justice S. Talapatra10 pages

!"#

$%#

&'()* $ +% % %

, - ## '.%#/% 0+

/% 1111111

23!2 0 "4+

! 6 "4+

# * 8

#"!!

%. "! ##

49:;< < &

& +# '

/% +49:;: =

/% &

& +# '

/% +49:;: $ ,

, +,% " &

& +# '

/% +49:;: &';;' 11111 !

> +6

- ! $

",%+

? + 8<8 @ "

" /

! " ! 7

7 7 √

## !!

! % ## #+88

/% + + %+

A>4-

& A #/% " ;88; 8; ! ##

' + %+ 8 4 $88 +

#! / + " 7 +

7 " <=8 7 ## / %

+ !

# "

! +

+ #

%+ 8: 88< 8; +

+ ;88 !/!

## !7

8 "

! #

7 ## + !

#/%

+ ! + ! !

%! 7 ! "

## ## + 7

A #/% 5!/

& 5!/

/% ' "

7 !

5!/

7 "

+ &

5!/

#D(&E >#.

@ ! $ # +

" 888; + + + 88 5 7 ! +

+ " /#!

+ +

4 #! + !/% +6 !

+ / # " !

+ &

+ 5!/

# D( &

+E >#.

! / <88; + !/

# )% *$

+ 6 +% "!

% ! ! !%""

" /#!

+ +

7 / "% "# " .

+ + !/#

* +6

7 / # ! <

7 !!% +

)% * 7

7 " <=8 "

# %+D4 $E

!!% + &

& + #

+ 7

! 88 88 &

& # 7 ! !%""

" /

" ! "/!

## !! +

# %+ +7 !%""

% " !

' 88

# !!

%+ +%

. !

##7

+ + +

7 !

+ #

+ ;88 )% * 7

)

%+ 9

! "

# # $ $

%& #'()*++,-.*/-'0'0/1%2(34%./ /-2/'-0&')56'(/1*/6'(7%)%-08*,-9*/%9'(/ 5%9-.*,,6 3*2%9 '0 /1% '+-0-'0 '& /1% +%.-*,-2/ '& '55*09 '2+-/*, :',;*/* *&/%) * /1')'(<1 -08%2/-<*/-'0 '& 6'() *-,5%0/ '& ## :# 7%& '8 = /' %. = *09 *..')9-0<,6 6'( 7%)% -22(%9 7-/1 * !-2.1*)<% %)/-&-.*/%"36/1%'5+%/%0/*(/1')-/6 1% %>-2/-0< )(,%2 9' 0'/ 1*8% *06 +)'8-2-'0 &') )%-02/*/%5%0/ '& +%)2'00%, 71' 1*8% 3%%0 9-2.1*)<%9 &)'5 2%)8-.% -0 *..')9*0.% 7-/1 /1% %2/*3,-21%9 +)'.%9()%2

9?@-,,%<-3,% *0%)4%% *4') 94(/*0/ &')'55*09*0/ = ! "

% ""

%!# #

% ""

! ##

% +% !"

$% #

# ! ## !

! !/ 6

9 !1%)%./7*22(&&%)-0<7-/1-,*/%)*, ',6.62/-.:-90%6 -2%*2% *09 /1% &(0./-'0 '& 1-2 ,%&/ ;-90%6 7*2 .'5+)'5-2%9*09/1%-09-8-9(*,7*29%%5%9/'3%(0&-/ &') 2/)%22&(, 5-,-/*)6 9(/-%2 1% )%./ 7*2 *,2' 8*..-0*/%9 7-/1 /1)%% 9'%2 '& %+*/-/-2 &/%) 9(% %>*5-0*/-'0 /1% -09-8-9(*, 7*2 .*/%<')-A%9 B *09 7*2 )%.'55%09%9 /' 3% -08*,-9*/%9 '(/ '& 2%)8-.% 36

%0-') 98-2') -0 %9-.-0% %+1)','<6 $ :',;*/*"

7 !

+ 7 ! + % " !

# %+

# ## ##

# + !7 % "%+

4 !

#$ +7 !!

% + <88D

)% * % ""

"%# )

7 ! "%+ G /#

# ? /

+ " "% !

" .

7 #!H

+ <8 !!% + !

# $

# )% *8 % ""

!!% + ;=8

7%#+ + 7 " <=8 "

## !

! "

+ / 6 ##

% " !

+ # !

> #

+%!

# //

! /#

#+% " ## +/ !! !!

!/ ! B% +

" ""

& + #

/% < !!% +

4!%//

" #

+%!

# "

" 5 &% "

*4%21:(5*)C21% 0-'0'& 09-* / B *3 B 5 "

+ "##7 / !%// " ! 9 1-2 '()/ -8-2-'0 %0.1 '0D3,% ) 4(2/-.% : -0<1*09'0D3,%) (2/-.% %08-9%/1% 4(9<5%0/ *09 ')9%) 9*/%9 EF +*22%9 -0 ' FB?F *09 *0'/1%) -8-2-'0 %0.1 '0D3,% )

(2/-.% 5* */1 -0<1$ 1-%& (2/-.% ./-0< *09 '0D3,% ) (2/-.% : -0<1 8-9% ')9%) 9*/%9 =F+*22%9-0'E?*)%'&/1%2*5% 8-%7/1*//1%'55*09-0< &&-.%)'&/1%22*5 -&,%2 -2 0'/ /1% .'5+%/%0/ *(/1')-/6 &') 9-25-22-0< /1% 2%)8-.% '& /1% -&,%5*0 *09 *8-,9*) (09%) %./-'0 '& /1% 22*5 -&,%2 ./$ FE '& 1%

(9<5%0/*09')9%)'&/1%-8-2-'0%0.1'&/1-2'()/ 9*/%9=F +*22%9-0'E?F)%*92*2 &',,'72 @ G -0<1$ ./-0< =F %*)9 ,%*)0%9 .'(02%, *++%*)-0< &') +*)/-%2 *09 +%)(2%9/1%)%.')9'&7)-/*++%*,2 1-2 ')9%) 21*,, *,2' 9-2+'2% '& 2-5-,*) )-/ ++%*, ' B? ,-2/%9 /'9*6 0% *09 '0,6 H(%2/-'0 /1*/0%%92 /' 3% *99)%22%91*2 *,)%*96 3%%0 .'0.,(9%9 8-9% *

(9<5%0/ 9*/%9 =I +*22%9 36 -8-2-'0 %0.1 1%*9%9 36 '0% '& (2 :

-0<1$

-0 ' ?$ 71%)%-0 -/ 1*2 3%%0 1%,9 /1*/ /1% 9-2.1*)<% ')9%) -0 /%)52 '& %./-'0 '& /1% 22*5 -&,%2 ./$ &') 21')/ D/1% ./ '& D 1*2 /' 3% +*22%9 36 * %+(/6 02+%./') %0%)*, '& 22*5

-&,%2 *09 0'/ 36 * '55*09*0/ ') %*26 )%&%)%0.%$ %./-'0 '& /1%2*-9./'&-2)%+)'9(.%91%)%-03%,'7 @ G -25-22*,$ )%5'8*, ') )%9(./-'0 36 -)%./')@%0%)*,*0936'/1%)'&&-.%)2@ 1% -)%./')@%0%)*,$ 99-/-'0*, -)%./')@ %0%)*, ') *06 02+%./')@%0%)*, 5*6 9-25-22'))%5'8%&)'52%)8-.%'))%9(.%/' * ,'7%) <)*9% ') )*0; ') /1% )*0;2 *06 +%)2'0 2(34%./ /' /1-2 ./ '/1%) /1*0 '0 '&&-.%)

0'&&-.%)0'/3%,'7/1%)*0;'&%+(/6 02+%./')@%0%)*, 5*6 9-25-22 ') )%5'8% &)'5 /1% 2%)8-.% *06 +%)2'0 (09%) 1-2 .'55*09 '/1%) /1*0 *0 '&&-.%) ') * 2(3')9-0*/% '&&-.%) '& 2(.1 )*0; ') /1% )*0;2*25*63%+)%2.)-3%9 062(.1'&&-.%)*2-25%0/-'0%9-02(3@ 2%./-'05*6)%9(.%/'*,'7%)<)*9%') )*0; ') /1% )*0;2 *06 +%)2'0 (09%) 1-2 .'55*09%>.%+/*0'&&-.%)')*2(3')9-0*/% '&&-.%) F 1% %>%).-2% '& *06 +'7%) (09%) /1-2 2%./-'021*,,3%2(34%.//'/1%+)'8-2-'02'& /1-2./*09/1%)(,%2*09)%<(,*/-'02G :

+ %!

# //

" #

/% 4!/

#" !!

! &

< 7

!!% !%+ +

D8E" !!

! 8

- $

+& # 6 &%!

# !!%

! "

# )/ +

#$ +

% !

* +"

! #

+% "

# ! "

! "

# $

# )/

+ +

+ $

+&& !+ 6 +" !%!

; - /% /!

" //

# ! / ,

+ #

+ %!

# "

! ! % ! % +!

+ % ""

+! + ! +!# #

! "

# )/ + +%# !

#$ +$

#$ +

# )/ /

! "

% !

" +

)

,% !+

%+ 88" &!

% " 4+

!!%7 !%

7%#+ # + +%

!" ## +/ !! !!

+ +

+ ! %

% !!

7 !%/ !

" B% !

" < &

! ! % "

" !

,%+

+ *4%21:(5*)C21% 0-'0'&09-* &% "

7 ! +

7 " + #

" !!

! 8/ 6 !%+ 9 -25-22*,$ )%5'8*, ') )%9(./-'0 36 -)%./')@ %0%)*,*0936'/1%)'&&-.%)2@ 1%-)%./')@%0%)*,$99-/-'0*,-)%./')@%0%)*, ')*0602+%./')@%0%)*,5*69-25-22'))%5'8%&)'5 2%)8-.%'))%9(.%/'*,'7%)<)*9%'))*0;')/1%)*0;2 *06+%)2'02(34%.//'/1-2./'/1%)/1*0*0'&&-.%) 0'&&-.%)0'/3%,'7/1%)*0;'&%+(/602+%./')@ %0%)*, 5*6 9-25-22 ') )%5'8% &)'5 /1% 2%)8-.% *06 +%)2'0 (09%) 1-2 .'55*09 '/1%) /1*0 *0 '&&-.%) ') *

2(3')9-0*/%'&&-.%)'&2(.1)*0;')/1%)*0;2*25*63% +)%2.)-3%9 062(.1'&&-.%)*2-25%0/-'0%9-02(3@2%./-'0 5*6)%9(.%/'*,'7%)<)*9%'))*0;')/1%)*0;2*06 +%)2'0 (09%) 1-2 .'55*09 %>.%+/ *0 '&&-.%) ') * 2(3')9-0*/%'&&-.%) F1%%>%).-2%'&*06+'7%)(09%)/1-22%./-'021*,, 3% 2(34%./ /' /1% +)'8-2-'02 '& /1-2 ./ *09 /1% )(,%2 *09)%<(,*/-'02

+/ 6 ! ## //#

# + / 6 !"

8" !!

! 8/ 6 !"##7!9 %)/-&-.*/% '& /%)5-0*/-'0 '& 2%)8-.%@ 2(3')9-0*/%'&&-.%)')*0(09%)@'&&-.%)')'/1%)%0)',,%9 +%)2'071'-2)%/-)%9$9-2.1*)<%9$)%,%*2%9$)%5'8%9') 9-25-22%9&)'52%)8-.%21*,,3%&()0-21%936/1%'&&-.%)$ /' 71'2% .'55*09 1% -2 2(34%./$ 7-/1 * .%)/-&-.*/% -0 /1% ,*0<(*<% 71-.1 -2 /1% 5'/1%)@/'0<(% '& 2(.1 +%)2'0 *09 *,2' -0 -09- *09 0<,-21 ,*0<(*<% 2%//-0< &')/1@*/1%*(/1')-/6/%)5-0*/-0<1-22%)8-.%J3/1% .*(2% &') 2(.1 /%)5-0*/-'0J *09 . /1% &(,, +%)-'9 '& 1-22%)8-.%-0/1% ').%

8" !!

! 8#

#/ 6 &

" ## +/ ! 7

+ + +

6 + + + "

! ## "% ! + '""

+ !%, 7

# % 7 ! * % " ! ! !%

! "

< !!% +

" + 7

+ !% ! " / 6 !"

8 " !!

! 8

8 #+! !% + ! "

+ #

!+ +

! ## + ! ! !